Hypothesis: Unifying model of domain architecture for conventional and novel protein kinase C isozymes

Illuminating the druggable genome: Pathways to progress

There are ∼4500 genes within the 'druggable genome', the subset of the human genome that expresses proteins able to bind drug-like molecules, yet existing drugs only target a few hundred. A substantial subset of druggable proteins are largely uncharacterized or understudied, with many falling within G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR), ion channel, and kinase protein families. To improve scientific understanding of these three understudied protein families, the US National Institutes of Health launched the Illuminating the Druggable Genome Program. Now, as the program draws to a close, this review will lay out resources developed by the program that are intended to equip the scientific community with the tools necessary to explore previously understudied biology with the potential to rapidly impact human health.

Single-residue mutation in protein kinase C toggles between cancer and neurodegeneration

Conventional protein kinase C (cPKC) isozymes tune the signaling output of cells, with loss-of-function somatic mutations associated with cancer and gain-of-function germline mutations identified in neurodegeneration. PKC with impaired autoinhibition is removed from the cell by quality-control mechanisms to prevent the accumulation of aberrantly active enzyme. Here, we examine how a highly conserved residue in the C1A domain of cPKC isozymes permits quality-control degradation when mutated to histidine in cancer (PKCβ-R42H) and blocks down-regulation when mutated to proline in the neurodegenerative disease spinocerebellar ataxia (PKCγ-R41P). Using FRET-based biosensors, we determined that mutation of R42 to any residue, including lysine, resulted in reduced autoinhibition as indicated by higher basal activity and faster agonist-induced plasma membrane translocation. R42 is predicted to form a stabilizing salt bridge with E655 in the C-tail and mutation of E655, but not neighboring E657, also reduced autoinhibition. Western blot analysis revealed that whereas R42H had reduced stability, the R42P mutant was stable and insensitive to activator-induced ubiquitination and down-regulation, an effect previously observed by deletion of the entire C1A domain. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and analysis of stable regions of the domain using local spatial pattern (LSP) alignment suggested that P42 interacts with Q66 to impair mobility and conformation of one of the ligand-binding loops. Additional mutation of Q66 to the smaller asparagine (R42P/Q66N), to remove conformational constraints, restored degradation sensitivity. Our results unveil how disease-associated mutations of the same residue in the C1A domain can toggle between gain- or loss-of-function of PKC.

Single-residue mutation in protein kinase C toggles between cancer and neurodegeneration

Conventional protein kinase C (PKC) isozymes tune the signaling output of cells, with loss-of-function somatic mutations associated with cancer and gain-of-function germline mutations identified in neurodegeneration. PKC with impaired autoinhibition is removed from the cell by quality-control mechanisms to prevent accumulation of aberrantly active enzyme. Here, we examine how a single residue in the C1A domain of PKCβ, arginine 42 (R42), permits quality-control degradation when mutated to histidine in cancer (R42H) and blocks downregulation when mutated to proline in the neurodegenerative disease spinocerebellar ataxia (R42P). Using FRET-based biosensors, we determined that mutation of R42 to any residue, including lysine, resulted in reduced autoinhibition as indicated by higher basal activity and faster agonist-induced plasma membrane translocation. R42 is predicted to form a stabilizing salt bridge with E655 in the C-tail and mutation of E655, but not neighboring E657, also reduced autoinhibition. Western blot analysis revealed that whereas R42H had reduced stability, the R42P mutant was stable and insensitive to activator-induced ubiquitination and downregulation, an effect previously observed by deletion of the entire C1A domain. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations and analysis of stable regions of the domain using local spatial pattern (LSP) alignment suggested that P42 interacts with Q66 to impair mobility and conformation of one of the ligand-binding loops. Additional mutation of Q66 to the smaller asparagine (R42P/Q66N), to remove conformational constraints, restored degradation sensitivity to that of WT. Our results unveil how disease-associated mutations of the same residue in the C1A domain can toggle between gain- or loss-of-function of PKC.

Dynamic phosphatase-recruitment controls B-cell selection and oncogenic signaling

Initiation of B-cell receptor (BCR) ¹ signaling, and subsequent antigen-encounter in germinal centers ^2,3 represent milestones of B-lymphocyte development that are both marked by sharp increases of CD25 surface-expression. Oncogenic signaling in B-cell leukemia (B-ALL) ⁴ and lymphoma ⁵ also induced CD25-surface expression. While CD25 is known as an IL2-receptor chain on T- and NK-cells ^6-9 , the significance of its expression on B-cells was unclear. Our experiments based on genetic mouse models and engineered patient-derived xenografts revealed that, rather than functioning as an IL2-receptor chain, CD25 expressed on B-cells assembled an inhibitory complex including PKCδ and SHIP1 and SHP1 phosphatases for feedback control of BCR-signaling or its oncogenic mimics. Recapitulating phenotypes of genetic ablation of PKCδ ¹⁰ - ¹² , SHIP1 ^13,14 and SHP1 ^{14, 15,16} , conditional CD25-deletion decimated early B-cell subsets but expanded mature B-cell populations and induced autoimmunity. In B-cell malignancies arising from early (B-ALL) and late (lymphoma) stages of B-cell development, CD25-loss induced cell death in the former and accelerated proliferation in the latter. Clinical outcome annotations mirrored opposite effects of CD25-deletion: high CD25 expression levels predicted poor clinical outcomes for patients with B-ALL, in contrast to favorable outcomes for lymphoma-patients. Biochemical and interactome studies revealed a critical role of CD25 in BCR-feedback regulation: BCR-signaling induced PKCδ-mediated phosphorylation of CD25 on its cytoplasmic tail (S ²⁶⁸ ). Genetic rescue experiments identified CD25-S ²⁶⁸ tail-phosphorylation as central structural requirement to recruit SHIP1 and SHP1 phosphatases to curb BCR-signaling. A single point mutation CD25 ^S268A abolished recruitment and activation of SHIP1 and SHP1 to limit duration and strength of BCR-signaling. Loss of phosphatase-function, autonomous BCR-signaling and Ca ²⁺ -oscillations induced anergy and negative selection during early B-cell development, as opposed to excessive proliferation and autoantibody production in mature B-cells. These findings highlight the previously unrecognized role of CD25 in assembling inhibitory phosphatases to control oncogenic signaling in B-cell malignancies and negative selection to prevent autoimmune disease.

Mutations in protein kinase Cγ promote spinocerebellar ataxia type 14 by impairing kinase autoinhibition

Spinocerebellar ataxia type 14 (SCA14) is a neurodegenerative disease caused by germline variants in the diacylglycerol (DAG)/Ca2+-regulated protein kinase Cγ (PKCγ), leading to Purkinje cell degeneration and progressive cerebellar dysfunction. Most of the identified mutations cluster in the DAG-sensing C1 domains. Here, we found with a FRET-based activity reporter that SCA14-associated PKCγ mutations, including a previously undescribed variant, D115Y, enhanced the basal activity of the kinase by compromising its autoinhibition. Unlike other mutations in PKC that impair its autoinhibition but lead to its degradation, the C1 domain mutations protected PKCγ from such down-regulation. This enhanced basal signaling rewired the brain phosphoproteome, as revealed by phosphoproteomic analysis of cerebella from mice expressing a human SCA14-associated H101Y mutant PKCγ transgene. Mutations that induced a high basal activity in vitro were associated with earlier average age of onset in patients. Furthermore, the extent of disrupted autoinhibition, but not agonist-stimulated activity, correlated with disease severity. Molecular modeling indicated that almost all SCA14 variants not within the C1 domain were located at interfaces with the C1B domain, suggesting that mutations in and proximal to the C1B domain are a susceptibility for SCA14 because they uniquely enhance PKCγ basal activity while protecting the enzyme from down-regulation. These results provide insight into how PKCγ activation is modulated and how deregulation of the cerebellar phosphoproteome by SCA14-associated mutations affects disease progression.

Two Sides of the Same Coin: Protein Kinase C γ in Cancer and Neurodegeneration

Protein kinase C (PKC) isozymes transduce myriad signals within the cell in response to the generation of second messengers from membrane phospholipids. The conventional isozyme PKCγ reversibly binds Ca²⁺ and diacylglycerol, which leads to an open, active conformation. PKCγ expression is typically restricted to neurons, but evidence for its expression in certain cancers has emerged. PKC isozymes have been labeled as oncogenes since the discovery that they bind tumor-promoting phorbol esters, however, studies of cancer-associated PKC mutations and clinical trial data showing that PKC inhibitors have worsened patient survival have reframed PKC as a tumor suppressor. Aberrant expression of PKCγ in certain cancers suggests a role outside the brain, although whether PKCγ also acts as a tumor suppressor remains to be established. On the other hand, PKCγ variants associated with spinocerebellar ataxia type 14 (SCA14), a neurodegenerative disorder characterized by Purkinje cell degeneration, enhance basal activity while preventing phorbol ester-mediated degradation. Although the basis for SCA14 Purkinje cell degeneration remains unknown, studies have revealed how altered PKCγ activity rewires cerebellar signaling to drive SCA14. Importantly, enhanced basal activity of SCA14-associated mutants inversely correlates with age of onset, supporting that enhanced PKCγ activity drives SCA14. Thus, PKCγ activity should likely be inhibited in SCA14, whereas restoring PKC activity should be the goal in cancer therapies. This review describes how PKCγ activity can be lost or gained in disease and the overarching need for a PKC structure as a powerful tool to predict the effect of PKCγ mutations in disease.

PHLPPing the balance: restoration of protein kinase C in cancer

Protein kinase signalling, which transduces external messages to mediate cellular growth and metabolism, is frequently deregulated in human disease, and specifically in cancer. As such, there are 77 kinase inhibitors currently approved for the treatment of human disease by the FDA. Due to their historical association as the receptors for the tumour-promoting phorbol esters, PKC isozymes were initially targeted as oncogenes in cancer. However, a meta-analysis of clinical trials with PKC inhibitors in combination with chemotherapy revealed that these treatments were not advantageous, and instead resulted in poorer outcomes and greater adverse effects. More recent studies suggest that instead of inhibiting PKC, therapies should aim to restore PKC function in cancer: cancer-associated PKC mutations are generally loss-of-function and high PKC protein is protective in many cancers, including most notably KRAS-driven cancers. These recent findings have reframed PKC as having a tumour suppressive function. This review focusses on a potential new mechanism of restoring PKC function in cancer - through targeting of its negative regulator, the Ser/Thr protein phosphatase PHLPP. This phosphatase regulates PKC steady-state levels by regulating the phosphorylation of a key site, the hydrophobic motif, whose phosphorylation is necessary for the stability of the enzyme. We also consider whether the phosphorylation of the potent oncogene KRAS provides a mechanism by which high PKC expression may be protective in KRAS-driven human cancers.