Genetic deletion of menin in mouse mesenchymal stem cells: an experimental and computational analysis

An Updated Perspective of the Clinical Features and Parathyroidectomy Impact in Primary Hyperparathyroidism Amid Multiple Endocrine Neoplasia Type 1 (MEN1): Focus on Bone Health

Background: Multiple endocrine neoplasia type 1 (MEN1)-related primary hyperparathyroidism (MPHPT) belongs to genetic PHPT that accounts for 10% of all PHPT cases, being considered the most frequent hereditary PHPT (less than 5% of all PHPT). Objective: We aimed to provide an updated clinical perspective with a double purpose: to highlight the clinical features in MPHPT, particularly, the bone health assessment, as well as the parathyroidectomy (PTx) impact. Methods: A comprehensive review of the latest 5-year, English-published, PubMed-accessed original studies. Results: The sample-based analysis (n = 17 studies) enrolled 2426 subjects (1720 with MPHPT). The study design was retrospective, except for one prospective and one case-control study. The maximum number of patients per study was of 517. Female predominance (an overall female-to-male ratio of 1.139) was confirmed (except for three studies). Age at MPHPT diagnosis (mean/median per study): 28.7 to 43.1 years; age at PTx: 32 to 43.5 years. Asymptomatic PHPT was reported in 38.3% to 67% of MPHPT. Mean total calcium varied between 1.31 and 2.88 mmol/L and highest PTH was of 317.2 pg/mL. Two studies reported similar PTH and calcaemic levels in MPHPT vs. sporadic PHPT, while another found higher values in MPHPT. Symptomatic vs. asymptomatic patients with MPHPT had similar PTH and serum calcium levels (n = 1). Osteoporosis (n = 8, N = 723 with MPHPT) was reported in 10% to 55.5% of cases, osteopenia in 5.88% to 43.9% (per study); overall fracture rate was 10% (of note, one study showed 0%). Lower bone mineral density (BMD) at DXA (n = 4) in MPHPT vs. sporadic PHPT/controls was found by some studies (n = 3, and only a single study provided third distal radius DXA-BMD assessment), but not all (n = 1). Post-PTx DXA (n = 3, N = 190 with MPHPT) showed a BMD increase (e.g., +8.5% for lumbar spine, +2.1% for total hip, +4.3% for femoral neck BMD); however, post-operatory, BMD remains lower than controls. Trabecular bone score (TBS) analysis (n = 2, N = 142 with MPHPT vs. 397 with sporadic PHPT) showed a higher prevalence of reduced TBS (n = 1) or similar (n = 1). PTx analysis in MPHPT (n = 14): rate of subtotal PTx of 39% to 66.7% (per study) or less than subtotal PTx of 46.9% (n = 1). Post-PTx complications: persistent PHPT (5.6% to 25%), recurrent PHPT (16.87% to 30%, with the highest re-operation rate of 71% in one cohort); hypoparathyroidism (12.4% to 41.7%). Genetic analysis pointed out a higher risk of post-PTx recurrence in exon 10 MEN1 pathogenic variant. Post-PTx histological exam showed a multi-glandular disease in 40% to 52.1% of MPHPT, and a parathyroid carcinoma prevalence of 1%. Conclusions: MPHPT remains a challenging ailment amid a multi-layered genetic syndrome. Current data showed a lower age at MPHPT diagnosis and surgery than found in general population, and a rate of female predominance that is lower than seen in sporadic PHPT cases, but higher than known, for instance, in MEN2. The bone involvement showed heterogeneous results, more consistent for a lower BMD, but not necessarily for a lower TBS vs. controls. PTx involves a rather high rate of recurrence, persistence and redo surgery. About one out of ten patients with MPHPT might have a prevalent fracture and PTx improves the overall bone health, but seems not to restore it to the general population level, despite the young age of the subjects. This suggests that non-parathyroid components and potentially menin protein displays negative bone effects in MEN1.

Effect of Menin Deletion in Early Osteoblast Lineage on the Mineralization of an In Vitro 3D Osteoid-like Dense Collagen Gel Matrix

Bone has a complex microenvironment formed by an extracellular matrix (ECM) composed mainly of mineralized type I collagen fibres. Bone ECM regulates signaling pathways important in the differentiation of osteoblast-lineage cells, necessary for bone mineralization and in preserving tissue architecture. Compared to conventional 2D cell cultures, 3D in vitro models may better mimic bone ECM and provide an environment to support osteoblastic differentiation. In this study, a biomimetic 3D osteoid-like dense collagen gel model was used to investigate the role of the nuclear protein menin plays in osteoblastic differentiation and matrix mineralization. Previous in vitro and in vivo studies have shown that when expressed at later stages of osteoblastic differentiation, menin modulates osteoblastogenesis and regulates bone mass in adult mice. To investigate the role of menin when expressed at earlier stages of the osteoblastic lineage, conditional knockout mice in which the Men1 gene is specifically deleted early (i.e., at the level of the pluripotent mesenchymal stem cell lineage), where generated and primary calvarial osteoblasts were cultured in plastically compressed dense collagen gels for 21 days. The proliferation, morphology and differentiation of isolated seeded primary calvarial osteoblasts from knockout (Prx1-Cre; Men1f/f) mice were compared to those isolated from wild-type (Men1f/f) mice. Primary calvarial osteoblasts from knockout and wild-type mice did not show differences in terms of proliferation. However, in comparison to wild-type cells, primary osteoblast cells derived from knockout mice demonstrated deficient mineralization capabilities and an altered gene expression profile when cultured in 3D dense collagen gels. In summary, these findings indicate that when expressed at earlier stages of osteoblast differentiation, menin is important in maintaining matrix mineralization in 3D dense collagen gel matrices, in vitro.