Strategies for engineering human chromosomes with therapeutic potential

Chromosome Engineering: Technologies, Applications, and Challenges

Chromosome engineering is a transformative field at the cutting edge of biological science, offering unprecedented precision in manipulating large-scale genomic DNA within cells. This discipline is central to deciphering how the multifaceted roles of chromosomes-guarding genetic information, encoding sequence positional information, and influencing organismal traits-shape the genetic blueprint of life. This review comprehensively examines the technological advancements in chromosome engineering, which center on engineering chromosomal rearrangements, generating artificial chromosomes, de novo synthesizing chromosomes, and transferring chromosomes. Additionally, we introduce the application progress of chromosome engineering in basic and applied research fields, showcasing its capacity to deepen our knowledge of genetics and catalyze breakthroughs in therapeutic strategies. Finally, we conclude with a discussion of the challenges the field faces and highlight the profound implications that chromosome engineering holds for the future of modern biology and medical applications.

Protecting a transgene expression from the HAC-based vector by different chromatin insulators

Human artificial chromosomes (HACs) are vectors that offer advantages of capacity and stability for gene delivery and expression. Several studies have even demonstrated their use for gene complementation in gene-deficient recipient cell lines and animal transgenesis. Recently, we constructed an advance HAC-based vector, alphoid^tetO-HAC, with a conditional centromere. In this HAC, a gene-loading site was inserted into a centrochromatin domain critical for kinetochore assembly and maintenance. While by definition this domain is permissive for transcription, there have been no long-term studies on transgene expression within centrochromatin. In this study, we compared the effects of three chromatin insulators, cHS4, gamma-satellite DNA, and tDNA, on the expression of an EGFP transgene inserted into the alphoid^tetO-HAC vector. Insulator function was essential for stable expression of the transgene in centrochromatin. In two analyzed host cell lines, a tDNA insulator composed of two functional copies of tRNA genes showed the highest barrier activity. We infer that proximity to centrochromatin does not protect genes lacking chromatin insulators from epigenetic silencing. Barrier elements that prevent gene silencing in centrochromatin would thus help to optimize transgenesis using HAC vectors.

Re-engineering an alphoid(tetO)-HAC-based vector to enable high-throughput analyses of gene function

Human artificial chromosome (HAC)-based vectors represent an alternative technology for gene delivery and expression with a potential to overcome the problems caused by the use of viral-based vectors. The recently developed alphoid^tetO-HAC has an advantage over other HAC vectors because it can be easily eliminated from cells by inactivation of the HAC kinetochore via binding of tTS chromatin modifiers to its centromeric tetO sequences. This provides unique control for phenotypes induced by genes loaded into the alphoid^tetO-HAC. However, inactivation of the HAC kinetochore requires transfection of cells by a retrovirus vector, a step that is potentially mutagenic. Here, we describe an approach to re-engineering the alphoid^tetO-HAC that allows verification of phenotypic changes attributed to expression of genes from the HAC without a transfection step. In the new HAC vector, a tTS-EYFP cassette is inserted into a gene-loading site along with a gene of interest. Expression of the tTS generates a self-regulating fluctuating heterochromatin on the alphoid^tetO-HAC that induces fast silencing of the genes on the HAC without significant effects on HAC segregation. This silencing of the HAC-encoded genes can be readily recovered by adding doxycycline. The newly modified alphoid^tetO-HAC-based system has multiple applications in gene function studies.

A new generation of human artificial chromosomes for functional genomics and gene therapy

Since their description in the late 1990s, human artificial chromosomes (HACs) carrying a functional kinetochore were considered as a promising system for gene delivery and expression with a potential to overcome many problems caused by the use of viral-based gene transfer systems. Indeed, HACs avoid the limited cloning capacity, lack of copy number control and insertional mutagenesis due to integration into host chromosomes that plague viral vectors. Nevertheless, until recently, HACs have not been widely recognized because of uncertainties of their structure and the absence of a unique gene acceptor site. The situation changed a few years ago after engineering of HACs with a single loxP gene adopter site and a defined structure. In this review, we summarize recent progress made in HAC technology and concentrate on details of two of the most advanced HACs, 21HAC generated by truncation of human chromosome 21 and alphoid(tetO)-HAC generated de novo using a synthetic tetO-alphoid DNA array. Multiple potential applications of the HAC vectors are discussed, specifically the unique features of two of the most advanced HAC cloning systems.

Human artificial chromosomes for gene delivery and the development of animal models

Random integration of conventional gene delivery vectors such as viruses, plasmids, P1 phage-derived artificial chromosomes, bacterial artificial chromosomes and yeast artificial chromosomes can be associated with transgene silencing. Furthermore, integrated viral sequences can activate oncogenes adjacent to the insertion site resulting in cancer. Various human artificial chromosomes (HACs) exhibit several potential characteristics desired for an ideal gene delivery vector, including stable episomal maintenance and the capacity to carry large genomic loci with their regulatory elements, thus allowing the physiological regulation of the introduced gene in a manner similar to that of native chromosomes. HACs have been generated mainly using either a "top-down approach" (engineered chromosomes), or a "bottom-up approach" (de novo artificial chromosomes). The recent emergence of stem cell-based tissue engineering has opened up new avenues for gene and cell therapies. This review describes the lessons learned and prospects identified mainly from studies in the construction of HACs and HAC-mediated gene expression systems in cultured cells, as well as in animals.

Introduction of a CD40L genomic fragment via a human artificial chromosome vector permits cell-type-specific gene expression and induces immunoglobulin secretion

Gene therapy using cDNA driven by an exogenous promoter is not suited for genetic disorders that require intrinsic expression of a transgene, such as hyperimmunoglobulin (Ig)M syndrome (HIGM), which is caused by mutations in the CD40L gene. The human artificial chromosome (HAC) vector has the potential to solve this problem, because it can be used to transfer large genomic fragments containing their own regulatory elements. In this study, we examined whether introduction of a genomic fragment of CD40L via the HAC vector permits intrinsic expression of the transgene and has an effect on immunoglobulin secretion. We constructed an HAC vector carrying the mouse CD40L genomic fragment (mCD40L-HAC) in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells and transferred the mCD40L-HAC vector into a human CD4-positive active T-cell line (Jurkat) and a human myeloid cell line (U937) via microcell-mediated chromosome transfer (MMCT). The mCD40L-HAC vector permits mCD40L expression in human active T cells but not in human myeloid cells. The mCD40L-HAC also functions to stimulate mouse B cells derived from CD40L(-/-) mice, inducing secretion of IgG. This study may be an initial step toward the therapeutic application of HAC vectors for intrinsic expression of genes, a potential new direction for genome-based gene therapy.

Human artificial chromosome vectors meet stem cells: new prospects for gene delivery

The recent emergence of stem cell-based tissue engineering has now opened up new venues for gene therapy. The task now is to develop safe and effective vectors that can deliver therapeutic genes into specific stem cell lines and maintain long-term regulated expression of these genes. Human artificial chromosomes (HACs) possess several characteristics that require gene therapy vectors, including a stable episomal maintenance, and the capacity for large gene inserts. HACs can also carry genomic loci with regulatory elements, thus allowing for the expression of transgenes in a genetic environment similar to the chromosome. Currently, HACs are constructed by a two prone approaches. Using a top-down strategy, HACs can be generated from fragmenting endogenous chromosomes. By a bottom-up strategy, HACs can be created de novo from cloned chromosomal components using chromosome engineering. This review describes the current advances in developing HACs, with the main focus on their applications and potential value in gene delivery, such as HAC-mediated gene expression in embryonic, adult stem cells, and transgenic animals.

Genetic modification of hematopoietic stem cells with nonviral systems: past progress and future prospects

Serious unwanted complications provoked by retroviral gene transfer into hematopoietic stem cells (HSCs) have recently raised the need for the development and assessment of alternative gene transfer vectors. Within this context, nonviral gene transfer systems are attracting increasing interest. Their main advantages include low cost, ease of handling and large-scale production, large packaging capacity and, most importantly, biosafety. While nonviral gene transfer into HSCs has been restricted in the past by poor transfection efficiency and transient maintenance, in recent years, biotechnological developments are converting nonviral transfer into a realistic approach for genetic modification of cells of hematopoietic origin. Herein we provide an overview of past accomplishments in the field of nonviral gene transfer into hematopoietic progenitor/stem cells and we point at future challenges. We argue that episomally maintained self-replicating vectors combined with physical methods of delivery show the greatest promise among nonviral gene transfer strategies for the treatment of disorders of the hematopoietic system.

Exogenous gene expression and growth regulation of hematopoietic cells via a novel human artificial chromosome

A number of gene delivery systems are currently being developed for potential use in gene therapy. Here, we demonstrate the feasibility of 21deltaqHAC, a newly developed human artificial chromosome (HAC), as a gene delivery system. We first introduced a 21deltaqHAC carrying an EGFP reporter gene and a geneticin-resistant gene (EGFP-21deltaqHAC) into hematopoietic cells by microcell-mediated chromosome transfer. These HAC-containing hematopoietic cells showed resistance to geneticin, expressed EGFP and retained the ability to differentiate into various lineages, and the EGFP-21deltaqHAC was successfully transduced into primary hematopoietic cells. Hematopoietic cells harboring the EGFP-21deltaqHAC could still be detected at two weeks post-transplantation in immunodeficient mice. We also showed effective expansion of hematopoietic cells by introducing the 21deltaqHAC containing ScFvg, a gp130-based chimeric receptor that transmits growth signals in response to specific-antigen of this receptor. All of these results demonstrate the usefulness of HAC in gene therapy.

Engineering chromosomes for delivery of therapeutic genes

The ability to create fully functional human chromosome vectors represents a potentially exciting gene-delivery system for the correction of human genetic disorders with several advantages over viral delivery systems. However, for the full potential of chromosome-based gene-delivery vectors to be realized, several key obstacles must be overcome. Methods must be developed to insert therapeutic genes reliably and efficiently and to enable the stable transfer of the resulting chromosomal vectors to different therapeutic cell types. Research to achieve these outcomes continues to encounter major challenges; however recent developments have reiterated the potential of chromosome-based vectors for therapeutic gene delivery. Here we review the different strategies under development and discuss the advantages and problems associated with each.

Artificial and engineered chromosomes: developments and prospects for gene therapy

At the gene therapy session of the ICCXV Chromosome Conference (2004), recent advances in the construction of engineered chromosomes and de novo human artificial chromosomes were presented. The long-term aims of these studies are to develop vectors as tools for studying genome and chromosome function and for delivering genes into cells for therapeutic applications. There are two primary advantages of chromosome-based vector systems over most conventional vectors for gene delivery. First, the transferred DNA can be stably maintained without the risks associated with insertion, and second, large DNA segments encompassing genes and their regulatory elements can be introduced, leading to more reliable transgene expression. There is clearly a need for safe and effective gene transfer vectors to correct genetic defects. Among the topics discussed at the gene therapy session and the main focus of this review are requirements for de novo human artificial chromosome formation, assembly of chromatin on de novo human artificial chromosomes, advances in vector construction, and chromosome transfer to cells and animals.

The manipulation of chromosomes by mankind: the uses of microcell-mediated chromosome transfer

Microcell-mediated chromosome transfer (MMCT) was a technique originally developed in the 1970s to transfer exogenous chromosome material into host cells. Although, the methodology has not changed considerably since this time it is being used to great success in progressing several different fields in modern day biology. MMCT is being employed by groups all over the world to hunt for tumour suppressor genes associated with specific cancers, DNA repair genes, senescence-inducing genes and telomerase suppression genes. Some of these genomic discoveries are being investigated as potential treatments for cancer. Other fields have taken advantage of MMCT, and these include assessing genomic stability, genomic imprinting, chromatin modification and structure and spatial genome organisation. MMCT has also been a very useful method in construction and manipulation of artificial chromosomes for potential gene therapies. Indeed, MMCT is used to transfer mainly fragmented mini-chromosome between cell types and into embryonic stem cells for the construction of transgenic animals. This review briefly discusses these various uses and some of the consequences and advancements made by different fields utilising MMCT technology.

Construction of a novel expression system on a human artificial chromosome

Efficient regulation of transgene would greatly facilitate the analysis of gene function in biological systems for basic research and clinical applications. The tetracycline-regulatable system (TRS) has proven to be a promising tool for such purposes. Despite their widespread application, a number of challenges are still associated with the use of TRS, including clonal variability in the regulation and copy number. We have recently constructed a novel human artificial chromosome (HAC) called 21DeltaqHAC. By housing a TRS-based DNA-PKcs expression cassette in this HAC, we were able to circumvent the problems associated with conventional TRS-based vectors. We achieved tight control of DNA-PKcs expression and rescued the radiosensitive phenotype of DNA-PKcs-deficient CHO cells. The combined use of HAC and the TRS serves as a model for controllable and fixed copy number expression vectors. Our study also demonstrates the suitability of the HAC to accommodate multi-subunit constructs such as that of the TRS.

Rapid creation of BAC-based human artificial chromosome vectors by transposition with synthetic alpha-satellite arrays

Efficient construction of BAC-based human artificial chromosomes (HACs) requires optimization of each key functional unit as well as development of techniques for the rapid and reliable manipulation of high-molecular weight BAC vectors. Here, we have created synthetic chromosome 17-derived alpha-satellite arrays, based on the 16-monomer repeat length typical of natural D17Z1 arrays, in which the consensus CENP-B box elements are either completely absent (0/16 monomers) or increased in density (16/16 monomers) compared to D17Z1 alpha-satellite (5/16 monomers). Using these vectors, we show that the presence of CENP-B box elements is a requirement for efficient de novo centromere formation and that increasing the density of CENP-B box elements may enhance the efficiency of de novo centromere formation. Furthermore, we have developed a novel, high-throughput methodology that permits the rapid conversion of any genomic BAC target into a HAC vector by transposon-mediated modification with synthetic alpha-satellite arrays and other key functional units. Taken together, these approaches offer the potential to significantly advance the utility of BAC-based HACs for functional annotation of the genome and for applications in gene transfer.

Biotechnology, the brain and the future

Several new approaches to illness, inspired by recent advances in molecular biology, informatics and nanoscience, are readily applicable to diseases of the central nervous system. Novel classes of drugs will widen the scope of therapeutic action beyond merely modifying transmitter function and stem cell and gene therapies could offer an even more selective mode of targeting. Further into the future, nanotechnology has the potential to allow development of new medicines and novel access routes via miniaturized monitoring and screening devices: these systems, together with increasing use of carbon-silicon interfacing, will challenge traditional neuropharmacology. As the 21(st) century unfolds, the structure and function of the brain, which is incomparable with any other organ, will present unique technological and ethical questions.

Approaches to enhance the efficacy of DNA vaccines

DNA vaccines consist of antigen-encoding bacterial plasmids that are capable of inducing antigen-specific immune responses upon inoculation into a host. This method of immunization is advantageous in terms of simplicity, adaptability, and cost of vaccine production. However, the entry of DNA vaccines and expression of antigen are subjected to physical and biochemical barriers imposed by the host. In small animals such as mice, the host-imposed impediments have not prevented DNA vaccines from inducing long-lasting, protective humoral, and cellular immune responses. In contrast, these barriers appear to be more difficult to overcome in large animals and humans. The focus of this article is to summarize the limitations of DNA vaccines and to provide a comprehensive review on the different strategies developed to enhance the efficacy of DNA vaccines. Several of these strategies, such as altering codon bias of the encoded gene, changing the cellular localization of the expressed antigen, and optimizing delivery and formulation of the plasmid, have led to improvements in DNA vaccine efficacy in large animals. However, solutions for increasing the amount of plasmid that eventually enters the nucleus and is available for transcription of the transgene still need to be found. The overall conclusions from these studies suggest that, provided these critical improvements are made, DNA vaccines may find important clinical and practical applications in the field of vaccination.

Modulation of immune responses to bovine herpesvirus-1 in cattle by immunization with a DNA vaccine encoding glycoprotein D as a fusion protein with bovine CD154

The objective of this study was to determine whether a DNA vaccine encoding bovine CD154 linked to a truncated version of bovine herpesvirus-1 (BHV-1) glycoprotein D (tgD-CD154) induces enhanced tgD-specific immune responses in cattle. In vitro characterization demonstrated that tgD and tgD-CD154 both bind to cultured bovine B cells, whereas only tgD-CD154 induces interleukin-4-dependent proliferation, suggesting that tgD-CD154 specifically binds the CD40 receptor and induces receptor signalling. Calves were immunized with plasmid encoding either tgD or tgD-CD154 by intradermal injection with a needle-free device. After two immunizations, tgD-specific immune responses were observed in both vaccinated groups and after challenge with BHV-1 these responses further increased. Animals immunized with plasmid encoding tgD-CD154 had significantly higher tgD-specific serum titres of immunoglobulins G and A but significantly lower numbers of tgD-specific interferon-gamma-secreting cells than animals immunized with plasmid encoding tgD after BHV-1 challenge. This suggests that the expression of an antigen as a chimeric protein with CD154 can qualitatively alter immune responses in cattle. Since we previously showed that plasmid encoding tgD-CD154 induces significantly enhanced secondary tgD-specific antibody responses in sheep, there appear to be interspecies differences in the immune responses induced by tgD-CD154, which suggests that both proteins in the chimeric molecule may influence protein targeting and the induction of an immune response.

Efficient transfer of chromosome-based DNA constructs into mammalian cells

Artificial chromosomes, engineered minichromosomes and other chromosome-based DNA constructs are promising new vectors for use in gene therapy, protein production and transgenics. However, a major drawback in the application of chromosome-based DNA is the lack of a suitable and convenient procedure for large-scale cellular introduction, which is particularly frustrated by their size (1 by 2 microm). Here we present a method to transfer Artificial Chromosome Expression systems (ACEs) into mammalian cells, which relies on a combined approach of using cationic amphiphiles and high frequency ultrasound. Thus, when cells were preincubated with liposomes consisting of the cationic lipid SAINT-2 and the phospholipid dioleoylphosphatidylethanolamine (molar ratio 1:1), followed by ultrasound, ACEs could be introduced into mammalian cells, which resulted in the expression of ACEs-harbored reporter genes, such as Green Fluorescent Protein. Depending on cell type, transfection efficiencies ranged from 12% to 53%. Interestingly, no detectable delivery occurred when cells were treated alone with either ultrasound or liposomes. Evidence is provided, based on cellular entry of differently sized beads and trypan-blue permeation, which supports a mechanism in which integration of the lipids creates unstable membrane domains, which are particularly prone to ultrasound-induced pore formation. Time- and temperature-dependent experiments indicate that these pores display a transient stability. Hence, following ultrasound, the pores disappear as a function of time as suggested by a time-window for ACEs entry, and trypan blue exclusion, 80% of the cells becoming stained immediately following ultrasound, dropping to approximately 20% after 30 min. Co-expression of different genes in conjunction with fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis indicates that the current procedure provides a means to introduce functionally active artificial chromosomes into eukaryotic cells.

Microcell-mediated chromosome transfer (MMCT): small cells with huge potential

Microcell-mediated chromosome transfer (MMCT) is a technique that has been in use since the 1970s for the fusion of microcells, containing single or a small number of chromosomes, with whole cells, and the subsequent selection of the hybrids. MMCT can be carried out with somatic cells, embryonic carcinoma (EC) or embryonic stem (ES) cell recipients, to study in vitro or in vivo effects of the transferred genetic material. These effects may be unpredictable--do the transferred genes function normally while in the regulatory milieu of the host cell? Will epigenetic effects become apparent, and how will these alter gene expression? What happens to the host cell phenotype? Here, we present a review of MMCT in which we argue that, although this is an old technique, its adaptability and efficiency make it an excellent method for the dissection of gene function and dysfunction in a very wide range of current systems.

Chromosome-based vectors for gene therapy

Currently used vectors in human gene therapy suffer from a number of limitations with respect to safety and reproducibility. There is increasing agreement that the ideal vector for gene therapy should be completely based on chromosomal elements and behave as an independent functional unit after integration into the genome or when retained as an episome. In this review we will first discuss the chromosomal elements, such as enhancers, locus control regions, boundary elements, insulators and scaffold- or matrix-attachment regions, involved in the hierarchic regulation of mammalian gene expression and replication. These elements have been used to design vectors that behave as artificial domains when integrating into the genome. We then discuss recent progress in the use of mammalian artificial chromosomes and small circular non-viral vectors for their use as expression systems in mammalian cells.

Neocentromeres: role in human disease, evolution, and centromere study

The centromere is essential for the proper segregation and inheritance of genetic information. Neocentromeres are ectopic centromeres that originate occasionally from noncentromeric regions of chromosomes. Despite the complete absence of normal centromeric alpha-satellite DNA, human neocentromeres are able to form a primary constriction and assemble a functional kinetochore. Since the discovery and characterization of the first case of a human neocentromere in our laboratory a decade ago, 60 examples of constitutional human neocentromeres distributed widely across the genome have been described. Typically, these are located on marker chromosomes that have been detected in children with developmental delay or congenital abnormalities. Neocentromeres have also been detected in at least two types of human cancer and have been experimentally induced in Drosophila. Current evidence from human and fly studies indicates that neocentromere activity is acquired epigenetically rather than by any alteration to the DNA sequence. Since human neocentromere formation is generally detrimental to the individual, its biological value must lie beyond the individual level, such as in karyotype evolution and speciation.

Construction of neocentromere-based human minichromosomes for gene delivery and centromere studies

Human neocentromeres are fully functional centromeres that arise naturally in non-centromeric regions devoid of alpha-satellite DNA. We have successfully produced a series of minichromosomes by telomere-associated truncation of a marker chromosome mardel(10) containing a neocentromere. The resulting minichromosomes are either linear or circular in nature, and range in size from approximately 650 kb to 2 Mb. These minichromosomes exhibit full centromeric activity, bind to essential centromere proteins, and are mitotically stable over many generations. They provide a useful system for dissecting the functional domains of complex eukaryotic centromeres and as vectors for therapeutic gene delivery.