Robust estimation of pulse wave transit time using group delay

Improved cerebrovascular reactivity mapping using coherence weighted general linear model in the frequency domain

Cerebrovascular reactivity (CVR) is a prognostic indicator of cerebrovascular health. Estimating CVR from endogenous end-tidal carbon dioxide (CO2) fluctuation and MRI signal recorded under resting state can be difficult due to the poor signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) of signals. Thus, we aimed to improve the method of estimating CVR from end-tidal CO2 and MRI signals. We proposed a coherence weighted general linear model (CW-GLM) to estimate CVR from the Fourier coefficients weighted by the signal coherence in frequency domain, which confers two advantages. First, it requires no signal alignment in time domain, which simplifies experimental methods. Second, it limits the GLM analysis within the frequency band where CO2 and MRI signals are highly correlated, which automatically suppresses noise and nuisance signals. We compared the performance of our method with time-domain GLM (TD-GLM) and frequency-domain GLM (FD-GLM) in both synthetic and in-vivo data; wherein we calculated CVR from signals recorded under both resting state and sinusoidal stimulus. In synthetic data, CW-GLM has a remarkable performance on CVR estimation from narrow band signals with a mean-absolute error of 0.7 % (gray matter) and 1.2 % (white matter), which was lower than all the other methods. Meanwhile, CW-GLM maintains a comparable performance on CVR estimation from resting signals, with a mean-absolute error of 4.1 % (gray matter) and 8 % (white matter). The superior performance was maintained across the 36 in-vivo measurements, with CW-GLM exhibiting limits of agreement of -16.7 % - 9.5 % between CVR calculated from the resting and sinusoidal CO2 paradigms which was 12 % - 209 % better than current time-domain methods. Evaluating of the cross-coherence spectrum revealed highest signal coherence within the frequency band from 0.01 Hz to 0.05 Hz, which overlaps with previously recommended frequency band (0.02 Hz to 0.04 Hz) for CVR analysis. Our data demonstrates that CW-GLM can work as a self-adaptive band-pass filter to improve CVR robustness, while also avoiding the need for signal temporal alignment.

A Novel Form Factor For PPG-based Blood Pressure Monitoring

Blood pressure (BP) is one of the four main vital signs in medicine and may be a useful signal for wellness tracking and for user-aware interfaces in human-computer interaction. The current standard for BP measurement uses cuff-based devices that block an artery temporarily to get a single, discrete measurement of BP. Recently, there have been significant efforts to measure correlates of BP continuously and non-invasively from relevant signals like photoplethysmography (PPG), which responds to volumetric changes in arteries due to blood pulsations. In this paper, we explore a novel setup with two points of instrumentation, one on the head and a second on the wrist, for recording PPG and estimating the pulse wave velocity, which is a major correlate of BP, along with other waveform-related features. We prospectively tested the device on 10 subjects who followed a protocol for the deliberate variation of BP while ground truth measurements were taken using a reference cuff-device. Generic absolute BP models, which use the collected data for leave-one-subject-out cross-validation, yielded an error of -0.14 ± 7.3 mmHg for systolic BP (SBP) and -0.21±6.7 mmHg for diastolic BP (DBP), which are within the regulatory limits of 5 ± 8 mmHg. Notably, the correlation between the predicted BPs and the ground truth BPs was higher for SBP (r = 0.74, p < 0.001) than for DBP (r = 0.34, p < 0.001). The results show that the proposed form factor can extract BP-related features that could be used for continuous, cuff-less BP monitoring.

Aortic Stiffness Measured from Either 2D/4D Flow and Cine MRI or Applanation Tonometry in Coronary Artery Disease: A Case-Control Study

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Aortic stiffness can be evaluated by aortic distensibility or pulse wave velocity (PWV) using applanation tonometry, 2D phase contrast (PC) MRI and the emerging 4D flow MRI. However, such MRI tools may reach their technical limitations in populations with cardiovascular disease. Accordingly, this work focuses on the diagnostic value of aortic stiffness evaluated either by applanation tonometry or MRI in high-risk coronary artery disease (CAD) patients.

METHODS

35 patients with a multivessel CAD and a myocardial infarction treated 1 year before were prospectively recruited and compared with 18 controls with equivalent age and sex distribution. Ascending aorta distensibility and aortic arch 2D PWV were estimated along with 4D PWV. Furthermore, applanation tonometry carotid-to-femoral PWV (cf PWV) was recorded immediately after MRI.

RESULTS

While no significant changes were found for aortic distensibility; cf PWV, 2D PWV and 4D PWV were significantly higher in CAD patients than controls (12.7 ± 2.9 vs. 9.6 ± 1.1; 11.0 ± 3.4 vs. 8.0 ± 2.05 and 17.3 ± 4.0 vs. 8.7 ± 2.5 m·s^-1 respectively, p < 0.001). The receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis performed to assess the ability of stiffness indices to separate CAD subjects from controls revealed the highest area under the curve (AUC) for 4D PWV (0.97) with an optimal threshold of 12.9 m·s^-1 (sensitivity of 88.6% and specificity of 94.4%).

CONCLUSIONS

PWV estimated from 4D flow MRI showed the best diagnostic performances in identifying severe stable CAD patients from age and sex-matched controls, as compared to 2D flow MRI PWV, cf PWV and aortic distensibility.

Magnetic Resonance Imaging and Computed Tomography for the Noninvasive Assessment of Arterial Aging: A Review by the VascAgeNet COST Action

Magnetic resonance imaging and computed tomography allow the characterization of arterial state and function with high confidence and thus play a key role in the understanding of arterial aging and its translation into the clinic. Decades of research into the development of innovative imaging sequences and image analysis techniques have led to the identification of a large number of potential biomarkers, some bringing improvement in basic science, others in clinical practice. Nonetheless, the complexity of some of these biomarkers and the image analysis techniques required for their computation hamper their widespread use. In this narrative review, current biomarkers related to aging of the aorta, their founding principles, the sequence, and postprocessing required, and their predictive values for cardiovascular events are summarized. For each biomarker a summary of reference values and reproducibility studies and limitations is provided. The present review, developed in the COST Action VascAgeNet, aims to guide clinicians and technical researchers in the critical understanding of the possibilities offered by these advanced imaging modalities for studying the state and function of the aorta, and their possible clinically relevant relationships with aging.

Cardiovascular deconditioning and impact of artificial gravity during 60-day head-down bed rest—Insights from 4D flow cardiac MRI

Microgravity has deleterious effects on the cardiovascular system. We evaluated some parameters of blood flow and vascular stiffness during 60 days of simulated microgravity in head-down tilt (HDT) bed rest. We also tested the hypothesis that daily exposure to 30 min of artificial gravity (1 g) would mitigate these adaptations. 24 healthy subjects (8 women) were evenly distributed in three groups: continuous artificial gravity, intermittent artificial gravity, or control. 4D flow cardiac MRI was acquired in horizontal position before (−9 days), during (5, 21, and 56 days), and after (+4 days) the HDT period. The false discovery rate was set at 0.05. The results are presented as median (first quartile; third quartile). No group or group × time differences were observed so the groups were combined. At the end of the HDT phase, we reported a decrease in the stroke volume allocated to the lower body (−30% [−35%; −22%]) and the upper body (−20% [−30%; +11%]), but in different proportions, reflected by an increased share of blood flow towards the upper body. The aortic pulse wave velocity increased (+16% [+9%; +25%]), and so did other markers of arterial stiffness (CAVI; CAVI0). In males, the time-averaged wall shear stress decreased (−13% [−17%; −5%]) and the relative residence time increased (+14% [+5%; +21%]), while these changes were not observed among females. Most of these parameters tended to or returned to baseline after 4 days of recovery. The effects of the artificial gravity countermeasure were not visible. We recommend increasing the load factor, the time of exposure, or combining it with physical exercise. The changes in blood flow confirmed the different adaptations occurring in the upper and lower body, with a larger share of blood volume dedicated to the upper body during (simulated) microgravity. The aorta appeared stiffer during the HDT phase, however all the changes remained subclinical and probably the sole consequence of reversible functional changes caused by reduced blood flow. Interestingly, some wall shear stress markers were more stable in females than in males. No permanent cardiovascular adaptations following 60 days of HDT bed rest were observed.

Influence of Pulse Wave Velocity on Atherosclerosis and Blood Flow Reversal in the Aorta: A 4-Dimensional Flow Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study in Acute Stroke Patients and Matched Controls

BACKGROUND

Aortic stiffness is associated with a higher incidence of cardiovascular events including stroke. The primary aim of this study was to evaluate whether increased pulse wave velocity (PWV), a marker of stiffness, is an independent predictor of aortic atheroma. The secondary aim was to test whether increased PWV reinforces retrograde blood flow from the descending aorta (DAo), a mechanism of stroke.

METHODS

We performed a cross-sectional case-control study with prospective data acquisition. In all, 40 stroke and 60 ophthalmic patients matched for age and cardiovascular risk factors were included. Multicontrast magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) protocol of the aorta tailored to allow a detailed plaque analysis using 3-dimensional (D) T1-weighted bright blood, T2-weighted and proton density-weighted black blood, and hemodynamic assessment using 4D flow MRI was applied. Individual PWV was calculated based on 4D flow MRI data using the time-to-foot of the blood flow waveform. The extent of maximum retrograde blood flow from the proximal DAo into the arch was quantified.

RESULTS

PWV was higher in stroke patients compared with controls (7.62±2.59 vs. 5.96±2.49 m/s; P=0.005) and in patients with plaques (irrespective of thickness) compared with patients without plaques (7.47±2.89 vs. 5.62±1.89 m/s; P=0.002). Increased PWV was an independent predictor of plaque prevalence and contributed significantly to a predictor model explaining 36.5% (Nagelkerke R2) of the variance in plaque presence. Maximum retrograde flow extent from the proximal DAo was not correlated with PWV.

CONCLUSIONS

Aortic stiffness was higher in stroke patients and associated with a higher prevalence of plaques. Increased PWV was an independent predictor of plaque presence. Accordingly, regional PWV seems to be a valuable biomarker for the assessment and management of aortic atherosclerosis. However, no association was found for increased retrograde flow extent from the DAo.

Group delay method for MRI aortic pulse wave velocity measurements in clinical protocols with low temporal resolution: Validation in a heterogeneous cohort

BACKGROUND

MRI assessment of aortic pulse wave velocity (PWV) helps predict the risk of vascular events, but the recommended phase contrast sampling rate is faster than what is utilized in most clinical sequences. There are many existing MRI databases obtained for assessment of cardiac output using lower temporal frequency sampling where information might be obtained about aortic stiffness (PWV). In this work, we sought to evaluate whether the Group Delay (GD) method can generate a reproducible measure of stiffness and describe expected age-related stiffening of the aortic arch using lower sampling rates in standard clinical sequences.

METHODS

Phase contrast (PC) MRI was obtained on the ascending and descending aortic arch in a heterogeneous adult cohort (n = 23; 9 women) spanning over a wide range of ages (ages 24-89, mean 49.4 ± 18.4). Data was collected with standard cardiac MRI protocols for cardiac output evaluation (repetition time = 7.8 ms, views-per-segment = 4, encoding velocity = 200 cm/s). Pulse wave transit times (TT) were computed using the GD method, two other validated automated approaches (cross correlation TT Algorithm by Gaddum and Segment by Medviso), and the manual tangent method. Pressure waveforms from tonometry and flow waveforms from PC MRI were used to assess wave reflections.

RESULTS

Group Delay and TT-Algorithm showed significant and high retest reproducibility (r = 0.86 for both) as well as high PWV correlation with age (r = 0.93, P-value < 0.00005 and r = 0.96, P-value < 0.00005 respectively) and with each other (r = 0.94, P-value < 0.00001, RMSE = 0.94 m/s). Arbitrary altering of the image acquisition trigger in the GD method introduced error of 10%-13%, but the TT-algorithm error range was 11%-25%.

CONCLUSION

Group Delay enables reproducible assessment of transit time to derive PWV from low temporal resolution clinical cardiac MRI sequences that can also identify age-related stiffening.

Comparison of different methods for the estimation of aortic pulse wave velocity from 4D flow cardiovascular magnetic resonance

BACKGROUND

Arterial pulse wave velocity (PWV) is associated with increased mortality in aging and disease. Several studies have shown the accuracy of applanation tonometry carotid-femoral PWV (Cf-PWV) and the relevance of evaluating central aorta stiffness using 2D cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) to estimate PWV, and aortic distensibility-derived PWV through the theoretical Bramwell-Hill model (BH-PWV). Our aim was to compare various methods of aortic PWV (aoPWV) estimation from 4D flow CMR, in terms of associations with age, Cf-PWV, BH-PWV and left ventricular (LV) mass-to-volume ratio while evaluating inter-observer reproducibility and robustness to temporal resolution.

METHODS

We studied 47 healthy subjects (49.5 ± 18 years) who underwent Cf-PWV and CMR including aortic 4D flow CMR as well as 2D cine SSFP for BH-PWV and LV mass-to-volume ratio estimation. The aorta was semi-automatically segmented from 4D flow data, and mean velocity waveforms were estimated in 25 planes perpendicular to the aortic centerline. 4D flow CMR aoPWV was calculated: using velocity curves at two locations, namely ascending aorta (AAo) and distal descending aorta (DAo) aorta (S1, 2D-like strategy), or using all velocity curves along the entire aortic centreline (3D-like strategies) with iterative transit time (TT) estimates (S2) or a plane fitting of velocity curves systolic upslope (S3). For S1 and S2, TT was calculated using three approaches: cross-correlation (TTc), wavelets (TTw) and Fourier transforms (TTf). Intra-class correlation coefficients (ICC) and Bland-Altman biases (BA) were used to evaluate inter-observer reproducibility and effect of lower temporal resolution.

RESULTS

4D flow CMR aoPWV estimates were significantly (p < 0.05) correlated to the CMR-independent Cf-PWV, BH-PWV, age and LV mass-to-volume ratio, with the strongest correlations for the 3D-like strategy using wavelets TT (S2-TTw) (R = 0.62, 0.65, 0.77 and 0.52, respectively, all p < 0.001). S2-TTw was also highly reproducible (ICC = 0.99, BA = 0.09 m/s) and robust to lower temporal resolution (ICC = 0.97, BA = 0.15 m/s).

CONCLUSIONS

Reproducible 4D flow CMR aoPWV estimates can be obtained using full 3D aortic coverage. Such 4D flow CMR stiffness measures were significantly associated with Cf-PWV, BH-PWV, age and LV mass-to-volume ratio, with a slight superiority of the 3D strategy using wavelets transit time (S2-TTw).

Local Pulse Wave Velocity: Theory, Methods, Advancements, and Clinical Applications

Local pulse wave velocity (PWV) is evolving as one of the important determinants of arterial hemodynamics, localized vessel stiffening associated with several pathologies, and a host of other cardiovascular events. Although PWV was introduced over a century ago, only in recent decades, due to various technological advancements, has emphasis been directed toward its measurement from a single arterial section or from piecewise segments of a target arterial section. This emerging worldwide trend in the exploration of instrumental solutions for local PWV measurement has produced several invasive and noninvasive methods. As of yet, however, a univocal opinion on the ideal measurement method has not emerged. Neither have there been extensive comparative studies on the accuracy of the available methods. Recognizing this reality, makes apparent the need to establish guideline-recommended standards for the measurement methods and reference values, without which clinical application cannot be pursued. This paper enumerates all major local PWV measurement methods while pinpointing their salient methodological considerations and emphasizing the necessity of global standardization. Further, a summary of the advancements in measuring modalities and clinical applications is provided. Additionally, a detailed discussion on the minimally explored concept of incremental local PWV is presented along with suggestions of future research questions.

Proximal aortic stiffening in Turner patients may be present before dilation can be detected: a segmental functional MRI study

BACKGROUND

To study segmental structural and functional aortic properties in Turner syndrome (TS) patients. Aortic abnormalities contribute to increased morbidity and mortality of women with Turner syndrome. Cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) allows segmental study of aortic elastic properties.

METHOD

We performed Pulse Wave Velocity (PWV) and distensibility measurements using CMR of the thoracic and abdominal aorta in 55 TS-patients, aged 13-59y, and in a control population (n = 38;12-58y). We investigated the contribution of TS on aortic stiffness in our entire cohort, in bicuspid (BAV) versus tricuspid (TAV) aortic valve-morphology subgroups, and in the younger and older subgroups.

RESULTS

Differences in aortic properties were only seen at the most proximal aortic level. BAV Turner patients had significantly higher PWV, compared to TAV Turner (p = 0.014), who in turn had significantly higher PWV compared to controls (p = 0.010). BAV Turner patients had significantly larger ascending aortic (AA) luminal area and lower AA distensibility compared to both controls (all p < 0.01) and TAV Turner patients. TAV Turner had similar AA luminal areas and AA distensibility compared to Controls. Functional changes are present in younger and older Turner subjects, whereas ascending aortic dilation is prominent in older Turner patients. Clinically relevant dilatation (TAV and BAV) was associated with reduced distensibility.

CONCLUSION

Aortic stiffening and dilation in TS affects the proximal aorta, and is more pronounced, although not exclusively, in BAV TS patients. Functional abnormalities are present at an early age, suggesting an aortic wall disease inherent to the TS. Whether this increased stiffness at young age can predict later dilatation needs to be studied longitudinally.

BOLD delay times using group delay in sickle cell disease

Sickle cell disease (SCD) is an inherited blood disorder that effects red blood cells, which can lead to vasoocclusion, ischemia and infarct. This disease often results in neurological damage and strokes, leading to morbidity and mortality. Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI) is a non-invasive technique for measuring and mapping the brain activity. Blood Oxygenation Level-Dependent (BOLD) signals contain also information about the neurovascular coupling, vascular reactivity, oxygenation and blood propagation. Temporal relationship between BOLD fluctuations in different parts of the brain provides also a mean to investigate the blood delay information. We used the induced desaturation as a label to profile transit times through different brain areas, reflecting oxygen utilization of tissue. In this study, we aimed to compare blood flow propagation delay times between these patients and healthy subjects in areas vascularized by anterior, middle and posterior cerebral arteries. In a group comparison analysis with control subjects, BOLD changes in these areas were found to be almost simultaneous and shorter in the SCD patients, because of their increased brain blood flow. Secondly, the analysis of a patient with a stenosis on the anterior cerebral artery indicated that signal of the area vascularized by this artery lagged the MCA signal. These findings suggest that sickle cell disease causes blood propagation modifications, and that these changes could be used as a biomarker of vascular damage.

Toward Ubiquitous Blood Pressure Monitoring via Pulse Transit Time: Theory and Practice

Ubiquitous blood pressure (BP) monitoring is needed to improve hypertension detection and control and is becoming feasible due to recent technological advances such as in wearable sensing. Pulse transit time (PTT) represents a well-known potential approach for ubiquitous BP monitoring. The goal of this review is to facilitate the achievement of reliable ubiquitous BP monitoring via PTT. We explain the conventional BP measurement methods and their limitations; present models to summarize the theory of the PTT-BP relationship; outline the approach while pinpointing the key challenges; overview the previous work toward putting the theory to practice; make suggestions for best practice and future research; and discuss realistic expectations for the approach.

Estimation of aortic pulse wave transit time in cardiovascular magnetic resonance using complex wavelet cross-spectrum analysis

BACKGROUND

Aortic pulse wave velocity (PWV), which substantially increases with arterial stiffness and aging, is a major predictor of cardiovascular mortality. It is commonly estimated using applanation tonometry at carotid and femoral arterial sites (cfPWV). More recently, several cardiovascular magnetic resonance (CMR) studies have focused on the measurement of aortic arch PWV (archPWV). Although the excellent anatomical coverage of CMR offers reliable segmental measurement of arterial length, accurate transit time (TT) determination remains a challenge. Recently, it has been demonstrated that Fourier-based methods were more robust to low temporal resolution than time-based approaches.

METHODS

We developed a wavelet-based method, which enables temporal localization of signal frequencies, to estimate TT from ascending and descending aortic CMR flow curves. This method (archPWVWU) combines the robustness of Fourier-based methods to low temporal resolution with the possibility to restrict the analysis to the reflectionless systolic upslope. We compared this method with Fourier-based (archPWVF) and time domain upslope (archPWVTU) methods in relation to linear correlations with age, cfPWV and effects of decreasing temporal resolution by factors of 2, 3 and 4. We studied 71 healthy subjects (45 ± 15 years, 29 females) who underwent CMR velocity acquisitions and cfPWV measurements.

RESULTS

Comparison with age resulted in the highest correlation for the wavelet-based method (archPWVWU:r = 0.84,p < 0.001; archPWVTU:r = 0.74,p < 0.001; archPWVF:r = 0.63,p < 0.001). Associations with cfPWV resulted in the highest correlations for upslope techniques whether based on wavelet (archPWVWU:r = 0.58,p < 0.001) or time (archPWVTU:r = 0.58,p < 0.001) approach. Furthermore, while decreasing temporal resolution by 4-fold induced only a minor decrease in correlation of both archPWVWU (r decreased from 0.84 to 0.80) and archPWVF (r decreased from 0.63 to 0.51) with age, it induced a major decrease for the archPWVTU age relationship (r decreased from 0.74 to 0.38).

CONCLUSIONS

By CMR, measurement of aortic arch flow TT using systolic upslopes resulted in a better correlation with age and cfPWV, as compared to the Fourier-based approach applied on the entire cardiac cycle. Furthermore, methods based on harmonic decomposition were less affected by low temporal resolution. Since the proposed wavelet approach combines these two advantages, it might help to overcome current technical limitations related to CMR temporal resolution and evaluation of patients with highly stiff arteries.