Polyethylene glycol-fusion repair of sciatic allografts in female rats achieves immunotolerance via attenuated innate and adaptive responses

Polyethylene glycol fusion repair of severed rat sciatic nerves reestablishes axonal continuity and reorganizes sensory terminal fields in the spinal cord

JOURNAL/nrgr/04.03/01300535-202507000-00030/figure1/v/2024-09-09T124005Z/r/image-tiff Peripheral nerve injuries result in the rapid degeneration of distal nerve segments and immediate loss of motor and sensory functions; behavioral recovery is typically poor. We used a plasmalemmal fusogen, polyethylene glycol (PEG), to immediately fuse closely apposed open ends of severed proximal and distal axons in rat sciatic nerves. We have previously reported that sciatic nerve axons repaired by PEG-fusion do not undergo Wallerian degeneration, and PEG-fused animals exhibit rapid (within 2-6 weeks) and extensive locomotor recovery. Furthermore, our previous report showed that PEG-fusion of severed sciatic motor axons was non-specific, i.e., spinal motoneurons in PEG-fused animals were found to project to appropriate as well as inappropriate target muscles. In this study, we examined the consequences of PEG-fusion for sensory axons of the sciatic nerve. Young adult male and female rats (Sprague-Dawley) received either a unilateral single cut or ablation injury to the sciatic nerve and subsequent repair with or without (Negative Control) the application of PEG. Compound action potentials recorded immediately after PEG-fusion repair confirmed conduction across the injury site. The success of PEG-fusion was confirmed through Sciatic Functional Index testing with PEG-fused animals showing improvement in locomotor function beginning at 35 days postoperatively. At 2-42 days postoperatively, we anterogradely labeled sensory afferents from the dorsal aspect of the hindpaw following bilateral intradermal injection of wheat germ agglutinin conjugated horseradish peroxidase. PEG-fusion repair reestablished axonal continuity. Compared to unoperated animals, labeled sensory afferents ipsilateral to the injury in PEG-fused animals were found in the appropriate area of the dorsal horn, as well as inappropriate mediolateral and rostrocaudal areas. Unexpectedly, despite having intact peripheral nerves, similar reorganizations of labeled sensory afferents were also observed contralateral to the injury and repair. This central reorganization may contribute to the improved behavioral recovery seen after PEG-fusion repair, supporting the use of this novel repair methodology over currently available treatments.

Polyethylene glycol has immunoprotective effects on sciatic allografts, but behavioral recovery and graft tolerance require neurorrhaphy and axonal fusion

JOURNAL/nrgr/04.03/01300535-202504000-00033/figure1/v/2024-07-06T104127Z/r/image-tiff Behavioral recovery using (viable) peripheral nerve allografts to repair ablation-type (segmental-loss) peripheral nerve injuries is delayed or poor due to slow and inaccurate axonal regeneration. Furthermore, such peripheral nerve allografts undergo immunological rejection by the host immune system. In contrast, peripheral nerve injuries repaired by polyethylene glycol fusion of peripheral nerve allografts exhibit excellent behavioral recovery within weeks, reduced immune responses, and many axons do not undergo Wallerian degeneration. The relative contribution of neurorrhaphy and polyethylene glycol-fusion of axons versus the effects of polyethylene glycol per se was unknown prior to this study. We hypothesized that polyethylene glycol might have some immune-protective effects, but polyethylene glycol-fusion was necessary to prevent Wallerian degeneration and functional/behavioral recovery. We examined how polyethylene glycol solutions per se affect functional and behavioral recovery and peripheral nerve allograft morphological and immunological responses in the absence of polyethylene glycol-induced axonal fusion. Ablation-type sciatic nerve injuries in outbred Sprague-Dawley rats were repaired according to a modified protocol using the same solutions as polyethylene glycol-fused peripheral nerve allografts, but peripheral nerve allografts were loose-sutured (loose-sutured polyethylene glycol) with an intentional gap of 1-2 mm to prevent fusion by polyethylene glycol of peripheral nerve allograft axons with host axons. Similar to negative control peripheral nerve allografts not treated by polyethylene glycol and in contrast to polyethylene glycol-fused peripheral nerve allografts, animals with loose-sutured polyethylene glycol peripheral nerve allografts exhibited Wallerian degeneration for all axons and myelin degeneration by 7 days postoperatively and did not recover sciatic-mediated behavioral functions by 42 days postoperatively. Other morphological signs of rejection, such as collapsed Schwann cell basal lamina tubes, were absent in polyethylene glycol-fused peripheral nerve allografts but commonly observed in negative control and loose-sutured polyethylene glycol peripheral nerve allografts at 21 days postoperatively. Loose-sutured polyethylene glycol peripheral nerve allografts had more pro-inflammatory and less anti-inflammatory macrophages than negative control peripheral nerve allografts. While T cell counts were similarly high in loose-sutured-polyethylene glycol and negative control peripheral nerve allografts, loose-sutured polyethylene glycol peripheral nerve allografts expressed some cytokines/chemokines important for T cell activation at much lower levels at 14 days postoperatively. MHCI expression was elevated in loose-sutured polyethylene glycol peripheral nerve allografts, but MHCII expression was modestly lower compared to negative control at 21 days postoperatively. We conclude that, while polyethylene glycol per se reduces some immune responses of peripheral nerve allografts, successful polyethylene glycol-fusion repair of some axons is necessary to prevent Wallerian degeneration of those axons and immune rejection of peripheral nerve allografts, and produce recovery of sensory/motor functions and voluntary behaviors. Translation of polyethylene glycol-fusion technologies would produce a paradigm shift from the current clinical practice of waiting days to months to repair ablation peripheral nerve injuries.

Engineering the Future of Restorative Clinical Peripheral Nerve Surgery

Peripheral nerve injury is a significant clinical challenge, often leading to permanent functional deficits. Standard interventions, such as autologous nerve grafts or distal nerve transfers, require sacrificing healthy nerve tissue and typically result in limited motor or sensory recovery. Nerve regeneration is complex and influenced by several factors: 1) the regenerative capacity of proximal neurons, 2) the ability of axons and support cells to bridge the injury, 3) the capacity of Schwann cells to maintain a supportive environment, and 4) the readiness of target muscles or sensory organs for reinnervation. Emerging bioengineering solutions, including biomaterials, drug delivery systems, fusogens, electrical stimulation devices, and tissue-engineered products, aim to address these challenges. Effective translation of these therapies requires a deep understanding of the physiology and pathology of nerve injury. This article proposes a comprehensive framework for developing restorative strategies that address all four major physiological responses in nerve repair. By implementing this framework, we envision a paradigm shift that could potentially enable full functional recovery for patients, where current approaches offer minimal hope.

An analysis of differential gene expression in peripheral nerve and muscle utilizing RNA sequencing after polyethylene glycol nerve fusion in a rat sciatic nerve injury model

Application of polyethylene glycol (PEG) to a peripheral nerve injury at the time of primary neurorrhaphy is thought to prevent Wallerian degeneration via direct axolemma fusion. The molecular mechanisms of nerve fusion and recovery are unclear. Our study tested the hypothesis that PEG alters gene expression in neural and muscular environments as part of its restorative properties. Lewis rats underwent unilateral sciatic nerve transection with immediate primary repair. Subjects were randomly assigned to receive either PEG treatment or standard repair at the time of neurorrhaphy. Samples of sciatic nerve distal to the injury and tibialis muscle at the site of innervation were harvested at 24 hours and 4 weeks postoperatively. Total RNA sequencing and subsequent bioinformatics analyses were used to identify significant differences in differentially expressed genes (DEGs) and their related biological pathways (p<0.05) in PEG-treated subjects compared to non-PEG controls. No significant DEGs were identified in PEG-treated sciatic nerve compared to controls after 24 hours, but 1,480 DEGs were identified in PEG-treated tibialis compared to controls. At 4 weeks, 918 DEGs were identified in PEG-treated sciatic nerve, whereas only 3 DEGs remained in PEG-treated tibialis compared to controls. DEGs in sciatic were mostly upregulated (79%) and enriched in pathways present during nervous system development and growth, whereas DEGs in muscle were mostly downregulated (77%) and related to inflammation and tissue repair. Our findings indicate that PEG application during primary neurorrhaphy leads to significant differential gene regulation in the neural and muscular environment that is associated with improved functional recovery in animals treated with PEG compared to sham non-PEG controls. A detailed understanding of key molecules underlying PEG function in recovery after peripheral nerve repair may facilitate amplification of PEG effects through systemic or focal treatments at the time of neurotmesis.

The Role of Nerve Tension on Nerve Repair Success

Peripheral nerve injuries that are not acutely repaired may lead to a nerve gap because of the surrounding zone of injury and elastic recoil of nerve tissue after laceration. This can result in tension across the repair site during primary neurorrhaphy. Decades of basic science literature using in vivo models consistently demonstrate a relationship between increasing strain at a neurorrhaphy site and compromised microvascular blood flow. Clinical and laboratory data suggest tension-free repairs are associated with optimal outcomes; in the setting of a short segmental nerve gap, data suggest primary repair may continue to yield good functional results. In the case of high strain, nerve grafting or other methods should be considered given poor results of primary repairs performed under high tension because of local ischemia and fibrosis on a cellular level.

Polyethylene Glycol-Fusion Repair of Peripheral Nerve Injuries

Axons successfully repaired with polyethylene glycol (PEG) fusion tecnology restored axonal continuity thereby preventing their Wallerian degeneration and minimizing muscle atrophy. PEG fusion studies in animal models and preliminary clinical trials involving patients with digital nerve repair have shown promise for this therapeutic approach. PEG fusion is safe to perform, and given the enormous potential benefits, there is no reason not to explore its therapeutic potential.

3D Printed Personalized Nerve Guide Conduits for Precision Repair of Peripheral Nerve Defects

The treatment of peripheral nerve defects has always been one of the most challenging clinical practices in neurosurgery. Currently, nerve autograft is the preferred treatment modality for peripheral nerve defects, while the therapy is constantly plagued by the limited donor, loss of donor function, formation of neuroma, nerve distortion or dislocation, and nerve diameter mismatch. To address these clinical issues, the emerged nerve guide conduits (NGCs) are expected to offer effective platforms to repair peripheral nerve defects, especially those with large or complex topological structures. Up to now, numerous technologies are developed for preparing diverse NGCs, such as solvent casting, gas foaming, phase separation, freeze-drying, melt molding, electrospinning, and three-dimensional (3D) printing. 3D printing shows great potential and advantages because it can quickly and accurately manufacture the required NGCs from various natural and synthetic materials. This review introduces the application of personalized 3D printed NGCs for the precision repair of peripheral nerve defects and predicts their future directions.

Innovations in Peripheral Nerve Injury: Current Concepts and Emerging Techniques to Improve Recovery

Despite the surgical advances in treatment of peripheral nerve injuries, consistent recovery of function is limited suggesting that a multimodal approach is required to optimize nerve regeneration. This approach should include advanced surgical repair techniques, as well as tissue engineering, cellular therapies, and application of local and systemic modulators of neuroregeneration. Further research is needed to advance these therapies from the laboratory to clinical practice, and to further understand how these treatments and techniques can act in concert to optimize functional nerve regeneration.

Typical and atypical properties of peripheral nerve allografts enable novel strategies to repair segmental-loss injuries

We review data showing that peripheral nerve injuries (PNIs) that involve the loss of a nerve segment are the most common type of traumatic injury to nervous systems. Segmental-loss PNIs have a poor prognosis compared to other injuries, especially when one or more mixed motor/sensory nerves are involved and are typically the major source of disability associated with extremities that have sustained other injuries. Relatively little progress has been made, since the treatment of segmental loss PNIs with cable autografts that are currently the gold standard for repair has slow and incomplete (often non-existent) functional recovery. Viable peripheral nerve allografts (PNAs) to repair segmental-loss PNIs have not been experimentally or clinically useful due to their immunological rejection, Wallerian degeneration (WD) of anucleate donor graft and distal host axons, and slow regeneration of host axons, leading to delayed re-innervation and producing atrophy or degeneration of distal target tissues. However, two significant advances have recently been made using viable PNAs to repair segmental-loss PNIs: (1) hydrogel release of Treg cells that reduce the immunological response and (2) PEG-fusion of donor PNAs that reduce the immune response, reduce and/or suppress much WD, immediately restore axonal conduction across the donor graft and re-innervate many target tissues, and restore much voluntary behavioral functions within weeks, sometimes to levels approaching that of uninjured nerves. We review the rather sparse cellular/biochemical data for rejection of conventional PNAs and their acceptance following Treg hydrogel and PEG-fusion of PNAs, as well as cellular and systemic data for their acceptance and remarkable behavioral recovery in the absence of tissue matching or immune suppression. We also review typical and atypical characteristics of PNAs compared with other types of tissue or organ allografts, problems and potential solutions for PNA use and storage, clinical implications and commercial availability of PNAs, and future possibilities for PNAs to repair segmental-loss PNIs.

Functional and immunological peculiarities of peripheral nerve allografts

This review addresses the accumulating evidence that live (not decellularized) allogeneic peripheral nerves are functionally and immunologically peculiar in comparison with many other transplanted allogeneic tissues. This is relevant because live peripheral nerve allografts are very effective at promoting recovery after segmental peripheral nerve injury via axonal regeneration and axon fusion. Understanding the immunological peculiarities of peripheral nerve allografts may also be of interest to the field of transplantation in general. Three topics are addressed: The first discusses peripheral nerve injury and the potential utility of peripheral nerve allografts for bridging segmental peripheral nerve defects via axon fusion and axon regeneration. The second reviews evidence that peripheral nerve allografts elicit a more gradual and less severe host immune response allowing for prolonged survival and function of allogeneic peripheral nerve cells and structures. Lastly, potential mechanisms that may account for the immunological differences of peripheral nerve allografts are discussed.

Methylene blue enhances polyethylene glycol-fusion repair of completely severed rat sciatic nerves

Complete transection of peripheral mixed nerves immediately produces loss of sensory perception, muscle contractions and voluntary behavior mediated by the severed distal axons. In contrast to natural regeneration (~1 mm/d) of proximal axons that may eventually reinnervate denervated targets, re-innervation is restored within minutes by PEG-fusion that consists of neurorrhaphy and a sequence of well specified hypo- and isotonic calcium-free or calcium-containing solutions, the anti-oxidant methylene blue (MB) and the membrane fusogen polyethylene glycol (PEG). In this study, we examined the relative efficacy of PEG-fusion with no MB (0%), 0.5% MB, or 1% MB on the recovery of voluntary behaviors by female Sprague-Dawley rats with a complete mid-thigh severance of their sciatic nerve bathed in extracellular fluid or calcium-containing isotonic saline. The recovery of voluntary behaviors is the most relevant measure of success of any technique to repair peripheral nerve injuries. We assessed recovery by the sciatic functional index, a commonly used measure of voluntary hindlimb behaviors following complete sciatic transections. We reported that both 1% MB and 0.5% MB in sterile distilled water in our PEG-fusion protocol with neurorrhaphy significantly increased the rate and extent of behavioral recovery compared to PEG plus neurorrhaphy alone. Furthermore, 0.5% MB was as effective as 1% MB in voluntary behavioral recovery as assessed by the sciatic functional index. Since sterile 1% MB is no longer clinically available, we therefore recommend that 0.5% MB be included in upcoming human clinical trials to evaluate the safety and efficacy of PEG-fusion. All animal procedures were approved by the University of Texas Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee (AUP-2019-00225) on September 9, 2020.

Coding transcriptome analyses reveal altered functions underlying immunotolerance of PEG-fused rat sciatic nerve allografts

BACKGROUND

Current methods to repair ablation-type peripheral nerve injuries (PNIs) using peripheral nerve allografts (PNAs) often result in poor functional recovery due to immunological rejection as well as to slow and inaccurate outgrowth of regenerating axonal sprouts. In contrast, ablation-type PNIs repaired by PNAs, using a multistep protocol in which one step employs the membrane fusogen polyethylene glycol (PEG), permanently restore sciatic-mediated behaviors within weeks. Axons and cells within PEG-fused PNAs remain viable, even though outbred host and donor tissues are neither immunosuppressed nor tissue matched. PEG-fused PNAs exhibit significantly reduced T cell and macrophage infiltration, expression of major histocompatibility complex I/II and consistently low apoptosis. In this study, we analyzed the coding transcriptome of PEG-fused PNAs to examine possible mechanisms underlying immunosuppression.

METHODS

Ablation-type sciatic PNIs in adult Sprague-Dawley rats were repaired using PNAs and a PEG-fusion protocol combined with neurorrhaphy. Electrophysiological and behavioral tests confirmed successful PEG-fusion of PNAs. RNA sequencing analyzed differential expression profiles of protein-coding genes between PEG-fused PNAs and negative control PNAs (not treated with PEG) at 14 days PO, along with unoperated control nerves. Sequencing results were validated by quantitative reverse transcription PCR (RT-qPCR), and in some cases, immunohistochemistry.

RESULTS

PEG-fused PNAs display significant downregulation of many gene transcripts associated with innate and adaptive allorejection responses. Schwann cell-associated transcripts are often upregulated, and cellular processes such as extracellular matrix remodeling and cell/tissue development are particularly enriched. Transcripts encoding several potentially immunosuppressive proteins (e.g., thrombospondins 1 and 2) also are upregulated in PEG-fused PNAs.

CONCLUSIONS

This study is the first to characterize the coding transcriptome of PEG-fused PNAs and to identify possible links between alterations of the extracellular matrix and suppression of the allorejection response. The results establish an initial molecular basis to understand mechanisms underlying PEG-mediated immunosuppression.