Treatment selection for base of tongue carcinoma

Survival patterns in patients with carcinoma base of tongue treated with external beam irradiation and salvage surgery

OBJECTIVE

The current study was designed to assess the treatment results and survival in the patients with carcinoma of base of tongue that were treated with primary radiotherapy, radiotherapy with chemotherapy and salvage surgery when indicated.

DESIGN

A prospective study was carried out in 78 cases of carcinoma of the base of tongue between 1995 and 1999.

METHODS

The majority of cases belonged to stage IV 60/78 (76.92%) as per AJCC staging. Radiotherapy in the dose of 60 Gy was given primarily to the patients with stage III tongue base cancer. Patients with early stage IV cancer were given split course radiotherapy followed by assessment for surgery. For the patients with advanced stage IV disease with poor general condition, palliative radiotherapy of 24 Gy with or without palliative chemotherapy was given. 15 patients were subjected to salvage surgery in the form of radical neck dissection alone (8 cases), extended total laryngectomy with neck dissection (3 cases), extended total laryngectomy (2 cases) and extended supraglottic laryngectomy with RND in 2 cases.

RESULTS

Two and 5 years Kaplan - Meier actuarial survival rates were 45% and 10% respectively with local control rates equivalent to survival rates. All surviving patients maintained good function and quality-of-life with few tolerable side effects.

CONCLUSIONS

External beam radiotherapy with salvage surgery results in satisfactory local and regional control in stage III and IV carcinoma base of tongue.

Carcinoma of the oral pharynx: an analysis of subsite treatment heterogeneity

The data indicate that SCC of the various subsites of the oropharynx can be treated successfully with acceptable locoregional control and survival rates by using either surgery or primary radiotherapy for TI or T2 primary lesions. Treatment success data for late-stage disease (T3 and T4) are less encouraging. regardless of which modality is used or which treatment center is administering treatment. This finding may suggest an intrinsic property of these lesions or the patient that may be going unnoticed.One problem is that the diversity of approaches to these lesions hinders any meaningful comparisons between series from different treatment centers. There exists heterogeneity in patient populations and approaches to staging and characterization of these diseases. This situation has ensured the same heterogeneity in treatment philosophy, which is largely institutionally based.

Effect of treatment time on outcome of radiotherapy for oral tongue carcinoma

PURPOSE

To investigate the importance of total treatment time on the outcome of external beam radiotherapy (EBRT) followed by internal brachytherapy for the treatment of oral tongue carcinoma.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Ninety-four patients with T1-T2N0 squamous cell carcinoma of the oral tongue were treated using 35-40 Gy EBRT followed by 35-40 Gy interstitial (137)Cs brachytherapy between 1985 and 1995. The interval between the end of EBRT and the start of interstitial treatment varied for numerous unavoidable reasons, with a mean of 25.3 days and standard deviation of 3.5 days. The median follow-up period was 59.1 months (range 6-146).

RESULTS

The actuarial survival rate of all cases was 78.4% at 5 years. The 5-year local control rate for those with T1 and T2 was 92.8% and 62.7%, respectively (p < 0.05). The local control rate of the primary tumor in patients with a total treatment time >43 days was statistically lower than that of patients with a total treatment time < or =43 days in all patients (p < 0.05) and in the subgroup of Stage T2 patients (p < 0.05). Multivariate analysis revealed that the local control rates in all cases were significantly related to the T stage (T2 or not), total treatment time (>43 days or not), and location of disease (posterior or not). Regression analysis for 5-year local control as a function of treatment duration showed a 2% loss of local control per day of treatment extension >30 days (r = 0.94, p < 0.01).

CONCLUSION

The total treatment time was associated with the local control rate in the RT of oral tongue carcinoma. The loss in local control was estimated to be 2.0% per additional day in our series for oral tongue carcinoma.

Analysis of treatment results for base of tongue cancer

OBJECTIVE

The study reported the results of treatment for base of tongue cancer with five different treatment modalities with long-term follow-up.

STUDY DESIGN

This was a retrospective study of 262 patients with base of tongue cancer treated in the Departments of Otolaryngology-Head and Neck Surgery and Radiation Therapy at Washington University School of Medicine (St. Louis, MO) from July 1955 to January 1998.

METHODS

The study population included previously untreated patients with biopsy-proven squamous cell carcinoma of the base of tongue who were treated with curative intent by one of five modalities and were all eligible for 5-year follow-up. The treatment modalities included local resection alone, composite resection alone, radiation therapy alone, local resection with radiation therapy, and composite resection with radiation therapy. Multiple diagnostic, treatment, and follow-up parameters were studied using standard statistical analysis to determine statistical significance.

RESULTS

The overall 5-year disease-specific survival (DSS) was 49.6% with death due to tumor in 50.4%. The 5-year cumulative disease-specific survival probability (CDSS) was 0.526 (Kaplan-Meier) with a mean of 7.8 years and a median of 5.6 years. Patients with early disease had significantly improved DSS compared with patients with more advanced disease (stages I and II; TN stages T1N0, T2N0, and T2N1; and T stages T1 and T2.). Patients with N0 had better DSS than patients with positive lymph nodes (P =.010). The DSS for all stages by treatment modality included local resection (70.0%), composite resection (47.6%), radiation therapy (40.4%), local resection and radiation therapy (50.0%), and composite resection with radiation therapy (51.5%). Overall and within the stages there was no significant difference in either DSS or CDSS by treatment modality. Local-regional recurrence occurred in 26% of patients, and overall salvage was 10.5%. Patients with clear resection margins did better than patients with close or involved margins (DSS and CDSS). Patients treated with radiation therapy alone had improved capacity to swallow (P =.001), speak (P =.01), and work (P =.001) compared with patients treated with the other modalities.

CONCLUSIONS

Cancer of the base of tongue is a lethal disease, and its treatment results in significant disability. No treatment produced a significantly improved survival advantage. Focus on improving local-regional control might improve overall survival. All treatment modalities were associated with major treatment-related complications. Radiation alone produced significantly improved post-treatment function and quality of life compared with the other modalities. Because of the recurrence rates at the primary and neck sites and the high rates of development of distant metastasis and second primary cancers, patients should be monitored for a minimum of at least 4 years.

Advanced squamous cell carcinoma of the base of the tongue treated with surgery and post-operative radiotherapy

BACKGROUND

Early stage squamous cell carcinoma of the base of the tongue has been successfully treated with radiotherapy and brachytherapy. However, the vast majority of these tumours seen in Western Europe are already at an advanced stage. Medical records of 79 patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the base of the tongue treated between 1980 and 1994 were examined.

METHODS

Eighty-three per cent of the primary tumours were stage T3 or T4. Fifty-nine patients were treated with surgery and post-operative radiotherapy. Quality of life assessment amongst the survivors was performed by means of a questionnaire.

RESULTS

Five year disease free survival in patients undergoing excision for T3-T4 tumours was 59%. Patients with T2-T3 tumours undergoing partial excision of the tongue base had a 3 year recurrence free survival rate of 68%. Distant metastasis occurred in 16%. Seventy-eight per cent of the patients judged their quality of life to be near normal.

CONCLUSION

Surgery and post-operative radiotherapy offer a reasonably good survival in advanced carcinoma of the base of the tongue with preservation of quality of life.

Combined surgery and postoperative radiotherapy for carcinoma of the base of radiotherapy for carcinoma of the base of tongue: analysis of treatment outcome and prognostic value of margin status

BACKGROUND

Choice of treatment for base of tongue carcinoma is controversial, with options including surgery alone, radiotherapy alone, or multimodality treatment. Given the highly aggressive nature of these tumors, it has been our institutional policy to manage this disease with combined partial glossectomy (with attempt to avoid laryngectomy if possible) with planned postoperative radiotherapy (RT). We reported on our institutional experience with this approach.

METHODS

A retrospective review of the charts of 17 patients with primary base of tongue squamous cell carcinoma treated with surgery and postoperative RT was performed. Patients treated with chemotherapy as part of their management were excluded. All patients underwent partial, hemi-, or subtotal glossectomy; 15/17 patients underwent ipsilateral radical or modified radical neck dissection. All patients received comprehensive postoperative RT (median dose 6000 cGy; range 5040-6920 cGy). Stage distribution was as follows: stage I, 2; stage II, 3; stage III, 2; stage IV, 10. Positive margins for invasive carcinoma were found in 9/17 patients. Median follow-up of surviving patients is 46 months; median follow-up for all patients is 31 months.

RESULTS

For the entire group of patients, the actuarial 3-year local-regional control rate was 68%. The actuarial 3-year overall survival rate was 46%. The local-regional control rate was 83% for patients with stage I-III disease versus 50% for stage IV disease. There were no local failures among eight patients with negative margins (local control 100%) compared with an actuarial local control rate of 36% among patients with positive margins (p = .03). Survival, disease-specific survival, and locoregional control were also highly correlated with margin status (p = .003). Late major complications included 5/17 patients requiring permanent G-tubes and/or tracheostomy to prevent aspiration.

CONCLUSIONS

Surgery plus postoperative RT is an intensive treatment for carcinoma of the base of tongue which offers high locoregional control in patients in whom negative margins are achieved. Positive margins indicate a high risk of locoregional and systemic failure, and these patients should be considered for innovative clinical trials after surgery.

Oropharyngeal carcinoma treated with radiotherapy: a 30-year experience

PURPOSE

This study was done to determine the outcome in patients with oropharyngeal carcinoma treated at the University of Florida with radiotherapy alone to the primary site, for comparison with reported results of other types of treatment.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Of a consecutive cohort of 785 patients with biopsy-proven, previously untreated, invasive squamous cell carcinoma of the oropharynx, this report is based on the 490 patients who had continuous-course irradiation with curative intent at the University of Florida between October 1964 and January 1991. All patients had a minimum 2-year follow-up. Forty-eight percent had Stage T3 or T4 disease, and 64% had clinically apparent neck node metastases. The median radiation dose was 68 Gy for once-a-day treatment and 76.8 Gy for twice-a-day treatment. Patients with advanced neck node disease had planned neck dissection(s) after radiotherapy.

RESULTS

The overall local control rate after radiotherapy alone was 73%. The ultimate local control rate (including surgical salvage) was 78%. At 5 years, the probability of control of neck disease was 85%; control above the clavicles, 67%; absolute survival, 44%; cause-specific survival, 77%; distant metastasis (as the first or only site of failure), 11%. Thirteen patients (2.6%) experienced severe treatment complications.

CONCLUSION

Radiotherapy results in tumor control and survival rates comparable with rates achieved with combined irradiation and surgery, with less morbidity.

Treatment selection for carcinoma of the base of the tongue

Between 1974 and 1984, 173 patients were treated for squamous cell carcinoma of the tongue base. Fifty-four patients had T1 or T2 primaries, while 115 patients had T3 or T4 tumors (4 were not staged). Lymph node metastasis was present in 120 patients. Early primary tumors treated with surgery or radiotherapy had a control rate of 83% (5 of 6 tumors) and 89% (40 of 45 tumors), respectively. For advanced primary tumors, definitive radiotherapy produced a local control rate of 55% (42 of 76 tumors), compared with 79% (23 of 29 tumors) for surgery and postoperative radiotherapy. If primary control was obtained, the regional failure rate was less than 10%. Tumor growth patterns were predictive of the response to radiotherapy. The primary control rate at 2 years for 21 patients with exophytic tumors was 84% as opposed to 58% for 62 patients with ulcerative-infiltrative tumors (p = 0.04). Radiotherapy is effective for early stage or exophytic tumors, whereas for advanced or deeply invasive tumors combined therapy enhances local control.