Comparing monolithic and microparticular capillary columns for the separation and analysis of peptide mixtures by liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry

Monoliths in capillary electrochromatography and capillary liquid chromatography in conjunction with mass spectrometry

Here, we have reviewed separation studies utilizing monolithic capillary columns for separation of compounds preceding MS analysis. The review is divided in two parts according to the used separation method, namely CEC and capillary LC (cLC). Based on our overview, monolithic CEC-MS technique have been more focused on the syntheses of highly specialized and selective separation phase materials for fast and efficient separation of specific types of analytes. In contrast, monolithic cLC-MS is more widely used and is often employed, for instance, in the analysis of oligonucleotides, metabolites, and peptides and proteins in proteomic studies. While poly(styrene-divinylbenzene)-based and silica-based monolithic capillaries found their place in proteomic analyses, the other laboratory-synthesized monoliths still wait for their wider utilization in routine analyses. The development of new monolithic materials will most likely continue due to the demand of more efficient and rapid separation of increasingly complex samples.

Preparation and characterization of alkyl methacrylate-based monolithic columns for capillary gas chromatography applications

Gas chromatography (GC) is considered the least common application of both polymer and silica-based monolithic columns. This study describes the fabrication of alkyl methacrylate monolithic materials for use as stationary phases in capillary gas chromatography. Following the deactivation of the capillary surface with 3-(trimethoxysilyl)propyl methacrylate (TMSM), the monoliths were formed by the co-polymerization of either hexyl methacrylate (HMA) or lauryl methacrylate (LMA) with different percentage of ethylene glycol dimethacrylate (EDMA) in presence of an initiator (azobisisobutyronitrile, AIBN) and a mixture of porogens include 1-propanol, 1,4-butanediol and water. The monoliths were prepared in 500mm length capillaries possessing inner diameters of 250μm. The efficiencies of the monolithic columns for low molecular weight compounds significantly improved as the percentage of crosslinker was increased, because of the greater proportion of pores less than 50nm. The columns containing lower percentages of crosslinker were able to rapidly separate a series of 8 alkane members in 0.7min, but the separation was less efficient for the light alkanes. Columns prepared with the lauryl methacrylate monomer yielded a different morphology for the monolith-interconnected channels. The channels were more branched, which increased the separation time, and unlike the other columns, allowed for temperature programming.

Silica-based and organic monolithic capillary columns for LC: recent trends in proteomics

The use of monolithic liquid chromatography (LC) columns for proteomics, covering the scientific literature from 2004 to the beginning of 2011, is reviewed. Attention is paid to recent developments in column technology and materials, focusing on silica-based and organic (polystyrene and methacrylate) monolithic capillary columns for proteomics. The applicability of these columns is illustrated by examples of the analysis of (complex) protein digests and proteins conveniently summarized in tables. Furthermore, characteristics of column materials are compared and future trends and prospects are presented.

Potential of poly(styrene-co-divinylbenzene) monolithic columns for the LC-MS analysis of protein digests

Two polystyrene-based capillary monolithic columns of different length (50 and 250 mm) were used to evaluate the effects of column length on gradient separation of protein digests. A tryptic digest of a 9-protein mixture was used as a test sample. Peak capacities were determined from selected extracted ion chromatograms, and tandem mass spectrometry data were used for database matching using the MASCOT search engine. Peak capacities and protein identification scores were higher for the long column with all gradients. Peak capacities appear to approach a plateau for longer gradient times; maximum peak capacity was estimated to be 294 for the short column and 370 for the long column. Analyses with similar gradient slope produced a ratio of the peak capacities of 3.36 for the long and the short column, which is slightly higher than the expected value of the square root of the column length ratio. The use of a longer monolith improves peptide separation, as reflected by higher peak capacity, and also increases protein identification, as observed from higher identification scores and a larger number of identified peptides. Attention has also been paid to the peak production rate (PPR, peak capacity per unit time). For short analysis times, the short column produces a higher PPR, while for analysis times longer than 40 min, the PPR of the 250-mm column is higher.

Emerging mass spectrometry-based technologies for analyses of chromatin changes: analysis of histones and histone modifications

Mass spectrometry (MS) is rapidly becoming an indispensable tool for the analysis of posttranslational modifications (PTMs) of proteins, and particularly histone PTMs that regulate physiological processes. The more traditional bottom-up approach of searching for modifications on peptides rather than intact proteins (top-down) has proven useful for finding phosphorylation, acetylation, and ubiquitination sites. With the use of modern instrumentation and various MS-based techniques, peptides and their PTMs can be characterized in a high-throughput manner while still maintaining high sensitivity and specificity. In complement to bottom-up MS, recent advances in MS technology, such as high-field Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR)-mass spectrometry, have permitted the study of intact proteins and their modifications. On-line and off-line protein separation instruments coupled to FTICR-MS allow the characterization of PTMs previously undetectable with bottom-up approaches. The use of unique fragmentation techniques in FTICR-MS provides a viable option for the study of labile modifications. In this chapter, we provide a detailed description of the analytical tools - mass spectrometry in particular - that are used to characterize modifications on peptides and proteins. We also examine the applicability of these mass spectrometric techniques to the study of PTMs on histones via both the bottom-up and top-down proteomics approaches.

Performance of five different electrospray ionisation sources in conjunction with rapid monolithic column liquid chromatography and fast MS/MS scanning

The performances of five different ESI sources coupled to a polystyrene-divinylbenzene monolithic column were compared in a series of LC-ESI-MS/MS analyses of Escherichia coli outer membrane proteins. The sources selected for comparison included two different modifications of the standard electrospray source, a commercial low-flow sprayer, a stainless steel nanospray needle and a coated glass Picotip. Respective performances were judged on sensitivity and the number and reproducibility of significant protein identifications obtained through the analysis of multiple identical samples. Data quality varied between that of a ground silica capillary, with 160 total protein identifications, the lowest number of high quality peptide hits obtained (3012), and generally peaks of lower intensity; and a stainless steel nanospray needle, which resulted in increased precursor ion abundance, the highest-quality peptide fragmentation spectra (5414) and greatest number of total protein identifications (259) exhibiting the highest MASCOT scores (average increase in score of 27.5% per identified protein). The data presented show that, despite increased variability in comparative ion intensity, the stainless steel nanospray needle provides the highest overall sensitivity. However, the resulting data were less reproducible in terms of proteins identified in complex mixtures -- arguably due to an increased number of high intensity precursor ion candidates.

Computational quantification of peptides from LC-MS data

Liquid chromatography coupled to mass spectrometry (LC-MS) has become a major tool for the study of biological processes. High-throughput LC-MS experiments are frequently conducted in modern laboratories, generating an enormous amount of data per day. A manual inspection is therefore no longer a feasible task. Consequently, there is a need for computational tools that can rapidly provide information about mass, elution time, and abundance of the compounds in a LC-MS sample. We present an algorithm for the detection and quantification of peptides in LC-MS data. Our approach is flexible and independent of the MS technology in use. It is based on a combination of the sweep line paradigm with a novel wavelet function tailored to detect isotopic patterns of peptides. We propose a simple voting schema to use the redundant information in consecutive scans for an accurate determination of monoisotopic masses and charge states. By explicitly modeling the instrument inaccuracy, we are also able to cope with data sets of different quality and resolution. We evaluate our technique on data from different instruments and show that we can rapidly estimate mass, centroid of retention time, and abundance of peptides in a sound algorithmic framework. Finally, we compare the performance of our method to several other techniques on three data sets of varying complexity.

Prospects for monolithic nano-LC columns in shotgun proteomics

We report a premier side-by-side comparison of two leading types of monolithic nano-LC column (silica-C(18), polystyrene) in shotgun proteomics experiments. Besides comparing the columns in terms of the number of peptides from a real-life sample (Arabidopsis thaliana chloroplast) that they identified, we compared the monoliths in terms of peak capacity and retention behavior for standard peptides. For proteomics applications where the mobile phase composition is constrained by electrospray ionization considerations (i.e., there is a restricted choice of ion-pairing modifiers), the polystyrene nano-LC column exhibited reduced identification power. The silica monolith column was superior in all measured values and compared very favorably with traditional packed columns. Finally, we investigated the performances of the monoliths at high flow rates in an attempt to demonstrate their advantages for high-throughput identification.

Development of capillary electrochromatography with poly(styrene-divinylbenzene-vinylbenzenesulfonic acid) monolith as the stationary phase

A new polystyrene-based monolithic stationary phase, which was prepared by single step in situ copolymerization of styrene, divinylbenzene and vinylbenzenesulfonic acid (VBSA), was developed as a separation column for capillary electrochromatography, in which VBSA was employed as the charge-bearing monomer. Polymerization time of the polystyrene-based monolith had slightly influenced the separation time of the tested analytes, but it effectively altered their separation resolutions. Furthermore, baseline separation for a wider range of acetonitrile levels of mobile phase was achieved when a monolithic column prepared by a longer polymerization time was used. This novel polystyrene-based monolithic column provided an adequate electroosmotic flow either in basic or acidic mobile phase when VBSA level was maintained at 2.6% (w/w). Finally, this proposed polystyrene-based column allowed seven tested analytes to achieve a reproducible baseline separation within 2.2 min with theoretical plate numbers higher than 164 000 plates/m.

Statistical learning of peptide retention behavior in chromatographic separations: a new kernel-based approach for computational proteomics

Background

High-throughput peptide and protein identification technologies have benefited tremendously from strategies based on tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) in combination with database searching algorithms. A major problem with existing methods lies within the significant number of false positive and false negative annotations. So far, standard algorithms for protein identification do not use the information gained from separation processes usually involved in peptide analysis, such as retention time information, which are readily available from chromatographic separation of the sample. Identification can thus be improved by comparing measured retention times to predicted retention times. Current prediction models are derived from a set of measured test analytes but they usually require large amounts of training data.

Results

We introduce a new kernel function which can be applied in combination with support vector machines to a wide range of computational proteomics problems. We show the performance of this new approach by applying it to the prediction of peptide adsorption/elution behavior in strong anion-exchange solid-phase extraction (SAX-SPE) and ion-pair reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography (IP-RP-HPLC). Furthermore, the predicted retention times are used to improve spectrum identifications by a p-value-based filtering approach. The approach was tested on a number of different datasets and shows excellent performance while requiring only very small training sets (about 40 peptides instead of thousands). Using the retention time predictor in our retention time filter improves the fraction of correctly identified peptide mass spectra significantly.

Conclusion

The proposed kernel function is well-suited for the prediction of chromatographic separation in computational proteomics and requires only a limited amount of training data. The performance of this new method is demonstrated by applying it to peptide retention time prediction in IP-RP-HPLC and prediction of peptide sample fractionation in SAX-SPE. Finally, we incorporate the predicted chromatographic behavior in a p-value based filter to improve peptide identifications based on liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry.

Less common applications of monoliths. III. Gas chromatography

Porous polymer monoliths emerged about two decades ago. Despite this short time, they are finding applications in a variety of fields. In addition to the most common and certainly best known use of this new category of porous media as stationary phases in liquid chromatography, monolithic materials also found their applications in other areas. This review article focuses on monoliths in capillaries designed for separations in gas chromatography.

Use of monolithic supports in proteomics technology

An overview on the utilization of monoliths in proteomics technology will be given. Both silica- and polymer-based monoliths have broad use for microseparation of tryptic peptides in reversed-phase (RP) mode before identification by mass spectrometry (MS) or by MS/MS. For two-dimensional (2D) LC separation of peptides before MS or MS/MS analysis, a combination of ion-exchange, usually cation-exchange (CEX) chromatography with RP chromatography on monolithic supports can be employed. Immobilized metal ion affinity chromatography monoliths with immobilized Fe3+-ions are used for the isolation of phosphopeptides. Monoliths with immobilized affinity ligands are usually applied to the rapid separation of proteins and peptides. Miniaturized reactors with immobilized proteolytic enzymes are utilized for rapid on- or offline digestion of isolated proteins or protein mixtures prior to identification by LC-MS/MS. Monoliths also have broad potential for application in sample preparation, prior to further proteomic analyses. Monolithic supports with large pore sizes can be exploited for the isolation of nanoparticles, such as cells, organelles, viruses and protein aggregates. The potential for further adoption of monolithic supports in protein separation and enrichment of low abundance proteins prior to proteolytic digestion and final LC-MS/MS protein identification will be discussed.

A New Fast Method for nanoLC−MALDI-TOF/TOF−MS Analysis Using Monolithic Columns for Peptide Preconcentration and Separation in Proteomic Studies

A new fast method for identification and characterization of proteolytic digests of proteins by monolithic liquid chromatography coupled with mass spectrometry has been developed. The advantages of the monolithic columns are a high-pressure stability and low back pressure resulting in higher flow rates for capillary or nanosize columns simplifying the system handling. As was shown in several publications, such monolithic stationary phases are highly qualified for the analysis of peptides and proteins, but so far, only small volumes could be injected into the system, which might hamper the sample preparation leading to protein precipitation and partial loss of sample. To overcome the problem of small injection volumes, we established a system including a short monolithic trap column to allow preconcentration of the peptides. The injected sample is flushed at higher flow rates onto the trap column, bound to the stationary phase, and in this way concentrated in a few nanoliters before starting the separation. The expanded system was optimized and tested using different reference protein samples. Eluting peptides were detected by MALDI-TOF/TOF-MS and identified by database searching. The system is now a permanent part for proteome analysis in our lab, and as such, it was successfully applied for the detection of post-translational modifications and the analysis of membrane proteins. One example for these analyses is also included in this paper.

CEC with monolithic poly(styrene-divinylbenzene-vinylsulfonic acid) as the stationary phase

In this study, poly(styrene-divinylbenzene-vinylsulfonic acid) monolithic columns, prepared by singlestep in situ polymerization, were first used as separation columns for CEC in which vinylsulfonic acid was employed as the charge-bearing monomer. The effects of the polymerization conditions (compositions of monomer and porogenic solvent, and polymerization time) on the chromatographic property of the polystyrene-based monolithic column were examined. Furthermore, an increase in water content of the porogenic solvent markedly altered the retention behaviors of these analytes, where the monolithic column was able to be produced in a higher ratio of vinylsulfonic acid. Finally, the study demonstrated that acidic analytes could be successfully separated by the polystyrene-based monolithic column under an acidic mobile phase.

Proteome Analysis of Myxococcus xanthus by Off-Line Two-Dimensional Chromatographic Separation Using Monolithic Poly-(styrene-divinylbenzene) Columns Combined with Ion-Trap Tandem Mass Spectrometry

Myxobacteria are potent producers of secondary metabolites exhibiting diverse biological activities and pharmacological potential. The proteome of Myxococcus xanthus DK1622 was characterized by two-dimensional chromatographic separation of tryptic peptides from a lysate followed by tandem mass spectrometric identification. The high degree of orthogonality of the separation system employing polymer-based strong cation-exchange and monolithic reversed-phase stationary phases was clearly demonstrated. Upon automated database searching, 1312 unique peptides were identified, which were associated with 631 unique proteins. High-molecular polyketide synthetases and nonribosomal peptide synthetases, known to be involved in the biosynthesis of various secondary metabolites, were readily detected. Besides the identification of gene products associated with the production of known secondary metabolites, proteins could also be identified for six gene clusters, for which no biosynthetic product has been known so far.

Monolithic organic polymeric columns for capillary liquid chromatography and electrochromatography

This review briefly summarizes the present state of the preparation and use of capillary monolithic columns for liquid chromatography (LC) and electrochromatography (EC). Most important approaches to the preparation of monolithic stationary phases based on organic polymers are outlined and the properties of the monoliths obtained are compared with those of classical particulate phases. A few selected applications of monolithic columns are shown to demonstrate the most important advantages of monolithic capillary columns. It is concluded that both the monolithic and particulate capillary columns are important and that judicious choice of the type suitable for a particular application requires careful consideration of the purpose of the separation and the properties of the solutes to be separated. Monolithic columns are substantially younger than packed ones and thus will require further theoretical and experimental study to further improve their preparation and to enable reliable prediction of their properties and applicability; nevertheless, they are very promising for the future.

Comparison of different separation technologies for proteome analyses: Isoform resolution as a prerequisite for the definition of protein biomarkers on the level of posttranslational modifications

In this article we evaluate methods used to reveal the molecular complexity, which is generated in biological samples by posttranslational modifications (PTM) of proteins. We show how distinct molecular differences on the level of phosphorylation sites in a single protein (ovalbumin) can be resolved with different success using 1D and 2D gel-electrophoresis and reversed-phase liquid chromatography (LC) with monolithic polystyrol-divinylbenzol (PS-DVB) columns for protein separation, and matrix-assisted laser desorption ionisation-time of flight mass spectrometry (MALDI-TOF MS) for protein identification. Phosphorylation site analysis was performed using enzymatic dephosphorylation in combination with differential peptide mass mapping. Liquid chromatography-MALDI-TOF MS coupling with subsequent on-target tryptic protein digestion turned out to be the fastest method tested but yielded low resolution for the analysis of PTM, whereas 2D gel-electrophoresis, due to its unique capability of resolving highly complex isoform pattern, turned out to be the most suitable method for this purpose. The evaluated methods complement one another and in connection with efficient technologies for differential and quantitative analysis, these approaches have the potential to reveal novel molecular details of protein biomarkers.

Separation of parabens in capillary electrochromatography using poly(styrene-divinylbenzene-methacrylic acid) monolithic column

In this study, a series of poly(styrene-divinylbenzene-methacrylic acid) monolithic capillaries was used as the separation column of CEC for the analyses of parabens in commercial pharmaceutical and cosmetic products. The results showed that the chromatographic characteristics of these analytes were strongly affected by the preparation condition of the monolithic column including monomer content, porogenic solvent composition, and polymerization time. Baseline separations were markedly sped up by lowering the polymerization time without any obvious loss of resolution. Furthermore, mobile-phase composition (pH, ACN, and electrolyte concentration) was also able to effectively improve the separation behavior. Similar to the influence of lowering the polymerization time, retention times for all analytes were significantly shortened in the CEC method by decreasing the electrolyte concentration in the mobile phase.

Ultra-fast tandem mass spectrometry scanning combined with monolithic column liquid chromatography increases throughput in proteomic analysis

Liquid chromatography combined with electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (LC/ESI-MS) has been used successfully for the characterization of biomolecules in proteomics in the last few years. This methodology relied largely on the use of reversed-phase chromatography, in particular C18-based resins, which are suitable for separation of peptides. Here we show that polymeric [polystyrene divinylbenzene] monolithic columns can be used to separate peptide mixtures faster and at a higher resolution. For 500 fmol bovine serum albumin, up to 68% sequence coverage and Mascot Mowse scores of >2000 were obtained using a 9 min gradient on a monolithic column coupled to an ion trap mass spectrometer with ultra-fast MS/MS scan rates. In order to achieve similar results using C18 columns, it was necessary to extend gradient times to 30 min. In addition, we demonstrate the utility of this approach for the analysis of whole Escherichia coli cell lysates by one-dimensional sodium dodecyl sulfate polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis (1D-SDS-PAGE) in combination with LC/MS/MS using 4 min gradients on monolithic columns. Our results indicate higher throughput capabilities of monolithic columns (3-fold gain in time or more) for conventional proteomics applications, such as protein identification and high sequence coverage usually required for detection of post-translational modifications (PTMs). Further optimization of sensitivity and quality of sequence information is discussed, in particular when combined with mass spectrometers that have very fast MS-MS/MS switching and scanning capabilities.