Characterization of a highly stable zwitterionic hydrophilic interaction chromatography stationary phase based on hybrid organic/inorganic particles

Matrix effect evaluation using multi-component post-column infusion in untargeted hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry plasma metabolomics

Metabolomics based on hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) coupled with mass spectrometry (MS) is a powerful tool for polar metabolite identification and quantification to further contribute to biomarker discovery and disease mechanism elucidation. However, matrix effect (ME), which may lead to altered ionization efficiency due to co-eluting compounds, is a significant challenge during biological analysis. Therefore, ME evaluation plays a crucial role during method development. Two approaches to evaluate ME are using stable isotope labelled-internal standards (SIL-IS) and post-column infusion (PCI) of standards. In this study, we developed an untargeted HILIC-MS method by applying four PCI standards for ME evaluation. We found PCI is a compelling approach for ME assessment compared to SIL-IS method due to its advantage in untargeted analysis. Through the ME evaluation and chromatographic performance comparison of 18 SIL standards across three columns and three different mobile phase pH conditions, our findings revealed that the BEH-Z-HILIC column operated at pH 4 with 10 mM ammonium formate exhibited minimal ME and superior performance. The method showed exceptional linearity (R² > 0.98), reliable repeatability (RSD < 15 %), good inter-day precision (RSD < 30 %), and acceptable recovery (>75 %) for all SIL standards. Absolute matrix effect (AME) and relative matrix effect (RME) assessment in three plasma donors revealed a high consistency between PCI and SIL-IS approaches. Finally, this method coupled with the PCI approach was applied to 40 plasma samples. Fifty endogenous compounds were detected and their AME and RME were evaluated. Results showed that many compounds experienced severe ion suppression, though their ME variation between 40 samples is low. In conclusion, PCI method is a robust alternative for monitoring ME and evaluating ME of endogenous compounds during untargeted method optimization and biological analysis.

EMBL-MCF 2.0: an LC-MS/MS method and corresponding library for high-confidence targeted and untargeted metabolomics using low-adsorption HILIC chromatography

INTRODUCTION

Over the past two decades, liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry (LC-MS)-based metabolomics has experienced significant growth, playing a crucial role in various scientific disciplines. However, despite these advance-ments, metabolite identification (MetID) remains a significant challenge. To address this, stringent MetID requirements were established, emphasizing the necessity of aligning experimental data with authentic reference standards using multiple criteria. Establishing dependable methods and corresponding libraries is crucial for instilling confidence in MetID and driving further progress in metabolomics.

OBJECTIVE

The EMBL-MCF 2.0 LC-MS/MS method and public library was designed to facilitate both targeted and untargeted metabolomics with exclusive focus on endogenous, polar metabolites, which are known to be challenging to analyze due to their hydrophilic nature. By accompanying spectral data with robust retention times obtained from authentic standards and low-adsorption chromatography, high confidence MetID is achieved and accessible to the metabolomics community.

METHODS

The library is built on hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) and state-of-the-art low adsorption LC hardware. Both high-resolution tandem mass spectra and manually optimized multiple reaction monitoring (MRM) transitions were acquired on an Orbitrap Exploris 240 and a QTRAP 6500+, respectively.

RESULTS

Implementation of biocompatible HILIC has facilitated the separation of isomeric metabolites with significant enhancements in both selectivity and sensitivity. The resulting library comprises a diverse collection of more than 250 biologically relevant metabolites. The methodology was successfully applied to investigate a variety of biological matrices, with exemplary findings showcased using murine plasma samples.

CONCLUSIONS

Our work has resulted in the development of the EMBL-MCF 2.0 library, a powerful resource for sensitive metabolomics analyses and high-confidence MetID. The library is freely accessible and available in the universal .msp file format under the CC-BY 4.0 license: mona.fiehnlab.ucdavis.edu https://mona.fiehnlab.ucdavis.edu/spectra/browse?query=exists(tags.text:%27EMBL-MCF_2.0_HRMS_Library%27) , EMBL-MCF 2.0 HRMS https://www.embl.org/groups/metabolomics/instrumentation-and-software/#MCF-library .

Understanding retention and intra-particle diffusivity of alkylsulfobetaine-bonded Ethylene Bridged Particles with different mesopore sizes for hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography applications

The role of the average pore diameter (APD) of 1.7μm AtlantisTM Premier BEHTM Particles derivatized with a zwitterionic group (propylsulfobetaine) on the efficiency of their 2.1 × 50 mm hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) packed columns is investigated experimentally. Van Deemter plots for toluene (neutral, hydrophobic), cytosine (neutral, polar), tosylate (negatively charged), bretylium and atenolol (positively charged) were measured on three HILIC columns packed with BEH Z-HILIC Particles having APDs of 95 Å, 130 Å, and 300 Å. The intraparticle diffusivities of the analytes across these three BEH Z-HILIC Particles were measured by the peak parking method. The experimental data reveal that the slope of the C-branch of the van Deemter plots can be reduced by factors of about 15 for toluene, 2.5 for cytosine, 6 for atenolol, 5 for tosylate, and 14 for bretylium with increasing the APD from 95 Å to 300 Å. This observation is explained by: (1) the reduced amount of the highly viscous water diffuse layer and subsequent increase of the amount of acetonitrile-rich eluent in the mesopores, (2) the localized electrostatic adsorption of the retained analytes onto the zwitterion-bonded BEH Particles, and (3) depletion/excess of the analytes into the water diffuse layer. A general model of intraparticle diffusivity was then proposed to account for the impact of the APD of Z-HILIC Particles on the solid-to-liquid mass transfer resistance of small molecules. The model highlights the relevance of the thickness of the water diffuse layer, the access of the bulk eluent into the mesopore, the localized electrostatic adsorption, and the partitioning constant of the retained analyte between the bulk eluent and the water diffuse layer.

Low swelling and high mechanical strength organosilane hybrid polydivinylbenzene microspheres for hydrophilic interaction chromatography applications

In this work, monodisperse organosilane hybrid polymer microspheres with a particle size of about 5 µm were synthesized using seed swelling polymerization. The organosilicon reagent methacryloxypropyltrimethoxysilane was introduced into the polymer framework as a copolymerization monomer, and the crosslinking degree of the microspheres was improved by the hydrolysis-condensation reaction of siloxanes. The synthesized hybrid microspheres have good mechanical strength as well as low swelling, with swelling propensity values of 0.167 and 0.348 in methanol and acetonitrile, respectively. Hybrid microspheres modified with cysteine have a hydrophilic interaction chromatography/reversed-phase liquid chromatography mixed-mode retention mechanism. Compared to the commercial cysteine-modified silica column, the synthesized stationary phase has higher separation selectivity for partially acidic or basic samples and better basic resistance for use under high pH mobile phase conditions (at least 10).

Selective analysis of intracellular UDP-GlcNAc and UDP-GalNAc by hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry

Uridine diphosphate-N-acetylglucosamine (UDP-GlcNAc) is one of the major nucleotide sugars in living organisms and serves as the key donor substrate for the post-translational modification of protein O-GlcNAcylation. It undergoes interconversion to its epimer uridine diphosphate-N-acetylgalactosamine (UDP-GalNAc), which acts as a sugar donor initiating mucin-type O-linked glycosylation. The intracellular levels of the two differ between the cell lines and largely fluctuate in response to metabolic perturbations, and recent studies have focused on the details of their biosynthesis or turnover. However, due to their similar chemical properties, sufficient resolution for the two epimers required non-volatile mobile phases that cannot be applied directly to a mass spectrometer. In this study, to implement simple liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry for UDP-GlcNAc and UDP-GalNAc, we optimized a condition of hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography-mass spectrometry. We found that the use of ammonium hydroxide and an amide column with an optimized water-acetonitrile ratio, flow rate, and column temperature, provided complete separation of the two. The method allowed the analysis of intracellular levels, a stable isotope-labeled target, and patterns of product ion spectra in a single run with fewer sample preparation steps. The new method can be widely used for mass spectrometric analysis of UDP-GlcNAc and UDP-GalNAc.

Preparation of three structurally similar stationary phases with different ionizable terminal groups and evaluation of their retention performances under multiple modes in high performance liquid chromatography

Three structurally similar silane reagents with different terminal groups were prepared and bonded to silica to obtain three structurally similar stationary phases (Sil-Ph-COOH, Sil-Phe and Sil-Ph-NH2). The prepared stationary phases were characterized through elemental analysis (EA) and Fourier Transform Infrared Spectroscopy (FT-IR). These three stationary phases provided acceptable retention repeatability (relative standard deviations between 0.08% and 0.13%) and high column efficiency (7.3 × 104 plates/m for uridine on Sil-Phe). The retention behavior of the three columns was investigated under different chromatographic conditions including different mobile phase ratio, salt concentration, pH etc. The retention mechanisms were explored by linear solvation energy relationships and Van't Hoff plots. Applications in separation under reversed phase liquid chromatography (RPLC), hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) and ion exchange chromatography (IEC) mode were investigated. The results showed that the retention capacity of the stationary phases with different terminal groups to the analytes is very different, especially for carboxylic acids, because the surface charges of amino groups and carboxyl groups under weakly acidic conditions produce different electrostatic effects with dissociated carboxylic acids. Finally, the Sil-Phe column was employed to detect ibuprofen extracted from pharmaceutical ibuprofen capsules and vitamins extracted from vitamin tablets.

OsTST1, a key tonoplast sugar transporter from source to sink, plays essential roles in affecting yields and height of rice (Oryza sativa L.)

MAIN CONCLUSION

OsTST1 affects yield and development and mediates sugar transportation of plants from source to sink in rice, which influences the accumulation of intermediate metabolites from tricarboxylic acid cycle indirectly. Tonoplast sugar transporters (TSTs) are essential for vacuolar sugar accumulation in plants. Carbohydrate transport across tonoplasts maintains the metabolic balance in plant cells, and carbohydrate distribution is crucial to plant growth and productivity. Large plant vacuoles store high concentrations of sugars to meet plant requirements for energy and other biological processes. The abundance of sugar transporter affects crop biomass and reproductive growth. However, it remains unclear whether the rice (Oryza sativa L.) sugar transport protein OsTST1 affects yield and development. In this study, we found that OsTST1 knockout mutants generated via CRISPR/Cas9 exhibited slower development, smaller seeds, and lower yield than wild type (WT) rice plants. Notably, plants overexpressing OsTST1 showed the opposite effects. Changes in rice leaves at 14 days after germination (DAG) and at 10 days after flowering (DAF) suggested that OsTST1 affected the accumulation of intermediate metabolites from the glycolytic pathway and the tricarboxylic acid (TCA) cycle. The modification of the sugar transport between cytosol and vacuole mediated by OsTST1 induces deregulation of several genes including transcription factors (TFs). In summary, no matter the location of sucrose and sink is, these preliminary results revealed that OsTST1 was important for sugar transport from source to sink tissues, thus affecting plant growth and development.

Liquid Chromatography-Tandem Mass Spectrometry Analysis of Aminoglycosides in Foods Using an Ethylene-Bridged Hybrid Zwitterionic Stationary Phase and Hydrophilic-Lipophilic-Balanced Solid-Phase Extraction Cartridges

This work aimed to develop an analytical method for the screening of multiple aminoglycoside residues in foods of animal origin using an ethylene-bridged hybrid (BEH) particle-based sulfoalkylbetaine stationary phase. The effects of chromatographic conditions on the separation of 17 aminoglycosides have been systematically investigated. Sample preparation and mass spectrometry detection have also been investigated and optimized. In contrast to high buffer concentrations in the mobile phase required for silica-based sulfoalkylbetaine stationary phases, a moderate buffer concentration (20 mM) provided the optimal separation of 17 aminoglycosides with the BEH sulfoalkylbetaine stationary phase. The developed method has been evaluated in milk, beef, pork, liver, and honey samples with good performance for retention, selectivity, sensitivity, linearity, precision, and accuracy. The majority of the limit of quantitation estimated with the matrix was less than 25 μg/kg. The overall accuracy across five matrices was in the range from 96 to 111%, with standard deviations of less than 19%.

Managing nonspecific adsorption to liquid chromatography hardware: A review

The choice of alternative materials over stainless steel hardware in the construction of liquid chromatography systems has unveiled the degree to which nonspecific adsorption impacts the reproducibility of LC methods. Some of the major contributors to nonspecific adsorption losses are charged metallic surfaces and leached metallic impurities, that may interact with the analyte and result in analyte loss and overall poor chromatographic performance. In this review, we describe several mitigation strategies available to chromatographers to minimize nonspecific adsorption to chromatographic systems. Alternative surfaces to stainless steel such as titanium, PEEK, and hybrid surface technologies are discussed. Furthermore, mobile phase additives used to prevent metal ion-analyte interactions are reviewed. Nonspecific adsorption of analytes is not reserved to metallic surfaces, as analytes may adsorb to the surfaces of filters, tubes, and pipette tips during sample preparation. Identifying the source of nonspecific interactions is paramount, as mitigation strategies may differ depending on what stage nonspecific losses are taking place. With this in mind, we discuss diagnostic methods that may help the chromatographer to differentiate losses resulting from sample preparation, and losses during LC runs.

Retention and mass transfer properties of the series of unbonded, amide-bonded, and alkylsulfobetaine-bonded ethylene bridged hybrid hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography columns

This work investigates the link between the retentivity and the stationary phase to mobile phase mass transfer resistance of hydrophilic interaction liquid chromatography (HILIC) columns packed with the same base ethylene-bridged hybrid particles (BEH). The retention volumes, the plate heights, and the volume of the adsorbed water layer were measured for the ACQUITY^TM UPLC^TM BEH^TM 130 Å HILIC Column (unbonded BEH), ACQUITY UPLC BEH 130 Å Amide Column (amide group attached), and Atlantis^TM Premier BEH 95 Å Z-HILIC (zwitterionic group attached) Column. The method of Guo (toluene retention volumes in pure acetonitrile and in the HILIC eluent) was validated from the UNIFAC group-contribution method and applied to measure accurately the water layer volumes in these columns. A strong correlation was found between the retention volumes of most neutral polar analytes and the volume of the water layer adsorbed in the HILIC column. The fraction of the pore volume occupied by the water layer increases significantly from the BEH HILIC Column to the BEH Amide Column, and to the BEH Z-HILIC Column. This is explained by the water solvation of the attached ligands in the pore volume of the BEH Particles and to the smaller average mesopore size of the BEH Z-HILIC Particles. A second and strong correlation is also observed between the water content in the HILIC particle and the stationary phase to mobile phase mass transfer resistance of the HILIC columns at high mobile phase linear velocities. The measured intra-particle diffusivity normalized to the bulk diffusion coefficient decreased from 0.33 (BEH HILIC Column) to 0.10 (BEH Amide Column) and to only 0.03 (BEH Z-HILIC Column) for comparable retention of cytosine. These results are fully consistent with the higher viscosity of the internal eluent (higher water content) and higher internal obstruction for diffusion (smaller mesopores and internal porosity) in the BEH Z-HILIC Particles. Still, in gradient elution mode, the peak capacity was found to be 18% higher for the BEH Z-HILIC Column than that on the BEH Amide Column because the retention factors at elution were smaller when maintaining the same analysis time and starting eluent composition.

Further Evaluation of the Base Stability of Hydrophilic Interaction Chromatography Columns Packed with Silica or Ethylene-Bridged Hybrid Particles

One of the fundamental attributes of a liquid chromatography column is its stability when exposed to acidic and basic mobile phases. However, there have been relatively few reports to date on the stability of hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) columns. Here, we report the results of stability evaluations carried out for HILIC columns packed with ethylene-bridged hybrid or silica particles using accelerated conditions, employing a 100% aqueous pH 11.3 ammonium bicarbonate mobile phase at 70 °C. Under these conditions, the primary mode of column failure was a loss of efficiency due to the formation of voids resulting from the hydrolysis of the particles. We investigated the dependence of stability on the surface area of both unbonded and sulfobetaine-bonded ethylene-bridged hybrid stationary phases. The results show a clear trend of stability increasing as the surface area decreases. Several commercially available HILIC columns that are recommended for use with high-pH mobile phases were also evaluated. The results show times to 50% loss of the initial efficiency ranging from 0.3 to 9.9 h. Columns containing unbonded, sulfobetaine-bonded or diol-bonded ethylene-bridged hybrid stationary phases had longer lifetimes than amino-bonded silica or sulfobetaine-bonded, hybrid-coated, superficially porous silica columns.

Factors affecting mixed-mode retention properties of cation-exchange stationary phases

Cation-exchange stationary phases were characterized in different chromatographic modes (HILIC, RPLC, IC) and applied to the separation of non-charged hydrophobic and hydrophilic analytes. The set of columns under investigation included both commercially available cation-exchangers and self-prepared PS/DVB-based columns, the latter consisting of adjustable amounts of carboxylic and sulfonic acid functional groups. The influence of cation-exchange site and polymer substrate on the multimodal properties of cation-exchangers was identified using selectivity parameters, polymer imaging and excess adsorption isotherms. Introducing weakly acidic cation-exchange functional groups to the unmodified PS/DVB-substrate effectively reduced hydrophobic interactions, whilst a low degree of sulfonation (0.09 to 0.27% w/w sulphur) mainly influenced electrostatic interactions. Silica substrate was found to be another important factor for inducing hydrophilic interactions. The presented results demonstrate that cation-exchange resins are suitable for mixed-mode applications and offer versatile selectivity.

Comprehensive evaluation of zwitterionic hydrophilic liquid chromatography stationary phases for oligonucleotide characterization

Hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) has been proposed as a valuable alternative to ion-pairing reversed-phase chromatography (IP-RPLC) for oligonucleotide (ON) analysis. In this context, the potential of seven zwitterionic HILIC columns has been evaluated against amide- and poly-hydroxy fructan-functionalized HILIC columns and a C18 column operated under IP-RPLC mode. Based on the retention characteristics of key small molecule pairs, each zwitterionic HILIC column showed a unique radar-shaped profile, suggesting different selectivities for distinct structural differences. Unmodified DNA and RNA samples were then evaluated, and the columns classified based on their retentivity. Two zwitterionic columns were particularly promising in terms of overall resolution, especially for the largest ONs (> 40-mer). Finally, separations between a chemically modified drug-like ON and its closely related impurities were performed. Although the ZIC-cHILIC column showed similar selectivity values as compared to the reference IP-RPLC technique, all columns demonstrated a general decrease in selectivity due to the minor structural differences present in the highly complex samples. This work highlights the utility of zwitterionic HILIC mode for ON analysis and it reveals the importance of understanding columns characteristics - in terms of retention and selectivity - when selecting a stationary phase for specific ON applications.

Evaluation of the Base Stability of Hydrophilic Interaction Chromatography Columns Packed with Silica or Ethylene-Bridged Hybrid Particles

Stability as a function of mobile phase pH is an important consideration when selecting a chromatographic column. While the pH stability of reversed-phase columns is widely studied, there are relatively few reports of the stability of hydrophilic interaction chromatography (HILIC) columns. We evaluated the stability of silica and ethylene-bridged hybrid HILIC columns when used with mobile phases containing basic buffers. The predominant mode of column degradation observed in our studies was a decrease in efficiency due to voiding, resulting from the hydrolysis of the silica particles. Associated with this were increases in tailing factors. Retention factor changes were also noted but were smaller than the efficiency losses. The dependence of the rate of efficiency decrease on the key variables of temperature, mobile phase pH and water content were studied for an unbonded silica column. The effect of the acetonitrile concentration on the pH of the mixed aqueous/acetonitrile mobile phases was also investigated. Using conditions found to cause a 50% decrease in efficiency after approximately five hours of exposure to the basic solution, we evaluated eight different commercially available HILIC columns containing silica or ethylene-bridged hybrid particles. The results show large differences between the stability of the silica and ethylene-bridged hybrid particle stationary phases, with the latter exhibiting greater stability.

Modifying the Metal Surfaces in HPLC Systems and Columns to Prevent Analyte Adsorption and Other Deleterious Effects

Interactions of certain analytes with metal surfaces in high performance liquid chromatography (HPLC) instruments and columns cause a range of deleterious effects, including peak broadening and tailing, low peak areas, and the formation of new peaks due to chemical reactions. To mitigate these effects, we have developed a novel surface modification technology in which a hybrid organic/inorganic surface based on an ethylene-bridged siloxane chemistry is applied to the metal components in HPLC instruments and columns. We demonstrate the impact of this technology on peak symmetry, peak area, and injection-to-injection and column-to-column reproducibility for several metal-sensitive analytes. We also show an example of the mitigation of an on-column oxidation reaction. A variant of this technology has recently been developed for size-exclusion chromatography of proteins. An example is shown demonstrating the use of this variant applied to size-exclusion columns for the separation of a monoclonal antibody monomer and higher molecular weight species. Together, these results highlight the importance of preventing interactions of analytes with metal surfaces in HPLC in order to achieve accurate and precise results.