Idiopathic ulcerative laryngitis causing midmembranous vocal fold granuloma

De Novo Granuloma of the Membranous Vocal Fold: A Marker of Occult Malignancy

OBJECTIVE

De novo occurrence of granuloma (granulation tissue) on the membranous vocal fold is not readily explained by usual causes of granuloma at the vocal process. We describe a series of patients.

STUDY DESIGN

Case series.

SETTING

Single academic institution.

METHODS

Cases were identified over a 16-year period. All patients exhibited granulation tissue on pathology. Demographic details, presentation, treatment, histology, and clinical outcomes were recorded.

RESULTS

Five patients (mean age: 74.0 ± 6.1 years, 40.0% male, 40.0% former smokers) underwent a biopsy. Persistent or recurrent granulation led to a second biopsy in 4 patients an average of 1423.5 days later, revealing a new diagnosis of squamous cell carcinoma (SCC) in situ in one and mild dysplasia in another. Further persistence or recurrence led to a third biopsy or excision an average of 302.3 days later in 3 patients, demonstrating SCC in situ in 1. An average of 2.5 biopsies were required with a mean time to SCC in situ diagnosis of 919.5 days from presentation. Two patients continued to demonstrate persistent granulation tissue on histology.

CONCLUSION

The membranous vocal fold is an atypical location for granuloma and portends a risk of occult malignancy. The occurrence of de novo granuloma at this site should prompt close long-term clinical surveillance with a low threshold for biopsy. Consideration should be given to tissue collection in the operating room to adequately sample the lesion's base. Concern should persist even after a negative biopsy, and serial observation with repeat biopsy as needed should be pursued.

Idiopathic Ulcerative Laryngitis (IUL): An Indian Perspective

Idiopathic ulcerative laryngitis (IUL) is characterized by bilateral ulceration of vocal cords which is followed by a protracted course of healing. It is rarely diagnosed, with a paucity of published data in English literature. There is no published data on this topic in the Indian population. Twenty-one patients from 3 centres were prospectively evaluated for clinical presentation, diagnosis, treatment, and follow-up. All patients underwent fibreoptic laryngoscopic evaluation and stroboscopic assessment. They were treated with supportive care and stringent follow-up. 21 patients with a median age of 39 years were included. This condition was commonly seen in males. All patients were treated conservatively except two who underwent a biopsy. The average time for full recovery in 14 of our patients who had compliant follow-ups was 9.24 weeks. GRBAS score improved from 9 to 5.93(p < 0.0001). Self-reported voice outcomes improved in all patients except for one patient who had a biopsy. IUL is uncommon but not rare in the Indian population. It shows full recovery with conservative management that involves at least more than 3-4 weeks.

Increased Incidence of Ulcerative Laryngitis During Spring 2022 Omicron-Variant Wave of COVID19

OBJECTIVES

Ulcerative laryngitis is a distinctive condition which typically follows illness with severe cough, and is characterized by dysphonia, ulcerative lesions of the vocal folds, and a prolonged clinical course. We present four patients with ulcerative laryngitis who presented in close succession amid the surge in omicron-variant COVID19 cases.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective review.

METHODS

Patient records for patients with ulcerative laryngitis from April and May 2022 were reviewed and compared with patients who presented with the same diagnosis from January 2017 through March 2022. Incidence, patient demographics, occupation, vaccination status, disease history, and treatment were obtained and compared.

RESULTS

Four patients presented with ulcerative laryngitis over six weeks. Compared to the previous 4 years, this represented an eight-fold increase in monthly incidence. Average time from symptom onset to presentation was 15 days. All patients presented with dysphonia, with an average VHI10 of 23 and SVHI10 of 28. Two patients were COVID positive, one negative, and one had unknown COVID status. Three patients were fully vaccinated while one patient had only received one dose. Treatments included voice rest, steroids, antibiotics, antireflux medicine, and cough suppressants. Clinical course tended to be shorter and outcomes similar to the comparison group.

CONCLUSION

The incidence of ulcerative laryngitis appeared to increase markedly with the prevalence of omicron-variant COVID19. Potential explanations include the apparent upper airway focus of omicron infection in contrast with prior variants and/or change in COVID19 infection characteristics in a vaccinated population.

Membranous Vocal Fold Lesions in Patients With Chronic Cough: A Case Series

OBJECTIVES

Trauma related to chronic cough and forceful glottal closure has been associated with lesions of the vocal process; however, there is limited description of cough leading to membranous vocal fold lesions. We present a series of mid-membranous vocal fold lesions in a cohort of patients with chronic cough, with a proposed mechanism of lesion formation.

METHODS

Patients treated for chronic cough with membranous vocal fold lesions affecting phonation were identified. Presentation, diagnosis, treatment strategies (behavioral, medical, and surgical), patient-reported outcome measures (PROMs), and videostroboscopy were reviewed.

RESULTS

Five patients are included (four females, one male, aged 56±16 years). Mean cough duration was 2.6±3.5 years. All patients were on acid suppressive medications for existing gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD) prior to referral. All lesions were identified at the mid-membranous vocal folds and morphologically encompassed a wound healing spectrum between ulceration and/or granulation tissue (granuloma) formation. Patients were treated in an interdisciplinary fashion with behavioral cough suppression therapy, superior laryngeal nerve block, and neuromodulators. Three had persistent lesions requiring procedural intervention (one office-based steroid injection and two surgical excisions). At the completion of treatment, all five patients had improvement in Cough Severity Index with an average decrease of 15.2±4.8. All but one patient had improvement in their Voice Handicap Index-10 with an average decrease of 13.2±11.1. One patient undergoing surgical intervention was noted to have a persistent lesion on follow-up.

CONCLUSION

Mid-membranous vocal fold lesions in patients with chronic cough are uncommon. When they do occur, they represent epithelial change arising in context of shear injury and are distinct from phonotraumatic lesions in the lamina propria. An interdisciplinary approach including behavioral cough suppression therapy, neuromodulators, superior laryngeal nerve block, and acid suppression are reasonable for initial management, reserving surgical intervention for refractory lesions once the inciting source of injury has been controlled.

[Prolonged ulcerative laryngitis]

Hintergrund

Die prolongierte ulzerierende Laryngitis ist eine seltene, gutartige, über Monate andauernde entzündliche Veränderung des Larynx. Der lupenlaryngoskopische Befund lässt einen malignen Prozess vermuten und kann somit eine Herausforderung für den behandelnden Hals-Nasen-Ohren-Arzt (HNO-Arzt) darstellen.

Fragestellung

Darstellung der aktuellen Datenlage, um einen für den klinischen Alltag hilfreichen Überblick über Ätiologie, Verlauf und Therapieoptionen zu geben.

Material und Methoden

Präsentation von 3 Fallbeispielen aus der Abteilung für Phoniatrie und Klinische Logopädie der ORL-Klinik des Universitätsspitals Zürich. Analyse und Diskussion der aktuellen Studienlage und von Einzelfallberichten aus der englischsprachigen Literatur.

Ergebnisse

Ätiologie und prädisponierende Faktoren sind unklar. Ein vorangegangener Atemwegsinfekt mit Husten und Heiserkeit scheint die häufigste Ursache zu sein. Die Erkrankung weist einen selbstlimitierenden Krankheitsverlauf ohne strukturell dauerhafte Folgen auf. Biopsien sollten vermieden werden.

Schlussfolgerung

Der typische laryngoskopische Befund zeigt umschriebene korrespondierende lanzettförmige Ulzerationen im mittleren Stimmlippendrittel. Der Krankheitsverlauf scheint selbstlimitierend zu sein und ohne strukturell dauerhafte Folgen abzulaufen. Deswegen sollten eine gute Patientenaufklärung und engmaschige laryngoskopische Kontrollen vorgenommen werden.

Idiopathic Ulcerative Laryngitis: A National Survey of Academic Laryngologists

OBJECTIVES

Idiopathic ulcerative laryngitis (IUL) is a rare disorder characterized by ulceration in the mid-membranous portions of the vocal folds. The etiology and optimal management of this condition are poorly understood. We aimed to survey laryngologists on their experiences with managing IUL in order to better understand the diagnosis and treatment of this unusual condition.

METHODS

An online survey was sent to 149 laryngologists practicing at academic institutions in the United States. Survey questions assessed respondents' professional backgrounds and clinical experiences with IUL. Individual responses were tallied and calculated as percentages of total responses.

RESULTS

A total of 96 out of 149 academic laryngologists completed the survey, leading to an overall response rate of 64.4%. All respondents reported that they had encountered IUL in practice, including 56.3% who reported having seen 1-10 cases, 22.9% reporting 11-20 cases, and 20.8% reporting greater than 20 cases over their careers. Dysphonia (99.0%) and cough (84.4%) were the two co-occurring primary presenting symptoms reported. Most base diagnosis on laryngeal videostroboscopy (93.8%). Fungal/bacterial cultures and operative biopsy had been performed by approximately 30% of respondents with occasional candidiasis reported but otherwise negative or nonspecific results. Common therapies used were empiric: antireflux therapy (91.7%), modified voice rest (91.7%), and oral steroids (80.2%). Among survey respondents with experience managing more than 10 cases of IUL, many found complete voice rest (60.0%), oral steroids (55.9%), behavioral cough suppression (46.7%), and modified voice rest (46.3%) to be at least moderately effective treatment options. Resolution of symptoms was most commonly reported to occur over the course of 1-3 months (59.4%) and recurrences were seen not very often or never (85.4%). However, permanent sequelae were common, including vocal fold stiffness (89.6%) and dysphonia (81.3%).

CONCLUSIONS

IUL is a rare disorder of unknown etiology. Diagnosis is typically made with laryngeal videostroboscopy and spontaneous resolution occurs over 1-3 months. Laryngologists commonly treat empirically with antireflux therapy, voice rest, antimicrobials, and oral steroids. While no empiric treatment appears to be highly effective for the management of IUL, complete or modified voice rest, oral steroids, and behavioral cough suppression may be the most effective of the currently available options. Further research is necessary to improve the understanding and optimal management of IUL.

Spontaneous Giant Laryngeal Granuloma in the Absence of Laryngeal Injury

The etiology of laryngeal granuloma can typically be attributed to endotracheal intubation, vocal abuse, or gastroesophageal reflux disease. There is a strong male predominance, except in cases due to intubation, where incidence is higher in women. We report a case of spontaneous development of multiple granulomas in a female with no history of intubation who presented with hoarseness and massive bilateral supraglottic masses obscuring her glottis. The disparity between the massive lesions and asymptomatic reflux highlights the need for further research in the pathophysiology of laryngeal granulomas.

Granulomas of the membranous vocal fold after intubation and other airway instrumentation

OBJECTIVES/HYPOTHESIS

We describe the clinical features of granulomas of the membranous vocal fold secondary to endotracheal intubation, bronchoscopy or esophagogastroduodenoscopy.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective case series.

METHODS

Review of cases at a single tertiary institution with evaluation of patient demographic characteristics, time to presentation, time to treatment, and clinical outcomes.

RESULTS

Thirteen adult patients were identified with postintervention granuloma of the membranous vocal fold. All patients were female, with a mean age of 60 years (range, 28-81 years). None noted hoarseness prior to the intervention, and all noted significant hoarseness postoperatively. Conservative treatment with proton pump inhibitors and vocal rest was initially implemented in all patients. Four cases resolved without further intervention. Nine underwent surgical management because of airway symptoms, failure to improve, or patient request. One patient had injury to the contralateral vocal fold upon intubation. None experienced recurrence. Five had complete recovery of voice postoperatively, four did not.

CONCLUSION

Iatrogenic granulomas of the membranous vocal fold after intubation or other upper airway instrumentation are rare complications presenting in the early postprocedure period with worsening hoarseness. Initial conservative treatment may be sufficient to yield resolution, and surgical treatment is effective for those failing medical management. Permanent voice damage may result from the original injury.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

4 Laryngoscope, 129:441-447, 2019.

Characteristics and Voice Outcomes of Ulcerative Laryngitis

OBJECTIVES

Ulcerative laryngitis (UL) is challenging in terms of treatment and patient counseling, with few reports in the literature. This study describes UL patients and their clinical course including detailed voice and stroboscopic outcomes after treatment which have not been described in previous literature.

METHODS

Single-institution, retrospective review of 23 UL patients. Demographics, historical factors, disease course, treatment, and outcomes are presented. Treatment results were compared to prior studies.

RESULTS

Seventy four percent had inflammatory/infectious precipitating event. Average presenting Voice-Handicap-Index-10 (VHI-10) was 25 (range: 6-38) and average final VHI-10 was 9 (range: 0-26). Ninty five percent had improvement in VHI-10 (average decrease of 15). Only 50% had final VHI-10 within "normal" limits. Treatment comprised reflux medications (85%), antibiotics (22%), antifungals (39%), antivirals (52%) steroids (52%), and/or voice rest (65%). Average symptom duration before evaluation was 42 days; average follow-up was 6.8 months. Final laryngovideostroboscopy revealed no ulcers in 78%, but 65% had persistently decreased mucosal wave vibration. Average time to ulcer resolution was 2.25 months but resolution or plateau of voice symptoms occurred later, average 2.7 months. Multiple regression analyses revealed that younger age, shorter symptom duration, and antireflux treatment were significant predictors of decrease in VHI-10 (P < 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Most patients have good voice outcomes following resolution of UL, although vocal fold mucosal wave abnormalities may persist. This study provides the most detailed report of UL, disease course and treatment outcomes to date. Additionally, this study is also the first to suggest that earlier initiation of treatment may improve voice outcome after UL.

Viral laryngitis: a mimic and a monster - range, presentation, management

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

The purpose of this review is to highlight recent literature relating to the diagnosis and treatment of some less common forms of viral laryngitis. The main conditions addressed in this review are chronic cough or postviral vagal neuropathy, varicella zoster infection of the larynx, and a condition increasingly suspected as being virally induced, idiopathic ulcerative laryngitis.

RECENT FINDINGS

Diagnosis of these conditions requires a thorough history and physical exam, and in certain cases referral to other subspecialties such as gastroenterology and pulmonology. Chronic cough due to postviral vagal neuropathy is a diagnosis of exclusion; however, recent literature does suggest that certain studies such as laryngeal electromyography can be of use in reaching a diagnosis. Treatment of this neuropathy has focused on use of neuromodulators. Treatment of laryngeal shingles and idiopathic ulcerative laryngitis has not been well defined because of the rarity of these conditions.

SUMMARY

Recent studies regarding these conditions and potential future treatment options will be discussed.

Mid-membranous Vocal Fold Webs: Case Series

INTRODUCTION

Laryngeal webs are a rare clinical entity, with those in the mid-membranous region occurring even less commonly. This is the first case series describing this condition.

CASE REPORT

We describe the clinical course of four patients with mid-glottic webs and propose the possible pathophysiology.

DISCUSSION

Trauma to the vocal folds followed by an inflammatory reaction is the likely event leading to the development of this lesion. Endoscopic division of this type of web has shown good postoperative voice outcomes without any recurrences.

CONCLUSION

The mid-glottic web is a rare clinical entity for which there is no defined etiology. It is likely that trauma results in an inflammatory reaction and, ultimately, web formation. Further studies are needed to identify risk factors for this condition.