The low-output carbon dioxide laser for cutaneous wound closure of scalpel incisions: comparative tensile strength studies of the laser to the suture and staple for wound closure

Comparing the Tolerability of a Novel Wound Closure Device Using a Porcine Wound Model

Objective: To compare the tolerability and mechanical tensile strength of acute skin wounds closed with nylon suture plus a novel suture bridge device (SBD) with acute skin wounds closed with nylon suture in a porcine model. Approach: Four Yucatan pigs each received 12 4.5 cm full-thickness incisions that were closed with 1 of 4 options: Suture bridge with nylon, suture bridge with nylon and subdermal polyglactin, nylon simple interrupted, and nylon simple interrupted with subdermal polyglactin. Epithelial reaction, inflammation, and scarring were examined histologically at days 10 and 42. Wound strength was examined mechanically at days 10 and 42 on ex vivo wounds from euthanized pigs. Results: Histopathology in the suture entry/exit planes showed greater dermal inflammation with a simple interrupted nylon suture retained for 42 days compared with the SBD retained for 42 days (p < 0.03). While tensile wound strength in the device and suture groups were similar at day 10, wounds closed with the devices were nearly 8 times stronger at day 42 compared with day 10 (p < 0.001). Innovation: A novel SBD optimized for cutaneous wound closure that protects the skin surface from suture strands, forms a protective bridge over the healing wound edges, and knotlessly clamps sutures. Conclusion: This study suggests that the use of a SBD increases the tolerability of nylon sutures in porcine acute skin wound closures allowing for prolonged mechanical support of the wound. For slow healing wounds, this may prevent skin wound disruption, such as edge necrosis and dehiscence.

The role of wound healing and its everyday application in plastic surgery: a practical perspective and systematic review

BACKGROUND

After surgery it is often recommended that patients should refrain from strenuous physical activity for 4-6 weeks. This recommendation is based on the time course of wound healing. Here, we present an overview of incisional wound healing with a focus on 2 principles that guide our postoperative recommendations: the gain of tensile strength of a wound over time and the effect of mechanical stress on wound healing.

METHODS

A systematic search of the English literature was conducted using OVID, Cochrane databases, and PubMed. Inclusion criteria consisted of articles discussing the dynamics of incisional wound healing, and exclusion criteria consisted of articles discussing nonincisional wounds.

RESULTS

Experiments as early as 1929 laid the groundwork for our postoperative activity recommendations. Research using animal models has shown that the gain in tensile strength of a surgical wound is sigmoidal in trajectory, reaching maximal strength approximately 6 weeks postoperatively. Although human and clinical data are limited, the principles gained from laboratory investigation have provided important insights into the relationship among mechanical stress, collagen dynamics, and the time course of wound healing.

CONCLUSION

Our postoperative activity recommendations are based on a series of animal studies. Clinical research supporting these recommendations is minimal, with the most relevant clinical data stemming from early motion protocols in the orthopedic literature. We must seek to establish clinical data to support our postoperative activity recommendations so that we can maximize the physiologic relationships between wound healing and mechanical stress.

Preliminary biocompatibility experiment of polymer films for laser-assisted tissue welding

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to examine the impact of a polymer film for liquid solder strength reinforcement on the short term healing of a wound closed by laser-tissue soldering.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Full thickness incisions created on the dorsum of Sprague-Dawley rats were closed by laser-tissue soldering: albumin solder with Indocyanine Green (ICG) dye was inserted between the incision edges and photothermally coagulated with a diode laser. A poly(DL-lactic-co-glycolic acid) (PLGA) polymer film was implanted subcutaneously in the bottom of the incision (controls had no film). Specimens were harvested at 0, 3, 7, and 14 days for breaking strength testing and histological analysis.

RESULTS

Breaking strengths of the controls at 0 and 14 days were statistically stronger than the specimens with the implanted films (t-test, P < 0.05). A slight difficulty in apposing the wound edges due to the film presence may have contributed to the low acute strengths. Interference with the wound contraction process by the films possibly contributed to the lower breaking strength at 14 days. Wound histology indicated a mild foreign body reaction to the polymer film material.

CONCLUSIONS

The polymer film was well tolerated by the tissue, and the tissue response to the material was consistent with that seen in the literature. The breaking strength differences between control and film-implanted specimens at 0 and 14 days were probably the result of mechanical complications (tissue apposition and wound contraction) due to the presence of the film, and not due to the film material itself. The use of polymer film patches for liquid solder reinforcement and breaking strength enhancement may have certain application specific issues that need to be addressed. Strategies to account for these issues require further research.

Can thermal lasers promote skin wound healing?

Lasers are now widely used for treating numerous cutaneous lesions, for scar revision (hypertrophic and keloid scars), for tissue welding, and for skin resurfacing and remodeling (wrinkle removal). In these procedures lasers are used to generate heat. The modulation of the effect (volatilization, coagulation, hyperthermia) of the laser is obtained by using different wavelengths and laser parameters. The heat source obtained by conversion of light into heat can be very superficial, yet intense, if the laser light is well absorbed (far-infrared:CO(2) or Erbium:Yttrium Aluminum Garnet [Er:YAG] lasers), or it can be much deeper and less intense if the laser light is less absorbed by the skin (visible or near-infrared). Lasers transfer energy, in the form of heat, to surrounding tissues and, regardless of the laser used, a 45-50 degrees C temperature gradient will be obtained in the surrounding skin. If a wound healing process exists, it is a result of live cells reacting to this low temperature increase. The generated supraphysiologic level of heat is able to induce a heat shock response (HSR), which can be defined as the temporary changes in cellular metabolism. These changes are rapid and transient, and are characterized by the production of a small family of proteins termed the heat shock proteins (HSP). Recent experimental studies have clearly demonstrated that HSP 70, which is over-expressed following laser irradiation, could play a role with a coordinated expression of other growth factors such as transforming growth factor (TGF)-beta. TGF-beta is known to be a key element in the inflammatory response and the fibrogenic process. In this process, the fibroblasts are the key cells since they produce collagen and extracellular matrix. In conclusion, the analysis of the literature, and the fundamental considerations concerning the healing process when using thermal lasers, are in favor of a modification of the growth factors synthesis after laser irradiation, induced by an HSR. An extensive review of the different techniques and several clinical studies confirm that thermal lasers could effectively promote skin wound healing, if they are used in a controlled manner.

Laser soldering of rat skin, using fiberoptic temperature controlled system

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Laser soldering of tissues is based on the application of a biological solder on the approximated edges of a cut. Our goal was to use laser soldering for sealing cuts in skin under temperature feedback control and compare the results with ones obtained using standard sutures.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Albumin solder was applied onto the approximated edges of cuts created in rat skin. A fiberoptic system was used to deliver the radiation of a CO(2) laser, to heat a spot near the cut edges, and to control the temperature. Laser soldering was carried out, spot by spot, where the temperature at each spot was kept at 65-70 degrees C for 10 sec.

RESULTS

The tensile strength of laser-soldered cuts was measured after 3-28 days postoperatively and was found comparable to that of sutured cuts. Histopathological studies showed no thermal damage and less inflammatory reaction than that caused by standard sutures (P = 0.04).

CONCLUSIONS

Temperature controlled laser soldering of cuts in rat skin gave strong bonding. The cosmetic and histological results were very good, in comparison to those of standard sutures.

Laser assisted skin closure (LASC) by using a 815-nm diode-laser system accelerates and improves wound healing

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to evaluate a 815-nm diode-laser system to assist wound closure to accelerate and improve healing process.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

A total of 25 male hairless rats (mutant OFA Sprague-Dawley rats, IFFA-CREDO, L'Arbresle, France) with four dorsal skin incisions were used for the study. For each wound, the good apposition of the edges was obtained with buried absorbable suture. In the laser group, the laser beam was applied spot by spot through a transparent adhesive dressing along two incisions with the following parameters: 1.5 W; 3 seconds; spot diameter, 2 mm; fluence, 145 J/cm(2). Both control wounds were closed with conventional suture techniques. The duration of the closure procedure was noted for each group. Clinical examination, histologic study, and measurement of tensile strength were performed at 3, 7, 15, and 21 days after surgery. Determination of activation of heat shock protein 70 (Hsp70) through immunocytochemistry was performed at days 1 and 7.

RESULTS

LASC was 4 times faster to process than conventional suture: 1 minute 49 +/- 20.6 seconds vs. 7 minutes 26 +/- 62.2 seconds. In the laser group, healing was accelerated resulting in a more indiscernible scar than in the control groups. Histologic aspect was better with earlier continuous epidermis and dermis and a thinner resulting scar. Tensile strength was 30 to 58% greater than in control groups at 7 and 15 days (P < 0.001). Expression of Hsp70 was markedly induced in skin structures examined after laser exposure.

CONCLUSIONS

This study shows the ability of the 815-nm diode-laser system to assist wound closure leading to an acceleration and an improvement of wound healing with indiscernible resulting scar. The mechanisms of this phenomenon are still unclear but further investigations are in progress to attempt to explain them.

Radiometric surface temperature measurements during dye-assisted laser skin closure: in vitro and in vivo results

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

A thermal camera was used to measure surface temperatures during laser skin welding to provide feedback for optimization of the laser parameters.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two-centimeter-long, full-thickness incisions were made in guinea pig skin in vitro and in vivo. India ink was applied to the incision edges, which were then mechanically apposed. Continuous-wave, 1.06-microm Nd:YAG laser radiation was scanned over the incisions, producing an effective pulse duration of approximately 100 msec. Cooling durations between scans of 1.6, 4.0, and 8.0 sec were studied in vitro. A 5-mm-diameter laser spot was used with the power kept constant at 10 W. Thermal images were obtained at 30 frames per second with a thermal camera detecting 3-5 microm radiation. Surface temperatures were recorded at 0, 1, and 6 mm from the center line of the incision.

RESULTS/CONCLUSIONS

Cooling durations of 1.6 and 4.0 seconds in vitro resulted in temperatures at the weld site that remained above approximately 65 degrees C for prolonged periods of time. Cooling durations of 8.0 seconds were sufficient both in vitro and in vivo to prevent a significant rise in baseline temperatures at the weld site over time.

Laser skin welding: in vivo tensile strength and wound healing results

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Laser skin welding was investigated as a general model for laser tissue closure. Scanned delivery of near-infrared laser radiation in combination with a dye can produce strong welds with limited thermal damage.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

Two-centimeter-long, full-thickness incisions were made on the backs of guinea pigs. Wounds were closed either by laser welding or sutures and then biopsied at 0, 3, 6, 10, 14, 21, and 28 days postoperatively. Welding was achieved by using continuous-wave, 1. 06-micrometer, Nd:YAG laser radiation scanned over the incisions to produce a dwell time of approximately 80 msec. The cooling time between scans was fixed at 8 seconds. A 4-mm-diameter laser spot was maintained during the experiments, and the power was kept constant at 10 W. The operation time was fixed at 10 minutes per incision. India ink was used as an absorber of the laser radiation at the weld site, and clamps were used temporarily to appose the incision edges.

RESULTS

Acute weld strengths of 2.1 +/- 0.7 kg/cm(2) were significantly higher than suture apposition strengths of 0.4 +/- 0.1 kg/cm(2) (P < 0.01), and weld strengths continued to increase over time. Lateral thermal damage in the laser welds was limited to 200 +/- 40 micrometer near the epidermal surface with less thermal damage deeper within the dermis.

CONCLUSION

Our welding technique produced higher weld strengths and less thermal damage than reported in previous skin welding studies and may represent an alternative to sutures.

Cryogen spray cooling during laser tissue welding

Cryogen cooling during laser tissue welding was explored as a means of reducing lateral thermal damage near the tissue surface and shortening operative time. Two centimetre long full-thickness incisions were made on the epilated backs of guinea pigs, in vivo. India ink was applied to the incision edges then clamps were used to appose the edges. A 4 mm diameter beam of 16 W, continuous-wave, 1.06 microm, Nd:YAG laser radiation was scanned over the incisions, producing approximately 100 ms pulses. There was a delay of 2 s between scans. The total irradiation time was varied from 1-2 min. Cryogen was delivered to the weld site through a solenoid valve in spurt durations of 20, 60 and 100 ms. The time between spurts was either 2 or 4 s, corresponding to one spurt every one or two laser scans. Histology and tensile strength measurements were used to evaluate laser welds. Total irradiation times were reduced from 10 min without surface cooling to under 1 min with surface cooling. The thermal denaturation profile showed less denaturation in the papillary dermis than in the mid-dermis. Welds created using optimized irradiation and cooling parameters had significantly higher tensile strengths (1.7 +/- 0.4 kg cm(-2)) than measured in the control studies without cryogen cooling (1.0 +/- 0.2 kg cm(-2)) (p < 0.05). Cryogen cooling of the tissue surface during laser welding results in increased weld strengths while reducing thermal damage and operative times. Long-term studies will be necessary to determine weld strengths and the amount of scarring during wound healing.

Laser patch welding: experimental study for application to endoscopic closure of bronchopleural fistula, a preliminary report

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVE

Postoperative bronchopleural fistula is a serious complication following pulmonary resection. To close the bronchopleural fistula, we developed a new method of endoscopic patch welding using laser tissue welding between bronchial tissue and a patch.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIALS AND METHODS

The feasibility of the laser patch welding was examined by in vitro and in vivo animal experiments. A newly developed carbon monoxide (CO) laser and an Argon ion laser were evaluated. Various tissue membranes and artificial membranes were evaluated as patch materials.

RESULTS

We found that the combination of expanded polytetrafluoroethylene (e-PTFE; 200 microns in thickness) and the CO laser with contact irradiation method offered the strongest laser patch welding. Using this combination, the irradiation at 400 W/cm2 for 10 seconds resulted in 16-18 g of measured traction strength at the welding spot (2 mm in diameter). The welded e-PTFE patch at bronchial stump remained for 5 weeks.

CONCLUSION

Our results encourage use of this novel laser patch technique for clinical applications.

Clinical uses of lasers in dermatology

The accessibility of the skin to examination and study has permitted dermatologists to play an extremely important role in defining the clinical usefulness and limitations of many laser systems as well as developing innovative concepts, techniques and devices that further improved the effectiveness of laser treatment. As new laser technology evolved over the years, dermatologists have also helped define the specificity of laser-tissue interaction and employed the newly developed laser technologies in innovative ways which further expanded the usefulness of these devices. One of the most important concepts to be developed by dermatologists--selective photothermolysis--has led to the creation of a series of laser systems which have provided numerous unique advantages in the management of many common vascular and pigmented conditions of the skin and mucous membranes, even in infants and children. The net result of these technologic advances has been the creation of new and effective treatment techniques which have been so profoundly superior to existing technology that they have been rapidly incorporated into the daily practice of most dermatologists.

Dye-enhanced laser welding for skin closure

The use of a laser to weld tissue in combination with a topical photosensitizing dye permits selective delivery of energy to the target tissue. A combination of indocyanine green (IG), absorption peak 780 nm, and the near-infrared (IR) alexandrite laser was studied with albino guinea pig skin. IG was shown to bind to the outer 25 microns of guinea pig dermis and appeared to be bound to collagen. The optical transmittance of full-thickness guinea pig skin in the near IR was 40% indicating that the alexandrite laser should provide adequate tissue penetration. Laser "welding" of skin in vivo was achieved at various concentrations of IG from 0.03 to 3 mg/cc using the alexandrite at 780 nm, 250-microseconds pulse duration, 8 Hz, and a 4-mm spot size. A spectrum of welds was obtained from 1- to 20-W/cm2 average irradiance. Weak welds occurred with no thermal damage obtained at lower irradiances: stronger welds with thermal damage confined to the weld site occurred at higher irradiances. At still higher irradiances, local vaporization occurred with failure to "weld." Thus, there was an optimal range of irradiances for "welding," which varied inversely with dye concentration. Histology confirmed the thermal damage results that were evident clinically. IG dye-enhanced laser welding is possible in skin and with further optimization may have practical application.

Low-energy CO2 laser intestinal anastomosis: an experimental study

Intestinal anastomosis was performed in 17 Wistar rats via tissue welding by the low-energy CO2 laser. The postoperative course in the animals studied was uneventful. The integrity of the anastomosis was investigated manometrically, immediately upon completion of the anastomosis as well as 20 days later. Ten additional Wistar rats served as controls in which conventional interrupted one-layer anastomosis was performed. The results show a significant superiority of the intestinal anastomoses that were constructed by means of laser tissue welding. The time to complete the anastomosis was also significantly shorter when laser rather than manual suturing was used. Serial histological examinations for up to 90 days following surgery revealed complete healing and epithelization of the anastomotic site.

Use of lasers for closure of cutaneous wounds: experience with Nd:YAG, argon and CO2 lasers

The concept of tissue fusion by laser has been recently established. In this study, we have examined the skin welding by laser and tested the efficacy of four different lasers for this application. The results attest to the feasibility of the procedure and suggest that laser welding may represent an alternative for closure of cutaneous wounds.