Effect quantification and value prediction of factors in noninvasive detection for specific fetal copy number variants by semiconductor sequencing

A fetal fraction enrichment method reduces false negatives and increases test success rate of fetal chromosome aneuploidy detection in early pregnancy loss

OBJECTIVE

We and others have previously demonstrated that the size-selection enrichment method could remarkably improve fetal fraction (FF) in the early gestational age (GA, 12-13 weeks), suggesting that 9 or 10 weeks should not be used as a threshold for GA in size-selection noninvasive prenatal screening (NIPS). Here, we assessed whether this method was reliable for detecting fetal chromosomal aneuploidy at the earliest GA (6-8 weeks).

METHODS

Size-selection NIPS for fetal chromosomal aneuploidy was applied to 208 pregnancy plasma samples (102 male and 106 female fetuses), while the 169 pregnancy samples with male fetuses also underwent standard NIPS. Multivariable linear regression models were used to evaluate the association between fold-change of FF and experimental factors.

RESULTS

The sensitivity of the cell-free DNA (cfDNA) test in detecting aneuploidy was 100% when screened with FF enrichment, whereas the sensitivity of the same patients was only 62.5% (5/8) without FF enrichment. In the 102 pregnancy samples with male fetuses, FF increased from 6.1% to 15.7%, and the median increase in FF was 2.8-fold with enrichment. Moreover, there was a trend toward an increasing success rate of the cfDNA test from 6 to 13 weeks of gestation, especially when the test success rate reached 100% after 7 weeks with FF enrichment. Multivariate linear regression analysis demonstrated that a lower initial FF, shorter cfDNA size, increased body mass index (BMI), and later GA were all independent predictors of a higher fold-change of FF. Compared with ≤ 120 bp cfDNA fragments, the mean fold-change of FF differences was 0.820 for 121-125 bp, 0.229 for 126-130 bp, - 0.154 for 131-135 bp, - 0.525 for 136-140 bp and - 0.934 for > 140 bp (P_trend < 0.0001), suggesting that fold-change of FF significantly decreased with cfDNA fragments > 125 bp. These results were statistically significant after adjusting for confounding factors in the models for fold-change of FF.

CONCLUSIONS

The FF enrichment method is a reasonable strategy to detect fetal chromosomal aneuploidy in early pregnancy loss with reduced false negatives and increased test success rate after 7 weeks of GA and should be recommended for patients with early pregnancy loss.

Clinical value for the detection of fetal chromosomal deletions/duplications by noninvasive prenatal testing in clinical practice

Objective

This study was to report the experiences on the clinical value of noninvasive prenatal testing (NIPT) for the screening of fetal chromosomal deletions/duplications.

Methods

We performed a retrospective analysis of a cohort of 20,439 pregnancies undergoing NIPT from March 2017 to September 2020 at a single center. Patients with positive NIPT results for fetal chromosomal deletions or duplications had options of invasive diagnostic testing or no further testing. The data were complied from all cases with positive NIPT results for chromosomal deletions/duplications. The positive predictive value (PPV) was calculated from tabulated data.

Results

In this cohort, positive NIPT results for fetal chromosomal deletions/duplications were found in 60 pregnant women. Of the positive samples, further invasive testing was performed in 39 cases, in which 9 cases were found to be true positive. The overall PPV for chromosomal deletions/duplications was 23.1%. In addition, fetal structural anomaly was found by ultrasound examination in three cases, in which the chromosomal deletions/duplications of three cases were not verified. Moreover, an unexpected pathogenic 8p23.3 deletion was identified by invasive testing in 1 fetus with a false positive NIPT screen for 3q27.3q29 duplication.

Conclusions

In summary, positive NIPT results of chromosomal deletions/duplications were not uncommon in clinical practice, whereas the PPV for the testing was low. Hence, potential risks and high percentage of false positives for these abnormal NIPT results might be informed to pregnant women before the choice made of invasive testing.

Effect quantification and value prediction of factors in noninvasive detection for specific fetal copy number variants by semiconductor sequencing

Background

The detection limit of noninvasive prenatal testing (NIPT) by next generation sequencing for any given fetal copy number variants (CNV) can be influenced by several factors. In this study, we quantified the effects and predicted the value of parameters for CNVs detection by NIPT.

Methods

Genomic DNA from patient's leucocytes with 3.16 Mb microdeletion in 22q11.21 was mixed with DNA from aborted fetal tissues without CNV at various concentrations by an enzyme digestion method. Abnormal DNA at 0% served as negative control. Sequencing of mixture samples (at 0%, 4%, 12%, and 20%) by Ion Proton Sequencer was performed at flow 500, with WISECONDOR as the pipeline in CNV‐calling and bin of 500, 750 and 1,000 kb for counting unique reads. The parameters were evaluated with Box–Behnken design. The region with Z score ≦−3 was marked as a potential microdeletion.

Results

The equation of Z score depending on fetal fraction, unique read number and bin size was obtained by Box–Behnken design. The negative effect was quantified as the coefficient in the equation. The smallest values of these parameters were defined as 4 M unique read number, and 10.08% fetal DNA concentration at bin of 750 kb for detecting subchromosomal microdeletion of 3.16 Mb.

Conclusion

The quantification of effect and value of parameters as well as the method used in this study can benefit the establishment of quality standards for CNVs detection and interpretation of CNVs detection results.