Wandering nerve graft technique for management of the recalcitrant painful neuroma in the hand: a case report

Management of Neuropathic Pain with Neurectomy Combined with Dermal Sensory Regenerative Peripheral Nerve Interface (DS-RPNI)

Neuropathic pain affects a large percentage of the U.S. population and leads to tremendous morbidity. Numerous nonsurgical and surgical treatments have been utilized to try and manage neuropathic pain with varying degrees of success. Recent research investigating ways to improve prosthetic control have identified new mechanisms for preventing neuromas in both motor and sensory nerves with free muscle and dermal grafts, respectively. These procedures have been used to treat chronic neuropathic pain in nonamputees, as well, in order to reduce failure rates found with traditional neurectomy procedures. Herein, we focus our attention on Dermal Sensory-Regenerative Peripheral Nerve Interfaces (DS-RPNI, free dermal grafts) which can be used to physiologically "cap" sensory nerves following neurectomy and have been shown to significantly decrease neuropathic pain.

RPNI, TMR, and Reset Neurectomy/Relocation Nerve Grafting after Nerve Transection in Headache Surgery

In the context of headache surgery, greater occipital nerve (GON) transection is performed when the nerve appears severely damaged, if symptoms are recurrent or persistent, and when neuromas are excised. Lesser occipital nerve (LON) excision is commonly performed during the primary decompression surgery. Advanced techniques to address the proximal nerve stump after nerve transection such as regenerative peripheral nerve interface (RPNI), targeted muscle reinnervation (TMR), relocation nerve grafting, and reset neurectomy have been shown to improve chronic pain and neuroma formation. These techniques have not been described in the head and neck region.

Dorsal Coaptation for the Treatment of Digital Neuroma

PURPOSE

The formation of a symptomatic neuroma after digital tip amputation presents a vexing problem. There is currently no procedure that completely and consistently prevents hypersensitive neuroma formation. This report presents the results of a technique designed to limit axon regeneration and mechanical irritation by neuroma excision, dorsal transposition, and coaptation with the corresponding digital nerve.

METHODS

A retrospective chart review was conducted to assess the effectiveness of neuroma excision with dorsal transposition and epineurial coaptation for postamputation symptomatic digital neuromas. Neuromas were excised using a midlateral fish-mouth incision. Digital nerves were mobilized to the dorsum of the digital tip and coapted using 9-0 nylon epineurial suture. The procedure was modified to salvage viable fingernails or to avoid excessive tension. Mass et al's criteria system was used to evaluate effectiveness.

RESULTS

Twenty-four patients with painful neuromas of the radial and ulnar digital nerves after traumatic amputation were included. Thirty-two digits underwent dorsal coaptation. This procedure was associated with a result considered good or excellent in 28 of 32 digits. Twenty-seven of 32 digits registered no pain or stump anesthesia after dorsal coaptation. Twenty-five of 32 digits demonstrated no interference with activities of daily living. Twenty-one of 24 patients returned to work.

CONCLUSIONS

Neuroma excision with dorsal transposition and epineurial coaptation is an effective treatment for postamputation symptomatic digital neuroma.

TYPE OF STUDY/LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic IV.

Targeted Muscle Reinnervation in the Hand: Treatment and Prevention of Pain After Ray Amputation

Targeted muscle reinnervation (TMR), originally developed as an experimental technique for prosthetic control, has been shown to be safe and effective for the treatment and prevention of postamputation pain. Targeted muscle reinnervation involves coaptation of residual nerve ends to nearby motor nerve branches of healthy but expendable muscles proximal to an amputation. It has been shown to prevent and reduce residual limb pain and phantom limb pain after major upper and lower extremity amputation. However, the use of this technique has not been described distal to the forearm because bioprosthetic use is not a consideration at that level. The aim of this article was to (1) present 2 cases of TMR performed in the setting of ray amputation, and (2) provide technical strategies for maximizing success and efficiency.

Current State of the Surgical Treatment of Terminal Neuromas

Painful terminal neuromas resulting from nerve injury following amputation are common. However, there is currently no universally accepted gold standard of treatment for this condition. A comprehensive literature review is presented on the treatment of terminal neuromas. Four categories of terminal neuroma surgical procedures are assessed: epineurial closure; nerve transposition with implantation; neurorrhaphy, and alternate target reinnervation. Significant patient and case studies are highlighted in each section, focusing on surgical technique and patient outcome metrics. Studies presented consisted of a PubMed search for "terminal neuromas," without year limitation. The current available research supports the use of implantation into muscle for the surgical treatment of terminal neuromas. However, this technique has several fundamental flaws that limit its utility, as it does not address the underlying physiology behind neuroma formation. Regenerative peripheral nerve interfaces and targeted muscle reinnervation are 2 techniques that seem to offer the most promise in preventing and treating terminal neuroma formation. Both techniques are also capable of generating control signals which can be used for both motor and sensory prosthetic control. Such technology has the potential to lead to the future restoration of lost limb function in amputees. Further clinical research employing larger patient groups with high-quality control groups and reproducible outcome measures is needed to determine the most effective and beneficial surgical treatment for terminal neuromas. Primary focus should be placed on investigating techniques that most closely approximate the theoretically ideal neuroma treatment, including targeted muscle reinnervation and regenerative peripheral nerve interfaces.

Novel Uses of Nerve Transfers

Nerve transfer surgery involves using a working, functional nerve with an expendable or duplicated function as a donor to supply axons and restore function to an injured recipient nerve. Nerve transfers were originally popularized for the restoration of motor function in patients with peripheral nerve injuries. However, more recently, novel uses of nerve transfers have been described, including nerve transfers for sensory reinnervation, nerve transfers for spinal cord injury and stroke patients, supercharge end-to-side nerve transfers, and targeted muscle reinnervation for the prevention and treatment of postamputation neuroma pain. The uses for nerve transfers and the patient populations that can benefit from nerve transfer surgery continue to expand. Awareness about these novel uses of nerve transfers among the medical community is important in order to facilitate evaluation and treatment of these patients by peripheral nerve specialists. A lack of knowledge of these techniques continues to be a major barrier to more widespread implementation.

Use of collagen conduits in management of painful neuromas of the foot and ankle

BACKGROUND

Painful neuromas of the foot and ankle frequently pose a treatment dilemma due to persistent pain or recurrence after resection. The purpose of this survey was to evaluate the clinical and functional outcomes in patients in which collagen nerve conduits were used as an adjunct to the resection of a painful neuroma. Our prior experience with vein conduits for this purpose suggested that we might have similar success with the use of these devices.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Chart reviews and telephone surveys were performed on patients operated by the senior surgeon (JSG) at our medical center from June 2006 to June 2011. A total of 50 patients underwent excision of painful single or multiple neuromas with the end of the resected nerve sutured into the collagen conduit. Each patient preoperatively was asked to describe the amount of pain he or she was experiencing on a scale from 1 to 10, with 10 indicating the most severe pain. In the telephone interview conducted during this study, the same question was asked of each patient following revision. Patient ages ranged from 16 to 77 years, with a mean of 54 years. In all, 30 right and 20 left sides were operated, and 1 patient had bilateral involvement. Mean follow-up was 36 months (6-55 months). There were a total of 69 nerves that underwent conduit procedures.

RESULTS

Of 69 nerve conduit constructs, 30 (43%) were painless at final outcome, 23 (33%) had pain scores of 1 to 4, 6 (9%) had pain scores of 5 to 7, and 10 (15%) had severe symptoms with pain scores of 8 to 10. Satisfactory outcomes in which patients stated that they were significantly improved with the procedure and now functional occurred in 59/69 (85%). In all, 24 (48%) patients were completely symptom free, 13 (26%) had a pain score of 1 to 4, 6 (12%) had scores of 5 to 7, and 10 (15%) had severe pain with scores of 8 to 10. Three patients had superficial infections (stitch abscesses): 2 resolved with oral antibiotics and 1 resolved spontaneously. Three patients developed complex regional pain syndrome. One patient responded to a dorsal column stimulator and 2 responded to sympathetic blocks. No other complications were reported.

CONCLUSION

Collagen conduits were safe and generally successful adjuncts to simple excision in the management of painful neuromas of the foot and ankle.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level IV, retrospective case series.

Pedicle and free flaps for painful nerve

Treatment of the chronic painful nerve by pedicled or free tissue transfer is a complex surgical procedure, requiring specialized microsurgical training and technique. This procedure is indicated only in patients who have had repeated failure of simpler, conventional procedures. Patients with chronic painful peripheral nerves may be potentially salvaged by external neurolysis and circumferential wrapping of the involved segments of nerve with well-vascularized pedicled or free flaps of fascia, subcutaneous fatty tissue, omentum or muscle, or by the replacement of superficial hypersensitive cutaneous areas and nerves with the same tissues.

The potential role of nerve growth factor (NGF) in painful neuromas and the mechanism of pain relief by their relocation to muscle

Painful neuromas have been successfully treated by surgical procedures including relocation to muscle, but the underlying molecular mechanism remains unclear. Nerve growth factor (NGF) is secreted by tissues and promotes the expression of ion channels and neuropeptides in sensory neurons involved in pain transmission. We hypothesised that excess of NGF may lead to pain in neuromas and that the efficacy of surgical relocation results from deprivation of NGF, i.e. translocation from NGF-rich regions, particularly sub-cutaneous structures associated with injury or inflammation, to NGF-poor structures such as muscle or bone. Using immunohistological methods with primary antibodies to rhNGF, we report that NGF levels were elevated in 13 painful neuromas in comparison with six control nerves. However, in four painful neuromata re-located into muscle with pain relief, the NGF level was similar to that of controls. NGF levels suggest an explanation for the development of painful neuromas and the efficacy of relocation.

Coverage of painful peripheral nerve neuromas with vascularized soft tissue: method and results

OBJECTIVE

Our goals are to describe a method of treating painful peripheral nerve neuromas by means of vascularized tissue coverage, report the results in seven patients, and discuss the indications for this treatment modality. An analysis of pain, functionality of the affected body part, professional activities of the patients, and medications before and after surgery is presented.

METHODS

Seven male patients (mean age, 45.1 yr) with posttraumatic nerve injuries, who had developed painful stump neuromas or neuromas-in-continuity, and who had unsuccessfully undergone several treatment procedures, were selected for the surgery described here. The operation included resection of the stump neuroma (four patients) or neurolysis of the neuroma-in-continuity (three patients) and coverage of the nerve with a vascularized fascial, fasciocutaneous, or perforator flap (three pedicled regional flaps and four free flaps). A modified quadruple visual analog scale was used to quantify pain before and after surgical treatment. The mean follow-up was 16.6 months.

RESULTS

The mean values of the quadruple visual analog scale (pain now/typically/at its best/at its worst) before surgery were 6.5/6.5/4.7/7.9. These values changed to 0.3/0.4/0/0.9 at a mean follow-up of 16.6 months after surgery. Five patients returned to their original profession, one receives a pension, and one began a less demanding job after undergoing surgery. Six of the seven patients received opioids before surgery (one had a spinal cord stimulator). After surgery, all patients stopped taking regular pain killers and the spinal cord stimulator was deactivated in one; two patients still take nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs occasionally, but not on a regular basis.

CONCLUSION

Vascularized soft tissue coverage of painful peripheral nerve neuromas seems to be an effective and attractive, but also complex, method of treatment. This option may be considered and reserved for patients who have already undergone several pain treatment modalities without success.

The Position of Crossing Branches of the Medial Antebrachial Cutaneous Nerve during Cubital Tunnel Surgery in Humans

The posterior branch of the medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve courses in proximity to the cubital tunnel and is particularly prone to injury during ulnar nerve release at the elbow. Inadvertent injury to medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve branches during surgery can result in the formation of painful neuromas that can be misdiagnosed as recurrent disease. It is important to understand the relevant anatomy of the medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve branches during cubital tunnel surgery to avoid significant postoperative morbidity. This prospective observational anatomic study examined the position of the posterior branch of the medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve in relationship to a standard approach to the cubital tunnel in a randomly selected group of 97 patients undergoing primary surgery over a 3-year period. Medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve branches were noted to cross at or proximal to the medial humeral epicondyle 61 percent of the time at an average proximal distance of 1.8 cm. Medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve branches were noted to cross distal to the medial humeral epicondyle 100 percent of the time at an average distal distance of 3.1 cm. Understanding the general position of crossing medial antebrachial cutaneous nerve branches during ulnar nerve release at the elbow may help to prevent iatrogenic injury to this cutaneous nerve.

The treatment of painful neuroma on the lower extremity by resection and nerve stump transplantation into a vein

Lower extremity neuroma resection with nerve stump transposition into a vein was employed in eight patients (five male, three female). The neuromas resulted from amputations (four patients), vein stripping procedures (two patients), tumor resection, and toe-harvest for thumb reconstruction. Follow-up averaged 17 months (range, 8-37). Four of the patients experienced complete and permanent relief of pain; in three patients mild pain recurred within 3 months. All of these patients were satisfied with the result and did not request further treatment. In one case, a painful neuroma recurred. Our results suggest the possibility of inhibiting the formation of painful neuromas by nerve transposition into a vein. Further use of this method is encouraged.

Treatment of painful neuroma by resection and nerve stump transplantation into a vein

Twenty-three patients (14 men, 9 women) with 24 painful neuromas underwent resection of neuroma and transposition of the nerve stump into an adjacent vein. The neuromas resulted from amputations (N = 7), tumor excision (N = 5), laceration injuries (N = 4), different types of wrist surgery (N = 3), vein-stripping procedures (N = 2), open fracture of the radius (N = 1), and toe harvest for thumb reconstruction (N = 1). The duration of painful symptoms averaged 66.7 weeks at the time of operation. Average follow-up was 26.5 months. In 22 patients the symptoms improved permanently. Twelve patients experienced complete and permanent relief of pain; some mild degree of pain returned in 8 patients. Two patients experienced moderate pain, and pain recurred unchanged 2 months postoperatively in 1 patient. The results presented are consistent with results of animal experiments demonstrating that typical neuroma does not develop in nerve stumps transposed into veins. Further clinical use of this approach is encouraged.

Management of neuromas

After nerve injury and regeneration, significant pain may be associated with the scar and altered sensation observed within the distribution of the injured nerve. A bulbous swelling may form at the severed nerve end, constituting a traumatic neuroma. The development of a painful neuroma may be more disabling to the patient than an area of anesthesia or even loss of motor function. Effective treatment of the painful neuroma remains a difficult problem. Diminished productivity, alterations in patient lifestyle, and possible progression to chronic pain syndromes must be considered within the scope of neuroma management, and treatment must focus on alleviating the pain and restoring the functional loss caused by the nerve injury. Careful patient selection is the cornerstone of successful outcomes. Once the patient has been selected, the surgical management of the painful neuroma throughout the body is based on basic principles that vary only slightly from region to region. Using these tenets, a neuroma management algorithm has been developed based on the pathophysio-logy of the neuroma, the results of experimental studies, review of patient outcomes, and understanding the psychology of pain in the surgical patient.

Nerve stripping: new treatment for neuromas of the palmar cutaneous branch of the median nerve

We present a new method for the treatment of painful neuromas of the palmar cutaneous branch of the median nerve. A preliminary cadaver study was done to investigate the extraneural and intraneural course of the palmar cutaneous branch of the median nerve with respect to the main trunk of the median nerve. Seven patients presented with a painful neuroma following previous surgery on the palmar aspect of the wrist. The neuroma was dissected and excised by stripping the whole of the palmar cutaneous branch from the main trunk of the median nerve. In all cases complete relief from pain and discomfort was achieved. The resulting area of numbness in the palm did not represent a significant problem.

The surgical treatment of painful traumatic neuromas

Pain following suspected nerve injury was comprehensively evaluated with detailed examination including history, neurological evaluation, electrodiagnostic studies, quantitative sensory testing, thermography, anesthetic agents, and sympathetic nerve blocks. Forty-two surgically treated patients fell into four discrete groups: Group 1 patients had distal sensory neuromas treated by excision of the neuroma and reimplantation of the proximal nerve into muscle or bone marrow; Group 2 patients had suspected distal sensory neuromas in which the involved nerve was sectioned proximal to the injury site and reimplanted; Group 3 patients had proximal in-continuity neuromas of major sensorimotor nerves treated by external neurolysis; and Group 4 patients had proximal major sensorimotor nerve injuries at points of anatomical entrapment treated by external neurolysis and transposition, if possible. Patient follow-up monitoring from 2 to 32 months (average 11 months) was possible in 40 (95%) of 42 patients. Surgical success was defined as 50% or greater improvement in pain using the Visual Analog Scale or pain relief subjectively rated as either good or excellent, without postoperative narcotic usage. Overall, 16 (40%) of 40 patients met those criteria. Success rates varied as follows: 44% in 18 Group 1 patients, 40% in 10 Group 2 patients, 0% in five Group 3 patients, and 57% in seven Group 4 patients. Twelve (30%) of 40 patients were employed both pre- and postoperatively. It is concluded that: 1) neuroma excision, neurectomy, and nerve release for injury-related pain of peripheral nerve origin yield substantial subjective improvement in a minority of patients; 2) external neurolysis of proximal mixed nerves is ineffective in relieving pain; 3) surgically proving the existence of a neuroma with confirmed excision may be preferable; 4) traumatic neuroma pain is only partly due to a peripheral source; 5) demographic and neurological variables do not predict success; 6) the presence of a discrete nerve syndrome and mechanical hyperalgesia modestly predict pain relief; 7) ongoing litigation is the strongest predictor of failure; and 8) change in work status is not a likely outcome.