Prospective study on trisomy 18 and fetal choroid plexus cysts

Second trimester markers of aneuploidy

The risks of aneuploidy associated with identification of a sonographic marker in the low risk population is controversial. Prior risk estimates have been derived usually from high risk populations. Screening programmes in the first trimester, second trimester and combined first and second trimester will undoubtedly alter the second trimester scan as a screening tool for aneuploidy. This chapter reviews the current sonographic markers and the difficulties in their application to the general population.

Choroid plexus cysts and aneuploidy

The association of choroid plexus cysts with fetal aneuploidy, particularly trisomy 18, was first noted in 1986. Through the years there have been numerous reports on this subject, but no consensus has been reached with regard to chromosomal risk. In this review, we attempt to summarise published reports on second trimester choroid plexus cysts, with an emphasis on the strengths and weaknesses of each report. Based on these reports, additional malformations are a significant risk factor for aneuploidy and an indication for determination of fetal karyotype. The management of isolated choroid plexus cysts remains controversial.

Clinical significance of fetal choroid plexus cysts

Choroid plexus (CP) cysts are commonly detected on routine mid-trimester ultrasound scan. When associated anomalies are detected, the risk is sufficient to justify an invasive diagnostic test such as amniocentesis. However, the risk when no associated anomalies are detected is much less well defined. This information is required to determine the appropriate management in cases of apparently isolated CP cysts. We thought the only way to resolve the difficulties in counselling prospective parents was to conduct a prospective study in a large unselected population. A registry of fetal CP cysts detected over 3 years in the Yorkshire Region was compiled and we identified 524 CP cysts. These cases were then amalgamated and analysed with 1361 cases from prospective studies reported in the world English literature and a further 71 unpublished cases identified from a 2 year prospective series from Ninewells Hospital, Dundee. The risk of chromosomal abnormalities was 1 in 150 (95% CI 1 in 85, 1 in 261) when no fetal anatomic abnormalities, apart from the CP cysts themselves, were detected antenatally. The risk increased to approximately 1 in 3 if any other associated ultrasound abnormalities were detected antenatally. The risk did not appear to be related to whether or not cyst size diminished as gestation progresses, whether they were unilateral or bilateral, and whether they were small or large in size (60-80% < 10 mm). 76% of aneuploidic cases were trisomy 18 and 17% were trisomy 21. The risk of Down's syndrome in fetuses with CP cysts but no other anomalies detected antenatally is 1 in 880. The probability of a chromosomal abnormality is high when CP cysts are associated with any other antenatally detected anomaly, indicating a clear need to offering amniocentesis. The predictive value is much lower when no other anomalies are detected. In such cases, it is probably advisable to regard CP cysts as an indication for detailed ultrasound assessment, rather than invasive testing.

Isolated choroid plexus cyst(s): an indication for amniocentesis

OBJECTIVE

Our purpose was to prospectively evaluate the risk of chromosomal abnormalities associated with isolated choroid plexus cyst(s) in gravid women undergoing second-trimester ultrasonographic examination.

STUDY DESIGN

During a 24-month period 9100 pregnant women underwent midtrimester ultrasonographic evaluation. Women with a fetal diagnosis of choroid plexus cyst(s) were offered amniocentesis and a repeat examination in 4 to 6 weeks.

RESULTS

A diagnosis of choroid plexus cyst(s) was made in 102 fetuses (1.1%). In four of these fetuses multiple congenital anomalies were noted. Three of the four fetuses had a chromosomal abnormality, two trisomy 18 and one unbalanced translocation, t(3;13). In the remaining 98 fetuses the choroid plexus cysts were isolated findings, that is, there were no other ultrasonographically detected anomalies. Seventy-five of these 98 fetuses underwent amniocentesis. An abnormal karyotype was identified in four fetuses: three had Down syndrome (two trisomy 21 and one unbalanced translocation, t[14;21]), and one trisomy 18. The offspring of the 23 patients in which amniocentesis was declined were phenotypically normal.

CONCLUSIONS

In our prospective study the risk of chromosomal abnormality with isolated choroid plexus cyst(s) was 1:25, a risk that exceeds the 1:200 risk of pregnancy loss after amniocentesis and the 1:126 and 1:260 risk for aneuploidy and Down syndrome, respectively, in a 35-year-old pregnant women during the midtrimester. These findings indicate that amniocentesis should be offered to pregnant women in the presence of isolated fetal choroid plexus cyst(s).

Choroid plexus cysts: significance and current management practices

Choroid plexus cysts are commonly found in normal fetuses in the second trimester, but the presence of cysts is an indication for a targeted ultrasound scan for signs associated with aneuploidy. In this review the authors explain the histological basis for choroid plexus cyst formation, the association with aneuploidy, and the management controversies that continues to be debated in the literature.