Chemical cross-linkers for protein structure studies by mass spectrometry

Selective Removal of Unhydrolyzed Monolinked Peptides from Enriched Crosslinked Peptides To Improve the Coverage of Protein Complex Analysis

Chemical crosslinking combined with mass spectrometry (CXMS) has allowed the global characterization of protein complexes with high throughput and accuracy. Although enrichable crosslinkers have been introduced to exclude the interference of regular peptides, the crosslinked peptide identification is still severely inhibited by a large amount of monolinked peptides. In this work, we proposed a strategy called MoTE (unhydrolyzed Monolinked peptide Targeting Elimination) to remove the unhydrolyzed monolinked peptides, while enriching crosslinked peptides for regular peptide removal. In this strategy, followed by the crosslinking reaction, an amine biotin reagent was used to block the unreacted reactive groups on the crosslinker, and subsequently, the crosslinked proteins were tagged by a cleavable biotin-azide ligand based on click chemistry for enrichment. The following crosslinked protein digestion, purification by streptavidin beads, and release by chemical cleavage of the biotin-azide ligand were sequentially performed. In this case, the amine biotin-blocked unhydrolyzed monolinked peptides with the unbreakable arm remained on the streptavidin beads, which realized selective removal without any additional steps. By combining in vivo crosslinking with our proposed MoTE strategy for protein complex analysis of the HeLa cell, the number of high reliability (score <E-04) interlinked peptides increased 43% in a single LC-MS run, and the structural and interaction mapping capacity for low-abundance and flexible proteins were greatly enhanced. These results demonstrated that the MoTE strategy has great potential to improve the coverage of CXMS-based protein complex analysis. Notably, it was also the first report focused on removing the highly abundant monolinked peptides.

Protein Chemistry Combined with Mass Spectrometry for Protein Structure Determination

The advent of soft-ionization mass spectrometry for biomolecules has opened up new possibilities for the structural analysis of proteins. Combining protein chemistry methods with modern mass spectrometry has led to the emergence of the distinct field of structural proteomics. Multiple protein chemistry approaches, such as surface modification, limited proteolysis, hydrogen-deuterium exchange, and cross-linking, provide diverse and often orthogonal structural information on the protein systems studied. Combining experimental data from these various structural proteomics techniques provides a more comprehensive examination of the protein structure and increases confidence in the ultimate findings. Here, we review various types of experimental data from structural proteomics approaches with an emphasis on the use of multiple complementary mass spectrometric approaches to provide experimental constraints for the solving of protein structures.

Progress in methodologies and quality-control strategies in protein cross-linking mass spectrometry

Deciphering the interaction networks and structural dynamics of proteins is pivotal to better understanding their biological functions. Cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS) is a powerful and increasingly popular technology that provides information about protein-protein interactions and their structural constraints for individual proteins and multiprotein complexes on a proteome-scale. In this review, we first assess the coverage and depth of the XL-MS technique by utilizing publicly available datasets. We then delve into the progress in XL-MS experimental and computational methodologies and examine different quality-control strategies reported in the literature. Finally, we discuss the progress in XL-MS applications along with the scope for future improvements.

Proximity labeling and other novel mass spectrometric approaches for spatiotemporal protein dynamics

BACKGROUND

Proteins are highly dynamic and their biological function is controlled by not only temporal abundance changes but also via regulated protein-protein interaction networks, which respond to internal and external perturbations. A wealth of novel analytical reagents and workflows allow studying spatiotemporal protein environments with great granularity while maintaining high throughput and ease of analysis.

AREAS COVERED

We review technology advances for measuring protein-protein proximity interactions with an emphasis on proximity labeling, and briefly summarize other spatiotemporal approaches including protein localization, and their dynamic changes over time, specifically in human cells and mammalian tissues. We focus especially on novel technologies and workflows emerging within the past 5 years. This includes enrichment-based techniques (proximity labeling and crosslinking), separation-based techniques (organelle fractionation and size exclusion chromatography), and finally sorting-based techniques (laser capture microdissection and mass spectrometry imaging).

EXPERT OPINION

Spatiotemporal proteomics is a key step in assessing biological complexity, understanding refined regulatory mechanisms, and forming protein complexes and networks. Studying protein dynamics across space and time holds promise for gaining deep insights into how protein networks may be perturbed during disease and aging processes, and offer potential avenues for therapeutic interventions, drug discovery, and biomarker development.

Computational methods in mass spectrometry-based structural proteomics for studying protein structure, dynamics, and interactions

Mass spectrometry (MS) has made enormous contributions to comprehensive protein identification and quantification in proteomics. MS is also gaining momentum for structural biology in a variety of ways, complementing conventional structural biology techniques. Here, we will review how MS-based techniques, such as hydrogen/deuterium exchange, covalent labeling, and chemical cross-linking, enable the characterization of protein structure, dynamics, and interactions, especially from a perspective of their data analyses. Structural information encoded by chemical probes in intact proteins is decoded by interpreting MS data at a peptide level, i.e., revealing conformational and dynamic changes in local regions of proteins. The structural MS data are not amenable to data analyses in traditional proteomics workflow, requiring dedicated software for each type of data. We first provide basic principles of data interpretation, including isotopic distribution and peptide sequencing. We then focus particularly on computational methods for structural MS data analyses and discuss outstanding challenges in a proteome-wide large scale analysis.

Cross-linking/mass spectrometry at the crossroads

Cross-linking/mass spectrometry (XL-MS) has come a long way. Originally, XL-MS was used to study relatively small, purified proteins. Meanwhile, it is employed to investigate protein-protein interactions on a proteome-wide level, giving snapshots of cellular processes. Currently, XL-MS is at the intersection of a multitude of workflows and the impact this technique has in addressing specific biological questions is steadily growing. This article is intended to give a bird's-eye view of the current status of XL-MS, the benefits of using MS-cleavable cross-linkers, and the challenges posed in the future development of this powerful technology. We also illustrate how XL-MS can deliver valuable structural insights into protein complexes when used in combination with other structural techniques, such as electron microscopy. Graphical abstract.

To Cleave or Not To Cleave in XL-MS?

Cross-linking mass spectrometry (XL-MS) is an efficient technique for uncovering structural features and interactions of the in-solution state of the proteins under investigation. Distance constraints obtained by this technique are highly complementary to classical structural biology approaches like X-ray crystallography and cryo-EM and have successfully been leveraged to shed light on protein structures of increasing size and complexity. To accomplish this, small reagents are used that typically incorporate two amine reactive moieties connected by a spacer arm and that can be applied in solution to protein structures of any size. Over the years, many reagents initially developed for different applications were adopted, and others were specifically developed for XL-MS. This has resulted in a vast array of options, making it difficult to make the right choice for specific experiments. Here, we delve into the previous decade of published XL-MS literature to uncover which workflows have been predominantly applied. We focus on application papers as these represent proof that biologically valid results can be extracted. This ignores some more recent approaches that did not have sufficient time to become more widely applied, for which we supply a separate discussion. From our selection, we extract information on the types of samples, cross-linking reagent, prefractionation, instruments, and data analysis, to highlight widely used workflows. All of the results are summarized in an easy-to-use flow chart defined by selection points resulting from our analysis. Although potentially biased by our own experiences, we expect this overview to be useful for novices stepping into this rapidly expanding field.

The Isotope-Labeled, MS-Cleavable Cross-Linker Disuccinimidyl Dibutyric Urea for Improved Cross-Linking/Mass Spectrometry Studies

Previous studies have shown the benefits of the amine-reactive, CID-MS/MS-cleavable cross-linker disuccinimidyl dibutyric urea (DSBU) for structural proteomics studies via cross-linking/MS (XL-MS). To further facilitate the automation of XL-MS experiments, we synthesized a deuterated (D₁₂) version of the DSBU cross-linker combining the advantages of MS-cleavable linkers and isotope labeling. The rationale of conducting XL-MS with a mixture of unlabeled and stable isotope-labeled DSBU is to obtain characteristic mass differences at the MS level indicating cross-linked species. These cross-linked species can then be selected for fragmentation by collisional activation. At the MS/MS level, the characteristic 26-u doublets arising from cleavage of the central urea group in DSBU confirm the amino acid sequences of cross-linked peptides as well as the exact cross-linking sites. D₁₂-labeled DSBU was tested on three systems with increasing complexity: (i) bovine serum albumin as purified protein, (ii) Escherichia coli ribosome as large, multimeric protein assembly, and (iii) Drosophila embryo extract as complete proteome. We demonstrate the benefits arising from the use of isotope-labeled DSBU for an automated assignment of cross-linked products. Combining isotope labeling and MS cleavability in one cross-linker resulted in higher cross-link identification numbers especially for highly complex protein mixtures.

Mass spectrometric approaches for profiling protein folding and stability

Protein stability reports on protein homeostasis, function, and binding interactions, such as to other proteins, metabolites and drugs. As such, there is a pressing need for technologies that can report on protein stability. The ideal technique could be applied in vitro or in vivo systems, proteome-wide, independently of matrix, under native conditions, with residue-level resolution, and on protein at endogenous levels. Mass spectrometry has rapidly become a preferred technology for identifying and quantifying proteins. As such, it has been increasingly incorporated into methodologies for interrogating protein stability and folding. Although no single technology can satisfy all desired applications, several emerging approaches have shown outstanding success at providing biological insight into the stability of the proteome. This chapter outlines some of these recent emerging technologies.

Covalent Cross-Linking as an Enabler for Structural Mass Spectrometry

The number of studies referring to the structural elucidation of intact biomolecular systems using mass spectrometry techniques has gradually increased in the post-2000s literature topics. As part of native mass spectrometry, this domain capitalizes on the kinetic trapping of physiological folds in view of probing solution-like conformational properties of isolated molecules or complexes after their electrospray transfer to the gas phase. Despite its efficiency for a wide array of analytes, this approach is expected to be pushed to its limits when considering highly dynamic systems or when dealing with nonideal operating conditions. To circumvent these limitations, we challenge the adequacy of an original strategy based on cross-linkers to improve the gas-phase stability of isolated proteins and ensure the preservation of folded conformations when measuring with strong transmission voltages, by spraying from denaturing solvents, or trapping for extended periods of time. Tested on cytochrome c, myoglobin, and β-lactoglobulin cross-linked using BS³, we validated the process as structurally nonintrusive in solution using far-ultraviolet circular dichroism and unraveled the preservation of folded conformations showing better resilience to denaturation on cross-linked species using ion mobility. The resulting collision cross sections were found in agreement with the native fold, and a preservation of the proteins' secondary and tertiary structures was evidenced using molecular dynamics simulations. Our results provide new insights concerning the fate of electro-sprayed cross-linked conformers in the gas phase, while constituting promising evidence for the validation of this technique as part of future structural mass spectrometry workflows.

Prediction of an Upper Limit for the Fraction of Interprotein Cross-Links in Large-Scale In Vivo Cross-Linking Studies

Chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometry is of growing use for establishment of distance constraints on protein conformations and interactions. Whereas intraprotein cross-links can arise from proteins in isolation, interprotein cross-links reflect proximity of two interacting proteins in the sample. Prediction of expected ratios of the number of interprotein to intraprotein cross-links is hindered by lacking comprehensive knowledge on the interactome network and global occupancy levels for all interacting complex subunits. Here we determine the theoretical number of possible inter- and intraprotein cross-links in available PDB structures of proteins bound in complexes to predict a maximum expected fraction of interprotein cross-links in large scale in vivo cross-linking studies. We show how the maximum fraction can guide interpretation of reported interprotein fractions with respect to the extent of sample protein binding, comparing whole cell and lysate cross-linked samples as an example. We also demonstrate how an observation of interprotein cross-link fractions greater than the maximum value can result from the presence of false positive cross-links which are predominantly interprotein, their number estimable from the observed surplus fraction of interprotein cross-links.

Systems structural biology measurements by in vivo cross-linking with mass spectrometry

This protocol describes a workflow for utilizing large-scale cross-linking with mass spectrometry (XL-MS) to make systems-level structural biology measurements in complex biological samples, including cells, isolated organelles, and tissue samples. XL-MS is a structural biology technique that provides information on the molecular structure of proteins and protein complexes using chemical probes that report the proximity of probe-reactive amino acids within proteins, typically lysine residues. Information gained through XL-MS studies is often complementary to more traditional methods, such as X-ray crystallography, nuclear magnetic resonance, and cryo-electron microscopy. The use of MS-cleavable cross-linkers, including protein interaction reporter (PIR) technologies, enables XL-MS studies on protein structures and interactions in extremely complex biological samples, including intact living cells. PIR cross-linkers are designed to contain chemical bonds at specific locations within the cross-linker molecule that can be selectively cleaved by collision-induced dissociation or UV light. When broken, these bonds release the intact peptides that were cross-linked, as well as a reporter ion. Conservation of mass dictates that the sum of the two released peptide masses and the reporter mass equals the measured precursor mass. This relationship is used to identify cross-linked peptide pairs. Release of the individual peptides permits accurate measurement of their masses and independent amino acid sequence determination by tandem MS, allowing the use of standard proteomics search engines such as Comet for peptide sequence assignment, greatly simplifying data analysis of cross-linked peptide pairs. Search results are processed with XLinkProphet for validation and can be uploaded into XlinkDB for interaction network and structural analysis.

MS methods to study macromolecule-ligand interaction: Applications in drug discovery

The interaction of small compounds (i.e. ligands) with macromolecules or macromolecule assemblies (i.e. targets) is the mechanism of action of most of the drugs available today. Mass spectrometry is a popular technique for the interrogation of macromolecule-ligand interactions and therefore is also widely used in drug discovery and development. Thanks to its versatility, mass spectrometry is used for multiple purposes such as biomarker screening, identification of the mechanism of action, ligand structure optimization or toxicity assessment. The evolution and automation of the instruments now allows the development of high throughput methods with high sensitivity and a minimized false discovery rate. Herein, all these approaches are described with a focus on the methods for studying macromolecule-ligand interaction aimed at defining the structure-activity relationships of drug candidates, along with their mechanism of action, metabolism and toxicity.

Structural basis for substrate selection by the translocation and assembly module of the β-barrel assembly machinery

The assembly of proteins into bacterial outer membranes is a key cellular process that we are only beginning to understand, mediated by the β-barrel assembly machinery (BAM). Two crucial elements of that machinery are the core BAM complex and the translocation and assembly module (TAM), with each containing a member of the Omp85 superfamily of proteins: BamA in the BAM complex, TamA in the TAM. Here, we used the substrate protein FimD as a model to assess the selectivity of substrate interactions for the TAM relative to those of the BAM complex. A peptide scan revealed that TamA and BamA bind the β-strands of FimD, and do so selectively. Chemical cross-linking and molecular dynamics are consistent with this interaction taking place between the first and last strand of the TamA barrel domain, providing the first experimental evidence of a lateral gate in TamA: a structural element implicated in membrane protein assembly. We suggest that the lateral gates in TamA and BamA provide different environments for substrates to engage, with the differences observed here beginning to address how the TAM can be more effective than the BAM complex in the folding of some substrate proteins.

Optimizing the Parameters Governing the Fragmentation of Cross-Linked Peptides in a Tribrid Mass Spectrometer

We compared the five different ways of fragmentation available on a tribrid mass spectrometer and optimized their collision energies with regard to optimal sequence coverage of cross-linked peptides. We created a library of bis(sulfosuccinimidyl)suberate (BS3/DSS) cross-linked precursors, derived from the tryptic digests of three model proteins (Human Serum Albumin, creatine kinase, and myoglobin). This enabled in-depth targeted analysis of the fragmentation behavior of 1065 cross-linked precursors using the five fragmentation techniques: collision-induced dissociation (CID), beam-type CID (HCD), electron-transfer dissociation (ETD), and the combinations ETciD and EThcD. EThcD gave the best sequence coverage for cross-linked m/z species with high charge density, while HCD was optimal for all others. We tested the resulting data-dependent decision tree against collision energy-optimized single methods on two samples of differing complexity (a mix of eight proteins and a highly complex ribosomal cellular fraction). For the high complexity sample the decision tree gave the highest number of identified cross-linked peptide pairs passing a 5% false discovery rate (on average ∼21% more than the second best, HCD). For the medium complexity sample, the higher speed of HCD proved decisive. Currently, acquisition speed plays an important role in allowing the detection of cross-linked peptides against the background of linear peptides. Enrichment of cross-linked peptides will reduce this role and favor methods that provide spectra of higher quality. Data are available via ProteomeXchange with identifier PXD006131.

Development of Large-scale Cross-linking Mass Spectrometry

Cross-linking mass spectrometry (CLMS) provides distance constraints to study the structure of proteins, multiprotein complexes and protein-protein interactions which are critical for the understanding of protein function. CLMS is an attractive technology to bridge the gap between high-resolution structural biology techniques and proteomic-based interactome studies. However, as outlined in this review there are still several bottlenecks associated with CLMS which limit its application on a proteome-wide level. Specifically, there is an unmet need for comprehensive software that can reliably identify cross-linked peptides from large data sets. In this review we provide supporting information to reason that targeted proteomics of cross-links may provide the required sensitivity to reliably detect and quantify cross-linked peptides and that a reporter ion signature for cross-linked peptides may become a useful approach to increase confidence in the identification process of cross-linked peptides. In addition, the review summarizes the recent advances in CLMS workflows using the analysis of condensin complex in intact chromosomes as a model complex.

Mass spectrometry-based cross-linking study shows that the Psb28 protein binds to cytochrome b559 in Photosystem II

Photosystem II (PSII), a large pigment protein complex, undergoes rapid turnover under natural conditions. During assembly of PSII, oxidative damage to vulnerable assembly intermediate complexes must be prevented. Psb28, the only cytoplasmic extrinsic protein in PSII, protects the RC47 assembly intermediate of PSII and assists its efficient conversion into functional PSII. Its role is particularly important under stress conditions when PSII damage occurs frequently. Psb28 is not found, however, in any PSII crystal structure, and its structural location has remained unknown. In this study, we used chemical cross-linking combined with mass spectrometry to capture the transient interaction of Psb28 with PSII. We detected three cross-links between Psb28 and the α- and β-subunits of cytochrome b₅₅₉, an essential component of the PSII reaction-center complex. These distance restraints enable us to position Psb28 on the cytosolic surface of PSII directly above cytochrome b₅₅₉, in close proximity to the Q_B site. Protein-protein docking results also support Psb28 binding in this region. Determination of the Psb28 binding site and other biochemical evidence allow us to propose a mechanism by which Psb28 exerts its protective effect on the RC47 intermediate. This study also shows that isotope-encoded cross-linking with the "mass tags" selection criteria allows confident identification of more cross-linked peptides in PSII than has been previously reported. This approach thus holds promise to identify other transient protein-protein interactions in membrane protein complexes.

The Life of Pi Star: Exploring the Exciting and Forbidden Worlds of the Benzophenone Photophore

The widespread applications of benzophenone (BP) photochemistry in biological chemistry, bioorganic chemistry, and material science have been prominent in both academic and industrial research. BP photophores have unique photochemical properties: upon n-π* excitation at 365 nm, a biradicaloid triplet state is formed reversibly, which can abstract a hydrogen atom from accessible C-H bonds; the radicals subsequently recombine, creating a stable covalent C-C bond. This light-directed covalent attachment process is exploited in many different ways: (i) binding/contact site mapping of ligand (or protein)-protein interactions; (ii) identification of molecular targets and interactome mapping; (iii) proteome profiling; (iv) bioconjugation and site-directed modification of biopolymers; (v) surface grafting and immobilization. BP photochemistry also has many practical advantages, including low reactivity toward water, stability in ambient light, and the convenient excitation at 365 nm. In addition, several BP-containing building blocks and reagents are commercially available. In this review, we explore the "forbidden" (transitions) and excitation-activated world of photoinduced covalent attachment of BP photophores by touring a colorful palette of recent examples. In this exploration, we will see the pros and cons of using BP photophores, and we hope that both novice and expert photolabelers will enjoy and be inspired by the breadth and depth of possibilities.

Full-Length Anion Exchanger 1 Structure and Interactions with Ankyrin-1 Determined by Zero Length Crosslinking of Erythrocyte Membranes

Anion exchanger 1 (AE1) is a critical transporter and the primary structural scaffold for large macromolecular complexes responsible for erythrocyte membrane flexibility and integrity. We used zero-length crosslinking and mass spectrometry to probe AE1 structures and interactions in intact erythrocyte membranes. An experimentally verified full-length model of AE1 dimers was developed by combining crosslink-defined distance constraints with homology modeling. Previously unresolved cytoplasmic loops in the AE1 C-terminal domain are packed at the domain-domain interface on the cytoplasmic face of the membrane where they anchor the N-terminal domain's location and prevent it from occluding the ion channel. Crosslinks between AE1 dimers and ankyrin-1 indicate the likely topology for AE1 tetramers and suggest that ankyrin-1 wraps around AE1 tetramers, which may stabilize this oligomer state. This interaction and interactions of AE1 with other major erythrocyte membrane proteins show that protein-protein contacts are often substantially more extensive than previously reported.

Blind testing cross-linking/mass spectrometry under the auspices of the 11th critical assessment of methods of protein structure prediction (CASP11)

Determining the structure of a protein by any method requires various contributions from experimental and computational sides. In a recent study, high-density cross-linking/mass spectrometry (HD-CLMS) data in combination with ab initio structure prediction determined the structure of human serum albumin (HSA) domains, with an RMSD to X-ray structure of up to 2.5 Å, or 3.4 Å in the context of blood serum. This paper reports the blind test on the readiness of this technology through the help of Critical Assessment of protein Structure Prediction (CASP). We identified between 201-381 unique residue pairs at an estimated 5% FDR (at link level albeit with missing site assignment precision evaluation), for four target proteins. HD-CLMS proved reliable once crystal structures were released. However, improvements in structure prediction using cross-link data were slight. We identified two reasons for this. Spread of cross-links along the protein sequence and the tightness of the spatial constraints must be improved. However, for the selected targets even ideal contact data derived from crystal structures did not allow modellers to arrive at the observed structure. Consequently, the progress of HD-CLMS in conjunction with computational modeling methods as a structure determination method, depends on advances on both arms of this hybrid approach.

SNaPe: a versatile method to generate multiplexed protein fusions using synthetic linker peptides for in vitro applications

Understanding the structure and function of protein complexes and multi-domain proteins is highly important in biology, although the in vitro characterization of these systems is often complicated by their size or the transient nature of protein/protein interactions. To assist in the characterization of such protein complexes, we have developed a modular approach to fusion protein generation that relies upon Sortase-mediated and Native chemical ligation using synthetic Peptide linkers (SNaPe) to link two separately expressed proteins. In this approach, we utilize two separate linking steps - sortase-mediated and native chemical ligation - together with a library of peptide linkers to generate libraries of fusion proteins. We have demonstrated the viability of SNaPe to generate libraries from fusion protein constructs taken from the biosynthetic enzymes responsible for late stage aglycone assembly during glycopeptide antibiotic biosynthesis. Crucially, SNaPe was able to generate fusion proteins that are inaccessible via direct expression of the fusion construct itself. This highlights the advantages of SNaPe to not only access fusion proteins that have been previously unavailable for biochemical and structural characterization but also to do so in a manner that enables the linker itself to be controlled as an experimental parameter of fusion protein generation. Copyright © 2016 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.

Cross-linking and other structural proteomics techniques: how chemistry is enabling mass spectrometry applications in structural biology

The biological function of proteins is heavily influenced by their structures and their organization into assemblies such as protein complexes and regulatory networks. Mass spectrometry (MS) has been a key enabling technology for high-throughput and comprehensive protein identification and quantification on a proteome-wide scale. Besides these essential contributions, MS can also be used to study higher-order structures of biomacromolecules in a variety of ways. In one approach, intact proteins or protein complexes may be directly probed in the mass spectrometer. Alternatively, various forms of solution-phase chemistry are used to introduce modifications in intact proteins and localizing these modifications by MS analysis at the peptide level is used to derive structural information. Here, I will put a spotlight on the central role of chemistry in such mass spectrometry-based methods that bridge proteomics and structural biology, with a particular emphasis on chemical cross-linking of protein complexes.

The Use of Advanced Mass Spectrometry to Dissect the Life-Cycle of Photosystem II

Photosystem II (PSII) is a photosynthetic membrane-protein complex that undergoes an intricate, tightly regulated cycle of assembly, damage, and repair. The available crystal structures of cyanobacterial PSII are an essential foundation for understanding PSII function, but nonetheless provide a snapshot only of the active complex. To study aspects of the entire PSII life-cycle, mass spectrometry (MS) has emerged as a powerful tool that can be used in conjunction with biochemical techniques. In this article, we present the MS-based approaches that are used to study PSII composition, dynamics, and structure, and review the information about the PSII life-cycle that has been gained by these methods. This information includes the composition of PSII subcomplexes, discovery of accessory PSII proteins, identification of post-translational modifications and quantification of their changes under various conditions, determination of the binding site of proteins not observed in PSII crystal structures, conformational changes that underlie PSII functions, and identification of water and oxygen channels within PSII. We conclude with an outlook for the opportunity of future MS contributions to PSII research.

Protein Structural Analysis via Mass Spectrometry-Based Proteomics

Modern mass spectrometry (MS) technologies have provided a versatile platform that can be combined with a large number of techniques to analyze protein structure and dynamics. These techniques include the three detailed in this chapter: (1) hydrogen/deuterium exchange (HDX), (2) limited proteolysis, and (3) chemical crosslinking (CX). HDX relies on the change in mass of a protein upon its dilution into deuterated buffer, which results in varied deuterium content within its backbone amides. Structural information on surface exposed, flexible or disordered linker regions of proteins can be achieved through limited proteolysis, using a variety of proteases and only small extents of digestion. CX refers to the covalent coupling of distinct chemical species and has been used to analyze the structure, function and interactions of proteins by identifying crosslinking sites that are formed by small multi-functional reagents, termed crosslinkers. Each of these MS applications is capable of revealing structural information for proteins when used either with or without other typical high resolution techniques, including NMR and X-ray crystallography.

Synthesis of two new enrichable and MS-cleavable cross-linkers to define protein-protein interactions by mass spectrometry

The cross-linking Mass Spectrometry (XL-MS) technique extracts structural information from protein complexes without requiring highly purified samples, crystallinity, or large amounts of material. However, there are challenges to applying the technique to protein complexes in vitro, and those challenges become more daunting with in vivo experiments. Issues include effective detection and identification of cross-linked peptides from complex mixtures. While MS-cleavable cross-linkers facilitate the sequencing and identification of cross-linked peptides, enrichable cross-linkers increase their detectability by allowing their separation from non-cross-linked peptides prior to MS analysis. Although a number of cross-linkers with single functionality have been developed in recent years, an ideal reagent would incorporate both capabilities for XL-MS studies. Therefore, two new cross-linkers have been designed and prepared that incorporate an azide (azide-A-DSBSO) or alkyne (alkyne-A-DSBSO) to enable affinity purification strategies based on click chemistry. The integration of an acid cleavage site next to the enrichment handle allows easy recovery of cross-linked products during affinity purification. In addition, these sulfoxide containing cross-linking reagents possess robust MS-cleavable bonds to facilitate fast and easy identification of cross-linked peptides using MS analysis. Optimized, gram-scale syntheses of these cross-linkers have been developed and the azide-A-DSBSO cross-linker has been evaluated with peptides and proteins to demonstrate its utility in XL-MS analysis.

Analysis of Protein-protein Interaction Interface between Yeast Mitochondrial Proteins Rim1 and Pif1 Using Chemical Cross-linking Mass Spectrometry

Defining protein-protein contacts is a challenging problem and cross-linking is a promising solution. Here, we present a case of mitochondrial single strand binding protein Rim1 and helicase Pif1, an interaction first observed in immuno-affinity pull-down from yeast cells using Pif1 bait. We found that only the short succinimidyl-diazirine cross-linker or formaldehyde captured the interaction between recombinant Rim1 and Pif1. In addition, Pif1 needed to be stripped of its N-terminal and C-terminal domains, and Rim1's C-terminus needed to be modified for the cross-linked product to become visible. Our report is an example of a non-trivial analysis, where a previously identified stable interaction escapes initial capture with cross-linking agents and requires substantial modification to recombinant proteins and fine-tuning of the mass spectrometry-based methods for the cross-links to become detectable. We used high resolution mass spectrometry to detect the cross-linked peptides. A 1:1 mixture of ¹⁵N and ¹⁴N-labeled Rim1 was used to validate the cross-links by their mass shift in the LC-MS profiles. Two sites on Rim1 were confirmed: 1) the N-terminus, and 2) the K29 residue. Performing cross-linking with a K29A variant visibly reduced the cross-linked product. Further, K29A-Rim1 showed a five-fold lower affinity to single stranded DNA compared to wild-type Rim1. Both the K29A variant and wild type Rim1 showed similar degrees of stimulation of Pif1 helicase activity. We propose structural models of the Pif1-Rim1 interaction and discuss its functional significance. Our work represents a non-trivial protein-protein interface analysis and demonstrates utility of short and non-specific cross-linkers.

Probing structures of large protein complexes using zero-length cross-linking

Structural mass spectrometry (MS) is a field with growing applicability for addressing complex biophysical questions regarding proteins and protein complexes. One of the major structural MS approaches involves the use of chemical cross-linking coupled with MS analysis (CX-MS) to identify proximal sites within macromolecules. Identified cross-linked sites can be used to probe novel protein-protein interactions or the derived distance constraints can be used to verify and refine molecular models. This review focuses on recent advances of "zero-length" cross-linking. Zero-length cross-linking reagents do not add any atoms to the cross-linked species due to the lack of a spacer arm. This provides a major advantage in the form of providing more precise distance constraints as the cross-linkable groups must be within salt bridge distances in order to react. However, identification of cross-linked peptides using these reagents presents unique challenges. We discuss recent efforts by our group to minimize these challenges by using multiple cycles of LC-MS/MS analysis and software specifically developed and optimized for identification of zero-length cross-linked peptides. Representative data utilizing our current protocol are presented and discussed.

Insights into Eukaryotic Translation Initiation from Mass Spectrometry of Macromolecular Protein Assemblies

Translation initiation in eukaryotes requires the interplay of at least 10 initiation factors that interact at the different steps of this phase of gene expression. The interactions of initiation factors and related proteins are in general controlled by phosphorylation, which serves as a regulatory switch to turn protein translation on or off. The structures of initiation factors and a complete description of their post-translational modification (PTM) status are therefore required in order to fully understand these processes. In recent years, mass spectrometry has contributed considerably to provide this information and nowadays is proving to be indispensable when studying dynamic heterogeneous protein complexes such as the eukaryotic initiation factors. Herein, we highlight mass spectrometric approaches commonly applied to identify interacting subunits and their PTMs and the structural techniques that allow the architecture of protein complexes to be assessed. We present recent structural investigations of initiation factors and their interactions with other factors and with ribosomes and we assess the models generated. These models allow us to locate PTMs within initiation factor complexes and to highlight possible roles for phosphorylation sites in regulating interaction interfaces.

Dithiothreitol (DTT) Acts as a Specific, UV-inducible Cross-linker in Elucidation of Protein-RNA Interactions

Protein-RNA cross-linking by UV irradiation at 254 nm wavelength has been established as an unbiased method to identify proteins in direct contact with RNA, and has been successfully applied to investigate the spatial arrangement of protein and RNA in large macromolecular assemblies, e.g. ribonucleoprotein-complex particles (RNPs). The mass spectrometric analysis of such peptide-RNA cross-links provides high resolution structural data to the point of mapping protein-RNA interactions to specific peptides or even amino acids. However, the approach suffers from the low yield of cross-linking products, which can be addressed by improving enrichment and analysis methods. In the present article, we introduce dithiothreitol (DTT) as a potent protein-RNA cross-linker. In order to evaluate the efficiency and specificity of DTT, we used two systems, a small synthetic peptide from smB protein incubated with U1 snRNA oligonucleotide and native ribonucleoprotein complexes from S. cerevisiae. Our results unambiguously show that DTT covalently participates in cysteine-uracil crosslinks, which is observable as a mass increment of 151.9966 Da (C(4)H(8)S(2)O(2)) upon mass spectrometric analysis. DTT presents advantages for cross-linking of cysteine containing regions of proteins. This is evidenced by comparison to experiments where (tris(2-carboxyethyl)phosphine) is used as reducing agent, and significantly less cross-links encompassing cysteine residues are found. We further propose insertion of DTT between the cysteine and uracil reactive sites as the most probable structure of the cross-linking products.

Recent advances in the use of mass spectrometry to examine structure/function relationships in photosystem II

Tandem mass spectrometry often coupled with chemical modification techniques, is developing into increasingly important tool in structural biology. These methods can provide important supplementary information concerning the structural organization and subunit make-up of membrane protein complexes, identification of conformational changes occurring during enzymatic reactions, identification of the location of posttranslational modifications, and elucidation of the structure of assembly and repair complexes. In this review, we will present a brief introduction to Photosystem II, tandem mass spectrometry and protein modification techniques that have been used to examine the photosystem. We will then discuss a number of recent case studies that have used these techniques to address open questions concerning PS II. These include the nature of subunit-subunit interactions within the phycobilisome, the interaction of phycobilisomes with Photosystem I and the Orange Carotenoid Protein, the location of CyanoQ, PsbQ and PsbP within Photosystem II, and the identification of phosphorylation and oxidative modification sites within the photosystem. Finally, we will discuss some of the future prospects for the use of these methods in examining other open questions in PS II structural biochemistry.

Solution structure of the reduced form of human peroxiredoxin-6 elucidated using zero-length chemical cross-linking and homology modelling

Peroxiredoxin-6 (PRDX6) is an unusual member of the peroxiredoxin family of antioxidant enzymes that has only one evolutionarily conserved cysteine. It reduces oxidized lipids and reactive oxygen species (ROS) by oxidation of the active-site cysteine (Cys(47)) to a sulfenic acid, but the mechanism for conversion back to a thiol is not completely understood. Moreover, it has phospholipase A2 (PLA2) activity in addition to its peroxidase activity. Interestingly, some biochemical data are inconsistent with a known high-resolution crystal structure of the catalytic intermediate of the protein, and biophysical data indicate that the protein undergoes conformational changes that affect enzyme activity. In order to further elucidate the solution structure of this important enzyme, we used chemical cross-linking coupled with high-resolution MS (CX-MS), with an emphasis on zero-length cross-links. Distance constraints from high confidence cross-links were used in homology modelling experiments to determine a solution structure of the reduced form of the protein. This structure was further evaluated using chemical cross-links produced by several homo-bifunctional amine-reactive cross-linking reagents, which helped to confirm the solution structure. The results show that several regions of the reduced version of human PRDX6 are in a substantially different conformation from that shown for the crystal structure of the peroxidase catalytic intermediate. The differences between these two structures are likely to reflect catalysis-related conformational changes. These studies also demonstrate that CX-MS using zero-length cross-linking is a powerful strategy for probing protein conformational changes that is complementary to alternative methods such as crystallographic, NMR and biophysical studies.

Formaldehyde cross-linking and structural proteomics: Bridging the gap

Proteins are dynamic entities constantly moving and altering their structures based on their functions and interactions inside and outside the cell. Formaldehyde cross-linking combined with mass spectrometry can accurately capture interactions of these rapidly changing biomolecules while maintaining their physiological surroundings. Even with its numerous established uses in biology and compatibility with mass spectrometry, formaldehyde has not yet been applied in structural proteomics. However, formaldehyde cross-linking is moving toward analyzing tertiary structure, which conventional cross-linkers have already accomplished. The purpose of this review is to describe the potential of formaldehyde cross-linking in structural proteomics by highlighting its applications, characteristics and current status in the field.

Chemical cross-linking and mass spectrometry to determine the subunit interaction network in a recombinant human SAGA HAT subcomplex

Understanding the way how proteins interact with each other to form transient or stable protein complexes is a key aspect in structural biology. In this study, we combined chemical cross-linking with mass spectrometry to determine the binding stoichiometry and map the protein-protein interaction network of a human SAGA HAT subcomplex. MALDI-MS equipped with high mass detection was used to follow the cross-linking reaction using bis[sulfosuccinimidyl] suberate (BS3) and confirm the heterotetrameric stoichiometry of the specific stabilized subcomplex. Cross-linking with isotopically labeled BS3 d0-d4 followed by trypsin digestion allowed the identification of intra- and intercross-linked peptides using two dedicated search engines: pLink and xQuest. The identified interlinked peptides suggest a strong network of interaction between GCN5, ADA2B and ADA3 subunits; SGF29 is interacting with GCN5 and ADA3 but not with ADA2B. These restraint data were combined to molecular modeling and a low-resolution interacting model for the human SAGA HAT subcomplex could be proposed, illustrating the potential of an integrative strategy using cross-linking and mass spectrometry for addressing the structural architecture of multiprotein complexes.

A mass spectrometry view of stable and transient protein interactions

Through an impressive range of dynamic interactions, proteins succeed to carry out the majority of functions in a cell. These temporally and spatially regulated interactions provide the means through which one single protein can perform diverse functions and modulate different cellular pathways. Understanding the identity and nature of these interactions is therefore critical for defining protein functions and their contribution to health and disease processes. Here, we provide an overview of workflows that incorporate immunoaffinity purifications and quantitative mass spectrometry (frequently abbreviated as IP-MS or AP-MS) for characterizing protein-protein interactions. We discuss experimental aspects that should be considered when optimizing the isolation of a protein complex. As the presence of nonspecific associations is a concern in these experiments, we discuss the common sources of nonspecific interactions and present label-free and metabolic labeling mass spectrometry-based methods that can help determine the specificity of interactions. The effective regulation of cellular pathways and the rapid reaction to various environmental stresses rely on the formation of stable, transient, and fast-exchanging protein-protein interactions. While determining the exact nature of an interaction remains challenging, we review cross-linking and metabolic labeling approaches that can help address this important aspect of characterizing protein interactions and macromolecular assemblies.

Protein painting reveals solvent-excluded drug targets hidden within native protein-protein interfaces

Identifying the contact regions between a protein and its binding partners is essential for creating therapies that block the interaction. Unfortunately, such contact regions are extremely difficult to characterize because they are hidden inside the binding interface. Here we introduce protein painting as a new tool that employs small molecules as molecular paints to tightly coat the surface of protein–protein complexes. The molecular paints, which block trypsin cleavage sites, are excluded from the binding interface. Following mass spectrometry, only peptides hidden in the interface emerge as positive hits, revealing the functional contact regions that are drug targets. We use protein painting to discover contact regions between the three-way interaction of IL1β ligand, the receptor IL1RI and the accessory protein IL1RAcP. We then use this information to create peptides and monoclonal antibodies that block the interaction and abolish IL1β cell signalling. The technology is broadly applicable to discover protein interaction drug targets.

Identifying the site where a protein binds to another molecule is an important factor for the design of therapeutics intended to prevent this interaction. Here, the authors coat protein–receptor complexes with surface-binding molecules, and determine their interacting regions using mass spectrometry.

Crosslinking constraints and computational models as complementary tools in modeling the extracellular domain of the glycine receptor

The glycine receptor (GlyR), a member of the pentameric ligand-gated ion channel superfamily, is the major inhibitory neurotransmitter-gated receptor in the spinal cord and brainstem. In these receptors, the extracellular domain binds agonists, antagonists and various other modulatory ligands that act allosterically to modulate receptor function. The structures of homologous receptors and binding proteins provide templates for modeling of the ligand-binding domain of GlyR, but limitations in sequence homology and structure resolution impact on modeling studies. The determination of distance constraints via chemical crosslinking studies coupled with mass spectrometry can provide additional structural information to aid in model refinement, however it is critical to be able to distinguish between intra- and inter-subunit constraints. In this report we model the structure of GlyBP, a structural and functional homolog of the extracellular domain of human homomeric α1 GlyR. We then show that intra- and intersubunit Lys-Lys crosslinks in trypsinized samples of purified monomeric and oligomeric protein bands from SDS-polyacrylamide gels may be identified and differentiated by MALDI-TOF MS studies of limited resolution. Thus, broadly available MS platforms are capable of providing distance constraints that may be utilized in characterizing large complexes that may be less amenable to NMR and crystallographic studies. Systematic studies of state-dependent chemical crosslinking and mass spectrometric identification of crosslinked sites has the potential to complement computational modeling efforts by providing constraints that can validate and refine allosteric models.

Analysis of amyloid nanostructures using photo-cross-linking: in situ comparison of three widely used photo-cross-linkers

Photoinduced cross-linking (PIC) has become a powerful tool in chemical biology for the identification and mapping of stable or transient interactions between biomacromolecules and their (unknown) ligands. However, the value of PIC for in vitro and in vivo structural proteomics can be realized only if cross-linking reports accurately on biomacromolecule secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structures with residue-specific resolution. Progress in this area requires rigorous and comparative studies of PIC reagents, but despite widespread use of PIC, these have rarely been performed. The use of PIC to report reliably on noncovalent structure is therefore limited, and its potentials have yet to be fully realized. In the present study, we compared the abilities of three probes, phenyl trifluoromethyldiazirine (TFMD), benzophenone (BP), and phenylazide (PA), to record structural information within a biomolecular complex. For this purpose, we employed a self-assembled amyloid-like peptide nanostructure as a tightly and specifically packed model environment in which to photolyze the reagents. Information about PIC products was gathered using mass spectrometry and ion mobility spectrometry, and the data were interpreted using a mechanism-oriented approach. While all three PIC groups appeared to generate information within the packed peptide environment, the data highlight technical limitations of BP and PA. On the other hand, TFMD displayed accuracy and generated straightforward results. Thus TFMD, with its robust and rapid photochemistry, was shown to be an ideal probe for cross-linking of peptide nanostructures. The implications of our findings for detailed analyses of complex systems, including those that are transiently populated, are discussed.

Probing large conformational rearrangements in wild-type and mutant spectrin using structural mass spectrometry

Conformational changes of macromolecular complexes play key mechanistic roles in many biological processes, but large, highly flexible proteins and protein complexes usually cannot be analyzed by crystallography or NMR. Here, structures and conformational changes of the highly flexible, dynamic red cell spectrin and effects of a common mutation that disrupts red cell membranes were elucidated using chemical cross-linking coupled with mass spectrometry. Interconversion of spectrin between closed dimers, open dimers, and tetramers plays a key role in maintaining red cell shape and membrane integrity, and spectrins in other cell types serve these as well as more diverse functions. Using a minispectrin construct, experimentally verified structures of closed dimers and tetramers were determined by combining distance constraints from zero-length cross-links with molecular models and biophysical data. Subsequent biophysical and structural mass spectrometry characterization of a common hereditary elliptocytosis-related mutation of α-spectrin, L207P, showed that cell membranes were destabilized by a shift of the dimer-tetramer equilibrium toward closed dimers. The structure of αL207P mutant closed dimers provided previously unidentified mechanistic insight into how this mutation, which is located a large distance from the tetramerization site, destabilizes spectrin tetramers and cell membrane integrity.

Dynamic protein ligand interactions--insights from MS

Proteins undergo dynamic interactions with carbohydrates, lipids and nucleotides to form catalytic cores, fine‐tuned for different cellular actions. The study of dynamic interactions between proteins and their cognate ligands is therefore fundamental to the understanding of biological systems. During the last two decades MS, and its associated techniques, has become accepted as a method for the study of protein–ligand interactions, not only for covalent complexes, where the use of MS is well established, but also, and significantly for protein–ligand interactions, for noncovalent assemblies. In this review, we employ a broad definition of a ligand to encompass protein subunits, drug molecules, oligonucleotides, carbohydrates, and lipids. Under the appropriate conditions, MS can reveal the composition, heterogeneity and dynamics of these protein–ligand interactions, and in some cases their structural arrangements and binding affinities. Herein, we highlight MS approaches for studying protein–ligand complexes, including those containing integral membrane subunits, and showcase examples from recent literature. Specifically, we tabulate the myriad of methodologies, including hydrogen exchange, proteomics, hydroxyl radical footprinting, intact complexes, and crosslinking, which, when combined with MS, provide insights into conformational changes and subtle modifications in response to ligand‐binding interactions.

Enhanced identification of zero-length chemical cross-links using label-free quantitation and high-resolution fragment ion spectra

Chemical cross-linking coupled to mass spectrometry provides structural information that is useful for probing protein conformations and providing experimental support for molecular models. "Zero-length" cross-links have greater value for these applications than longer cross-links because they provide more stringent distance constraints. However, this method is less commonly utilized because it cannot take advantage of isotopic labels, MS-labile bonds, or enrichment tags to facilitate identification. In this study, we combined label-free precursor ion quantitation and targeted tandem mass spectrometry with a new software tool, Zero-length Cross-link Miner (ZXMiner), to form a multitiered analysis strategy. A major, critical objective was to simultaneously achieve very high accuracy with essentially no false-positive cross-link identifications while maintaining a good depth of analysis. Our strategy was optimized on several proteins with known crystal structures. Comparison of ZXMiner to several existing cross-link analysis software showed that other algorithms detected less true positive cross-links and were far less accurate. Although prior use of zero-length cross-linking was typically restricted to small proteins, ZXMiner and the associated strategy enable facile analysis of very large protein complexes. This was demonstrated by identification of zero-length cross-links using purified 526 kDa spectrin heterodimers and intact red cell membranes and membrane skeletons.