Feasibility Study for the MALDI-MSI Analysis of Thyroid Fine Needle Aspiration Biopsies: Evaluating the Morphological and Proteomic Stability Over Time

The journey towards clinical adoption of MALDI-MS-based imaging proteomics: from current challenges to future expectations

Among the spatial omics techniques available, mass spectrometry imaging (MSI) represents one of the most promising owing to its capability to map the distribution of hundreds of peptides and proteins, as well as other classes of biomolecules, within a complex sample background in a multiplexed and relatively high-throughput manner. In particular, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionisation (MALDI-MSI) has come to the fore and established itself as the most widely used technique in clinical research. However, the march of this technique towards clinical utility has been hindered by issues related to method reproducibility, appropriate biocomputational tools, and data storage. Notwithstanding these challenges, significant progress has been achieved in recent years regarding multiple facets of the technology and has rendered it more suitable for a possible clinical role. As such, there is now more robust and extensive evidence to suggest that the technology has the potential to support clinical decision-making processes under appropriate circumstances. In this review, we will discuss some of the recent developments that have facilitated this progress and outline some of the more promising clinical proteomics applications which have been developed with a clear goal towards implementation in mind.

Paving the path toward multi-omics approaches in the diagnostic challenges faced in thyroid pathology

INTRODUCTION

Despite advancements in diagnostic methods, the classification of indeterminate thyroid nodules still poses diagnostic challenges not only in pre-surgical evaluation but even after histological evaluation of surgical specimens. Proteomics, aided by mass spectrometry and integrated with artificial intelligence and machine learning algorithms, shows great promise in identifying diagnostic markers for thyroid lesions.

AREAS COVERED

This review provides in-depth exploration of how proteomics has contributed to the understanding of thyroid pathology. It discusses the technical advancements related to immunohistochemistry, genetic and proteomic techniques, such as mass spectrometry, which have greatly improved sensitivity and spatial resolution up to single-cell level. These improvements allowed the identification of specific protein signatures associated with different types of thyroid lesions.

EXPERT COMMENTARY

Among all the proteomics approaches, spatial proteomics stands out due to its unique ability to capture the spatial context of proteins in both cytological and tissue thyroid samples. The integration of multi-layers of molecular information combining spatial proteomics, genomics, immunohistochemistry or metabolomics and the implementation of artificial intelligence and machine learning approaches, represent hugely promising steps forward toward the possibility to uncover intricate relationships and interactions among various molecular components, providing a complete picture of the biological landscape whilst fostering thyroid nodule diagnosis.

Advances and Emerging Medical Applications of Direct Mass Spectrometry Technologies for Tissue Analysis

Offering superb speed, chemical specificity, and analytical sensitivity, direct mass spectrometry (MS) technologies are highly amenable for the molecular analysis of complex tissues to aid in disease characterization and help identify new diagnostic, prognostic, and predictive markers. By enabling detection of clinically actionable molecular profiles from tissues and cells, direct MS technologies have the potential to guide treatment decisions and transform sample analysis within clinical workflows. In this review, we highlight recent health-related developments and applications of direct MS technologies that exhibit tangible potential to accelerate clinical research and disease diagnosis, including oncological and neurodegenerative diseases and microbial infections. We focus primarily on applications that employ direct MS technologies for tissue analysis, including MS imaging technologies to map spatial distributions of molecules in situ as well as handheld devices for rapid in vivo and ex vivo tissue analysis.

Applications of spatially resolved omics in the field of endocrine tumors

Endocrine tumors derive from endocrine cells with high heterogeneity in function, structure and embryology, and are characteristic of a marked diversity and tissue heterogeneity. There are still challenges in analyzing the molecular alternations within the heterogeneous microenvironment for endocrine tumors. Recently, several proteomic, lipidomic and metabolomic platforms have been applied to the analysis of endocrine tumors to explore the cellular and molecular mechanisms of tumor genesis, progression and metastasis. In this review, we provide a comprehensive overview of spatially resolved proteomics, lipidomics and metabolomics guided by mass spectrometry imaging and spatially resolved microproteomics directed by microextraction and tandem mass spectrometry. In this regard, we will discuss different mass spectrometry imaging techniques, including secondary ion mass spectrometry, matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization and desorption electrospray ionization. Additionally, we will highlight microextraction approaches such as laser capture microdissection and liquid microjunction extraction. With these methods, proteins can be extracted precisely from specific regions of the endocrine tumor. Finally, we compare applications of proteomic, lipidomic and metabolomic platforms in the field of endocrine tumors and outline their potentials in elucidating cellular and molecular processes involved in endocrine tumors.

Cytological Cytospin Preparation for the Spatial Proteomics Analysis of Thyroid Nodules Using MALDI-MSI

The application of innovative spatial omics approaches in the context of cytological specimens may open new frontiers for their diagnostic assessment. In particular, spatial proteomics using matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) mass spectrometry imaging (MSI) represents one of the most promising avenues, owing to its capability to map the distribution of hundreds of proteins within a complex cytological background in a multiplexed and relatively high-throughput manner. This approach may be particularly beneficial in the heterogeneous context of thyroid tumors where certain cells may not present clear-cut malignant morphology upon fine-needle aspiration biopsy, highlighting the necessity for additional molecular tools which are able to improve their diagnostic performance.This chapter aims to provide a detailed overview of a cytospin-based preparation workflow that has been optimized to facilitate the reliable spatial proteomics analysis of cytological thyroid specimens using MALDI-MSI, indicating the key aspects which should be considered when handling such samples.

Cytomolecular Classification of Thyroid Nodules Using Fine-Needle Washes Aspiration Biopsies

Fine-needle aspiration biopsies (FNA) represent the gold standard to exclude the malignant nature of thyroid nodules. After cytomorphology, 20–30% of cases are deemed “indeterminate for malignancy” and undergo surgery. However, after thyroidectomy, 70–80% of these nodules are benign. The identification of tools for improving FNA’s diagnostic performances is explored by matrix-assisted laser-desorption ionization mass spectrometry imaging (MALDI-MSI). A clinical study was conducted in order to build a classification model for the characterization of thyroid nodules on a large cohort of 240 samples, showing that MALDI-MSI can be effective in separating areas with benign/malignant cells. The model had optimal performances in the internal validation set (n = 70), with 100.0% (95% CI = 83.2–100.0%) sensitivity and 96.0% (95% CI = 86.3–99.5%) specificity. The external validation (n = 170) showed a specificity of 82.9% (95% CI = 74.3–89.5%) and a sensitivity of 43.1% (95% CI = 30.9–56.0%). The performance of the model was hampered in the presence of poor and/or noisy spectra. Consequently, restricting the evaluation to the subset of FNAs with adequate cellularity, sensitivity improved up to 76.5% (95% CI = 58.8–89.3). Results also suggest the putative role of MALDI-MSI in routine clinical triage, with a three levels diagnostic classification that accounts for an indeterminate gray zone of nodules requiring a strict follow-up.

Ex vivo thyroid fine needle aspirations as an alternative for MALDI-MSI proteomic investigation: intra-patient comparison

Fine needle aspiration (FNA) is the reference standard for the diagnosis of thyroid nodules. Matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization mass spectrometry imaging (MALDI-MSI) has been successfully used to discriminate the proteomic profiles of benign and malignant thyroid FNAs within the scope of providing support to pathologists for the classification of morphologically borderline cases. However, real FNAs provide a limited amount of material due to sample collection restrictions. Ex vivo FNAs could represent a valuable alternative, increasing sample size and the power of statistical conclusions. In this study, we compared the real and ex vivo MALDI-MSI proteomic profiles, extracted from thyrocyte containing regions of interest, of 13 patients in order to verify their similarity. Statistical analysis demonstrated the mass spectra similarity of the proteomic profiles by performing intra-patient comparison, using statistical similarity systems. In conclusion, these results show that post-surgical FNAs represent a possible alternative source of material for MALDI-MSI proteomic investigations in instances where pre-surgical samples are unavailable or the number of cells is scarce.

Classification of Thyroid Tumors Based on Mass Spectrometry Imaging of Tissue Microarrays; a Single-Pixel Approach

The primary diagnosis of thyroid tumors based on histopathological patterns can be ambiguous in some cases, so proper classification of thyroid diseases might be improved if molecular biomarkers support cytological and histological assessment. In this work, tissue microarrays representative for major types of thyroid malignancies—papillary thyroid cancer (classical and follicular variant), follicular thyroid cancer, anaplastic thyroid cancer, and medullary thyroid cancer—and benign thyroid follicular adenoma and normal thyroid were analyzed by mass spectrometry imaging (MSI), and then different computation approaches were implemented to test the suitability of the registered profiles of tryptic peptides for tumor classification. Molecular similarity among all seven types of thyroid specimens was estimated, and multicomponent classifiers were built for sample classification using individual MSI spectra that corresponded to small clusters of cells. Moreover, MSI components showing the most significant differences in abundance between the compared types of tissues detected and their putative identity were established by annotation with fragments of proteins identified by liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry in corresponding tissue lysates. In general, high accuracy of sample classification was associated with low inter-tissue similarity index and a high number of components with significant differences in abundance between the tissues. Particularly, high molecular similarity was noted between three types of tumors with follicular morphology (adenoma, follicular cancer, and follicular variant of papillary cancer), whose differentiation represented the major classification problem in our dataset. However, low level of the intra-tissue heterogeneity increased the accuracy of classification despite high inter-tissue similarity (which was exemplified by normal thyroid and benign adenoma). We compared classifiers based on all detected MSI components (n = 1536) and the subset of the most abundant components (n = 147). Despite relatively higher contribution of components with significantly different abundance and lower overall inter-tissue similarity in the latter case, the precision of classification was generally higher using all MSI components. Moreover, the classification model based on individual spectra (a single-pixel approach) outperformed the model based on mean spectra of tissue cores. Our result confirmed the high feasibility of MSI-based approaches to multi-class detection of cancer types and proved the good performance of sample classification based on individual spectra (molecular image pixels) that overcame problems related to small amounts of heterogeneous material, which limit the applicability of classical proteomics.

Molecular trait of follicular-patterned thyroid neoplasms defined by MALDI-imaging

In the field of thyroid neoplasms, the most interesting recent change regards the introduction of a new terminology for follicular-patterned thyroid tumors, named Noninvasive Thyroid Neoplasm with Papillary-like Nuclear Features (NIFTP). This pre-malignant tumor is considered to be the putative precursor of invasive carcinoma. However, given that several issues are still unresolved, the application of ancillary tools, based on omics-techniques, may improve the clinical management of these challenging cases. The present paper highlights the proteomic profiles of a series of NIFTPs submitted to Fine Needle Aspirations (FNAs) and analysed by MALDI-imaging in order to confirm the heterogeneous phenotype of nodules included in the present NIFTP terminology and to underline the necessity of more accurate biomarkers that can be used for their characterization. Ethical and economic implications in terms of healthcare costs, operative risks, morbidity, as well as the potential need for lifelong hormone replacement therapy, seem to be significant reasons to approach the characterization of NIFTPs using alternative tools such as MALDI-MSI.

Analysis of Hashimoto's thyroiditis on fine needle aspiration samples by MALDI-Imaging

Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization (MALDI)-Mass Spectrometry imaging (MSI) has been applied in various diseases aimed to biomarkers discovery. In this study diagnosis and prognosis of Hashimoto Thyroiditis (HT) in cytopathology by MALDI-MSI has been investigated. Specimens from a routine series of subjects who underwent UltraSound-guided thyroid Fine Needle Aspirations (FNAs) were used. The molecular classifier trained in a previous study was modified to include HT as a separate entity in the group of benign lesions, in the diagnostic proteomic triage of thyroid nodules. The statistical analysis confirmed the existence of signals that HT shares with hyperplastic lesions and others that are specific and characterize this subgroup. Statistically relevant HT-related peaks were included in the model. Then, the discriminatory capability of the classifier was tested in a second validation phase, showing a good agreement with cytological diagnoses. The possibility to overlap the molecular signatures of both the lymphocytes and epithelial cells components (ROIs or pixel-by-pixel analysis) confirmed the composite proteomic background of HT. These results open the way to their possible translation as alternative serum biomarkers of this autoimmune condition.

MALDI-MSI as a Complementary Diagnostic Tool in Cytopathology: A Pilot Study for the Characterization of Thyroid Nodules

The present study applies for the first time as Matrix-Assisted Laser Desorption/Ionization (MALDI) Mass Spectrometry Imaging (MSI) on real thyroid Fine Needle Aspirations (FNAs) to test its possible complementary role in routine cytology in the diagnosis of thyroid nodules. The primary aim is to evaluate the potential employment of MALDI-MSI in cytopathology, using challenging samples such as needle washes. Firstly, we designed a statistical model based on the analysis of Regions of Interest (ROIs), according to the morphological triage performed by the pathologist. Successively, the capability of the model to predict the classification of the FNAs was validated in a different group of patients on ROI and pixel-by-pixel approach. Results are very promising and highlight the possibility to introduce MALDI-MSI as a complementary tool for the diagnostic characterization of thyroid nodules.