Embryotoxicity induced by alkylating agents: 7. Low dose prenatal-toxic risk estimation based on NOAEL risk factor approach, dose-response relationships, and DNA adducts using methylnitrosourea as a model compound

Analysis of reproductive toxicity and classification of glufosinate-ammonium

CONCLUSION REGARDING CLASSIFICATION OF GLUFOSINATE-AMMONIUM: Science Partners' Evaluation Group (Evaluation Group) has conducted an independent analysis of the herbicide glufosinate-ammonium (GA) relative to its potential to cause reproductive toxicity in humans. Further, the Evaluation Group has evaluated the implementation of Annex 6 of Commission Directive 2001/59/EC (28th ATP of Council Directive 67/548/EEC) and Council Directive 91/414/EEC, with respect to classification of chemicals posing potential reproductive hazards. After consideration of all information available to us relevant to the potential of glufosinate-ammonium (GA) to cause reproductive toxicity, the Science Partners Evaluation Group concludes that no classification of GA is justified. The following form the basis of this conclusion. There are no human data to suggest that GA causes reproductive toxicity in women or in their conceptus. The issue concerning possible reproductive hazard to humans is raised solely on the basis of positive animal test results that show GA to cause preimplantation or implantation losses in rats. SPECIFICALLY: a. Daily treatment with GA had no detectable effect on the earliest stages of the reproductive sequence including gametogenesis, ovulation, mating and conception; b. Treatment with GA interfered with rat gestation before and at the stage when the conceptus implants into the uterus. This effect occurred at doses of 360 ppm in the feed (corresponding to daily doses of 27.8 mg/kg bw) and above; and c. After implantation, no further effect of GA on prenatal and post-natal development was recognized. Previous concerns that GA might be toxic to embryonic stages after implantation were not supported by the data. Abortions and stillbirth seen were associated with, and regarded as secondary to, maternal toxicity. There was no evidence suggesting the induction of malformations in the offspring. The mechanism underlying this adverse effect in experimental laboratory animals is identified-inhibition of glutamine synthetase. Glutamine is essential to the viability of the embryo. The embryo is dependent on a maternal source of the amino acid. For embryo lethality to occur, a significant reduction of maternal glutamine is required. Such reduction in maternal glutamine depends on a significant inhibition of glutamine synthetase by GA. This can only occur when the mother is exposed to very high levels of GA. SPECIFICALLY: a. The reproductive toxicity of GA is confined to very short, early stages of reproduction, during which the conceptus is dependent on maternal glutamine; and b. In order for the effect to occur, significant reduction in maternal blood glutamine level is required, which in turn depends on a significant inhibition of glutamine synthetase, induced by high levels of GA in the maternal system. There is no evidence for accumulation of GA in the mammalian organism beyond a factor of two and no evidence for its metabolic toxification. To raise a concern in humans, women would have to be exposed to GA during the very limited time frame of preimplantation or implantation and the exposure would have to be to the exceedingly high levels necessary to alter the maternal metabolism and, correspondingly, result in glutamine levels in maternal tissue and blood plasma being drastically reduced. There is no basis to suggest that such exposures would occur under conditions of normal handling and use. SPECIFICALLY: a. Under conditions of normal handling and use, operators would never be exposed to GA levels that could potentially inhibit glutamine synthetase to the extent that this inhibition could impair preimplantation or implantation. b. All acceptable exposure measurements and predictive calculations confirm this conclusion, and in fact demonstrate that reasonably foreseeable exposure of workers would be to levels significantly below the AOEL. c. The evidence is also clear that there is no reproductive toxicity hazard to workers upon reentry tosprayed fields, bystanders, consumers or toddlers. The safety margin compared to the NOAEL in animal studies is sufficiently large to assure protection of the health of workers using GA as well as bystanders, consumers, and toddlers. Pursuant to Annex 6 of Commission Directive 2001/59/EC (28th ATP of Council Directive 67/548/EEC), to justify a classification of category 2 there must be sufficient evidence to produce a strong presumption that human exposure to the substance may result in impaired fertility in humans. It is the conclusion of the Science Partners Evaluation Group that there is no reasonable evidence to suggest a strong presumption of impairment. To the contrary, there is clear evidence demonstrating a strong presumption that exposure to GA would not cause the adverse effect demonstrated in rats. Pursuant to Annex 6 of Commission Directive 2001/59/EC (28th ATP of Council Directive 67/548/EEC), to justify a classification of category 3, there must be sufficient evidence to provide a strong suspicion of impaired fertility in humans. There is no basis to conclude that the animal data demonstrating impaired preimplantation or implantation has any relevance to humans in that the effect found in rats only occurs at levels which would never be experienced by workers under conditions of normal handling and use or by bystanders, consumers, or toddlers.

Biochemical toxicology of chemical teratogenesis

Although exposure during pregnancy to many drugs and environmental chemicals is known to cause in utero death of the embryo of fetus, or initiate birth defects (teratogenesis) in the surviving offspring, surprisingly, little is known about the underlying biochemical and molecular mechanisms, or the determinants of teratological susceptibility, particularly in humans. In vitro and in vivo studies based primarily on rodent models suggest that many potential embryotoxic xenobiotics are actually proteratogens that must be bioactivated by enzymes such as the cytochromes P450 and peroxidases such as prostaglandin H synthase to teratogenic reactive intermediary metabolites. These reactive intermediates generally are electrophiles or free radicals that bind covalently (irreversibly) to, or directly of indirectly oxidize, embryonic cellular macromolecules such as DNA, protein, and lipid, irreversibly altering cellular function. Target oxidation, known as oxidase stress, often appears to be mediated by reactive oxygen species (ROS) such as hydroxyl radicals. The precise nature of the teratologically relevant molecular targets remains to be established, as do the relative conditions of the various types of macromolecular lesions. Teratological suseptibility appears to be determined in part by a balance among pathways of maternal xenobiotic elimination, embryonic xenobiotic bioactivation and detoxification of the xenobiotic reactive intermediate, direct and indirect pathways for the detoxification of ROS (cytoprotection), and repair of macromolecular lesions. Due largely to immature or otherwise compromised embryonic pathways for detoxification, Cytoprotection, and repair, the embryo is relatively susceptible to reactive intermediates, and teratogenesis via this mechanism can occur from exposure to therapeutic concentrations of drugs, or supposedly safe concentrations of environmental chemicals. Greater insight into the mechanisms involved in human reactive intermediate-mediated teratogenicity, and the determinants of individual teratological susceptibility, will be necessary to reduce the unwarranted embryonic attrition from xenobiotic exposure.

Embryotoxicity induced by alkylating agents: 9. Low dose prenatal-toxic risk estimation of ethylmethanesulfonate based on no-observed-adverse-effect-level risk factor approach, dose-response relationships, and molecular dosimetry

Analogously to an earlier study using methylnitrosourea (MNU) the prenatal-toxic risk of low doses of ethylmethanesulfonate (EMS) was estimated using different procedures, comparatively. First, the risk of low doses was estimated using linear extrapolation to zero. When using the variable "all gross structural abnormalities" the lowest effective dose in the experiment was 150 mg/kg body wt (5.6% incidence), the additional risk over background was calculated to be 5.0%, and the hypothetical incidence 0.1% was associated with the dose 3 mg/kg EMS. When evaluating "gross structural limb abnormalities," which are not observed in controls, the dose associated with the hypothetical incidence 0.1% was 17.4 mg/kg EMS. Furthermore, derived from a dose-response study of teratogenicity extrapolation to the possible risk of low doses was performed using nonlinear mathematical models. In this case, the results obtained are dependent on the dose response variable as well as from the statistical approach which was chosen. As an example, the values obtained from one evaluation are given: all gross structural abnormalities, Weibull transformation, jackknife approach: ED0.1% = 72 mg/kg EMS. For comparison a "virtually safe dose" was calculated by use of the no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) risk factor approach. The NOAEL under our experimental conditions was 100 mg per kg body wt. By using an arbitrarily chosen risk factor of 100 a "safe dose" of 1 mg EMS per kg body wt was obtained. In addition, molecular dosimetry of the DNA adduct rate of O6-ethylguanine in the 11-day-old embryos was used. Based on the assumption that a linear correlation exists between this specific adduct rate and the incidence of teratogenic effects, the hypothetical incidence of 0.1% was associated with a dose of 99 mg/kg EMS. This value is quite similar to that obtained by extrapolation using probit analysis which is in contrast to the results obtained with MNU.

Embryotoxicity induced by alkylating agents: 10. Analysis of the combined teratogenic effects of methylnitrosourea and ethylmethanesulfonate in mice

In previous studies the direct-acting alkylating model compounds methylnitrosourea (MNU) and ethylmethanesulfonate (EMS) were investigated with regard to dose-response of teratogenicity as well as DNA adduct formation in mice. In this study the teratogenic effects induced by combined treatment with these substances were analyzed using doses which, following single treatment with either substance, were around the threshold level, i.e., no adverse effect level (NOAEL) and lowest observed adverse effect level (LAOEL). Combined treatment of LAOELs resulted in a threshold-like response, while the combination of the NOAEL of one substance with the LAOEL of the other increased the response rate dramatically to nearly 100%. This phenomenon was further evaluated using biometrical methods. The dose-response surface as well as isobolograms were calculated in order to describe the combination effect. In addition, a dose-response model was fitted to the data. In conclusion, the initially surprising high combination effect revealed to be not so extraordinary when considering the steepness of the dose-response relationships of the single substances.

DNA modification induced by 6-mercaptopurine riboside in murine embryos

The cytostatic drug 6-mercaptopurine riboside (6-MPr) was investigated in mice in order to test the hypothesis that the teratogenicity of this antimetabolite is paralleled by an incorporation into the DNA of the embryos during organogenesis. DNA modification in the embryos was analysed 4 h following s.c. administration of [35S]-labelled 6-MPr to the dams on day 11 of pregnancy. The DNA of the embryos was isolated and hydrolysed to the bases by formic acid. Following separation by cation-exchange HPLC 6-thioguanine was found in the hydrolysate. Quantitation was performed by liquid scintillation counting. Evaluations of 6 doses in the range of 8-25 mg/kg were performed. An incorporation rate of 6-thioguanine from 32-56 pmol per mumol guanine was found in the DNA of the embryos. These findings suggest that, similar to the previously studied alkylating agents, the teratogenicity of 6-MPr may be, at least in part, induced via DNA modification of the embryos.

Comparison of effects of direct-acting DNA methylating and ethylating agents on inducible gene expression in vivo

Our laboratory is interested in whether chemical carcinogen-induced DNA damage is non-randomly distributed in the genome, i.e., "targeted," at the level of individual genes. As one means of investigating this, we have examined whether carcinogen treatment differentially alters the expression of specific genes in vivo. In this study, we have compared the effects of four direct-acting simple alkylating agents (methyl methanesulfonate, ethyl methanesulfonate, methylnitrosourea, and ethylnitrosourea) on the steady-state mRNA expression of a model inducible gene, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxykinase (PEPCK), using the chick embryo as a simple in vivo test system. We observed no effect of any of these four carcinogens on the steady-state mRNA expression of the constitutively expressed beta-actin, transferrin, or albumin genes in chick embryo liver following a single dose of carcinogen. In contrast, these same treatments significantly altered both the basal and inducible expression of the glucocorticoid-inducible PEPCK gene. These results support the hypothesis that inducible gene expression is a target for the effects of chemical carcinogens in vivo. In addition, the direction, magnitude, and time course of these effects were agent-specific. Qualitative and quantitative differences in effects between the methylating and ethylating agents and between the methanesulfonates and nitrosoureas were correlated with differences in their specific patterns of DNA adduct formation, suggesting that different DNA lesions have different effects on inducible gene expression.

Embryotoxicity induced by alkylating agents: 8. DNA adduct formation induced by ethylmethanesulfonate in mouse embryos

In previous studies using methylating agents a correlation was found between the initial DNA adduct rate (O6-methylguanine) in the embryo and the teratogenic efficiency. This was shown by measuring DNA adduct rates in the teratogenic dose range which exhibited similar adduct rates at the equivalent teratogenic dose levels. A similar approach was performed using the ethylating agent ethylmethanesulfonate (EMS). In the teratogenic dose range (150-250 mg/kg bw) the adduct rates of O6-ethylguanine were similar compared to those of O6-methylguanine which were obtained with methylating agents. We conclude that a correlation between teratogenicity and adduct rate (O6-alkylguanine) exists for both methylating and ethylating agents. Furthermore, DNA adduct formation following doses at and below the no-observed-adverse-effect-level (NOAEL) of teratogenicity was determined. The lowest experimental dose was 45 mg/kg EMS. Substantial DNA adduct rates in the embryos were found. These data will be used for molecular dosimetry in a risk assessment of low doses.