The added value of 3D/4D ultrasound imaging in fetal cardiology: has the promise been fulfilled?

Visualization of the arterial valve morphology and number of leaflets in a fetus with common arterial trunk by spatiotemporal image correlation imaging

Spatiotemporal imaging correlation (STIC) technology has been employed to visualize the fetal heart for close to two decades, but the additional value of the technology remains debatable. The value of the technology in identifying the morphology of the cardiac valves is being recognized. We report a 21-week gestational age fetus with common arterial trunk where STIC imaging enabled us to identify a bicuspid arterial valve.

Three- and four-dimensional ultrasound in fetal echocardiography: an up-to-date overview

Congenital heart diseases (CHD) are the most commonly overlooked lesions in prenatal screening programs. Real-time two-dimensional ultrasound (2DUS) is the conventionally used tool for fetal echocardiography. Although continuous improvements in the hardware and post-processing software have resulted in a good image quality even in late first trimester, 2DUS still has its limitations. Four-dimensional ultrasound with spatiotemporal image correlation (STIC) is an automated volume acquisition, recording a single three-dimensional (3D) volume throughout a complete cardiac cycle, which results in a four-dimensional (4D) volume. STIC has the potential to increase the detection rate of CHD. The aim of this study is to provide a practical overview of the possibilities and (dis)advantages of STIC. A review of literature and evaluation of the current status and clinical value of 3D/4D ultrasound in prenatal screening and diagnosis of congenital heart disease are presented.

Screening for Congenital Heart Disease

Compared with the assessment of most fetal anatomic structures, the assessment of the fetal heart during routine obstetric screening represents a diagnostic challenge for sonographers and interpreting physicians. This is due to a number of factors: the structural complexity of the heart, the rate at which it moves, the position of the fetus relative to the transducer, and variations in assessment protocols used by sonographers and physicians. The fetal heart is a relatively small and complex structure, as seen in an early second-trimester sonogram. In some forms of congenital heart disease, the abnormality may be detectable within only a relatively small fraction of the heart volume. Congenital heart disease represents a range of structural defects, a number of which have specific sonographic features that can be identified during routine assessment. Many approaches have been proposed to improve the assessment of the fetal heart, including specific still images, color Doppler, 3D imaging techniques, and cineloops.

Prenatal Visualization of the Pulmonary and Aortic Valves and Leaflets Is Feasible Using 4-Dimensional Sonography

OBJECTIVES

The purpose of this study was to determine whether the morphologic characteristics and area of the semilunar valves in healthy fetuses and fetuses with cardiac defects can be visualized by using spatiotemporal image correlation (STIC).

METHODS

Spatiotemporal image correlation volumes from 74 healthy fetuses were recorded in 5 examinations between the 15th and 36th weeks of pregnancy. Second, we recorded STIC volumes from 64 fetuses with various cardiac defects. The quality of the volumes was rated. The areas of the aortic and pulmonary valves were measured in systole by rendering the valves on 4-dimensional sonography. The number of leaflets was examined. Longitudinal data analysis using linear mixed models was performed.

RESULTS

Two hundred ninety-three volumes from normal hearts were examined. In 82.5%, the quality of the normal volumes was sufficient. Visualization of the valve opening was feasible in 96.1% of the normal hearts and 97.4% of the abnormal hearts. The success rate of visualization of the pulmonary and aortic valve leaflets was dependent on the gestational age, with the highest percentage (72.1% in normal hearts) at 19 to 24 weeks. Longitudinal regression analysis showed a positive relationship of the aortic and pulmonary valve areas with gestational age (P < .0001) and fetal biometric measurements (P < .0001). Fifty-eight abnormal volumes were examined. Cardiac defects with abnormal valve areas due to aortic and pulmonary stenosis could be clearly visualized by using STIC.

CONCLUSIONS

Examination of the morphologic characteristics of the semilunar valves using STIC is feasible, which is difficult when using 2-dimensional sonography. With increasing implementation of 4-dimensional sonography, the understanding of rendered images might be useful for anyone practicing fetal echocardiography.

Evaluating Spatiotemporal Image Correlation Technology as a Tool for Training Nonexpert Sonographers to Perform Examinations of the Fetal Heart

OBJECTIVES

We aimed to evaluate the use of spatiotemporal image correlation (STIC) as a tool for training nonexpert examiners to perform screening examinations of the fetal heart by acquiring and examining STIC volumes according to a standardized questionnaire based on the 5 transverse planes of the fetal heart.

METHODS

We conducted a prospective study at 2 tertiary care centers. Two sonographers without formal training in fetal echocardiography received theoretical instruction on the 5 fetal echocardiographic transverse planes, as well as STIC technology. Only women with conditions allowing 4-dimensional STIC volume acquisitions (grayscale and Doppler) were included in the study. Acquired volumes were evaluated offline according to a standardized protocol that required the trainee to mark 30 specified structures on 5 required axial planes. Volumes were then reviewed by an expert examiner for quality of acquisition and correct identification of specified structures.

RESULTS

Ninety-six of 112 pregnant women examined entered the study. Patients had singleton pregnancies between 20 and 32 weeks' gestation. After an initial learning curve of 20 examinations, trainees succeeded in identifying 97% to 98% of structures, with a highly significant degree of agreement with the expert's analysis (P < .001). A median of 2 STIC volumes for each examination was necessary for maximal structure identification. Acquisition quality scores were high (8.6-8.7 of a maximal score of 10) and were found to correlate with identification rates (P = .017).

CONCLUSIONS

After an initial learning curve and under expert guidance, STIC is an excellent tool for trainees to master extended screening examinations of the fetal heart.

Real-time three-dimensional foetal echocardiography using a new transabdominal xMATRIX array transducer

BACKGROUND

Foetal echocardiography has been used to diagnose congenital heart disease. However, conventional echocardiography can only display two-dimensional (2D) structural images of the intricate three-dimensional (3D) foetal heart.

AIM

The purpose of this study was to report the first use of a new transabdominal xMATRIX array transducer and to describe its ability to perform all 3D modalities: intelligent spatiotemporal image correlation (iSTIC) acquisition, xPlane imaging and 3D surface imaging.

METHODS

Eighty foetuses without congenital heart disease were included consecutively, with a gestational age between 20 and 37 weeks. 2D and 3D scans were performed with a transabdominal xMATRIX array transducer. Cardiac-STIC volume datasets were acquired and postprocessed with new automatic software (the 'Fetal Heart Navigator').

RESULTS

A total of 224 iSTIC acquisitions were performed (mean time for each, 2 seconds). Only 78 iSTIC acquisitions (35%) were able to detect the ductal arch automatically. 'Fetal Heart Navigator' feasibility varied according to foetal position, including the descending aorta. Live xPlane imaging had excellent feasibility regardless of foetal position; using rotation, lateral and vertical tilts, all cardiac structures were identified from a unique reference plane. Live 3D surface imaging had variable feasibility depending on the target structure. Only 10% of the volume dataset offered comprehensive imaging of intracardiac views.

CONCLUSION

The new xMATRIX transabdominal transducer allows a multimodality approach to the foetal heart. Further studies that include foetuses with cardiac malformations are required.

Advantages and pitfalls of three-dimensional ultrasound imaging of carotid bifurcation

OBJECTIVES

Several specialists use three-dimensional (3D) ultrasound as adjuvant imaging technique in their clinical practice. It has been applied to study carotid plaque morphology, surface and volume during atherosclerosis progression. Nonetheless, no papers have so far described the use of this technique in conditions different than carotid stenosis, such as bifurcation anatomy changes of the caliber and vessel course modifications.

METHODS

Patients admitted to our ultrasound laboratory for vascular screening were submitted to standard carotid duplex and to 3D ultrasound reconstruction of the carotid bifurcation.

RESULTS

Forty normal subjects, 7 patients with caliber alterations (4 carotid bulb ectasia and 3 internal carotid lumen narrowing), 45 patients with course variations (tortuosities and kinking) and 35 patients with internal carotid artery stenosis of various degrees have been investigated.

CONCLUSIONS

3D ultrasound is a feasible technique. It can improve carotid axis imaging through a better presentation of caliber variations and vessel course 'at a glance'. 3D ultrasound from the inward flow can provide imaging of the stenosis, but stenosis quantification should always take into account the assessment of plaque morphology and vessel wall.

Added value of three-/four-dimensional ultrasound in offline analysis and diagnosis of congenital heart disease

OBJECTIVE

Many published studies have shown that application of three-dimensional (3D) and real-time 3D (4D) ultrasound modalities can improve certain aspects of fetal echocardiography, but have left open the question of whether these modalities improved the accuracy of prenatal detection of anatomical fetal cardiovascular malformations. We aimed to determine whether 3D/4D ultrasound improved diagnostic ability in cases of congenital heart disease (CHD).

METHODS

Women who attended for early- or midtrimester targeted organ scans had complete fetal echocardiography according to our five-planes protocol, as well as examination of the ductus venosus and longitudinal aortic arch planes, performed with 2D ultrasound combined with 2D color Doppler, spatiotemporal image correlation (STIC), STIC with color Doppler, and STIC with B-flow. Ultrasound data of cases of CHD were stored in a dedicated archive. Stored cases were anonymized and the list order was randomized. Stored 2D ultrasound cineloops and 4D ultrasound volumes were reviewed separately according to a standardized table of 23 specified structures on five required planes of visualization: the upper abdomen, four-chamber view, five-chamber view, pulmonary artery bifurcation view, and three vessels and trachea plane. Separate diagnoses were recorded and finally compared. Diagnoses were confirmed by pathological examination or neonatal echocardiography.

RESULTS

During the study period, 13 101 examinations were performed; 181 diagnoses of CHD were made. In 12 of these, 3D/4D ultrasound added to the accuracy of our diagnosis: one right aortic arch with anomalous branching; one transposition of the great arteries with pulmonary atresia diagnosed with tomographic ultrasound imaging (TUI); one segmental interrupted aortic arch diagnosed with TUI; one right ventricle aneurysm diagnosed with B-flow; two agenesis of ductus venosus to the coronary sinus diagnosed by multiplanar reconstruction (MPR) and B-flow; two total anomalous pulmonary venous connection diagnosed with MPR; and four ventricular septal defect (VSD) diagnosed with the aid of virtual planes. There were 12 missed diagnoses and no false-positive results.

CONCLUSIONS

3D/4D ultrasound modalities may have advantages in some aspects of fetal cardiovascular evaluation, however, overall 3D/4D ultrasound modalities had added value in only about 6% of cases of fetal anatomical cardiovascular anomalies.

Accuracy of four-dimensional spatiotemporal image correlation echocardiography in the prenatal diagnosis of congenital heart defects

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the accuracy of four-dimensional (4D) spatiotemporal image correlation (STIC) echocardiography for the diagnosis of fetal congenital heart disease (CHD) in a selected high-risk population.

METHODS

Three hundred and sixty-three pregnant women referred for suspected CHD on screening ultrasound were evaluated by means of conventional echocardiography between 14 and 41 weeks' gestation and 4D-STIC volumes were obtained (including gray-scale and color Doppler information). Stored volumes were analyzed, at least 1 year after they had been acquired, by examiners blinded to the patients' identities and outcomes. The STIC diagnoses were compared to those made on conventional two-dimensional echocardiography and the accuracy of diagnosis was assessed with respect to postnatal examination, or autopsy in cases of termination of pregnancy or perinatal death.

RESULTS

The mean gestational age at volume acquisition was 24 + 5 weeks. STIC evaluation was possible in 98% of cases. Twenty-one cases were lost to follow-up, with a total of 167 normal hearts and 175 cases of CHD diagnosed at postnatal evaluation. The overall accuracy, sensitivity, specificity and positive and negative predictive values of STIC in determining the presence or absence of CHD were 91.6, 94.9, 88.1, 89.7 and 94.0%, respectively. Absolute concordance with the final specific diagnosis among cases with confirmed CHD was 74.3% for STIC echocardiography, compared with 81.7% for real-time evaluation.

CONCLUSION

4D-STIC echocardiography performed by experienced operators can be used in fetuses at risk for cardiac anomalies in order to reliably provide reassurance of normality or to accurately diagnose major structural heart defects.