A stochastic model for CD8(+)T cell dynamics in human immunosenescence: implications for survival and longevity

The immune system in extreme longevity

Recent observations indicate that immunosenescence is not accompanied by an unavoidable and progressive deterioration of the immune function, but is rather the result of a remodeling where some functions are reduced, others remain unchanged or even increased. In addition, it appears that the ancestral/innate compartment of the immune system is relatively preserved during aging in comparison to the more recent and sophisticated adaptive compartment that exhibit more profound modifications. The T-cell branch displays an age-dependent decline of the absolute number of total T-cells (CD3+), involving both CD4+ and CD8+ subsets, accompanied by an increase of NK cells with well-preserved cytotoxic function and by a reduction of B-cells. One of the main characteristics of the immune system during aging is a progressive, age-dependent decline of the virgin T-cells (CD95-), which is particularly profound at the level of the CD8+ subpopulation of the oldest old subjects. The progressive exhaustion of this important T-cell subpopulation dedicated primarily to the defense against new antigenic challenges (viral, neoplastic, bacterial ones), could be a consequence of both the thymic involution and the lifelong chronic antigenic stimulation. The immune function of the elderly, is therefore weakened by the exhaustion of CD95- virgin cells that are replaced by large clonal expansions of CD28- T-cells. The origin of CD28- cells has not been completely clarified yet, but it is assumed that they represent cells in the phase of replicative senescence characterized by shortening telomers and reduced proliferative capacity. A major characteristic of the immune system during aging is the up-regulation of the inflammatory responses which appears to be detrimental for longevity. In this regard, we have recently observed a progressive age-dependent increase of type 1(IL-2, IFN-gamma, TNF-alpha) and type 2 (IL-4, IL-6, IL-10) positive CD8+ T-cells; in particular, type 1 cytokine-positive cells significantly increased, with age, in all CD8+ subsets particularly among effector/cytotoxic and memory cells. A major force able to drive a chronic pro-inflammatory state during aging may be represented by persistent viral infections by EBV and CMV. Therefore, we have determined the frequency and the absolute number of viral antigen-specific CD8+ T-cells in subjects older than 85 years, who were serologically positive for CMV or EBV. In the majority of these subjects we detected the presence of T lymphocytes positive for epitopes of CMV or EBV. In all subjects the absolute number of CMV-positive CD8+ cells outnumbered that of EBV-positive ones. In addition, the majority of CMV+ T cells were included within the CD28- subpopulation, while EBV+ T cells belonged mainly to the CD28+ subset. These data indicate that the chronic antigenic stimulation induced by persistent viral infections during aging bring about important modifications among CD8+ subsets, which are particularly evident in the presence of CMV persistence. The age-dependent expansions of CD8+CD28- T-cells, mostly positive for pro-inflammatory cytokines and including the majority of CMV-epitope-specific cells, underlines the importance of chronic antigenic stimulation in the pathogenesis of the main immunological alterations of aging and may favour the appearance of several pathologies (arteriosclerosis, dementia, osteoporosis, cancer) all of which share an inflammatory pathogenesis.

Complexity of Anti-immunosenescence Strategies in Humans

Immunosenescence is characterized by three main aspects: (i) the shrinkage of the T cell repertoire and the accumulation of oligoclonal expansions (megaclones) of memory/effector cells directed toward ubiquitary infectious agents; (ii) the involution of the thymus and the exhaustion of naïve T cells; and (iii) a chronic inflammatory status called inflamm-aging. We present here possible strategies to counteract these main aspects of immunosenescence in humans with particular attention to the reduction of antigenic load by pathogens, such as CMV, and the normalization of intestinal microflora, the possible utilization of IL-7 to reverse thymic involution, the purging of megaclones, the forced expression of CD28 on T lymphocytes, the reduction of inflamm-aging and the administration of nutrients such as vitamin D. Possible drawbacks of all these strategies are discussed. Finally, the complexity of a rejuvenation approach is stressed, with particular attention to the inhibitory role played by the "old microenvironment" on the performance of progenitor cells, the best candidate to counteract the decline in regenerative potential characteristic of organs and tissues from old organisms.

Age-dependent modifications of Type 1 and Type 2 cytokines within virgin and memory CD4+ T cells in humans

Several alterations in immune function and a concomitant progressive increase in pro-inflammatory status are the major characteristics of ageing process. Cytokines play a key role during ageing acting both in regulatory communication among cells and in effector activity during an immune response. The impact of age on intracellular Type 1 (IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha) and Type 2 (IL-4) cytokines, after stimulation with PMA/ionomycin, was determined in three CD4+ T subsets, i.e. CD95- CD28+ (virgin), CD95+ CD28+ (activated/memory), and CD95+ CD28- (effector/memory) from 47 subjects aged between 21 and 99 years. The percentage of IFN-gamma positive cells significantly decreased in virgin CD4+ subset both in old and nonagenarian subjects, as well as in activated/memory T cells from old in comparison with young subjects. The percentage of TNF-alpha positive cells significantly decreased in activated/memory CD4+ subset from old people. Regarding Type 2 cytokines, IL-4 positive cells significantly increased in activated/memory CD4+ subset from nonagenarians. On the whole our data indicate that: (1) different Type 1 and Type 2 cytokine-positive CD4+ T subsets are differently affected by ageing process; (2) activated/memory T cells appear to be the most affected subset; (3) a shift towards an increased role of Type 2 cytokines and a diminished role of Type 1 cytokines emerges with ageing.

Inflammation markers predicting frailty and mortality in the elderly

Greater numbers of individuals are living to older ages. A major concern at both individual and population levels is how to live these years at a high functional level. If we had physiological markers to identify those at risk for progressive functional decline and impeding death, therapies could be targeted towards these individuals to prevent adverse outcomes. Senescence is presently considered as the consequence of lifelong antigenic stress impinging upon the individual genetic background. We might consider inflammation markers as synthetic measures of lifelong attrition combined with genetic tendency to develop an inflammatory phenotype. Such biomarkers are the most powerful predictors of frailty and mortality in the elderly available today. The aim of this review is to translate results from the research on ageing into a practical view, suggesting new tools for the clinical approach to older people.

Immunoproteasomes and immunosenescence

Aging is a complex process which is accompanied with the decline and the reshaping of different functions of the body. In particular the immune system is characterized, during ageing (immunosenescence) by a remodeling of innate immunity (well preserved, up-regulated) and clonotypical immunity (severely altered) and by the occurrence of a chronic inflammatory process (inflammaging) which are, at least in part, genetically controlled. In this scenario, it can be anticipated that a crucial role is played by age-related structural and functional alterations and modifications of proteasomes and immunoproteasomes, the last being a key component of antigen processing and MHC class I antigen presentation. A variety of experimental data are available, suggesting that proteasomes are affected by age, and that in centenarians they are relatively preserved. On the contrary, few data are available on immunoproteasomes, likely as a consequence of the poverty of suitable cellular models. Lymphoblastoid cell lines from EBV immortalized B cells from old donors is envisaged as a possible model for the study of immunoproteasomes in humans and their changes with age. Thus, basic questions such as those related to possible consequences, for immune responses in infectious diseases and cancer, of age-related alterations of antigen processing and presenting, change with age of self-antigen repertoire, and the genetic basis of immunoproteasome activity and its change with age, remain largely unanswered.

Chronic antigenic stress, immunosenescence and human survivorship over the 3 last centuries: heuristic value of a mathematical model

In previous investigations we pursued the hypothesis that lifelong, chronic antigenic load (CAL) is the major driving force of immunosenescence, which impacts on human lifespan by reducing the number of virgin antigen-non experienced (ANE) T cells, and filling the immunological space with expanded clones of memory and effector, antigen-experienced (AE) T cells. A model has been proposed to relate CAL with the conversion rate from ANE to AE CD8+ T cells. In addition, in order to account for individual variations of immunosenescence and lifespan, a noise term has been introduced to describe the individual fluctuations of CAL. This model was able to follow with a reasonable approximation the age-related decrease of ANE CD8+ T cells, as well as human survival curves. In this paper we extend this approach to historical survival curves, starting from 1750 until present days, and show that the quality of the fit of historical demographic data improves as we approach the recent, quantitative and qualitative decrease of CAL. Indeed, the almost linearity in the increase of lifespan and in the decrease of the noise fluctuation amplitude within this historical period suggests that the improvement of life conditions has steadily lowered the intensity of CAL and restricted the variability which results from the interaction between the individuals and their immunological environment. On the whole, this approach allows to appreciate when and how immunosenescence has started to impact on survivorship, and predicts its increasing, crucial role in explaining human mortality in hygienized, economically developed societies.

Age related changes in population of peripheral T cells: towards a model of immunosenescence

In this paper, we presented the results of analysis of experimental evidence for the decline of the human immune system functioning with age using mathematical model of immunosenescence. The most prominent changes in this system are related to the decline in the T-cellular immunity. These include the decline in the nai;ve T cells generation rate, shrinkage of the volume of the peripheral lymphoid tissue, decline of absolute and relative concentrations of nai;ve T cells in the blood, shortening of the average telomere length of T cells. These alterations in the immune system are responsible for sharp increase of morbidity and mortality caused by infectious agents at old ages. Analysis shows that concentrations of memory and nai;ve T cells in peripheral lymphoid tissue are the key variables in this process. Simulation experiments with our model show that the average life span of memory T cells must grow with age, and that decreasing of antigenic load led to considerable increase in organism's resistance in middle ages, but only to slight increase in old ages. Restriction in the rate of thymus involution resulted in an increase of organism's resistance to infections in old ages. However, this growth is accompanied by the decline of concentration of memory T cells and shortening of their life span. The proposed model describes the trade-off between concentrations of nai;ve and memory T cells and their potential to proliferate in human organism.