Trapping reaction intermediates in macromolecular crystals for structural analyses

Not making the cut: Techniques to prevent RNA cleavage in structural studies of RNase-RNA complexes

RNases are varied in the RNA structures and sequences they target for cleavage and are an important type of enzyme in cells. Despite the numerous examples of RNases known, and of those with determined three-dimensional structures, relatively few examples exist with the RNase bound to intact cognate RNA substrate prior to cleavage. To better understand RNase structure and sequence specificity for RNA targets, in vitro methods used to assemble these enzyme complexes trapped in a pre-cleaved state have been developed for a number of different RNases. We have surveyed the Protein Data Bank for such structures and in this review detail methodologies that have successfully been used and relate them to the corresponding structures. We also offer ideas and suggestions for future method development. Many strategies within this review can be used in combination with X-ray crystallography, as well as cryo-EM, and other structure-solving techniques. Our hope is that this review will be used as a guide to resolve future yet-to-be-determined RNase-substrate complex structures.

Protein Dynamics and Time Resolved Protein Crystallography at Synchrotron Radiation Sources: Past, Present and Future

The ultrabright and ultrashort pulses produced at X-ray free electron lasers (XFELs) has enabled studies of crystallized molecular machines at work under ‘native’ conditions at room temperature by the so-called time-resolved serial femtosecond crystallography (TR-SFX) technique. Since early TR-SFX experiments were conducted at XFELs, it has been largely reported in the literature that time-resolved X-ray experiments at synchrotrons are no longer feasible or are impractical due to the severe technical limitations of these radiation sources. The transfer of the serial crystallography approach to newest synchrotrons upgraded for higher flux density and with beamlines using sophisticated focusing optics, submicron beam diameters and fast low-noise photon-counting detectors offers a way to overcome these difficulties opening new and exciting possibilities. In fact, there is an increasing amount of publications reporting new findings in structural dynamics of protein macromolecules by using time resolved crystallography from microcrystals at synchrotron sources. This review gathers information to provide an overview of the recent work and the advances made in this filed in the past years, as well as outlines future perspectives at the next generation of synchrotron sources and the upcoming compact pulsed X-ray sources.

High-viscosity injector-based pink-beam serial crystallography of microcrystals at a synchrotron radiation source

Since the first successful serial crystallography (SX) experiment at a synchrotron radiation source, the popularity of this approach has continued to grow showing that third-generation synchrotrons can be viable alternatives to scarce X-ray free-electron laser sources. Synchrotron radiation flux may be increased ∼100 times by a moderate increase in the bandwidth ('pink beam' conditions) at some cost to data analysis complexity. Here, we report the first high-viscosity injector-based pink-beam SX experiments. The structures of proteinase K (PK) and A_2A adenosine receptor (A_2AAR) were determined to resolutions of 1.8 and 4.2 Å using 4 and 24 consecutive 100 ps X-ray pulse exposures, respectively. Strong PK data were processed using existing Laue approaches, while weaker A_2AAR data required an alternative data-processing strategy. This demonstration of the feasibility presents new opportunities for time-resolved experiments with microcrystals to study structural changes in real time at pink-beam synchrotron beamlines worldwide.

Perspective: Opportunities for ultrafast science at SwissFEL

We present the main specifications of the newly constructed Swiss Free Electron Laser, SwissFEL, and explore its potential impact on ultrafast science. In light of recent achievements at current X-ray free electron lasers, we discuss the potential territory for new scientific breakthroughs offered by SwissFEL in Chemistry, Biology, and Materials Science, as well as nonlinear X-ray science.

Watching Proteins Function with Time-resolved X-ray Crystallography

Macromolecular crystallography was immensely successful in the last two decades. To a large degree this success resulted from use of powerful third generation synchrotron X-ray sources. An expansive database of more than 100,000 protein structures, of which many were determined at resolution better than 2 Å, is available today. With this achievement, the spotlight in structural biology is shifting from determination of static structures to elucidating dynamic aspects of protein function. A powerful tool for addressing these aspects is time-resolved crystallography, where a genuine biological function is triggered in the crystal with a goal of capturing molecules in action and determining protein kinetics and structures of intermediates (Schmidt et al., 2005a; Schmidt 2008; Neutze and Moffat, 2012; Šrajer 2014). In this approach, short and intense X-ray pulses are used to probe intermediates in real time and at room temperature, in an ongoing reaction that is initiated synchronously and rapidly in the crystal. Time-resolved macromolecular crystallography with 100 ps time resolution at synchrotron X-ray sources is in its mature phase today, particularly for studies of reversible, light-initiated reactions. The advent of the new free electron lasers for hard X-rays (XFELs; 5-20 keV), which provide exceptionally intense, femtosecond X-ray pulses, marks a new frontier for time-resolved crystallography. The exploration of ultra-fast events becomes possible in high-resolution structural detail, on sub-picosecond time scales (Tenboer et al., 2014; Barends et al., 2015; Pande et al., 2016). We review here state-of-the-art time-resolved crystallographic experiments both at synchrotrons and XFELs. We also outline challenges and further developments necessary to broaden the application of these methods to many important proteins and enzymes of biomedical relevance.

Detection of Reaction Intermediates in Mg2+-Dependent DNA Synthesis and RNA Degradation by Time-Resolved X-Ray Crystallography

Structures of enzyme-substrate/product complexes have been studied for over four decades but have been limited to either before or after a chemical reaction. Recently using in crystallo catalysis combined with X-ray diffraction, we have discovered that many enzymatic reactions in nucleic acid metabolism require additional metal ion cofactors that are not present in the substrate or product state. By controlling metal ions essential for catalysis, the in crystallo approach has revealed unprecedented details of reaction intermediates. Here we present protocols used for successful studies of Mg²⁺-dependent DNA polymerases and ribonucleases that are applicable to analyses of a variety of metal ion-dependent reactions.

Crystallographic snapshot of glycosylasparaginase precursor poised for autoprocessing

Glycosylasparaginase belongs to a family of N-terminal nucleophile hydrolases that autoproteolytically generate their mature enzymes from single-chain protein precursors. Previously, based on a precursor structure paused at pre-autoproteolysis stage by a reversible inhibitor (glycine), we proposed a mechanism of intramolecular autoproteolysis. A key structural feature, a highly strained conformation at the scissile peptide bond, had been identified and was hypothesized to be critical for driving autoproteolysis through an N-O acyl shift. To examine this "twist-and-break" hypothesis, we report here a 1. 9-Å-resolution structure of an autoproteolysis-active precursor (a T152C mutant) that is free of inhibitor or ligand and is poised to undergo autoproteolysis. The current crystallographic study has provided direct evidence for the natural conformation of the glycosylasparaginase autocatalytic site without influence from any inhibitor or ligand. This finding has confirmed our previous proposal that conformational strain is an intrinsic feature of an active precursor.

Photochemical tools to study dynamic biological processes

Light-responsive biologically active compounds offer the possibility to study the dynamics of biological processes. Phototriggers and photoswitches have been designed, providing the capability to rapidly cause the initiation of wide range of dynamic biological phenomena. We will discuss, in this article, recent developments in the field of light-triggered chemical tools, specially how two-photon excitation, "caged" fluorophores, and the photoregulation of protein activities in combination with time-resolved x-ray techniques should break new grounds in the understanding of dynamic biological processes.

Functional genomics and structural biology in the definition of gene function

By mid-2007, the three-dimensional (3D) structures of some 45,000 proteins have been solved, over a period where the linear structures of millions of genes have been defined. Technical challenges associated with X-ray crystallography are being overcome and high-throughput methods both for crystallization of proteins and for solving their 3D structures are under development. The question arises as to how structural biology can be integrated with and adds value to functional genomics programs. Structural biology will assist in the definition of gene function through the identification of the likely function of the protein products of genes. The 3D information allows protein sequences predicted from DNA sequences to be classified into broad groups, according to the overall 'fold', or 3D shape, of the protein. Structural information can be used to predict the preferred substrate of a protein, and thereby greatly enhance the accurate annotation of the corresponding gene. Furthermore, it will enable the effects of amino acid substitutions in enzymes to be better understood with respect to enzyme function and could thereby provide insights into natural variation in genes. If the molecular basis of transcription factor-DNA interactions were defined through precise 3D knowledge of the protein-DNA binding site, it would be possible to predict the effects of base substitutions within the motif on the specificity and/or kinetics of binding. In this chapter, we present specific examples of how structural biology can provide valuable information for functional genomics programs.

Structural basis for the catalytic mechanism of human phosphodiesterase 9

The phosphodiesterases (PDEs) are metal ion-dependent enzymes that regulate cellular signaling by metabolic inactivation of the ubiquitous second messengers cAMP and cGMP. In this role, the PDEs are involved in many biological and metabolic processes and are proven targets of successful drugs for the treatments of a wide range of diseases. However, because of the rapidity of the hydrolysis reaction, an experimental knowledge of the enzymatic mechanisms of the PDEs at the atomic level is still lacking. Here, we report the structures of reaction intermediates accumulated at the reaction steady state in PDE9/crystal and preserved by freeze-trapping. These structures reveal the catalytic process of a PDE and explain the substrate specificity of PDE9 in an actual reaction and the cation requirements of PDEs in general.

Dissecting the catalytic mechanism of a plant beta-D-glucan glucohydrolase through structural biology using inhibitors and substrate analogues

Higher plant, family GH3 beta-D-glucan glucohydrolases exhibit exo-hydrolytic and retaining (e-->e) mechanisms of action and catalyze the removal of single glucosyl residues from the non-reducing termini of beta-D-linked glucosidic substrates, with retention of anomeric configuration. The broad specificity beta-D-glucan glucohydrolases are likely to play roles in cell wall re-modelling, turn-over of cell wall components and possibly in plant defence reactions against pathogens. Crystal structures of the barley beta-D-glucan glucohydrolase, obtained from both native enzyme and from the enzyme in complex with a substrate analogues and mechanism-based inhibitors, have enabled the basis of substrate specificity, the mechanism of catalysis, and the role of domain movements during the catalytic cycle to be defined in precise molecular terms. The active site of the enzyme forms a shallow 'pocket' that is located at the interface of two domains of the enzyme and accommodates two glucosyl residues. The propensity of the enzyme to hydrolyze a broad range of substrates with (1-->2)-, (1-->3)-, (1-->4)- and (1-->6)-beta-D-glucosidic linkages is explained from crystal structures of the enzyme in complex with non-hydrolysable S-glycoside substrate analogues, and from molecular modelling. During binding of gluco-oligosaccharides, the glucosyl residue at subsite -1 is locked in a highly constrained position, but the glucosyl residue at the +1 subsite is free to adjust its position between two tryptophan residues positioned at the entry of the active site pocket. The flexibility at subsite +1 and the projection of the remainder of the substrate away from the pocket provide a structural rationale for the capacity of the enzyme to accommodate and hydrolyze glucosides with different linkage positions and hence different overall conformations. While mechanism-based inhibitors with micromolar Ki constants bind in the active site of the enzyme and form esters with the catalytic nucleophile, transition-state mimics bind with their 'glucose' moieties distorted into the 4E conformation, which is critical for the nanomolar binding of these inhibitors to the enzyme. The glucose product of the reaction, which is released from the non-reducing termini of substrates, remains bound to the beta-D-glucan glucohydrolase in the -1 subsite of the active site, until a new substrate molecule approaches the enzyme. If dissociation of the glucose from the enzyme active site could be synchronized throughout the crystal, time-resolved Laue X-ray crystallography could be used to follow the conformational changes that occur as the glucose product diffuses away and the incoming substrate is bound by the enzyme.

Crystallographic snapshot of a productive glycosylasparaginase-substrate complex

Glycosylasparaginase (GA) plays an important role in asparagine-linked glycoprotein degradation. A deficiency in the activity of human GA leads to a lysosomal storage disease named aspartylglycosaminuria. GA belongs to a superfamily of N-terminal nucleophile hydrolases that autoproteolytically generate their mature enzymes from inactive single chain protein precursors. The side-chain of the newly exposed N-terminal residue then acts as a nucleophile during substrate hydrolysis. By taking advantage of mutant enzyme of Flavobacterium meningosepticum GA with reduced enzymatic activity, we have obtained a crystallographic snapshot of a productive complex with its substrate (NAcGlc-Asn), at 2.0 A resolution. This complex structure provided us an excellent model for the Michaelis complex to examine the specific contacts critical for substrate binding and catalysis. Substrate binding induces a conformational change near the active site of GA. To initiate catalysis, the side-chain of the N-terminal Thr152 is polarized by the free alpha-amino group on the same residue, mediated by the side-chain hydroxyl group of Thr170. Cleavage of the amide bond is then accomplished by a nucleophilic attack at the carbonyl carbon of the amide linkage in the substrate, leading to the formation of an acyl-enzyme intermediate through a negatively charged tetrahedral transition state.

A newly designed microspectrofluorometer for kinetic studies on protein crystals in combination with x-ray diffraction

We present a new design for a fluorescence microspectrophotometer for use in kinetic crystallography in combination with x-ray diffraction experiments. The FLUMIX device (Fluorescence spectroscopy to monitor intermediates in x-ray crystallography) is built for 0 degrees fluorescence detection, which has several advantages in comparison to a conventional fluorometer with 90 degrees design. Due to the reduced spatial requirements and the need for only one objective, the system is highly versatile, easy to handle, and can be used for many different applications. In combination with a conventional stereomicroscope, fluorescence measurements or reaction initiation can be performed directly in a hanging drop crystallization setup. The FLUMIX device can be combined with most x-ray sources, normally without the need of a specialized mechanical support. As a biological model system, we have used H-Ras p21 with an artificially introduced photo-labile GTP precursor (caged GTP) and a covalently attached fluorophore (IANBD amide). Using the FLUMIX system, detailed information about the state of photolyzed crystals of the modified H-Ras p21 (p21(mod)) could be obtained. Measurements in combination with a synchrotron beamline showed significant fluorescence changes in p21(mod) crystals even within a few seconds of x-ray exposure at 100 K.

Protein-ligand interaction probed by time-resolved crystallography

Time-resolved (TR) crystallography is a unique method for determining the structures of intermediates in biomolecular reactions. The technique reached its mature stage with the development of the powerful third-generation synchrotron X-ray sources, and the advances in data processing and analysis of time-resolved Laue crystallographic data. A time resolution of 100 ps has been achieved and relatively small structural changes can be detected even from only partial reaction initiation. The remaining challenge facing the application of this technique to a broad range of biological systems is to find an efficient and rapid, system-specific method for the reaction initiation in the crystal. Other frontiers for the technique involve the continued improvement in time resolution and further advances in methods for determining intermediate structures and reaction mechanisms. The time-resolved technique, combined with trapping methods and computational approaches, holds the promise for a complete structure-based description of biomolecular reactions.

X-ray crystallography of protein-ligand interactions

Crystal structures of protein-ligand complexes provide a detailed view of their spatial arrangement and interactions. In the case of stable, unreactive ligands, such as inhibitors or allosteric regulators, the complexes can be generated by cocrystallization or by soaking the ligand into fully grown crystals. In order to obtain highly occupied stochiometric complexes, the concentration and amount of ligand used needs to be considered. Protein complexes with reactive short-lived species that occur in chemical or binding reactions can be determined using monochromatic X-ray diffraction techniques via kinetic trapping approaches. To this end, the kinetics of the reaction has to be determined in the crystalline state and triggering methods to start the reaction need to be established. To facilitate data interpretation, the experimental conditions are usually chosen such that the peak concentration of the reactive species under investigation is maximized.

Mycobacterium tuberculosis thymidylate kinase: structural studies of intermediates along the reaction pathway

Mycobacterium tuberculosis TMP kinase (TMPK(Mtub)) represents a promising target for developing drugs against tuberculosis because the configuration of its active site is unique in the TMPK family. To help elucidate the phosphorylation mechanism employed by this enzyme, structural changes occurring upon binding of substrates and subsequent catalysis were investigated by protein crystallography. Six new structures of TMPK(Mtub) were solved at a resolution better than 2.3A, including the first structure of an apo-TMPK, obtained by triggering catalysis in a crystal of a TMPK(Mtub)-TMP complex, which resulted in the release of the TDP product. A series of snapshots along the reaction pathway is obtained, revealing the closure of the active site in going from an empty to a fully occupied state, suggestive of an induced-fit mechanism typical of NMPKs. However, in TMPK(Mtub) the LID closure couples to the binding with an unusual location for a magnesium ion coordinating TMP in the active site. Our data suggest strongly that this ion is required for catalysis, acting as a clamp, possibly in concert with Arg95, to neutralise electrostatic repulsion between the anionic substrates, optimise their proper alignment and activate them through direct and water-mediated interactions. The 3'-hydroxyl moiety of TMP, critical to metal stabilisation, appears to be a target of choice for the design of potent inhibitors. On the other hand, the usual NTP-bound magnesium is not seen in our structures and Arg14, a P-loop residue unique to TMPK(Mtub), may take over its role. Therefore, TMPK(Mtub) seems to have swapped the use of a metal ion as compared with e.g. human TMPK. Finally, TTP was observed in crystals of TMPK(Mtub), locked by Arg14, thus providing a structural explanation for the observed inhibitory effect of TTP putatively involved in a mechanism of feedback regulation of the enzymatic activity.

Photochemically induced electron transfer

Biochemical reactions involving electron transfer between substrates or enzyme cofactors are both common and physiologically important; they have been studied by means of a variety of techniques. In this paper we review the application of photochemical methods to the study of intramolecular electron transfer in hemoproteins, thus selecting a small, well-defined sector of this otherwise enormous field. Photoexcitation of the heme populates short-lived excited states which decay by thermal conversion and do not usually transfer electrons, even when a suitable electron acceptor is readily available, e.g., in the form of a second oxidized heme group in the same protein; because of this, the experimental setup demands some manipulation of the hemoprotein. In this paper we review three approaches that have been studied in detail: (i) the covalent conjugation to the protein moiety of an organic ruthenium complex, which serves as the photoexcitable electron donor (in this case the heme acts as the electron acceptor); (ii) the replacement of the heme group with a phosphorescent metal-substituted porphyrin, which on photoexcitation populates long-lived excited states, capable of acting as electron donors (clearly the protein must contain some other cofactor acting as the electron acceptor, most often a second heme group in the oxidized state); (iii) the combination of the reduced heme with CO (the photochemical breakdown of the iron-CO bond yields transiently the ground-state reduced heme which is able to transfer one electron (or a fraction of it) to an oxidized electron acceptor in the protein; this method uses a "mixed-valence hybrid" state of the redox active hemoprotein and has the great advantage of populating on photoexcitation an electron donor at physiological redox potential).