Experimental and Computational Approaches for Single-Cell Enhancer Perturbation Assay

Enhancer regulatory networks globally connect non-coding breast cancer loci to cancer genes

BACKGROUND

Genetic studies have associated thousands of enhancers with breast cancer (BC). However, the vast majority have not been functionally characterized. Thus, it remains unclear how BC-associated enhancers contribute to cancer.

RESULTS

Here, we perform single-cell CRISPRi screens of 3513 regulatory elements associated with breast cancer to measure the impact of these regions on transcriptional phenotypes. Analysis of > 500,000 single-cell transcriptomes in two breast cancer cell lines shows that perturbation of BC-associated enhancers disrupts breast cancer gene programs. We observe BC-associated enhancers that directly or indirectly regulate the expression of cancer genes. We also find one-to-multiple and multiple-to-one network motifs where enhancers indirectly regulate cancer genes. Notably, multiple BC-associated enhancers indirectly regulate TP53. Comparative studies illustrate subtype specific functions between enhancers in ER + and ER - cells. Finally, we develop the pySpade package to facilitate analysis of single-cell enhancer screens.

CONCLUSIONS

Overall, we demonstrate that enhancers form regulatory networks that link cancer genes in the genome, providing a more comprehensive understanding of the contribution of enhancers to breast cancer development.

Enhancer regulatory networks globally connect non-coding breast cancer loci to cancer genes

Genetic studies have associated thousands of enhancers with breast cancer. However, the vast majority have not been functionally characterized. Thus, it remains unclear how variant-associated enhancers contribute to cancer. Here, we perform single-cell CRISPRi screens of 3,512 regulatory elements associated with breast cancer to measure the impact of these regions on transcriptional phenotypes. Analysis of >500,000 single-cell transcriptomes in two breast cancer cell lines shows that perturbation of variant-associated enhancers disrupts breast cancer gene programs. We observe variant-associated enhancers that directly or indirectly regulate the expression of cancer genes. We also find one-to-multiple and multiple-to-one network motifs where enhancers indirectly regulate cancer genes. Notably, multiple variant-associated enhancers indirectly regulate TP53. Comparative studies illustrate sub-type specific functions between enhancers in ER+ and ER- cells. Finally, we developed the pySpade package to facilitate analysis of single-cell enhancer screens. Overall, we demonstrate that enhancers form regulatory networks that link cancer genes in the genome, providing a more comprehensive understanding of the contribution of enhancers to breast cancer development.

Technological Convergence: Highlighting the Power of CRISPR Single-Cell Perturbation Toolkit for Functional Interrogation of Enhancers

Higher eukaryotic enhancers, as a major class of regulatory elements, play a crucial role in the regulation of gene expression. Over the last decade, the development of sequencing technologies has flooded researchers with transcriptome-phenotype data alongside emerging candidate regulatory elements. Since most methods can only provide hints about enhancer function, there have been attempts to develop experimental and computational approaches that can bridge the gap in the causal relationship between regulatory regions and phenotypes. The coupling of two state-of-the-art technologies, also referred to as crisprQTL, has emerged as a promising high-throughput toolkit for addressing this question. This review provides an overview of the importance of studying enhancers, the core molecular foundation of crisprQTL, and recent studies utilizing crisprQTL to interrogate enhancer-phenotype correlations. Additionally, we discuss computational methods currently employed for crisprQTL data analysis. We conclude by pointing out common challenges, making recommendations, and looking at future prospects, with the aim of providing researchers with an overview of crisprQTL as an important toolkit for studying enhancers.

Identifying enhancer-driven subtype-specific prognostic markers in breast cancer based on multi-omics data

Breast cancer is a cancer of high complexity and heterogeneity, with differences in prognosis and survival among patients of different subtypes. Copy number variations (CNVs) within enhancers are crucial drivers of tumorigenesis by influencing expression of their targets. In this study, we performed an integrative approach to identify CNA-driven enhancers and their effect on expression of target genes in four breast cancer subtypes by integrating expression data, copy number data and H3K27ac data. We identified 672, 555, 531, 361 CNA-driven enhancer-gene pairs and 280, 189, 113 and 98 CNA-driven enhancer-lncRNA pairs in the Basal-like, Her2, LumA and LumB subtypes, respectively. We then reconstructed a CNV-driven enhancer-lncRNA-mRNA regulatory network in each subtype. Functional analysis showed CNA-driven enhancers play an important role in the progression of breast cancer subtypes by influencing P53 signaling pathway, PPAR signaling pathway, systemic lupus erythematosus and MAPK signaling pathway in the Basal-like, Her2, LumA and LumB subtypes, respectively. We characterized the potentially prognostic value of target genes of CNV-driven enhancer and lncRNA-mRNA pairs in the subtype-specific network. We identified MUM1 and AC016876.1 as prognostic biomarkers in LumA and Basal-like subtypes, respectively. Higher expression of MUM1 with an amplified enhancer exhibited poorer prognosis in LumA patients. Lower expression of AC016876.1 with a deleted enhancer exhibited poorer survival outcomes of Basal-like patients. We also identified enhancer-related lncRNA-mRNA pairs as prognostic biomarkers, including AC012313.2-MUM1 in the LumA, AC026471.4-PLK5 in the LumB, AC027307.2-OAZ1 in the Basal-like and AC022431.1-HCN2 in the Her2 subtypes. Finally, our results highlighted target genes of CNA-driven enhancers and enhancer-related lncRNA-mRNA pairs could act as prognostic markers and potential therapeutic targets in breast cancer subtypes.

Global Analysis of Enhancer Targets Reveals Convergent Enhancer-Driven Regulatory Modules

Single-cell screens enable high-throughput functional assessment of enhancers in their endogenous genomic context. However, the design of current studies limits their application to identifying the primary gene targets of enhancers. Here, we improve the experimental and computational parameters of single-cell enhancer screens to identify the secondary gene targets of enhancers. Our analysis of >500 putative enhancers in K562 cells reveals an interwoven enhancer-driven gene regulatory network. We find that enhancers from distinct genomic loci converge to modulate the expression of common sub-modules, including the α- and β-globin loci, by directly regulating transcription factors. Our analysis suggests that several genetic variants associated with myeloid blood cell traits alter the activity of a distal enhancer of MYB (~140 kb away), with downstream consequences on hemoglobin genes expression and cell state. These data have implications for the understanding of enhancer-associated traits and emphasize the flexibility of controlling transcriptional systems by modifying enhancer activity.

Xie et al. apply improved strategies for single-cell screens to identify an enhancer-driven transcriptional regulatory network in K562 cells. They demonstrate that the same group of genes can be indirectly regulated by enhancers from distinct genomic loci. These data have implications for the understanding of enhancer-associated traits.