Functional studies of DNA-protein interactions using FRET techniques

Direct, ensemble FRET approaches to monitor transient state kinetics of human DNA polymerase δ holoenzyme assembly and initiation of DNA synthesis

In humans, DNA polymerase δ (pol δ) holoenzymes, comprised of pol δ and the processivity sliding clamp, proliferating cell nuclear antigen (PCNA), carry out DNA synthesis during lagging strand replication, the initiation of leading strand DNA replication as well as most of the major DNA damage repair pathways. In each of these contexts, pol δ holoenzymes are assembled at primer/template (P/T) junctions and initiate DNA synthesis in a stepwise process that involves the PCNA clamp loader, replication factor C and, depending on the DNA synthesis pathway, the major single strand DNA-binding protein complex, replication protein A (RPA). In a recent report from our laboratory, we designed and utilized direct, ensemble Förster Resonance Energy Transfer approaches to monitor the transient state kinetics of pol δ holoenzyme assembly and initiation of DNA synthesis on P/T junctions engaged by RPA. In this chapter, we detail the original approaches and discuss adaptations that can be utilized to monitor fast kinetic reactions in the millisecond (ms) timescale. All approaches described in this chapter utilize a commercially-available fluorescence spectrophotometer, can be readily evolved for alternative DNA polymerases and P/T DNA substrates, and permit incorporation of protein posttranslational modifications, accessory factors, DNA covalent modifications, accessory factors, enzymes, etc. Hence, these approaches are widely accessible and broadly applicable for characterizing DNA polymerase holoenzyme assembly and initiation of DNA synthesis during any PCNA-dependent DNA synthesis pathway.

Polymerase-mediated synthesis of p-vinylaniline-coupled fluorescent DNA for the sensing of nucleolin protein-c-myc G-quadruplex interactions

In this paper we report the synthesis of two deoxyuridine derivatives (dUCN2, dUPy)-featuring p-vinylaniline-based fluorophores linked through a propargyl unit at the 5' position-that function as molecular rotors. This probing system proved to be useful for the sensing of gene regulation arising from interactions between this G-quadruplex and nucleolin.

Functional 3D architecture in an intrinsically disordered E3 ligase domain facilitates ubiquitin transfer

The human genome contains an estimated 600 ubiquitin E3 ligases, many of which are single-subunit E3s (ssE3s) that can bind to both substrate and ubiquitin-loaded E2 (E2~Ub). Within ssE3s structural disorder tends to be located in substrate binding and domain linking regions. RNF4 is a ssE3 ligase with a C-terminal RING domain and disordered N-terminal region containing SUMO Interactions Motifs (SIMs) required to bind SUMO modified substrates. Here we show that, although the N-terminal region of RNF4 bears no secondary structure, it maintains a compact global architecture primed for SUMO interaction. Segregated charged regions within the RNF4 N-terminus promote compaction, juxtaposing RING domain and SIMs to facilitate substrate ubiquitination. Mutations that induce a more extended shape reduce ubiquitination activity. Our result offer insight into a key step in substrate ubiquitination by a member of the largest ubiquitin ligase subtype and reveal how a defined architecture within a disordered region contributes to E3 ligase function.

Ubiquitin transfer by a RING E3 ligase occurs from a closed E2~ubiquitin conformation

Based on extensive structural analysis it was proposed that RING E3 ligases prime the E2~ubiquitin conjugate (E2~Ub) for catalysis by locking it into a closed conformation, where ubiquitin is folded back onto the E2 exposing the restrained thioester bond to attack by substrate nucleophile. However the proposal that the RING dependent closed conformation of E2~Ub represents the active form that mediates ubiquitin transfer has yet to be experimentally tested. To test this hypothesis we use single molecule Förster Resonance Energy Transfer (smFRET) to measure the conformation of a FRET labelled E2~Ub conjugate, which distinguishes between closed and alternative conformations. We describe a real-time FRET assay with a thioester linked E2~Ub conjugate to monitor single ubiquitination events and demonstrate that ubiquitin is transferred to substrate from the closed conformation. These findings are likely to be relevant to all RING E3 catalysed reactions ligating ubiquitin and other ubiquitin-like proteins (Ubls) to substrates.

A multi-scale time-resolved study of photoactivated dynamics in 5-benzyl uracil, a model for DNA/protein interactions

We combine fluorescence up-conversion and time correlated single photon counting experiments to investigate the 5-benzyl uracil excited state dynamics in methanol from 100 fs up to several ns. This molecule has been proposed as a model for DNA/protein interactions. Our results show emission bands at about 310 and 350 nm that exhibit bi-exponential sub-ps decays. Calculations, including solvent effects by a mixed discrete-continuum model, indicate that the Franck Condon region is characterized by significant coupling between the excited states of the benzyl and the uracil moieties, mirrored by the short-lived emission at 310 nm. Two main ground state recovery pathways are identified, both contributing to the 350 nm emission. The first 'photophysical' decay path involves a ππ* excited state localized on the uracil and is connected to the ground electronic state by an easily accessible crossing with S0, accounting for the short lifetime component. Simulations indicate that a possible second pathway is characterized by exciplex formation, with partial benzene → uracil charge transfer character, that may lead instead to photocyclization. The relevance of our results is discussed in view of the photoactivated dynamics of DNA/protein complexes, with implications on their interaction mechanisms.

Global DNA dynamics of 8-oxoguanine repair by human OGG1 revealed by stopped-flow kinetics and molecular dynamics simulation

The toxic action of different endogenous and exogenous agents leads to damage in genomic DNA. 8-Oxoguanine is one of the most often generated and highly mutagenic oxidative forms of damage in DNA. Normally, in human cells it is promptly removed by 8-oxoguanine-DNA-glycosylase hOGG1, the key DNA-repair enzyme. An association between the accumulation of oxidized guanine and an increased risk of harmful processes in organisms was already found. However, the detailed mechanism of damaged base recognition and removal is still unclear. To clarify the role of active site amino acids in the damaged base coordination and to reveal the elementary steps in the overall enzymatic process we investigated hOGG1 mutant forms with substituted amino acid residues in the enzyme base-binding pocket. Replacing the functional groups of the enzyme active site allowed us to change the rates of the individual steps of the enzymatic reaction. To gain further insight into the mechanism of hOGG1 catalysis a detailed pre-steady state kinetic study of this enzymatic process was carried out using the stopped-flow approach. The changes in the DNA structure after mixing with enzymes were followed by recording the FRET signal using Cy3/Cy5 labels in DNA substrates in the time range from milliseconds to hundreds of seconds. DNA duplexes containing non-damaged DNA, 8-oxoG, or an AP-site or its unreactive synthetic analogue were used as DNA-substrates. The kinetic parameters of DNA binding and damage processing were obtained for the mutant forms and for WT hOGG1. The analyses of fluorescence traces provided information about the DNA dynamics during damage recognition and removal. The kinetic study for the mutant forms revealed that all introduced substitutions reduced the efficiency of the hOGG1 activity; however, they played pivotal roles at certain elementary stages identified during the study. Taken together, our results gave the opportunity to restore the role of substituted amino acids and main "damaged base-amino acid" contacts, which provide an important link in the understanding the mechanism of the DNA repair process catalyzed by hOGG1.

Real-time observation of conformational switching in single conjugated polymer chains

Conjugated polymers (CPs) are an important class of organic semiconductors that combine novel optoelectronic properties with simple processing from organic solvents. It is important to study CP conformation in solution to understand the physics of these materials and because it affects the properties of solution-processed films. Single-molecule techniques are unique in their ability to extract information on a chain-to-chain basis; however, in the context of CPs, technical challenges have limited their general application to host matrices or semiliquid environments that constrain the conformational dynamics of the polymer. We introduce a conceptually different methodology that enables measurements in organic solvents using the single-end anchoring of polymer chains to avoid diffusion while preserving polymer flexibility. We explore the effect of organic solvents and show that, in addition to chain-to-chain conformational heterogeneity, collapsed and extended polymer segments can coexist within the same chain. The technique enables real-time solvent-exchange measurements, which show that anchored CP chains respond to sudden changes in solvent conditions on a subsecond time scale. Our results give an unprecedented glimpse into the mechanism of solvent-induced reorganization of CPs and can be expected to lead to a new range of techniques to investigate and conformationally manipulate CPs.

High-affinity RNA binding by a hyperthermophilic single-stranded DNA-binding protein

Single-stranded DNA-binding proteins (SSBs), including replication protein A (RPA) in eukaryotes, play a central role in DNA replication, recombination, and repair. SSBs utilise an oligonucleotide/oligosaccharide-binding (OB) fold domain to bind DNA, and typically oligomerise in solution to bring multiple OB fold domains together in the functional SSB. SSBs from hyperthermophilic crenarchaea, such as Sulfolobus solfataricus, have an unusual structure with a single OB fold coupled to a flexible C-terminal tail. The OB fold resembles those in RPA, whilst the tail is reminiscent of bacterial SSBs and mediates interaction with other proteins. One paradigm in the field is that SSBs bind specifically to ssDNA and much less strongly to RNA, ensuring that their functions are restricted to DNA metabolism. Here, we use a combination of biochemical and biophysical approaches to demonstrate that the binding properties of S. solfataricus SSB are essentially identical for ssDNA and ssRNA. These features may represent an adaptation to a hyperthermophilic lifestyle, where DNA and RNA damage is a more frequent event.

Fluorescence-Based Strategies to Investigate the Structure and Dynamics of Aptamer-Ligand Complexes

In addition to the helical nature of double-stranded DNA and RNA, single-stranded oligonucleotides can arrange themselves into tridimensional structures containing loops, bulges, internal hairpins and many other motifs. This ability has been used for more than two decades to generate oligonucleotide sequences, so-called aptamers, that can recognize certain metabolites with high affinity and specificity. More recently, this library of artificially-generated nucleic acid aptamers has been expanded by the discovery that naturally occurring RNA sequences control bacterial gene expression in response to cellular concentration of a given metabolite. The application of fluorescence methods has been pivotal to characterize in detail the structure and dynamics of these aptamer-ligand complexes in solution. This is mostly due to the intrinsic high sensitivity of fluorescence methods and also to significant improvements in solid-phase synthesis, post-synthetic labeling strategies and optical instrumentation that took place during the last decade. In this work, we provide an overview of the most widely employed fluorescence methods to investigate aptamer structure and function by describing the use of aptamers labeled with a single dye in fluorescence quenching and anisotropy assays. The use of 2-aminopurine as a fluorescent analog of adenine to monitor local changes in structure and fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) to follow long-range conformational changes is also covered in detail. The last part of the review is dedicated to the application of fluorescence techniques based on single-molecule microscopy, a technique that has revolutionized our understanding of nucleic acid structure and dynamics. We finally describe the advantages of monitoring ligand-binding and conformational changes, one molecule at a time, to decipher the complexity of regulatory aptamers and summarize the emerging folding and ligand-binding models arising from the application of these single-molecule FRET microscopy techniques.

Biophysical Approaches to Bacterial Gene Regulation by Riboswitches

The last decade has witnessed the discovery of a variety of non-coding RNA sequences that perform a broad range of crucial biological functions. Among these, the ability of certain RNA sequences, so-called riboswitches, has attracted considerable interest. Riboswitches control gene expression in response to the concentration of particular metabolites to which they bind without the need for any protein. These RNA switches not only need to adopt a very specific tridimensional structure to perform their function, but also their sequence has been evolutionary optimized to recognize a particular metabolite with high affinity and selectivity. Thus, riboswitches offer a unique opportunity to get fundamental insights into RNA plasticity and how folding dynamics and ligand recognition mechanisms have been efficiently merged to control gene regulation. Because riboswitch sequences have been mostly found in bacterial organisms controlling the expression of genes associated to the synthesis, degradation or transport of crucial metabolites for bacterial survival, they offer exciting new routes for antibiotic development in an era where bacterial resistance is more than ever challenging conventional drug discovery strategies. Here, we give an overview of the architecture, diversity and regulatory mechanisms employed by riboswitches with particular emphasis on the biophysical methods currently available to characterise their structure and functional dynamics.

Binding dynamics of a monomeric SSB protein to DNA: a single-molecule multi-process approach

Single-stranded DNA binding proteins (SSBs) are ubiquitous across all organisms and are characterized by the presence of an OB (oligonucleotide/oligosaccharide/oligopeptide) binding motif to recognize single-stranded DNA (ssDNA). Despite their critical role in genome maintenance, our knowledge about SSB function is limited to proteins containing multiple OB-domains and little is known about single OB-folds interacting with ssDNA. Sulfolobus solfataricus SSB (SsoSSB) contains a single OB-fold and being the simplest representative of the SSB-family may serve as a model to understand fundamental aspects of SSB:DNA interactions. Here, we introduce a novel approach based on the competition between Förster resonance energy transfer (FRET), protein-induced fluorescence enhancement (PIFE) and quenching to dissect SsoSSB binding dynamics at single-monomer resolution. We demonstrate that SsoSSB follows a monomer-by-monomer binding mechanism that involves a positive-cooperativity component between adjacent monomers. We found that SsoSSB dynamic behaviour is closer to that of Replication Protein A than to Escherichia coli SSB; a feature that might be inherited from the structural analogies of their DNA-binding domains. We hypothesize that SsoSSB has developed a balance between high-density binding and a highly dynamic interaction with ssDNA to ensure efficient protection of the genome but still allow access to ssDNA during vital cellular processes.

Using sm-FRET and denaturants to reveal folding landscapes

RNA folding studies aim to clarify the relationship among sequence, tridimensional structure, and biological function. In the last decade, the application of single-molecule fluorescence resonance energy transfer (sm-FRET) techniques to investigate RNA structure and folding has revealed the details of conformational changes and timescale of the process leading to the formation of biologically active RNA structures with subnanometer resolution on millisecond timescales. In this review, we initially summarize the first wave of single-molecule FRET-based RNA techniques that focused on analyzing the influence of mono- and divalent metal ions on RNA function, and how these studies have provided very valuable information about folding pathways and the presence of intermediate and low-populated states. Next, we describe a second generation of single-molecule techniques that combine sm-FRET with the use of chemical denaturants as an emerging powerful approach to reveal information about the dynamics and energetics of RNA folding that remains hidden using conventional sm-FRET approaches. The main advantages of using the competing interplay between folding agents such as metal ions and denaturants to observe and manipulate the dynamics of RNA folding and RNA-ligand interactions is discussed in the context of the adenine riboswitch aptamer.

Quantitative characterization of protein-protein complexes involved in base excision DNA repair

Base Excision Repair (BER) efficiently corrects the most common types of DNA damage in mammalian cells. Step-by-step coordination of BER is facilitated by multiple interactions between enzymes and accessory proteins involved. Here we characterize quantitatively a number of complexes formed by DNA polymerase β (Polβ), apurinic/apyrimidinic endonuclease 1 (APE1), poly(ADP-ribose) polymerase 1 (PARP1), X-ray repair cross-complementing protein 1 (XRCC1) and tyrosyl-DNA phosphodiesterase 1 (TDP1), using fluorescence- and light scattering-based techniques. Direct physical interactions between the APE1-Polβ, APE1-TDP1, APE1-PARP1 and Polβ-TDP1 pairs have been detected and characterized for the first time. The combined results provide strong evidence that the most stable complex is formed between XRCC1 and Polβ. Model DNA intermediates of BER are shown to induce significant rearrangement of the Polβ complexes with XRCC1 and PARP1, while having no detectable influence on the protein–protein binding affinities. The strength of APE1 interaction with Polβ, XRCC1 and PARP1 is revealed to be modulated by BER intermediates to different extents, depending on the type of DNA damage. The affinity of APE1 for Polβ is higher in the complex with abasic site-containing DNA than after the APE1-catalyzed incision. Our findings advance understanding of the molecular mechanisms underlying coordination and regulation of the BER process.

DNA-protein interactions: methods for detection and analysis

DNA-binding proteins control various cellular processes such as recombination, replication and transcription. This review is aimed to summarize some of the most commonly used techniques to determine DNA-protein interactions. In vitro techniques such as footprinting assays, electrophoretic mobility shift assay, southwestern blotting, yeast one-hybrid assay, phage display and proximity ligation assay have been discussed. The highly versatile in vivo techniques such as chromatin immunoprecipitation and its variants, DNA adenine methyl transferase identification as well as 3C and chip-loop assay have also been summarized. In addition, some in silico tools have been reviewed to provide computational basis for determining DNA-protein interactions. Biophysical techniques like fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) techniques, FRET-FLIM, circular dichroism, atomic force microscopy, nuclear magnetic resonance, surface plasmon resonance, etc. have also been highlighted.