Relative indications for radiosurgery and microsurgery for acoustic schwannoma

Stereotactic radiosurgery for Koos grade IV vestibular schwannoma: a systematic review and meta-analysis

BACKGROUND

Stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) is a well-established treatment option for Koos stage I-III vestibular schwannomas (VS), often used as the first line of treatment or after subtotal resection. However, the optimal treatment for Koos-IV VS remains unclear. Therefore, our study aimed to evaluate the effectiveness of SRS as a primary treatment for large VS classified as Koos-IV.

METHODS

A systematic search was performed on December 28th, 2022, based on PubMed, Web of Science, and Scopus according to the PRISMA statement. The review was updated on September 7th, 2023. The risk of bias was assessed using the NIH Quality Assessment Tool. The R software (ver. 4.3.2) was used for all quantitative analyses and preparation of the forest plots. Publication bias and sensitivity analysis were performed to evaluate the reliability of the obtained results.

RESULTS

Among 2941 screened records, ten studies (1398 patients) have been included in quantitative synthesis. The overall tumor control rate was 90.7% (95%CI 86.3-94.4). Kaplan-Meier estimates of tumor control at 2, 6, and 10 years were 96.0% (95% CI 92.9-97.6%), 88.8% (95% CI 86.9-89.8%), and 84.5% (95% CI, 81.2-85.8%), respectively. The overall hearing preservation rate was 56.5% (95%CI 37-75.1). Kaplan-Meier estimates of hearing preservation rate at 2, 6, and 10 years were 77.1% (95% CI 67.9-82.5%), 53.5% (95% CI 44.2-58.5%), and 38.1% (95% CI 23.4-40.7%), respectively. The overall facial nerve preservation rate was 100% (95%CI 99.9-100.0). The overall trigeminal neuropathy rate reached 5.7% (95%CI 2.9-9.2). The overall rate of new-onset hydrocephalus was 5.6% (95%CI 3-9). The overall rates of worsening or new-onset tinnitus and vertigo were 6.8% (95%CI 4.2-10.0) and 9.1% (95%CI 2.1-19.6) respectively. No publication bias was detected according to the used methods.

CONCLUSIONS

Our systematic review and meta-analysis demonstrated a high overall tumor control rate, excellent facial nerve preservation, and low incidence of new-onset or worsened tinnitus and vertigo. However, several drawbacks associated with SRS should be noted, such as the presence of post-SRS hydrocephalus risk, mediocre long-term hearing preservation, and the lack of immediate tumor decompression. Nevertheless, the use of SRS may be beneficial in appropriately selected cases of Koos-IV VS. Moreover, further prospective studies directly comparing SRS with surgery are necessary to determine the optimal treatment for large VS and verify our results on a higher level of evidence. Registration and protocol: CRD42023389856.

Stereotactic Radiotherapy for the Management of Refractory Ventricular Tachycardia: Promise and Future Directions

Ventricular tachycardia (VT) caused by myocardial scaring bears a significant risk of mortality and morbidity. Antiarrhythmic drug therapy (AAD) and catheter ablation remain the cornerstone of VT management, but both treatments have limited efficacy and potential adverse effects. Stereotactic body radiotherapy (SBRT) is routinely used in oncology to treat non-invasively solid tumors with high precision and efficacy. Recently, this technology has been evaluated for the treatment of VT. This review presents the basic underlying principles, proof of concept, and main results of trials and case series that used SBRT for the treatment of VT refractory to AAD and catheter ablation.

Vestibular schwannomas: Accuracy of tumor volume estimated by ice cream cone formula using thin-sliced MR images

PURPOSE

We estimated the volume of vestibular schwannomas by an ice cream cone formula using thin-sliced magnetic resonance images (MRI) and compared the estimation accuracy among different estimating formulas and between different models.

METHODS

The study was approved by a local institutional review board. A total of 100 patients with vestibular schwannomas examined by MRI between January 2011 and November 2015 were enrolled retrospectively. Informed consent was waived. Volumes of vestibular schwannomas were estimated by cuboidal, ellipsoidal, and spherical formulas based on a one-component model, and cuboidal, ellipsoidal, Linskey's, and ice cream cone formulas based on a two-component model. The estimated volumes were compared to the volumes measured by planimetry. Intraobserver reproducibility and interobserver agreement was tested. Estimation error, including absolute percentage error (APE) and percentage error (PE), was calculated. Statistical analysis included intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC), linear regression analysis, one-way analysis of variance, and paired t-tests with P < 0.05 considered statistically significant.

RESULTS

Overall tumor size was 4.80 ± 6.8 mL (mean ±standard deviation). All ICCs were no less than 0.992, suggestive of high intraobserver reproducibility and high interobserver agreement. Cuboidal formulas significantly overestimated the tumor volume by a factor of 1.9 to 2.4 (P ≤ 0.001). The one-component ellipsoidal and spherical formulas overestimated the tumor volume with an APE of 20.3% and 29.2%, respectively. The two-component ice cream cone method, and ellipsoidal and Linskey's formulas significantly reduced the APE to 11.0%, 10.1%, and 12.5%, respectively (all P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

The ice cream cone method and other two-component formulas including the ellipsoidal and Linskey's formulas allow for estimation of vestibular schwannoma volume more accurately than all one-component formulas.

A comprehensive analysis of hearing preservation after radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma

Object

Gamma Knife surgery (GKS) has evolved into a practical alternative to open microsurgical resection in the treatment of patients with vestibular schwannoma (VS). Hearing preservation rates in GKS series suggest very favorable outcomes without the possible acute morbidity associated with open microsurgery. To mitigate institutional and practitioner bias, the authors performed an analytical review of the published literature on the GKS treatment of vestibular schwannoma patients. Their aim was to objectively characterize the prognostic factors that contribute to hearing preservation after GKS, as well as methodically summarize the reported literature describing hearing preservation after GKS for VS.

Methods

A comprehensive search of the English-language literature revealed a total of 254 published studies reporting assessable and quantifiable outcome data obtained in patients who underwent radiosurgery for VSs. Inclusion criteria for articles were 4-fold: 1) hearing preservation rates reported specifically for VS; 2) hearing status reported using the American Association of Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery (AAO-HNS) or Gardner-Robertson classification; 3) documentation of initial tumor size; and 4) GKS was the only radiosurgical modality in the treatment. In the analysis only patients with AAO-HNS Class A or B or Gardner-Robertson Grade I or II status at the last follow-up visit were defined as having preserved hearing. Hearing preservation and outcome data were then aggregated and analyzed based on the radiation dose, tumor volume, and patient age.

Results

The 45 articles that met the authors' inclusion criteria represented 4234 patients in whom an overall hearing preservation rate was 51%, irrespective of radiation dose, patient age, or tumor volume. Practitioners who delivered an average ≤ 13-Gy dose of radiation reported a higher hearing preservation rate (60.5% at ≤ 13 Gy vs 50.4% at > 13 Gy; p = 0.0005). Patients with smaller tumors (average tumor volume ≤ 1.5 cm3) had a hearing preservation rate (62%) comparable with patients harboring larger tumors (61%) (p = 0.8968). Age was not a significant prognostic factor for hearing preservation rates as in older patients there was a trend toward improved hearing preservation rates (56% at < 65 years vs 71% at ≥ 65 years of age; p < 0.1134). The average overall follow-up in the studies reviewed was 44.4 ± 32 months (median 35 months).

Conclusions

These data provide a methodical overview of the literature regarding hearing preservation with GKS for VS and a less biased assessment of outcomes than single-institution studies. This objective analysis provides insight into advising patients of hearing preservation rates for GKS treatment of VSs that have been reported, as aggregated in the published literature. Analysis of the data suggests that an overall hearing preservation rate of ~ 51% can be expected approaching 3–4 years after radiosurgical treatment, and the analysis reveals that patients treated with ≤ 13 Gy were more likely to have preserved hearing than patients receiving larger doses of radiation. Furthermore, larger tumors and older patients do not appear to be at any increased risk for hearing loss after GKS for VS than younger patients or patients with smaller tumors.

Non-audiofacial morbidity after Gamma Knife surgery for vestibular schwannoma

OBJECT

While many studies have been published outlining morbidity following radiosurgical treatment of vestibular schwannomas, significant interpractitioner and institutional variability still exists. For this reason, the authors conducted a systematic review of the literature for non-audiofacial-related morbidity after the treatment of vestibular schwannoma with radiosurgery.

METHODS

The authors performed a comprehensive search of the English-language literature to identify studies that published outcome data of patients undergoing radiosurgery treatment for vestibular schwannomas. In total, 254 articles were found that described more than 50,000 patients and were analyzed for satisfying the authors' inclusion criteria. Patients from these studies were then separated into 2 cohorts based on the marginal dose of radiation: < or = 13 Gy and > 13 Gy. All tumors included in this study were < 25 mm in their largest diameter.

RESULTS

A total of 63 articles met the criteria of the established search protocol, which combined for a total of 5631 patients. Patients receiving > 13 Gy were significantly more likely to develop trigeminal nerve neuropathy than those receiving < 13 Gy (p < 0.001). While we found no relationship between radiation dose and the rate of developing hydrocephalus (0.6% for both cohorts), patients with hydrocephalus who received doses > 13 Gy appeared to have a higher rate of symptomatic hydrocephalus requiring shunt treatment (96% [> 13 Gy] vs 56% [< or = 13 Gy], p < 0.001). The rates of vertigo or balance disturbance (1.1% [> 13 Gy] vs 1.8% [< or = 13 Gy], p = 0.001) and tinnitus (0.1% [> 13 Gy] vs 0.7% [< or = 13 Gy], p = 0.001) were significantly higher in the lower dose cohort than those in the higher dose cohort.

CONCLUSIONS

The results of our review of the literature provide a systematic summary of the published rates of nonaudiofacial morbidity following radiosurgery for vestibular schwannoma.

HEARING PRESERVATION AFTER GAMMA KNIFE RADIOSURGERY FOR VESTIBULAR SCHWANNOMAS PRESENTING WITH HIGH-LEVEL HEARING

OBJECTIVE

The aim of this study was to evaluate long-term hearing preservation after gamma knife radiosurgery (GKS) for vestibular schwannomas in patients with initially normal or subnormal hearing (Gardner-Robertson Class 1) and to determine the predictive factors for functional hearing preservation.

METHODS

Since July 1992, more than 2053 vestibular schwannomas have been treated by GKS and followed at the Timone University Hospital, Marseille. A minimum of 3 years of follow-up (range, 3–11 years; median, 48 months) is available for 74 patients (without neurofibromatosis Type 2 or previous surgery) with Gardner-Robertson Class 1 hearing.

RESULTS

The average age of the patients was 47.5 years (range, 17–76 years). The number of tumors in Koos Stage I was 8, the average number in Stage II was 21, the average number in Stage III was 43, and the average number in Stage IV was 2. The median number of isocenters was 8 (range, 2–45), and the median marginal dose was 12 Gy (range, 9–13 Gy). At the time of the last follow-up evaluation, 78.4% of the patients had preserved functional hearing. Tumor control was achieved in 93% of the cases. The probability of preserving functional hearing was higher in patients who had an initial symptom other than hearing decrease (91.1%), in patients younger than 50 years (83.7%), and in those treated with a dose to the cochlea of less than 4 Gy (90.9%).

CONCLUSION

This study shows that the probability of preserving functional hearing in the long term after GKS for patients presenting with unilateral vestibular schwannomas is very high. The positive predictive factors appear to be young age, an initial symptom other than hearing decrease, and a low dose to the cochlea.

Neurological complications after acoustic neurinoma radiosurgery: revised risk factors based on long-term follow-up

CONCLUSIONS

The precise risk factors for neurological complications after acoustic neurinoma radiosurgery were identified on long-term follow-up. Type 2 neurofibromatosis was found to be a risk factor for hearing loss and peripheral tumor dose was a risk factor for seventh and fifth cranial nerve injuries. These risk factors corresponded to those reported at other institutions. At the present time, controversy exists regarding history of prior surgical resection and tumor size as risk factors for cranial nerve complications.

OBJECTIVES

To identify more precisely the risk factors for neurological complications after stereotactic radiosurgery (SRS) based on long-term follow-up.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

Between June 1990 and September 1998, 138 patients with acoustic neurinomas had SRS at Tokyo University Hospital. Of these, the 125 patients who were followed up for at least 6 months were entered into the present study. The patients' ages ranged from 13 to 77 years (median 53 years). The average tumor diameter ranged from 6.7 to 25.4 mm (mean 13.9 mm). The maximum tumor doses ranged from 20 to 40 Gy (mean 29.8 Gy), and the peripheral doses ranged from 12 to 25 Gy (mean 15.4 Gy). One to 12 isocenters were used (median 4). The follow-up period ranged from 6 to 191 months (median 60 months). The potential risk factors for neurological complications were analyzed using two univariate actuarial analyses. The neurological complications studied included hearing loss, facial palsy, and trigeminal nerve dysfunction. The variables analyzed were age, gender, prior operation, neurofibromatosis type 2 (NF2), tumor diameter, maximum tumor dose, peripheral tumor irradiation dose, and the number of isocenters. Variables with significant p values (<0.05) on both actuarial analyses were considered risk factors.

RESULTS

NF2 was significantly correlated with both total hearing loss and pure tone threshold (PTA) elevation; a history of prior surgical resection, tumor size, and the peripheral tumor dose were significantly correlated with facial palsy; and the peripheral tumor dose was significantly correlated with trigeminal neuropathy.

Indications et résultats du traitement des neurinomes de l'acoustique par radiothérapie stéréotaxique avec LINAC: résultats préliminaires

INTRODUCTION

Radiosurgery is presently becoming an alternative to microsurgical resection of acoustic neuromas. The interest of radiosurgery consists in its lower morbidity compared to surgery and likely in similar rates of long-term tumor control. The goal of our study was to assess the clinical outcome (hearing preservation and neurological complications) as well as tumor control after low-dose radiosurgery for unilateral acoustic neuromas.

MATERIAL AND METHODS

Since April 2002, 22 patients with untreated acoustic neuromas underwent stereotactic radiosurgery using a linear accelerator (LINAC) and a micromultileaf collimator (mMLC, Brain Lab) at a low-dose of 12 Gy. The average age was 56.4 years (range 29-73 years). The treatment volume was 0.03 to 6.04 cm(3) (median 1.85 cm(3)). The median follow-up period was 18 months (range 6-36 months).

RESULTS

No morbidity was observed during the treatment. Preservation of a serviceable hearing (classes I and II according to the Gardner-Robertson scale) was achieved in 10 of 14 patients (71%). Radiological tumor growth control was obtained in all patients (100%). Trigeminal neuropathy was observed in two patients. One of these patients also experienced a slight facial weakness.

CONCLUSIONS

Low dose radiosurgery provides a low rate of post-therapeutic morbidity and yields the preservation of a serviceable hearing in 70% of cases. Tumor control is observed in all patients, but a longer follow-up period is needed to confirm the stability of the tumor size.

Stereotactic radiosurgery: indications and results - part 2

Stereotactic radiosurgery and fractionated stereotactic radiotherapy represent an increasingly important option in the treatment of central nervous system disease. In this article, we discuss indications for stereotactic radiosurgery and review results reported in the medical literature.

Radiosurgery of vestibular schwannomas: summary of experience in 829 cases

OBJECT

Management options for vestibular schwannomas (VSs) have greatly expanded since the introduction of stereotactic radiosurgery. Optimal outcomes reflect long-term tumor control, preservation of cranial nerve function, and retention of quality of life. The authors review their 15-year experience.

METHODS

Between 1987 and 2002, some 829 patients with VSs underwent gamma knife surgery (GKS). Dose selection, imaging, and dose planning techniques evolved between 1987 and 1992 but thereafter remained stable for 10 years. The average tumor volume was 2.5 cm3. The median margin dose to the tumor was 13 Gy (range 10-20 Gy). No patient sustained significant perioperative morbidity. The average duration of hospital stay was less than 1 day. Unchanged hearing preservation was possible in 50 to 77% of patients (up to 90% in those with intracanalicular tumors). Facial neuropathy risks were reduced to less than 1%. Trigeminal symptoms were detected in less than 3% of patients whose tumors reached the level of the trigeminal nerve. Tumor control rates at 10 years were 97% (no additional treatment needed).

CONCLUSIONS

Superior imaging, multiple isocenter volumetric conformal dose planning, and optimal precision and dose delivery contributed to the long-term success of GKS, including in those patients in whom initial microsurgery had failed. Gamma knife surgery provides a low risk, minimally invasive treatment option for patients with newly diagnosed or residual VS. Cranial nerve preservation and quality of life maintenance are possible in long-term follow up.

Radiosurgery of vestibular schwannomas: summary of experience in 829 cases

Object. Management options for vestibular schwannomas (VSs) have greatly expanded since the introduction of stereotactic radiosurgery. Optimal outcomes reflect long-term tumor control, preservation of cranial nerve function, and retention of quality of life. The authors review their 15-year experience.

Methods. Between 1987 and 2002, some 829 patients with VSs underwent gamma knife surgery (GKS). Dose selection, imaging, and dose planning techniques evolved between 1987 and 1992 but thereafter remained stable for 10 years. The average tumor volume was 2.5 cm3. The median margin dose to the tumor was 13 Gy (range 10–20 Gy).

No patient sustained significant perioperative morbidity. The average duration of hospital stay was less than 1 day. Unchanged hearing preservation was possible in 50 to 77% of patients (up to 90% in those with intracanalicular tumors). Facial neuropathy risks were reduced to less than 1%. Trigeminal symptoms were detected in less than 3% of patients whose tumors reached the level of the trigeminal nerve. Tumor control rates at 10 years were 97% (no additional treatment needed).

Conclusions. Superior imaging, multiple isocenter volumetric conformal dose planning, and optimal precision and dose delivery contributed to the long-term success of GKS, including in those patients in whom initial microsurgery had failed. Gamma knife surgery provides a low risk, minimally invasive treatment option for patients with newly diagnosed or residual VS. Cranial nerve preservation and quality of life maintenance are possible in long-term follow up.

Outpatient gamma knife surgery for vestibular schwannoma: definition of the therapeutic profile based on a 10-year experience

Object. The purpose of the study was to define the therapeutic profile of outpatient gamma knife surgery (GKS) for vestibular schwannoma (VS) by using sequential tumor volumetry to quantify changes following treatment.

Methods. A total of 111 patients met the inclusion criteria. The median follow-up duration was 7 years (range 5–9.6 years). Thirty-seven patients (33%) had undergone surgery before GKS and 10 (9%) had neurofibromatosis Type 2 (NF2). The median VS volume was 1.6 cm3 (range 0.08–8.7 cm3).

The actuarial 6-year tumor control rate after a single GKS treatment was 95%. Tumor swelling was observed in 43 patients (38.7%). Recurrence was significantly associated with NF2 (p < 0.003) and the reduced dose (p < 0.03) delivered to these tumors. The incidence of facial nerve neuropathy was mainly determined by surgery prior to GKS (p < 0.0001). Facial nerve radiation toxicity was mild and transient. No permanent facial nerve toxicity was observed. Trigeminal neuropathy occurred in 13 patients, and this was correlated with the VS volume (p < 0.02). The median hearing loss was −10 dB (range + 20 dB to −70 dB). The risk of hearing loss was correlated with age and transient tumor swelling (p < 0.05) but not with dose parameters or NF2.

Conclusions. Outpatient GKS is feasible, effective, and safe. Its therapeutic profile compares favorably with that of microsurgery.

Outpatient gamma knife surgery for vestibular schwannoma: definition of the therapeutic profile based on a 10-year experience

Object.The purpose of the study was to define the therapeutic profile of outpatient gamma knife surgery (GKS) for vestibular schwannoma (VS) by using sequential tumor volumetry to quantify changes following treatment.

Methods.A total of 111 patients met the inclusion criteria. The median follow-up duration was 7 years (range 5–9.6 years). Thirty-seven patients (33%) had undergone surgery before GKS and 10 (9%) had neurofibromatosis Type 2 (NF2). The median VS volume was 1.6 cm3(range 0.08–8.7 cm3).

The actuarial 6-year tumor control rate after a single GKS treatment was 95%. Tumor swelling was observed in 43 patients (38.7%). Recurrence was significantly associated with NF2 (p < 0.003) and the reduced dose (p < 0.03) delivered to these tumors. The incidence of facial nerve neuropathy was mainly determined by surgery prior to GKS (p < 0.0001). Facial nerve radiation toxicity was mild and transient. No permanent facial nerve toxicity was observed. Trigeminal neuropathy occurred in 13 patients, and this was correlated with the VS volume (p < 0.02). The median hearing loss was −10 dB (range + 20 dB to −70 dB). The risk of hearing loss was correlated with age and transient tumor swelling (p < 0.05) but not with dose parameters or NF2.

Conclusions.Outpatient GKS is feasible, effective, and safe. Its therapeutic profile compares favorably with that of microsurgery.

Pseudocapsule Formation After Gamma Knife Radiosurgery for Trigeminal Neurinoma-Case Report-

A 38-year-old female presented with a trigeminal neurinoma manifesting as left facial paresthesia. The diagnosis was based on magnetic resonance (MR) imaging findings. Gamma knife radiosurgery (GKR) was performed at another hospital at her request. Fifteen months after the GKR, follow-up MR imaging revealed tumor regrowth causing extensive compression of the brainstem, and cyst formation in the tumor. Her clinical symptoms including facial pain and diplopia had worsened, so she was referred to our affiliated hospital for microsurgery. The tumor was totally resected, but the left trigeminal nerve had to be sacrificed because of pseudocapsule formation which covered both the tumor and the trigeminal nerve fibers. The diplopia disappeared, but her facial pain deteriorated after the operation. GKR can induce fibrosis or degenerative change in nearby structures, which may complicate subsequent surgery.

Microneurosurgery and radiosurgery--an attractive combination

Microneurosurgery and radiosurgery have made tremendous progress in terms of increasing efficacy and reducing treatment related mobility. Both techniques have clear indications; however, there is still competition between the two modalities in a variety of diseases. In all instances, this rivalry should be replaced by the concept of using both methods as complementary. Skull base tumours, metastases as well as certain AVMs are good candidates for this approach.