Work performance breathing normoxic nitrogen or helium gas mixtures

Efficacy of closed cell wet-suit at various depths and gas mixtures for thermoprotection during military training dives

Purpose: To evaluate a closed-cell wet-suit for thermal protective capability during extreme cold water exposure at various depths. Methods: Thirteen (n = 13) elite military divers who were tasked with cold-water training, participated in this study. To mimic various depths, the Ocean Simulation Facility (OSF) at the Navy Experimental Diving Unit (NEDU) was pressurized to simulate dive depths of 30, 50, and 75fsw. Water temperature remained at 1.8-2.0°C for all dives. Four divers dove each day and used the MK16 underwater breathing apparatus with gas mixes of either N202 (79:21) or HeO2 (88:12). Mean skin temperature (T_SK) (Ramanathan, 1964), core temperature (Tc), hand and foot readings were obtained every 30 min for 30 and 50fsw and every 15 min during the 75fsw dive. Results: T_C was significantly reduced across all dives (p = 0.004); however, was preserved above the threshold for hypothermia (post dive Tc = 36.5 ± 0.4). There was no effect of gas mix on T_C. T_SK significantly decreased (p < 0.001) across all dives independent of depth and gas. Hand and foot temperatures resulted in the termination of three of the dives. There were no significant main effects for depth or gas, but there were significant main effects for time on hand temperature (p < 0.001) and foot temperature (p < 0.001). Conclusion: Core temperature is maintained above threshold for hypothermia. Variatioins in T_C and T_SK are a function of dive duration independent of depth or gas for a closed-cell wet-suit in cold water at various depths. However, both hand and foot temperatures reached values at which dexterity is compromised.

Heliox breathing equally influences respiratory mechanics and cycling performance in trained males and females

In this study we tested the hypothesis that inspiring a low-density gas mixture (helium-oxygen; HeO2) would minimize mechanical ventilatory constraints and preferentially increase exercise performance in females relative to males. Trained male (n = 11, 31 yr) and female (n = 10, 26 yr) cyclists performed an incremental cycle test to exhaustion to determine maximal aerobic capacity (V̇o2max; male = 61, female = 56 ml·kg(-1)·min(-1)). A randomized, single-blinded crossover design was used for two experimental days where subjects completed a 5-km cycling time trial breathing humidified compressed room air or HeO2 (21% O2:balance He). Subjects were instrumented with an esophageal balloon for the assessment of respiratory mechanics. During the time trial, we assessed the ability of HeO2 to alleviate mechanical ventilatory constraints in three ways: 1) expiratory flow limitation, 2) utilization of ventilatory capacity, and 3) the work of breathing. We found that HeO2 significantly reduced the work of breathing, increased the size of the maximal flow-volume envelope, and reduced the fractional utilization of the maximal ventilatory capacity equally between men and women. The primary finding of this study was that inspiring HeO2 was associated with a statistically significant performance improvement of 0.7% (3.2 s) for males and 1.5% (8.1 s) for females (P < 0.05); however, there were no sex differences with respect to improvement in time trial performance (P > 0.05). Our results suggest that the extent of sex-based differences in airway anatomy, work of breathing, and expiratory flow limitation is not great enough to differentially affect whole body exercise performance.

Ventilatory response to exercise in aged runners breathing He-O2 or inspired CO2

The ventilatory response to exercise below ventilatory threshold (VTh) increases with aging, whereas above VTh the ventilatory response declines only slightly. We wondered whether this same ventilatory response would be observed in older runners. We also wondered whether their ventilatory response to exercise while breathing He-O(2) or inspired CO(2) would be different. To investigate, we studied 12 seniors (63 +/- 4 yr; 10 men, 2 women) who exercised regularly (5 +/- 1 days/wk, 29 +/- 11 mi/wk, 16 +/- 6 yr). Each subject performed graded cycle ergometry to exhaustion on 3 separate days, breathing either room air, 3% inspired CO(2), or a heliox mixture (79% He and 21% O(2)). The ventilatory response to exercise below VTh was 0.35 +/- 0.06 l x min(-1) x W(-1) and above VTh was 0.66 +/- 0.10 l x min(-1) x W(-1). He-O(2) breathing increased (P < 0.05) the ventilatory response to exercise both below (0.40 +/- 0.12 l x min(-1) x W(-1)) and above VTh (0.81 +/- 0.10 l x min(-1) x W(-1)). Inspired CO(2) increased (P < 0.001) the ventilatory response to exercise only below VTh (0.44 +/- 0.10 l x min(-1) x W(-1)). The ventilatory responses to exercise with room air, He-O(2), and CO(2) breathing of these fit runners were similar to those observed earlier in older sedentary individuals. These data suggest that the ventilatory response to exercise of these senior runners is adequate to support their greater exercise capacity and that exercise training does not alter the ventilatory response to exercise with He-O(2) or inspired CO(2) breathing.

Hyperventilation with He-O2 breathing is not decreased by superimposed external resistance

The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of imposed external resistance on the ventilatory response to He-O(2) breathing during peak exercise. To accomplish this purpose, separate inspiratory and expiratory external resistances were applied to offset for the decrease in intrapulmonary airway resistance with He-O(2) breathing. Seven men and three women (69+/-3 years, mean+/-S.D.) with normal pulmonary function performed graded cycle ergometry to exhaustion breathing room air, He-O(2) (79% He, 21% O(2)), He-O(2) with imposed expiratory resistance, and He-O(2) with imposed inspiratory resistance. Ventilation (VE), lung mechanics, and PET(CO(2)) were measured during each 1 min increment in work rate and were analyzed by one-way ANOVA for repeated measures at rest, ventilatory threshold (VTh), and peak exercise. In response, VE was increased and PET(CO(2)) was decreased at VTh (P<0.01) and peak exercise (P<0.01) whenever breathing He-O(2). Thus, VE was increased during exercise above VTh with He-O(2) breathing regardless of increases in inspiratory or expiratory external resistance. In conclusion, these data suggest that inspiratory resistive unloading is no more important than expiratory resistive unloading to the increase in VE with He-O(2) breathing during heavy and peak exercise.

Effects of training with heliox and noninvasive positive pressure ventilation on exercise ability in patients with severe COPD

STUDY OBJECTIVES

We sought to determine whether breathing heliox or using nasal noninvasive positive pressure ventilation (NIPPV) would produce immediate improvements in exercise capability in patients with COPD, and whether training for 6 weeks with one of these modalities would result in greater exercise improvement than with training unassisted.

SETTING

US military medical center.

METHODS

Thirty-nine patients with severe COPD (mean FEV1 of 33.5% predicted) underwent three incremental treadmill tests to exhaustion unassisted, breathing heliox, or breathing with NIPPV. They were then randomized to undergo 6 weeks of twice-weekly rehabilitation with unassisted exercise training (UT group), training while breathing heliox (HT group), or training while breathing with NIPPV (NT group). The three exercise tests were then repeated.

RESULTS

Heliox treatment did not produce any immediate benefit in exercise time or maximum workload in the 39 patients initially tested, the 32 patients who completed the protocol, or the HT group. Furthermore, no training advantage was evident in the HT group (n = 10) compared to the UT group (n = 11). NIPPV did not produce an immediate benefit in the initial tests, but produced a small increase in exercise time in the 32 patients completing the protocol in the final tests. This effect was primarily because of the NT group, who exercised significantly longer (mean +/- SD, 16.8 +/- 4.9 min vs 14.2 +/- 5.6 min, p = 0.0045) and to a higher workload (4.46 +/- 1.55 metabolic equivalents [METs] vs 4.09 +/- 1.75 METs, respectively; p = 0.038) when tested using the ventilator. Compared to the UT group, the NT group started out with a lower exercise time (7.9 +/- 3.5 min vs 12.3 +/- 5.2 min, p = 0.031) in preliminary testing, but the statistical difference was eliminated in the final tests (14.2 +/- 5.6 min vs 16.0 +/- 5.8 min, respectively; p = 0.451). The NT group actually slightly exceeded the UT group when they used the ventilator in final testing, although this was not statistically significant (16.8 +/- 4.9 min vs 16.0 +/- 5.8 min, respectively).

CONCLUSION

Heliox treatment does not appear to offer an immediate or training advantage with exercise in patients with COPD. For patients who have undergone regular exercise conditioning with NIPPV, use of the ventilator produces an immediate improvement in both exercise time and maximum workload attained, and it may confer a training advantage.

Breathing He-O2 increases ventilation but does not decrease the work of breathing during exercise

We previously observed an increase in minute ventilation (V E) with resistive unloading (He-O2 breathing) in healthy elderly subjects with normal pulmonary function. To investigate the effects of resistive unloading in elderly subjects with mild chronic airflow limitation (FEV(1)/FVC: 61 +/- 4%), we studied 10 elderly men and women 70 +/- 3 yr of age. These subjects performed graded cycle ergometry to exhaustion, once breathing room air and once breathing a He-O2 gas mixture (79% He, 21% O2). V E, pulmonary mechanics, and PET(CO2) were measured during each 1-min increment in work rate. Data were analyzed by paired t test at rest, at ventilatory threshold (VTh), and during maximal exercise. V E was significantly (p < 0.05) increased at VTh (3.4 +/- 4.0 L/min or 12 +/- 15% increase) and maximal exercise (15.2 +/- 9.7 L/min or 22 +/- 13% increase) while breathing He-O2. Concomitant to the increase in V E, PET(CO2) was decreased at all levels (p < 0.01), whereas total work of breathing against the lung was not different. We concluded that V E is increased during He-O2 breathing because of resistive unloading of the airways and the maintenance of the relationship between the work of breathing and exercise work rate.

Evidence of skeletal muscle metabolic reserve during whole body exercise in patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease

When freed from central cardiorespiratory limitations, healthy human skeletal muscle has exhibited a significant metabolic reserve. We studied the existence of this reserve in 10 severely compromised (FEV1 = 0.97 +/- SE 0.01) patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD). To manipulate O2 supply and O2 demand in locomotor and respiratory muscles, subjects performed both maximal conventional two-legged cycle ergometry (large muscle mass) and single-leg knee extensor exercise (KE, small muscle mass) while breathing room air (RA), 100% O2, and 79% helium + 21% O2 (HeO2). With each gas mixture, peak ventilation, peak heart rate, and perceived breathlessness were lower in KE than cycle exercise (p < 0. 05). Arterial O2 saturation and maximal work capacity increased in both exercise modalities while subjects breathed 100% O2 (work: +10% bike, +25% KE, p < 0.05). HeO2 increased maximal work capacity on the cycle (+14%, p < 0.05) but had no effect on KE. HeO2 resulted in the greatest maximum minute ventilation in both bike and KE (p < 0. 05) but had no effect on arterial O2 saturation. Thus, a skeletal muscle metabolic reserve in these patients with COPD is evidenced by: (1) greater muscle mass specific work in KE; (2) greater work rates with higher fraction of inspired oxygen (FIO2); (3) an even greater effect of FIO2 during KE (i.e., when the lungs are less challenged); and (4) the positive effect of HeO2 on bicycle work rate. This skeletal muscle metabolic reserve suggests that reduced whole body exercise capacity in COPD is the result of central restraints rather than peripheral skeletal muscle dysfunction, while the beneficial effect of 100% O2 (with no change in maximum ventilation) suggests that the respiratory system is not the sole constraint to oxygen consumption.

The effects of breathing He-O2 mixtures on maximal oxygen consumption in normoxic and hypoxic men

1. The hypothesis that the ventilatory resistance to O2 flow (RV) does limit maximal O2 consumption (VO2,max) in hypoxia, but not in normoxia, at least in non-athletic subjects, was tested. RV was reduced by using He-O2 mixtures. 2. VO2,max was measured during graded cyclo-ergometric exercise in eight men (aged 30 +/- 3 years) who breathed N2-O2 and He-O2 mixtures in normoxia (inspired oxygen fraction (FI,O2) = 0.21) and hypoxia (FI,O2 = 0.11). O2 consumption, expired and alveolar ventilations (VE and VA, respectively), blood lactate and haemoglobin concentrations, heart rate and arterial oxygen saturation (Sa,O2) were determined at the steady state of each work load. Arterial O2 and CO2 partial pressures (Pa,O2 and Pa,CO2, respectively) were measured at rest and at the end of the highest work load. 3. Maximal VE and VA were significantly increased by He-O2 breathing in normoxia (+27 and +18%, respectively), without significant changes in Pa,O2, Sa,O2 and VO2,max. In hypoxia, VE and VA increased (+31 and +24%, respectively), together with Pa,O2 (+17%), Sa,O2 (+6%) and VO2,max (+14%). 4. The results support the hypothesis that the role of RV in limiting VO2,max is negligible in normoxia. In hypoxia, the finding that higher VE and VA values during He-O2 breathing led to higher VO2,max values suggests a greater role of RV as a limiting factor. It is unclear whether the finding that the VO2,max values were the same during He-O2 and N2-O2 breathing in normoxia is due to a non-linear response of the O2 transfer system, as previously proposed.

Ventilation and respiratory mechanics during exercise in younger subjects breathing CO2 or HeO2

To determine if ventilation (VE) during maximal exercise would be increased as much by 3% CO2 loading as by resistive unloading of the airways, we studied seven subjects (39 +/- 5 years; mean +/- S.D.) during graded-cycle ergometry to exhaustion while breathing: (1) room air (RA); (2) 3% CO2, 21% O2, and 76% N2; or (3) 79% He and 21% O2). VE and respiratory mechanics were measured during each 1-min increment (20 or 30 W) in work rate. VE during maximal exercise was increased 21 +/- 17% when breathing 3% CO2 and 23 +/- 16% when breathing HeO2 (P < 0.01). Further, the ventilatory response to exercise above ventilatory threshold (VTh) was increased (P < 0.05) when breathing HeO2 (0.89 +/- 0.26 L/min/W) as compared with breathing RA (0.65 +/- 0.12). When breathing HeO2, end-expiratory lung volume (% total lung capacity, TLC) was lower during maximal exercise (46 +/- 7) when compared with RA (53 +/- 6, P < 0.01). In conclusion, VE during maximal exercise can be augmented equally by 3% CO2 loading as by resistive unloading of the airways in younger subjects. This suggests that in younger subjects with normal lung function there are minimal mechanical ventilatory constraints on VE during maximal exercise.

Acute unloading of the work of breathing extends exercise duration in patients with heart failure

OBJECTIVES

This study investigated whether maximal exercise performance can be improved by acutely decreasing the work of breathing in these patients.

BACKGROUND

Exertional dyspnea is a frequent limiting symptom in patients with heart failure. It may result from increased work of breathing.

METHODS

Fifteen patients with heart failure and nine age-matched normal subjects underwent two maximal exercise tests. Subjects exercised twice in randomized, single-blind manner using room air (RA) and a 79% helium/21% oxygen mixture (He). Respiratory gas analysis, Borg scale recordings of perceived dyspnea and near infrared spectroscopy of an accessory respiratory muscle were obtained during exercise.

RESULTS

In normal subjects there was no significant difference in peak oxygen uptake (Vo2) ([mean +/- SD] RA 38 +/- 8 vs. He 35 +/- 7 ml/kg per min), exercise duration (RA 724 +/- 163 vs. He 762 +/- 123 s) or peak minute ventilation (RA 97 +/- 27 vs. He 97 +/- 28 liters/min, all p = NS). Only three of nine control subjects thought that exercise with the He mixture was subjectively easier. In contrast, patients with heart failure exercised an average of 146 s longer with the He mixture (RA 868 +/- 293 vs. He 1,014 +/- 338, p < 0.01). Peak Vo2 (RA 19 +/- 4 vs. He 18 +/- 5 ml/kg per min) and peak minute ventilation (RA 53 +/- 12 vs. He 53 +/- 15 liters/min) were unchanged (both p = NS). The respiratory quotient at peak exercise was lower with the He mixture (RA 1.05 +/- 0.08 vs. He 0.98 +/- 0.06, p < 0.05). Thirteen of the 15 patients thought that exercise with the He mixture was subjectively easier (p < 0.02 vs. control group).

CONCLUSIONS

In patients with heart failure, pulmonary factors, including respiratory muscle work and airflow turbulence, contribute to limiting exercise performance. Therapeutic interventions aimed at attenuating work of breathing may be beneficial.

Ventilatory response to exercise in subjects breathing CO2 or HeO2

To investigate the effects of mechanical ventilatory limitation on the ventilatory response to exercise, eight older subjects with normal lung function were studied. Each subject performed graded cycle ergometry to exhaustion once while breathing room air; once while breathing 3% CO2-21% O2-balance N2; and once while breathing HeO2 (79% He and 21% O2). Minute ventilation (VE) and respiratory mechanics were measured continuously during each 1-min increment in work rate (10 or 20 W). Data were analyzed at rest, at ventilatory threshold (VTh), and at maximal exercise. When the subjects were breathing 3% CO2, there was an increase (P < 0.001) in VE at rest and at VTh but not during maximal exercise. When the subjects were breathing HeO2, VE was increased (P < 0.05) only during maximal exercise (24 +/- 11%). The ventilatory response to exercise below VTh was greater only when the subjects were breathing 3% CO2 (P < 0.05). Above VTh, the ventilatory response when the subjects were breathing HeO2 was greater than when breathing 3% CO2 (P < 0.01). Flow limitation, as percent of tidal volume, during maximal exercise was greater (P < 0.01) when the subjects were breathing CO2 (22 +/- 12%) than when breathing room air (12 +/- 9%) or when breathing HeO2 (10 +/- 7%) (n = 7). End-expiratory lung volume during maximal exercise was lower when the subjects were breathing HeO2 than when breathing room air or when breathing CO2 (P < 0.01). These data indicate that older subjects have little reserve for accommodating an increase in ventilatory demand and suggest that mechanical ventilatory constraints influence both the magnitude of VE during maximal exercise and the regulation of VE and respiratory mechanics during heavy-to-maximal exercise.

Lack of importance of respiratory muscle load in ventilatory regulation during heavy exercise in humans

1. Seven active subjects (24 +/- 1 years; maximal oxygen uptake (VO2,max), 3.77 +/- 0.2 l min-1; mean +/- S.E.M.) performed constant work rate heavy exercise (CWHE, approximately 80% of maximal incremental work rate) to exhaustion on 2 days, one with (unload) and one without (control) respiratory muscle unloading. 2. With unloading, a special device applied flow-proportional mouth pressure assist (positive with inspiratory (I), negative with expiratory (E) flows) throughout each breath. No pressure assist occurred during control CWHE. To confirm unloading, respiratory muscle pressures (Pmus) were derived (n = 5) from measured pleural pressure and chest wall elastic and resistive pressures. 3. Other than minor differences in early exercise, the temporal course of minute ventilation (VE) was similar in both tests as exercise progressed. The fall in estimated mean alveolar CO2 (PA,CO2) throughout CWHE was identical in both tests. There were no significant differences (ANOVA) in VE, tidal volume, frequency, oxygen consumption rate (VO2), heart rate or PA,CO2, between unload and control CWHE, at matched times (at 50% of control duration and at the end of exercise). Unloading reduced Pmus significantly throughout CWHE; at 50% control duration, peak Pmus,I and Pmus,E fell by 24 and 41%, respectively, with unloading, as did mean Pmus,I and Pmus,E (21 and 44%). 4. The lack of any significant changes in VE, PA,CO2 or breathing pattern, despite a marked reduction in respiratory muscle load throughout CWHE, indicates that the load on the respiratory muscles has only a minor role in the regulation of ventilation during heavy exercise. 5. The absence of improvement in CWHE duration (control, 11.4 +/- 1.2 min; unload, 12.6 +/- 2.1 min, n.s.) with unloading implies that respiratory muscle function does not limit endurance exercise performance during cycling in healthy humans.

Effects of breathing a normoxic helium mixture on exercise tolerance of patients with cystic fibrosis

Breathing helium-oxygen (He-O2) mixtures of 20.9% O2/79.1% He has been shown to increase exercise ventilation and peak oxygen uptake in healthy subjects. The improved exercise performance is thought to be due to the reduced density of He-O2 compared to air and the resulting increases in ventilation. Patients with cystic fibrosis (CF) frequently have abnormal pulmonary function test results, low exercise ventilations and diminished exercise tolerance. This led to the hypothesis that in CF the exercise tolerance of patients might improve when breathing He-O2. To test this hypothesis, 11 patients with CF or mild to severe airway obstruction performed spirometry and progressive maximal exercise tests while breathing air or He-O2. The He-O2 mixture significantly increased (P < 0.05) forced expiratory volume in 1 sec (FEV1) by 8.2%, peak expired flow by 39%, and maximal voluntary ventilation (MVV) by 17.9% compared to air, while forced vital capacity (FVC) and forced mid-expiratory flow rate (FEF25-75%) were unchanged by breathing He-O2. Ventilation and oxygen uptake at matched submaximal power outputs were not increased while breathing He-O2, nor were peak exercise ventilation (VEpeak) or peak exercise oxygen uptake (VO2peak). Estimated hemoglobin saturation and total exercise time were also unchanged during He-O2 breathing. However, there was a trend for the subjects with the better FEV1 to increase VO2peak. Increases in VO2peak when breathing He-O2 and air were correlated (r = 0.67, P < 0.05) with the percent of predicted FEV1 values. Still, in the 11 patients as a group, breathing He-O2 did not significantly improve VO2peak, VEpeak, or exercise tolerance.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Ventilatory adjustments during sustained resistive unloading in exercising humans

Effect of He-O2-breathing (79.1%:20.9%) compared to air-breathing on inspiratory ventilation (VI) and its different components [tidal volume (VT), the duration of the phases of each respiratory cycle (tI, tTOT)] as well as on inspiratory mouth occlusion pressure (P0.1) were studied in six normal men at rest and during 72 constant-load exercises (90 W) over a much longer period than in previous studies. Results showed that, irrespective of the order of administration of the two gases (7 min air----7 min He-O2 or vice versa): at rest, P0.1 decreased during He-O2 inhalation but no changes in VI and breathing pattern were detectable; during exercise, sustained He-induced hyperventilation was observed without any change in the absolute value of P0.1; increase in P0.1 between the resting period and exercise (delta P0.1) was significantly higher during He-O2-breathing than during air breathing; this He-induced hyperventilation was associated with a sustained increase in VT/tI, but with constant tI/tTOT. Helium-breathing during exercise cannot be a simple situation of resistance unloading, as has been suggested. We conclude that He-O2-breathing, after the initial compensation period, induces reflex changes in ventilatory control with an increase in inspiratory neural drive. Moreover, it appears that exercise P0.1 is not a legitimate index of inspiratory neural drive whenever rest P0.1 changes according to the nature of the inhaled gas mixture.

Density-dependent airflow and ventilatory control during exercise

The influence of respired gas density on ventilatory control during cycle-ergometer exercise was investigated in six healthy subjects. They underwent constant-load exercise for 10 min both at 50% and 90% of the anaerobic threshold, inhaling air for the first 5 min followed abruptly by 80% helium-20% oxygen (He-O2) for the remaining 5 min (and vice versa). The He-O2 breathing elicited no discernible effect on ventilation (VI) or mean alveolar PCO2 (PACO2) at rest or at the lower work rate. However, at the higher work rate, He-O2 breathing resulted in a clear and sustained hyperventilation in all subjects. A compensatory response to the hypocapnia, consequent to the helium-induced hyperventilation, was not evident even though all subjects demonstrated a normal ventilatory responsiveness to inhaled CO2 while in this condition. These observations suggest that turbulent airflow normally imposes a constraint on the magnitude of the hyperpnea of high-intensity exercise.