Difficulties in assessing the effect of strychnine on the outcome of non-ketotic hyperglycinaemia. Observations on sisters with a mild T-protein defect

Clinical variability in glycine encephalopathy

Glycine encephalopathy (GCE) is an autosomal recessive error of glycine degradation, resulting in a poor outcome with severe mental retardation, intractable seizures and spasticity. Milder variants with a significantly better outcome have been reported, but an early prediction of the long-term outcome is not yet possible. With regard to the long-term outcome, the data reported in the literature of children with different GCE forms were compared. Determination of cerebrospinal fluid and plasma glycine concentrations at the time of diagnosis were not useful in differentiating mild and severe outcomes. By contrast, several clinical parameters correlate with a poor outcome: spastic quadriparesis, truncal hypotonia, typical electroencephalography patterns, congenital and cerebral malformations (e.g., corpus callosum hypoplasia). Hyperactivity, behavioral problems and choreiform movement disorders are associated with a milder outcome. Thus, prediction of the outcome of GCE may be facilitated by searching for selected clinical parameters. In addition, early neuroimaging may be a valuable tool in predicting the outcome of GCE.

Nonketotic hyperglycinemia (glycine encephalopathy): laboratory diagnosis

Nonketotic hyperglycinemia (NKH) is an autosomal recessive disorder of glycine metabolism caused by a defect in the glycine cleavage enzyme complex (GCS). GCS is a complex of four proteins encoded on four different chromosomes. In classical neonatal NKH, levels of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) glycine and CSF/plasma glycine ratio are very high but the CSF results, in particular, may be more difficult to interpret in later-onset, milder, or otherwise atypical NKH. Enzymatic confirmation of NKH requires a liver sample. Delineation of which protein of the complex is defective is necessary to screen for mutations in the appropriate gene. Except for Finnish NKH patients, few recurrent mutations have yet been found, although analysis of the P-protein gene (the site of the defect in the majority of patients) is at an early stage. Prenatal diagnosis by GCS assay in chorionic villus biopsies is not completely reliable and will be replaced by molecular analysis in families where the mutations are known.

Non-concordance of CVS and liver glycine cleavage enzyme in three families with non-ketotic hyperglycinaemia (NKH) leading to false negative prenatal diagnoses

We report three false negative prenatal diagnostic results, using direct measurement of glycine cleavage enzyme activity in uncultured chorionic villus tissue from 290 pregnancies at risk for non-ketotic hyperglycinaemia (NKH). Testing was done by two centres: Vancouver, Canada and Lyon, France. One false negative result had activity near the lower limit of the normal range but two samples gave completely normal results well within the control range. All three pregnancies continued and the three children were born affected with NKH. Because of the first result, we now counsel that there is a grey zone of uninterpretable activity where affected and normal enzyme values overlap. Because of the other two results we now counsel that there is an approximately 1% chance of a pregnancy with a normal CVS activity resulting in an affected child. The clinical and biochemical findings in the three families are discussed.

Atypical nonketotic hyperglycinemia with normal cerebrospinal fluid to plasma glycine ratio

The diagnosis of nonketotic hyperglycinemia is considered to depend upon the presence of increased cerebrospinal fluid glycine and an increased cerebrospinal fluid to plasma glycine ratio. We studied two siblings who have the neurologic and peripheral biochemical features of the atypical variant of nonketotic hyperglycinemia but have normal cerebrospinal fluid glycine and cerebrospinal fluid to plasma glycine ratios. The proband had reduced liver glycine cleavage system activity of 17% and 21% of mean normal values, confirmed in two independent laboratories. Her lymphoblast glycine cleavage system activity was normal. Nonketotic hyperglycinemia can be present in the absence of increased cerebrospinal fluid glycine. Measurement of liver glycine cleavage system activity is indicated when nonketotic hyperglycinemia is suggested by clinical features and peripheral glycine levels but cerebrospinal fluid glycine is normal.

Identification of the mutations in the T-protein gene causing typical and atypical nonketotic hyperglycinemia

We have investigated the molecular lesions of T-protein deficiency causing typical or atypical nonketotic hyperglycinemia (NKH) in two unrelated pedigrees. A patient with typical NKH was identified as being homozygous for a missense mutation in the T-protein gene, a G-to-A transition leading to a Gly-to-Asp substitution at amino acid 269 (G269D). Sibling patients of a second family with atypical NKH had two different missense mutations in the T-protein gene (compound heterozygote), a G-to-A transition leading to a Gly-to-Arg substitution at amino acid 47 (G47R) in one allele, and a G-to-A transition leading to an Arg-to-His substitution at amino acid 320 (R320H) in the other allele. Gly 269 is conserved in T-proteins of various species, even in E. coli, whereas Gly 47 and Arg 320 are replaced by Ala and Leu, respectively, in E. coli. The mutation occurring in more conservative amino acid residues thus results in more deleterious damage to the T-protein, and gives the severe clinical phenotype, viz., typical NKH.

Atypical nonketotic hyperglycinemia confirmed by assay of the glycine cleavage system in lymphoblasts

A 13-year-old girl with early-onset, mild, slowly progressive mental retardation caused by nonketotic hyperglycinemia is described. The plasma and cerebrospinal fluid glycine concentrations were elevated, but the cerebrospinal fluid/plasma glycine ratio was only mildly elevated. The diagnosis was confirmed by demonstration of a defect in the activity of the glycine cleavage system in cultured lymphoblasts.

Nonketotic hyperglycinemia: analyses of glycine cleavage system in typical and atypical cases

The molecular nature of the glycine cleavage system was investigated in eight patients with typical (neonatal) and two patients with atypical (late onset) nonketotic hyperglycinemia (NKH). The overall activity of the glycine cleavage system was found to be decreased in all of the liver and brain tissue studied, but it was undetectable or extremely low in typical NKH, whereas there was some residual activity in atypical NKH. Six patients with typical NKH had a specific defect in the P protein, and one a defect in the T protein; the activity of the T protein was defective in one patient with atypical NKH.