Evidence for the presence of a benzodiazepine receptor binding substance in cerebrospinal fluid of a rabbit model of hepatic encephalopathy

Improvement of chronic hepatic encephalopathy in dogs by the benzodiazepine-receptor partial inverse agonist sarmazenil, but not by the antagonist flumazenil

Therapeutic modulation of the increased GABAergic tone in chronic hepatic encephalopathy (HE) by the benzodiazepine receptor (BR) antagonist flumazenil (F) has led to conflicting results in humans and animal models for HE. The BR inverse agonist sarmazenil (S) has only been used in animal models of acute HE. Therefore we investigated the effects of intravenous injection of F and S in dogs with chronic HE 8 to 12 weeks after placement of a portocaval shunt and 40% hepatectomy (n=7), compared to sham-operated pair-fed controls (n=7). The HE dogs had hyperammonemia (298 +/- 48 microM v 33 +/- 3 before surgery (mean +/- SEM)) and signs of HE at the start of the experiments (0.9 +/- 0.1 (scale 0-4)). Three (S3) and 8 (S8) mg/kg of S resulted in a significant improvement of encephalopathy (grade 0.9 +/- 0.2 immediately before v 0.5 +/- 0.1 after injection (S3) and 0.7 +/- 0.1 v 0.3 +/- 0.1 (S8)) and increase in mean dominant frequency of the EEG (MDF; 9.1 +/- 0.7 Hz v 11.1 +/- 0.3 (S3) and 8.9 +/- 0.5 v 11.0 +/- 0.3 (S8)) in HE dogs, whereas 15 mg/kg of S, 3 and 8 mg/kg of F, and the vehicle had no significant effects. The efficacy of S in these dogs is consistent with an increased GABAergic tone in the pathogenesis of chronic HE. The lack of effects of F makes a role for endogenous benzodiazepines herein unlikely.

New aspects on etiology, biochemistry, and therapy of portal systemic encephalopathy: a critical survey

There is scientific agreement that portal systemic encephalopathy (PSE) is caused morphologically by portal systemic shunts and biochemically by constituents of the portal venous blood. Ammonium has a key role in the pathogenesis of PSE. Direct correlations with the degree of PSE have been established exclusively with glutamine, i.e. the terminal product of the peripheral detoxification of ammonium. In PSE, ammonium is probably responsible for damage to astrocytic and neuronal cells. Ammonium's toxic effect is due to the intracerebral glutamine synthesis. After several metabolic steps, which will be discussed in detail, brain cell damage is caused directly or indirectly (exitotoxically) by energy deficiency. Hyperammonemia and PSE are each well defined though different forms of disturbance. Therefore, ammonium is not the sole decisive factor in the pathogenesis of PSE. We performed a detailed and critical analysis of all studies on amino acid therapy of PSE, especially those that were randomized and controlled. This analysis revealed a close and direct correlation between qualitative and quantitative dosages of amino acids on one hand, and parallel improvements of amino acid imbalance (essentially associated with PSE) and degree of PSE on the other. A close and direct dose/efficacy correlation must be assumed. Disturbed plasmatic amino acid homeostasis and cerebral monoaminergic neurotransmission are probably important pathogenic factors of PSE. A fundamental cofactor in the efficacy of each adequate amino acid therapy might be a substantial decrease of endogenous ammonium production. Physiologic benzodiazepines may also have an important function in the pathogenesis of PSE: not so, however, the glutamate-ergic and GABA-ergic neurotransmission, which are disturbed principally in PSE. In close correlation to pathogenesis, established and proposed therapies of PSE are critically discussed.

Endogenous benzodiazepine activity in the peripheral and portal blood of dogs with congenital portosystemic shunts

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to determine whether an endogenous benzodiazepine receptor ligand (EBZ) was present in the arterial and portal blood of dogs with congenital portosystemic shunts (CPSS).

STUDY DESIGN

The presence or absence of an EBZ was determined by the collection of systemic and portal blood from dogs with CPSS.

ANIMALS

Fifteen client-owned dogs with a confirmed CPSS. All dogs had historical signs compatible with hepatic encephalopathy. Eight healthy dogs were used as controls.

METHODS

In all dogs, systemic blood samples were collected after they were anesthetized. Portal blood samples were collected intraoperatively. EBZ was measured by radioreceptor assay.

RESULTS

In 10 of 15 dogs, the portal blood concentration of EBZ was significantly elevated compared with normal dogs (mean, 13.2 +/- 18.55 ng/mL). Five dogs had elevated systemic blood EBZ levels (mean, 8.2 +/- 16.08 ng/mL). Eleven of 15 dogs had a higher portal than systemic blood concentration of EBZ. In contrast, control dogs had extremely low EBZ concentrations detected in their portal blood (mean, 0.16 +/- 0.3 ng/mL) and systemic blood (0 ng/mL). The mean portal and systemic blood concentrations in dogs with CPSS were significantly greater than in control dogs (P < .05).

CONCLUSIONS

Elevated blood levels of EBZ were found in dogs with CPSS. The portosystemic gradient noted in 11 dogs suggests the gastrointestinal tract as a possible source for the endogenous ligand.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE

Generalized motor seizures have been reported in dogs after surgical correction of CPSS. If the presence of a CPSS results in stimulation of brain receptors for benzodiazepines, post-CPSS ligation seizures may result from a withdrawal of EBZ after ligation of the portosystemic shunt.

Gut bacteria provide precursors of benzodiazepine receptor ligands in a rat model of hepatic encephalopathy

Benzodiazepine receptor (BZR) ligands are elevated in animals and humans with fulminant hepatic failure (FHF) and contribute to the pathogenesis of the associated hepatic encephalopathy (HE). As gut factors are proposed to play a role in the pathogenesis of HE, we investigated gut flora as a source of BZR ligands. Rats received daily oral neomycin, vancomycin and metronidazole (AB +) or saline (AB -) before and concurrent with the induction of FHF with thioacetamide. BZR ligands were extracted from brain and plasma and quantified using radiometric techniques. Plasma BZR ligand concentrations in AB(+) and AB(-) rats with HE were higher than AB(+) and AB(-) control rats. Brain BZR ligand concentrations increased in AB(+) and AB(-) rats with HE. Stool cultures from antibiotic treated rats with HE indicated the presence of multidrug resistant Acinetobacter lwoffii. Although no significant concentrations of BZR ligands were detected in culture media inoculated with A. lwoffii, administering A. lwoffii to normal rats significantly elevated BZR ligand levels in brain, but not plasma. Thus, antibiotic treatment of rats is associated with the growth of a resistant strain of bacterium which produces an inactive BZR ligand precursor. BZR ligands may be synthesized from these precursors in the brain and efficiently cleared by a normal liver following brain-to-plasma transfer. Impairment of this clearance process in FHF facilitates their accumulation, enabling agonist BZR ligands to contribute to the pathogenesis of HE by further enhancing GABAergic neurotransmission.

Do benzodiazepine ligands contribute to hepatic encephalopathy?

1. Levels of BZ receptor ligands are elevated in the brain of animal models of FHF and humans with FHF. Some of these ligands have agonist properties and some are known 1, 4-BZs which bind to the DS receptor. Much of the BZ receptor ligand activity in HE is unidentified and it is possible that some may bind to receptor subtypes other than the DS receptor. 2. Average levels of BZ receptor ligands in the brain in HE do not appear to be sufficient to augment GABAergic tone to a degree that would result in severe encephalopathy (i.e. coma). However, these ligands have a heterogeneous distribution in the brain and their neuroinhibitory effects may be potentiated by increased availability of GABA at GABAA receptors. Furthermore, that these ligands may contribute to HE is suggested by anecdotal reports of ameliorations of HE being induced in a majority of patients by the BZ receptor antagonist flumazenil. 3. The response of HE to flumazenil in humans is usually incomplete and in animal models may be modest. Potential explanations for these findings include pharmacokinetics, BZ receptor subtype specificity and higher levels of BZ receptor ligands in the brain in humans with HE than in animal models. 4. Certain BZ receptor ligands e.g. Ro 15-3505 and Ro 15-4513, that are structurally related to flumazenil, are more efficacious at ameliorating HE than flumazenil in animal models. These findings may be more dependent on differences in BZ receptor subtype specificity than differences in intrinsic activity. The properties of an ideal BZ receptor ligand for administration to a patient with HE would appear to be: (i) antagonist action at BZ receptors, (ii) no intrinsic activity apparent after a conventional pharmacologic dose, (iii) high specificity and affinity for BZ receptors, (iv) slow metabolism, and (v) absence of toxic effects. Promising ligands, such as Ro 15-3505, with weak partial inverse agonist actions and hence analeptic potential, require careful evaluation of their therapeutic index before clinical application. 5. BZ receptor ligands may be useful in the management of HE. Specifically, they may be given IV: (i) to reverse effects of exogenous BZs; (ii) to aid in the differential diagnosis of encephalopathy; (iii) to provide prognostic information; and (iv) to optimize brain function. They may also be given orally with the objective of reducing dietary protein intolerance in patients with chronic liver disease.

Regional distribution and kinetics of three sites on the GABAA receptor: lack of effect of portacaval shunting

The regional distribution of binding sites on the GABAA receptor and their kinetic parameters were measured by quantitative autoradiography in brains from normal rats and rats with a portacaval shunt, a model of portal systemic encephalopathy in which GABA neurotransmission may be altered. The ligands used were [3H]flunitrazepam (a benzodiazepine-site agonist), [3H]-Ro15-1788 (a benzodiazepine-site antagonist), [3H]muscimol (a GABA-site agonist), and [35S]t-butylbicyclophosphorothionate (35S-TBPS, a convulsant that binds to a site near the chloride channel). Some brains were analyzed by computerized image analysis and three-dimensional reconstruction. The regional distribution of binding of the benzodiazepines was very similar, but the patterns obtained with [3H]muscimol and [35S]TBPS were different in many areas, suggesting a heterogeneous distribution of several subtypes of the GABAA receptor. The kinetic parameters were determined in brain regions for [3H]flunitrazepam, [3H]Ro15-1788, and [3H]muscimol. For each ligand, the Kd showed a significant heterogeneity among brain regions (at least threefold), contrary to conclusions drawn from earlier studies. In portacaval shunted rats, binding of all four ligands was essentially unchanged from that in control rats, indicating that, if there was an abnormality in GABA neurotransmission during portal systemic shunting, it was not reflected by altered binding to the main sites on the GABAA receptor.

Neurochemical studies of hepatic encephalopathy

Despite intensive research, the neurochemical basis of hepatic encephalopathy (HE) has not been defined. Theories that are currently favoured to explain the cerebral dysfunction that accompanies acute or chronic hepatic failure include: (1) ammonia acting as the putative neurotoxin; (2) perturbed monoamine neutrotransmission as a result of altered plasmo amino acid metabolism; (3) an imbalance between excitatory amino acid neurotransmission, mediated by glutamate, and inhibitory amino acid neurotransmission, mediated by gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA); and (4) increased cerebral concentrations of an endogenous benzodiazepine-like substance. Studies of amino acid neurotransmitter receptors in HE have yielded conflicting results. The majority of studies in different animal models of acute and chronic HE and in patients have reported that brain GABA receptor density and affinity are unchanged. There have been fewer studies of excitatory amino acid receptors and these have also yielded conflicting results. However, the majority suggest that components of the glutamate receptor system are perturbed in HE. Further investigation is required to determine the significance of these findings to the pathogenesis of HE.

Elevated brain concentrations of 1,4-benzodiazepines in fulminant hepatic failure

BACKGROUND

Increased gamma-aminobutyric acid (GABA) neurotransmission has been implicated in the pathogenesis of hepatic encephalopathy. The mechanism by which GABA-ergic activity is increased in hepatic failure is unclear, but recent studies in animals with encephalopathy due to fulminant hepatic failure suggest that GABA-ergic neurotransmission may be increased by the presence of elevated concentrations of benzodiazepine agonists such as diazepam and N-desmethyldiazepam.

METHODS AND RESULTS

Samples of frontal cortex were obtained at autopsy from 11 patients with hepatic encephalopathy who died of acetaminophen-induced fulminant hepatic failure and 8 patients who died of cardiovascular disease or trauma. None of the 19 patients had received benzodiazepines while hospitalized. Chromatographic analyses of extracts of these samples revealed 4 to 19 peaks representing substances that inhibited the binding of a radiolabeled imidazobenzodiazepine ([3H]flumazenil) to its receptors. Several of these peaks had retention times corresponding to those of known 1,4-benzodiazepines. Ultraviolet- and mass-spectroscopic analysis confirmed that two of these peaks represented diazepam and N-desmethyldiazepam. The patients who died of fulminant hepatic failure could be divided into two groups: six who had had significantly elevated brain concentrations (2-fold to 10-fold higher than normal) of substances inhibiting the binding of [3H]flumazenil and five who had normal concentrations.

CONCLUSIONS

Brain concentrations of substances inhibiting the binding of [3H]flumazenil to its receptors are increased in some patients with hepatic encephalopathy due to fulminant hepatic failure. The origin of these substances is unknown, but these findings provide a rational basis for trials of benzodiazepine-receptor antagonists in the management of this disorder.

"Endogenous" benzodiazepine activity in body fluids of patients with hepatic encephalopathy

Body fluids from patients with hepatic encephalopathy and from controls with no renal or hepatic disease were assayed for benzodiazepine immunoreactivity and benzodiazepine-receptor-binding activity. The subjects had taken no synthetic benzodiazepines for at least 3 months. Benzodiazepine receptor binding in cerebrospinal fluid was significantly higher in hepatic encephalopathy patients than in controls (210 [SE 50.2] vs 40.7 [7.3] oxazepam equivalents [ng/ml]). The severity of hepatic encephalopathy was directly and significantly correlated with the level of benzodiazepine activity by radioreceptor assay or radioimmunoassay in urine and in plasma. Benzodiazepine activity equivalent to levels of more than 900 ng/ml was found in patients with advanced encephalopathy. Although the chemical identity and source of this substance (or substances) are still unknown, its properties and the estimated levels of activity suggest it may have a role in the pathogenesis of the neural inhibition seen in hepatic encephalopathy.

Hepatic encephalopathy, GABA-ergic neurotransmission and benzodiazepine receptor ligands

Evidence compatible with increased GABAergic tone contributing to the manifestations of hepatic encephalopathy (HE) in animal models of fulminant hepatic failure (FHF) includes: (i) increased resistance to drugs which induce seizures by reducing GABAergic tone; (ii) abnormalities of visual evoked responses (VERs) which resemble those induced by drugs which augment GABAergic tone; (iii) increased sensitivity of CNS neurons to a GABA agonist; and (iv) ameliorations of the encephalopathy induced by a GABA receptor antagonist. Evidence compatible with a benzodiazepine (BZ) receptor ligand with agonist properties contributing to increased GABAergic tone in animal models of FHF includes: (i) abnormalities of VERs which resemble those in BZ agonist-induced coma; (ii) increased sensitivity of CNS neurons to a BZ receptor agonist; (iii) excitation of CNS neurons induced by BZ receptor antagonists; (iv) reversal of the increased sensitivity of CNS neurons to a GABA agonist by a BZ receptor antagonist; (v) presence of a ligand(s) in brain which displaces a radiolabeled ligand from BZ receptors; and (vi) increased affinity of this ligand(s) for BZ receptors in the presence of GABA ("positive GABA shift").