Foramen magnum decompression versus terminal ventriculostomy for the treatment of syringomyelia

Chiari Type 1 Malformation and Syringomyelia in Children: Classification and Treatment Options

Chiari type 1 malformation (CIM) is defined as tonsillar ectopia of >5 mm, while syringomyelia (SM) is defined as a cerebrospinal fluid (CSF)-filled cavity larger than 3 mm dissecting the spinal cord. Over the last decades, our understanding of these pathologies has grown; however, many controversies still exist almost in every aspect of CIM and SM, including etiology, indication for treatment, timing of treatment, surgical technique, follow-up regime, and outcome. This chapter provides a comprehensive overview on different aspects of CIM and SM and on the still existing controversies, based on the evidence presently available. Future directions for clinical research concerning CIM and SM treatment and outcome are elaborated and discussed as well.

The surgical treatment of Chiari I malformation

A retrospective study was undertaken on 133 patients with a Chiari I malformation treated within the last 16 years at the Departments of Neurosurgery at the Nordstadt Hospital Hannover, Germany, and the University of California, Los Angeles, U.S.A. Ninety-seven patients presented with symptoms related to accompanying syringomyelia and 4 with associated syringobulbia. They underwent 149 surgical procedures and were followed for a mean of 39 +/- 52 months. A decompression at the foramen magnum was performed in 124 patients, while 22 of those with syringomyelia were treated by shunting (7 syringosubarachnoid shunts, 15 syringoperitoneal or -pleural shunts), and 3 by ventriculoperitoneal shunts for hydrocephalus. Except for ventriculoperitoneal shunting, at least a short-term decrease in size of an associated syrinx was observed for all procedures in the majority of cases. However, no long-term benefit was observed for syrinx shunting operations. The best clinical long-term results were obtained with decompression of the foramen magnum in patients with (86% free of a clinical recurrence) and without syringomyelia (77% free of a clinical recurrence). We advise against syrinx shunting, a large craniectomy, and obex plugging which are associated with higher recurrence rates. Instead, surgery should consist of a small craniectomy, opening of the dura, archnoid dissection to establish normal cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) outflow from the 4th ventricle, and a fascia lata dural graft.

Posterior fossa reconstruction: a surgical technique for the treatment of Chiari I malformation and Chiari I/syringomyelia complex--preliminary results and magnetic resonance imaging quantitative assessment of hindbrain migration

Experimental models have shown that Chiari I malformation is a primary paraaxial mesodermal insufficiency occurring after the closure of the neural folds takes place. According to these hypotheses, a small posterior fossa caused by an underdeveloped occipital bone would be the primary factor in the formation of the hindbrain hernia. The main objective in the surgical treatment of Chiari I malformation and related syringomyelia is directed to restore normal cerebrospinal fluid dynamics at the craniovertebral junction. The most widely accepted surgical approach is to perform a craniovertebral decompression of the posterior fossa contents with or without a dural graft. It has been emphasized that suboccipital craniectomy should be small enough to avoid downward migration of the hindbrain into the craniectomy. This slump of the hindbrain has been verified by studies using postoperative assessment by magnetic resonance imaging. Our aim in this study is to present a modification of the conventional surgical technique, which we have called posterior fossa reconstruction (PFR). Ten patients were operated on using this technique and compared with a historical control group operated on with the classic approach of making a small suboccipital craniectomy, opening the arachnoid, and closing the dura with a graft. To evaluate the morphological results in both groups objectively, preoperative and postoperative measurements of the relative positions of the fastigium and upper pons above a basal line in the midsagittal T1-weighted magnetic resonance images were obtained. In those cases with syringomyelia, syringo-to-cord ratios were calculated. The mean age of the PFR group was 35 +/- 16 years (mean +/- SD); in the control group it was 35.2 +/- 12 years. In the PFR group, the formation of an artificial cisterna magna was observed in every case; it was observed in only one case in the control group. An upward migration of the cerebellum was seen in all cases in the PFR group, with a mean ascent of the fastigium of 6.2 mm. A significant downward migration of the cerebellum was observed in seven cases in the control group. No significant differences were found in both groups when comparing syringo-to-cord ratios. This leads us to conclude that PFR is more effective than conventional surgical approaches in restoring the normal morphology of the craniovertebral junction. This allows cranial ascent of the hindbrain verified by magnetic resonance imaging and good short-term clinical results. Because PFR is mainly an extraarachnoidal approach, complications related to surgery using this technique can be kept to a minimum.

Cranio-cervical decompression for Chiari I malformation. A retrospective evaluation of functional outcome with particular attention to the motor deficits

We report a series of 26 patients affected by a Chiari I malformation treated at our department between 1987 and 1993. All patients underwent pre- and postoperative evaluation by magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Sequential perioperative motor evoked potential (MEP) recordings were performed in 8 patients. The preoperative symptoms can be divided into four subgroups: cephalgias (84.6%), cranial nerve deficits (69.2%), motor deficits (76.9%), sensory deficits (73%). Twenty-five out of 26 patients underwent craniovertebral decompression, 1 a transoral anterior decompression. One patient died 2 months after surgery because of progressive pulmonary failure. We registered following postoperative complications transient hypoglossal palsy (1 case), vertigo (2 cases), meningitis (1 case), minor CSF leaks (3 cases). Cephalgias subsided in 17 and improved in 4 out of 22 patients. Cranial nerve deficits improved in 8 and were stabilized in 7 out of 18 patients. A limited recovery of trigeminal function was possibly due to nuclear lesions. Five patients whose vestibular disturbances were not relieved by surgery were put on a course of carbazepine. Vertigo resolved in one case and in two others improved. While hypesthesia improved after decompression, the other sensory deficits were stabilized in 5% of the patients. Spasticity improved in 12 out of 18 patients, but weakness only in 7 out of 17 patients. Motor disturbances were always detected by MEP-recording. MEP-characteristics were not specific, resembling those of patients with other intra-, extramedullary myelopathies. Functional recovery was not matched by an improvement of the MEP parameters. MEP may be used as tool for surveillance of patients whose clinical findings are not progressive and are not at first surgical candidates.

Foraminal syringomyelia: suggestion for a grading system

The standard treatment of foraminal syringomyelia includes foramen magnum decompression and duraplasty. Improvement or stabilization of the disease are achieved in most of cases. However, at least one third of patients are reported to receive little or no benefit. In this paper we retrospectively reviewed a series of 40 consecutive foramen magnum decompressions in order to identify the possible pre-operative outcome predictors. Based on clinical evolution, neurological impairment and radiological features, a scale of severity was fixed and retrospectively tested. A pre-operative score was obtained for each patient and was correlated with the surgical results. Then a four level grading system was derived. All grade I and grade II patients achieved good results (improvement or stabilization), whereas grade III patients showed intermediate behaviour and grade IV invariably worsened. On this basis, surgical results of foramen magnum decompression might be further improved provided that a careful pre-operative selection is made.

The natural history and results of surgery in 50 cases of syringomyelia

In recent years, new neuroimaging techniques have revived interest in syringomyelia with respect to indications and results of surgery. Fifty patients, 36 of whom underwent surgery, have been reviewed. All patients but 3 underwent a new clinical assessment and 33 of them were also neurophysiologically investigated. In approximately one-third of the non-surgically treated patients the clinical course was benign. In 26 of the surgically treated patients an improvement was noted at the short-term assessment both for spasticity and pain, but in most of them it was not maintained in the medium term. Therefore, an accurate selection of the patients to be treated surgically is strongly recommended, particularly when the natural history of the disease is considered. Decompression of the posterior fossa seems to give the best results, yet no curative surgical treatment has been devised to date.

Hindbrain migration after decompression for hindbrain hernia: a quantitative assessment using MRI

Pre- and post-operative assessments are presented in 17 adult patients who have been treated with craniovertebral decompression for hindbrain herniation, 11 of whom had syringomyelia. Objective improvement in the size of the syrinx was seen in all 11 cases; contrary to expectation the hindbrain more frequently moved downwards than upwards after decompression of the tonsils and creation of an artificial cisterna magna. A method is reported for the quantitative assessment of hindbrain migration using magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The degree of 'slump', further downward displacement of the hindbrain, was compared with the clinical outcome and the MRI appearances. Slump was more common than expected, although the severity was not usually great enough to produce symptoms. Slump was less marked where the artificial cisterna magna was generous (p less than 0.02). This quantitative method may be useful in assessing patients with unexplained post-operative symptoms and in comparing different surgical techniques.

Syringo-subarachnoid shunt for syringomyelia associated with Chiari malformation (type 1)

The authors report the surgical results of 28 patients with syringomyelia associated with Chiari malformation (type 1). 28 patients underwent 34 operative procedures. Syringo-subarachnoid shunt was performed in 28 patients, foramen magnum decompression with syringo-subarachnoid shunt in three, ventriculo-peritoneal shunt in one, terminal syringostomy in one, and foramen magnum decompression with terminal syringostomy in one. In an average postoperative follow-up period of 3 years and 9 months ranging from one year to 7 years and one month, neurological symptoms and signs improved in 24 out of 28 patients (82%). Some improvement was noted in sensory deficit and motor weakness. In 3 patients, the symptoms did not change. In 3 patients whose symptoms were unchanged, preoperative studies demonstrated atrophy of the spinal cord, in which irreversible changes were shown. The symptoms deteriorated in one patient. In one patient whose symptoms increased 3 months after syringo-subarachnoid shunt, shunt insufficiency due to postoperative adhesive arachnoiditis was responsible for neurological deterioration. The authors propose that syringo-subarachnoid shunt is effective as a surgical procedure for syringomyelia associated with Chiari malformation (type 1) if the patient does not have symptoms due to Chiari malformation or has only mild signs and symptoms which do not require foramen magnum decompression, such as nystagmus or atrophy of sternocleidomastoid muscle.

Surgical treatment of syringomyelia: favorable results with syringosubarachnoid shunting

The authors review the clinical course of 29 patients who underwent syringosubarachnoid shunting for syringomyelia. Twenty-two patients presented hindbrain-related syringomyelia; seven patients had non-hindbrain-related syringomyelia secondary to trauma (four cases) and to spinal arachnoiditis (three cases). The surgical technique is described in detail. All patients showed postoperative deflation or collapse of the syrinx at follow-up magnetic resonance imaging evaluation. Symptoms stabilized in 17 cases (59%); 9 cases (31%) showed improvement in the neurological function; 3 cases (10%) presented delayed neurological deterioration, probably owing to spinal cord ischemia.