Craniofacial osteotomies for skull base access

Surgical Strategies for Recurrent Craniofacial Meningiomas

OBJECTIVE:

Recurrent cranial base meningiomas are among the most difficult tumors to treat surgically. Although they are histologically benign, these tumors often invade through the cranial base into the infratemporal and pterygopalatine fossae. We reviewed our experience with these tumors to describe the natural history of these lesions as well as provide a possible treatment paradigm.

METHODS:

Between 2000 and 2004, seven patients with meningiomas recurring through the cranial base into facial structures were treated at the University of Utah. Five patients were treated with transcranial approaches only, and two were treated with a combination of transcranial and transfacial approaches.

RESULTS:

The average age of our patients (6 women, 1 man) was 55 years. The original site of tumor was the sphenoid wing in four patients, the middle fossa in two patients, and the left frontal region in one patient. The average interval between the most recent tumor resection and recurrence into the face was 9.9 years. The mean number of resections a patient underwent before invasion into the face was two. All but one patient had adjunctive therapy (including either radiation or chemotherapy) before recurrence into the face.

CONCLUSION:

Meningiomas that recur into facial structures present a unique treatment challenge. These lesions have a high rate of recurrence once they have invaded through the cranial base. Although combined approaches may be necessary to achieve a gross total resection, these lesions can often be reached using standard transcranial techniques.

Spheno-orbital meningiomas: interdisciplinary surgical approach, resectability and long-term results

OBJECTIVE

To describe the interdisciplinary surgical approach in spheno-orbital meningiomas and to evaluate the operative results regarding resectability and functional outcome.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

A series of 16 patients underwent surgical resection of spheno-orbital meningiomas followed by bony reconstruction. Four patients presented with a recurrent meningioma and had undergone surgical resection previously. Radical tumour removal was attempted in all cases, although no aggressive effort was made to remove tumour tissue infiltrating the cavernous sinus or soft tissues deep in the orbit to avoid severe functional disturbances. All patients but one were female (mean age 53 years). Mean follow-up period was 68 months (range 4-155 months).

RESULTS

The leading symptom was proptosis in 14 patients, accompanied in 7 cases by progressive visual impairment. Surgical resection was thought to have been complete in 11 patients (69%) and incomplete in 5 (31%). Residual tumour was deliberately left when there was infiltration of the cavernous sinus (n = 4), the pterygopalatine fossa (n = 2) and/or the deep intraorbital soft tissues (n = 1). Tumour recurrence was observed in 9 patients, among whom were 6 patients with an initially "completely" resected meningioma. Eight patients underwent re-operation. Complete resection was achieved in 3 of these latter patients with an isolated exclusively intraorbital tumour manifestation.

CONCLUSION

By means of combined skull base approaches, spheno-orbital meningiomas are grossly resected totally with a long-term survival free of recurrence and an acceptable quality of life. In some cases, deliberate subtotal tumour resection is useful to avoid severe neurological damage with sufficient tumour control and a valuable progression-free survival.

Dumbbell tumor of the anterior skull base. Meningioma? No, adenoid cystic carcinoma!

BACKGROUND

Adenoid cystic carcinoma (ACC) is a rare neoplasm of the exocrine glands. Because of its tendency for skull base involvement and intracranial spread, ACC should be diagnosed promptly by the neurosurgeon, although discrimination from meningioma is often difficult. Radical resection of such tumors requires familiarity with complex craniofacial approaches.

CASE DESCRIPTION

An unusual case of dumbbell-shaped ACC centered over the planum sphenoidale is presented. Regular margins and neuroimaging features suggested a preoperative diagnosis of meningioma. The lesion was gross, totally resected in a two-staged procedure through frontobasal and transfacial approaches, with good functional and aesthetic result.

CONCLUSION

The epidemiologic, histologic, and clinical features of ACC are reviewed. ACC is rarely encountered by the neurosurgeon; however it should always be considered in the differential diagnosis of skull base tumors. Interdisciplinary surgical approaches represent the major advance in the treatment of these complex neoplasms.

Petroclival meningiomas: is radical resection always the best option?

BACKGROUND

The surgical management of petroclival meningiomas is, despite the invaluable technical achievements in the past decade, still burdened by a high operative morbidity. It seems doubtful whether radical surgical removal should always be the primary goal in those lesions as advocated until very recently.

METHODS

A series was critically analysed and the literature discussed to elucidate criteria for a different attitude. Between 1990 and 1995 a total of 19 patients harbouring petroclival meningiomas were operated on. The following approaches were used: petrosal (n = 13), retrosigmoidal (n = 5), and subtemporal (n = 1). Thirteen lesions were removed completely and six incompletely as assessed by postoperative MRI.

RESULTS

No recurrence or regrowth could be detected on MRI after a mean follow up of 18 months. Surgical mortality occurred in one patient (5%) and there was early postoperative dysfunction in 56%. At the time of follow up major permanent operative morbidity was present in two patients (11%).

CONCLUSIONS

In accord with recent literature subtotal resection of petroclival meningiomas should be contemplated in a subset of patients (with invasion of brain stem or cavernous sinus) to reduce the incidence of disabling deficits. Surgery should not be delayed in younger patients because surgical morbidity relates positively with tumour size.