Intracerebral temperature monitoring in severely head injured patients

Difference between brain temperature and core temperature in severe traumatic brain injury: a systematic review

INTRODUCTION

Intensive care management for traumatic brain injury (TBI) patients aims to prevent secondary cerebral damage. Targeted temperature management is one option to prevent cerebral damage, as hypothermia may have protective effects. By conducting a systematic literature review we evaluated: 1) the presence of a temperature difference (gradient) between brain temperature (Tb) and core temperature (Tc) in TBI patients; and 2) clinical factors associated with reported differences.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

The PubMed database was systematically searched using Mesh terms and key words, and Web of Sciences was assessed for additional article citations. We included studies that continuously and simultaneously measured Tb and Tc in severe TBI patients. The National Institutes of Health (NIH) quality assessment tool for observational cohort and cross-sectional studies was modified to fit the purpose of our study. Statistical data were extracted for further meta-analyses.

EVIDENCE SYNTHESIS

We included 16 studies, with a total of 480 patients. Clinical heterogeneity consisted of Tb/Tc measurement site, measurement device, physiological changes, local protocols, and medical or surgical interventions. The studies have a high statistical heterogeneity (I2). The pooled mean temperature gradient between Tb and Tc was +0.14 °C (95% confidence interval: 0.03 to 0.24) and ranged from -1.29 to +1.1 °C. Patients who underwent a decompressive (hemi)craniectomy showed lower Tb values compared to Tc found in three studies.

CONCLUSIONS

Studies on Tb and Tc are heterogeneous and show that, on average, Tb and Tc are not clinically significant different in TBI patients (<0.2 °C). Interpretations and interventions of the brain and central temperatures will benefit from standardization of temperature measurements.

Brain Temperature Influences Intracranial Pressure and Cerebral Perfusion Pressure After Traumatic Brain Injury: A CENTER-TBI Study

Background

After traumatic brain injury (TBI), fever is frequent. Brain temperature (BT), which is directly linked to body temperature, may influence brain physiology. Increased body and/or BT may cause secondary brain damage, with deleterious effects on intracranial pressure (ICP), cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP), and outcome.

Methods

Collaborative European NeuroTrauma Effectiveness Research in Traumatic Brain Injury (CENTER-TBI), a prospective multicenter longitudinal study on TBI in Europe and Israel, includes a high resolution cohort of patients with data sampled at a high frequency (from 100 to 500 Hz). In this study, simultaneous BT, ICP, and CPP recordings were investigated. A mixed-effects linear model was used to examine the association between different BT levels and ICP. We additionally focused on changes in ICP and CPP during the episodes of BT changes (Δ BT ≥ 0.5 °C lasting from 15 min to 3 h) up or downward. The significance of ICP and CPP variations was estimated with the paired samples Wilcoxon test (also known as Wilcoxon signed-rank test).

Results

Twenty-one patients with 2,435 h of simultaneous BT and ICP monitoring were studied. All patients reached a BT of 38 °C and experienced at least one episode of ICP above 20 mm Hg. The linear mixed-effects model revealed an association between BT above 37.5 °C and higher ICP levels that was not confirmed for lower BT. We identified 149 episodes of BT changes. During BT elevations (n = 79) ICP increased, whereas CPP was reduced; opposite ICP and CPP variations occurred during episodes of BT reduction (n = 70). All these changes were of moderate clinical relevance (increase of ICP of 4.5 and CPP decrease of 7.5 mm Hg for BT rise, and ICP reduction of 1.7 and CPP elevation of 3.7 mm Hg during BT defervescence), even if statistically significant (p < 0.0001). It has to be noted, however, that a number of therapeutic interventions against intracranial hypertension was documented during those episodes.

Conclusions

Patients after TBI usually develop BT > 38 °C soon after the injury. BT may influence brain physiology, as reflected by ICP and CPP. An association between BT exceeding 37.5 °C and a higher ICP was identified but not confirmed for lower BT ranges. The relationship between BT, ICP, and CPP become clearer during rapid temperature changes. During episodes of temperature elevation, BT seems to have a significant impact on ICP and CPP.

Brain temperature regulation in poor-grade subarachnoid hemorrhage patients - A multimodal neuromonitoring study

Elevated body temperature (T_core) is associated with poor outcome after subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH). Brain temperature (T_brain) is usually higher than T_core. However, the implication of this difference (T_delta) remains unclear. We aimed to study factors associated with higher T_delta and its association with outcome. We included 46 SAH patients undergoing multimodal neuromonitoring, for a total of 7879 h of averaged data of T_core, T_brain, cerebral blood flow, cerebral perfusion pressure, intracranial pressure and cerebral metabolism (CMD). Three-months good functional outcome was defined as modified Rankin Scale ≤2. T_brain was tightly correlated with T_core (r = 0.948, p < 0.01), and was higher in 73.7% of neuromonitoring time (T_delta +0.18°C, IQR -0.01 - 0.37°C). A higher T_delta was associated with better metabolic state, indicated by lower CMD-glutamate (p = 0.003) and CMD-lactate (p < 0.001), and lower risk of mitochondrial dysfunction (MD) (OR = 0.2, p < 0.001). During MD, T_delta was significantly lower (0°C, IQR -0.2 - 0.1; p < 0.001). A higher T_delta was associated with improved outcome (OR = 7.7, p = 0.002). Our study suggests that T_brain is associated with brain metabolic activity and exceeds T_core when mitochondrial function is preserved. Further studies are needed to understand how T_delta may serve as a surrogate marker for brain function and predict clinical course and outcome after SAH.

MR Thermometry in Cerebrovascular Disease: Physiologic Basis, Hemodynamic Dependence, and a New Frontier in Stroke Imaging

The remarkable temperature sensitivity of the brain is widely recognized and has been studied for its role in the potentiation of ischemic and other neurologic injuries. Pyrexia frequently complicates large-vessel acute ischemic stroke and develops commonly in critically ill neurologic patients; the profound sensitivity of the brain even to minor intraischemic temperature changes, together with the discovery of brain-to-systemic as well as intracerebral temperature gradients, has thus compelled the exploration of cerebral thermoregulation and uncovered its immutable dependence on cerebral blood flow. A lack of pragmatic and noninvasive tools for spatially and temporally resolved brain thermometry has historically restricted empiric study of cerebral temperature homeostasis; however, MR thermometry (MRT) leveraging temperature-sensitive nuclear magnetic resonance phenomena is well-suited to bridging this long-standing gap. This review aims to introduce the reader to the following: 1) fundamental aspects of cerebral thermoregulation, 2) the physical basis of noninvasive MRT, and 3) the physiologic interdependence of cerebral temperature, perfusion, metabolism, and viability.

Cerebral Temperature Dysregulation: MR Thermographic Monitoring in a Nonhuman Primate Study of Acute Ischemic Stroke

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Cerebral thermoregulation remains poorly understood. Temperature dysregulation is deeply implicated in the potentiation of cerebrovascular ischemia. We present a multiphasic, MR thermographic study in a nonhuman primate model of MCA infarction, hypothesizing detectable brain temperature disturbances and brain-systemic temperature decoupling.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Three Rhesus Macaque nonhuman primates were sourced for 3-phase MR imaging: 1) baseline MR imaging, 2) 7-hour continuous MR imaging following minimally invasive, endovascular MCA stroke induction, and 3) poststroke day 1 MR imaging follow-up. MR thermometry was achieved by multivoxel spectroscopy (semi-localization by adiabatic selective refocusing) by using the proton resonance frequency chemical shift. The relationship of brain and systemic temperatures with time and infarction volumes was characterized by using a mixed-effects model.

RESULTS

Following MCA infarction, progressive cerebral hyperthermia was observed in all 3 subjects, significantly outpacing systemic temperature fluctuations. Highly significant associations were observed for systemic, hemispheric, and global brain temperatures (F-statistic, P = .0005 for all regressions) relative to the time from stroke induction. Significant differences in the relationship between temperature and time following stroke onset were detected when comparing systemic temperatures with ipsilateral (P = .007), contralateral (P = .004), and infarction core (P = .003) temperatures following multiple-comparisons correction. Significant associations were observed between infarction volumes and both systemic (P ≤ .01) and ipsilateral (P = .04) brain temperatures, but not contralateral brain temperature (P = .08).

CONCLUSIONS

Successful physiologic and continuous postischemic cerebral MR thermography was conducted and prescribed in a nonhuman primate infarction model to facilitate translatability. The results confirm hypothesized temperature disturbance and decoupling of physiologic brain-systemic temperature gradients. These findings inform a developing paradigm of brain thermoregulation and the applicability of brain temperature as a neuroimaging biomarker in CNS injury.

Therapeutic hypothermia for acute brain injuries

Therapeutic hypothermia, recently termed target temperature management (TTM), is the cornerstone of neuroprotective strategy. Dating to the pioneer works of Fay, nearly 75 years of basic and clinical evidence support its therapeutic value. Although hypothermia decreases the metabolic rate to restore the supply and demand of O₂, it has other tissue-specific effects, such as decreasing excitotoxicity, limiting inflammation, preventing ATP depletion, reducing free radical production and also intracellular calcium overload to avoid apoptosis. Currently, mild hypothermia (33°C) has become a standard in post-resuscitative care and perinatal asphyxia. However, evidence indicates that hypothermia could be useful in neurologic injuries, such as stroke, subarachnoid hemorrhage and traumatic brain injury. In this review, we discuss the basic and clinical evidence supporting the use of TTM in critical care for acute brain injury that extends beyond care after cardiac arrest, such as for ischemic and hemorrhagic strokes, subarachnoid hemorrhage, and traumatic brain injury. We review the historical perspectives of TTM, provide an overview of the techniques and protocols and the pathophysiologic consequences of hypothermia. In addition, we include our experience of managing patients with acute brain injuries treated using endovascular hypothermia.

Proton resonance frequency chemical shift thermometry: experimental design and validation toward high-resolution noninvasive temperature monitoring and in vivo experience in a nonhuman primate model of acute ischemic stroke

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Applications for noninvasive biologic temperature monitoring are widespread in biomedicine and of particular interest in the context of brain temperature regulation, where traditionally costly and invasive monitoring schemes limit their applicability in many settings. Brain thermal regulation, therefore, remains controversial, motivating the development of noninvasive approaches such as temperature-sensitive nuclear MR phenomena. The purpose of this work was to compare the utility of competing approaches to MR thermometry by using proton resonance frequency chemical shift. We tested 3 methodologies, hypothesizing the feasibility of a fast and accurate approach to chemical shift thermometry, in a phantom study at 3T.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A conventional, paired approach (difference [DIFF]-1), an accelerated single-scan approach (DIFF-2), and a new, further accelerated strategy (DIFF-3) were tested. Phantom temperatures were modulated during real-time fiber optic temperature monitoring, with MR thermometry derived simultaneously from temperature-sensitive changes in the water proton chemical shift (∼0.01 ppm/°C). MR thermometry was subsequently performed in a series of in vivo nonhuman primate experiments under physiologic and ischemic conditions, testing its reproducibility and overall performance.

RESULTS

Chemical shift thermometry demonstrated excellent agreement with phantom temperatures for all 3 approaches (DIFF-1: linear regression R(2) = 0.994; P < .001; acquisition time = 4 minutes 40 seconds; DIFF-2: R(2) = 0.996; P < .001; acquisition time = 4 minutes; DIFF-3: R(2) = 0.998; P < .001; acquisition time = 40 seconds).

CONCLUSIONS

These findings confirm the comparability in performance of 3 competing approaches to MR thermometry and present in vivo applications under physiologic and ischemic conditions in a primate stroke model.

Do acute phase markers explain body temperature and brain temperature after ischemic stroke?

OBJECTIVE

Both brain and body temperature rise after stroke but the cause of each is uncertain. We investigated the relationship between circulating markers of inflammation with brain and body temperature after stroke.

METHODS

We recruited patients with acute ischemic stroke and measured brain temperature at hospital admission and 5 days after stroke with multivoxel magnetic resonance spectroscopic imaging in normal brain and the acute ischemic lesion (defined by diffusion-weighted imaging [DWI]). We measured body temperature with digital aural thermometers 4-hourly and drew blood daily to measure interleukin-6, C-reactive protein, and fibrinogen, for 5 days after stroke.

RESULTS

In 44 stroke patients, the mean temperature in DWI-ischemic brain soon after admission was 38.4° C (95% confidence interval [CI] 38.2-38.6), in DWI-normal brain was 37.7° C (95% CI 37.6-37.7), and mean body temperature was 36.6° C (95% CI 36.3-37.0). Higher mean levels of interleukin-6, C-reactive protein, and fibrinogen were associated with higher temperature in DWI-normal brain at admission and 5 days, and higher overall mean body temperature, but only with higher temperature in DWI-ischemic brain on admission.

CONCLUSIONS

Systemic inflammation after stroke is associated with elevated temperature in normal brain and the body but not with later ischemic brain temperature. Elevated brain temperature is a potential mechanism for the poorer outcome observed in stroke patients with higher levels of circulating inflammatory markers.

Therapeutic hypothermia for acute neurological injuries

Therapeutic hypothermia (TH) is the intentional reduction of core body temperature to 32°C to 35°C, and is increasingly applied by intensivists for a variety of acute neurological injuries to achieve neuroprotection and reduction of elevated intracranial pressure. TH improves outcomes in comatose patients after a cardiac arrest with a shockable rhythm, but other off-label applications exist and are likely to increase in the future. This comprehensive review summarizes the physiology and cellular mechanism of action of TH, as well as different means of TH induction and maintenance with potential side effects. Indications of TH are critically reviewed by disease entity, as reported in the most recent literature, and evidence-based recommendations are provided.

Therapeutic hypothermia: benefits, mechanisms and potential clinical applications in neurological, cardiac and kidney injury

Therapeutic hypothermia involves the controlled reduction of core temperature to attenuate the secondary organ damage which occurs following a primary injury. Clinicians have been increasingly using therapeutic hypothermia to prevent or ameliorate various types of neurological injury and more recently for some forms of cardiac injury. In addition, some recent evidence suggests that therapeutic hypothermia may also provide benefit following acute kidney injury. In this review we will examine the potential mechanisms of action and current clinical evidence surrounding the use of therapeutic hypothermia. We will discuss the ideal methodological attributes of future studies using hypothermia to optimise outcomes following organ injury, in particular neurological injury. We will assess the importance of target hypothermic temperature, time to achieve target temperature, duration of cooling, and re-warming rate on outcomes following neurological injury to gain insights into important factors which may also influence the success of hypothermia in other organ injuries, such as the heart and the kidney. Finally, we will examine the potential of therapeutic hypothermia as a future kidney protective therapy.

Induced hypothermia for trauma: current research and practice

Induction of hypothermia with the goal of providing therapeutic benefit has been accepted for use in the clinical setting of adult cardiac arrest and neonatal hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy (HIE). However, its potential as a treatment in trauma is not as well defined. This review discusses potential benefits and complications of induced hypothermia (IH) with emphasis on the current state of knowledge and practice in various types of trauma. There is excellent preclinical research showing that in cases of penetrating trauma with cardiac arrest, inducing hypothermia to 10 degrees C using cardiopulmonary bypass (CPB) could possibly save those otherwise likely to die without causing neurologic sequelae. A human trial of this intervention is about to get underway. Preclinical studies suggest that inducing hypothermia may be useful to delay cardiac arrest in penetrating trauma victims who are hypotensive. There is potential for IH to be used in cases of blunt trauma, but it has not been well studied. In the case of traumatic brain injury (TBI), clinical trials have shown conflicting results, despite almost uniform efficacy seen in preclinical experiments. Major studies are analyzed and ways to standardize its use and optimize future clinical trials are discussed. More preclinical and clinical research is needed to better define whether there could be a role for IH in the case of spinal cord injuries.

The evidence for hypothermia as a neuroprotectant in traumatic brain injury

This article reviews published experimental and clinical evidence for the benefits of modest hypothermia in the treatment of traumatic brain injury (TBI). Therapeutic hypothermia has been reported to improve outcome in several animal models of CNS injury and has been successfully translated to specific patient populations. A PubMed search for hypothermia and TBI was conducted, and important papers were selected for review. The research summarized was conducted at major academic institutions throughout the world. Experimental studies have emphasized that hypothermia can affect multiple pathophysiological mechanisms thought to participate in the detrimental consequences of TBI. Published data from several relevant clinical trials on the use of hypothermia in severely injured TBI patients are also reviewed. The consequences of mild to moderate levels of hypothermia introduced by different strategies to the head-injured patient for variable periods of time are discussed. Both experimental and clinical data support the beneficial effects of modest hypothermia following TBI in specific patient populations. Following on such single-institution studies, positive findings from multicenter TBI trials will be required before this experimental treatment can be considered standard of care.

Mechanisms of action, physiological effects, and complications of hypothermia

BACKGROUND

Mild to moderate hypothermia (32-35 degrees C) is the first treatment with proven efficacy for postischemic neurological injury. In recent years important insights have been gained into the mechanisms underlying hypothermia's protective effects; in addition, physiological and pathophysiological changes associated with cooling have become better understood.

OBJECTIVE

To discuss hypothermia's mechanisms of action, to review (patho)physiological changes associated with cooling, and to discuss potential side effects.

DESIGN

Review article.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MAIN RESULTS

A myriad of destructive processes unfold in injured tissue following ischemia-reperfusion. These include excitotoxicty, neuroinflammation, apoptosis, free radical production, seizure activity, blood-brain barrier disruption, blood vessel leakage, cerebral thermopooling, and numerous others. The severity of this destructive cascade determines whether injured cells will survive or die. Hypothermia can inhibit or mitigate all of these mechanisms, while stimulating protective systems such as early gene activation. Hypothermia is also effective in mitigating intracranial hypertension and reducing brain edema. Side effects include immunosuppression with increased infection risk, cold diuresis and hypovolemia, electrolyte disorders, insulin resistance, impaired drug clearance, and mild coagulopathy. Targeted interventions are required to effectively manage these side effects. Hypothermia does not decrease myocardial contractility or induce hypotension if hypovolemia is corrected, and preliminary evidence suggests that it can be safely used in patients with cardiac shock. Cardiac output will decrease due to hypothermia-induced bradycardia, but given that metabolic rate also decreases the balance between supply and demand, is usually maintained or improved. In contrast to deep hypothermia (<or=30 degrees C), moderate hypothermia does not induce arrhythmias; indeed, the evidence suggests that arrhythmias can be prevented and/or more easily treated under hypothermic conditions.

CONCLUSIONS

Therapeutic hypothermia is a highly promising treatment, but the potential side effects need to be properly managed particularly if prolonged treatment periods are required. Understanding the underlying mechanisms, awareness of physiological changes associated with cooling, and prevention of potential side effects are all key factors for its effective clinical usage.

Induced hypothermia and fever control for prevention and treatment of neurological injuries

Increasing evidence suggests that induction of mild hypothermia (32-35 degrees C) in the first hours after an ischaemic event can prevent or mitigate permanent injuries. This effect has been shown most clearly for postanoxic brain injury, but could also apply to other organs such as the heart and kidneys. Hypothermia has also been used as a treatment for traumatic brain injury, stroke, hepatic encephalopathy, myocardial infarction, and other indications. Hypothermia is a highly promising treatment in neurocritical care; thus, physicians caring for patients with neurological injuries, both in and outside the intensive care unit, are likely to be confronted with questions about temperature management more frequently. This Review discusses the available evidence for use of controlled hypothermia, and also deals with fever control. Besides discussing the evidence, the aim is to provide information to help guide treatments more effectively with regard to timing, depth, duration, and effective management of side-effects. In particular, the rate of rewarming seems to be an important factor in establishing successful use of hypothermia in the treatment of neurological injuries.

Use of induced hypothermia for neuroprotection: indications and application

Therapeutic temperature regulation has become an exciting field of interest. Mild-to-moderate hypothermia is a safe and feasible management strategy for neuroprotection and control of intracranial pressure in neurological catastrophies such as traumatic brain injury, subarachnoid and intracerebral hemorrhage, and large hemispheric stroke. Fever is associated with worse neurological outcome in patients with brain injury, normothermia may be of benefit in this patient population. The efficacy of mild-to-moderate hypothermia has been proven for neuroprotection after cardiac arrest with ventricular fibrillation as initial rhythm, and after neonatal asphyxia. Application of hypothermia and fever control in neurocritical care, available cooling technologies and systemic effects and complications of hypothermia will be discussed.

Rapid non-invasive external cooling to induce mild therapeutic hypothermia in adult human-sized swine

AIM OF THE STUDY

Mild therapeutic hypothermia is a promising new therapy for patients resuscitated from cardiac arrest. Early and fast induction of hypothermia seems to be crucial for best results. The aim of the study was to investigate the feasibility and safety of a new surface cooling method using cold metal plates.

SUBJECTS AND METHODS

Twelve adult human-sized swine (79+/-9 kg) were cooled from 38 to 33 degrees C brain temperature. The skin surface was covered with -20 degrees C metal plates (M), as compared to ice packs, alcohol rubs, and fans used in a control group (C). Each method was tested during spontaneous circulation and, after re-warming, during cardiac arrest. Temperatures were recorded continuously. Data are given as mean+/-standard deviation or as median (interquartile range), if not normally distributed. Comparisons between the treatment groups were performed with the independent samples t-test, or the Mann-Whitney rank-sum test.

RESULTS

During spontaneous circulation, cooling rates were 9.3+/-1.4 degrees C/h (M), and 6.1+/-1.4 degrees C/h (C) (p=0.003); no skin lesions were observed. During cardiac arrest, cooling rates were 4.1 degrees C/h (1.8-4.8) (M), and 3.7 degrees C/h (3.1-5.3) (C) (p=0.9); no skin lesions were observed.

CONCLUSION

Cooling with cold metal plates was an effective method for rapid induction of mild therapeutic hypothermia in adult human-sized swine during spontaneous circulation, without any signs of skin damage. This new surface-cooling device, independent of energy supply during use, should be further investigated.

Unexpected fatal neurological deterioration after successful cardio-pulmonary resuscitation and therapeutic hypothermia

A 77-year-old woman was admitted to the intensive care unit after successful cardiopulmonary resuscitation for out-of-hospital cardiac arrest due to pulseless electrical activity. She was treated with mild therapeutic hypothermia to minimise secondary anoxic brain damage. After a 24 h period of therapeutic hypothermia with a temperature of 32.5 degrees C, the patient was rewarmed and sedation discontinued. Neurological evaluation after 24 h revealed a maximum Glasgow Coma Score of E4M4Vt with spontaneous breathing. However the patient developed a fever reaching 39 degrees C for several hours that was unresponsive to conventional cooling methods. In the subsequent 24 h patient developed apnoea, hypotension and bradycardia with deterioration of the coma score. Diabetes insipidus was confirmed. Cerebral CT was performed which showed diffuse brain oedema with herniation and brainstem compression. The patient died within hours. Autopsy showed massive brain swelling and tentorial herniation. Hyperthermia possibly played a pivotal role in the development of this fatal insult to this vulnerable brain after cardiac arrest and therapeutic hypothermia treatment. The acute histopathological alterations in the brain, possibly caused by the deleterious effects of fever after cardiac arrest in human brain, may be considered a new observation.

Neuroprotection (including hypothermia)

There have been over 2000 publications in the last year addressing the topic of neuroprotection. Novel and emerging therapeutic targets that have been explored include cerebral inflammation, hypothermia, neural transplantation and repair and gene therapy. Unfortunately, with few exceptions, the successes of experimental neuroprotection have not been translated into clinical practice. The possible reasons for the discrepancy between experimental success and clinical benefit are explored.

Comparing no-touch and tympanic thermometer temperature recordings

Temperature is a vital sign which can be measured using various types of clinical thermometers. Pulmonary artery temperature is considered the 'gold standard', but this measurement is not usually clinically practical. There is currently no consensus for optimal alternative site or equipment. This research compares 178 simultaneous measurements from 5 clinical areas, using two types of thermometers: tympanic and no-touch temporal. No-touch thermometers were all set to oral equivalent. Tympanic thermometers were adjusted to either oral (n=105) or core (n=73) equivalent. Maximum acceptable difference was identified as 1oC. Two data sets (oral/core; oral/oral) were analysed using Bland-Altman method on Excel programmes, comparing all thermometers and separating oral and core-equivalent tympanics. The two thermometers were found not to be equivalent. As a simple comparison between two thermometers, this research cannot identify which thermometer is more accurate.

Brain oxygen metabolism may relate to the temperature gradient between the jugular vein and pulmonary artery after cardiopulmonary resuscitation

OBJECTIVE

A gradient between the jugular vein temperature and core body temperature has been reported in animal and clinical studies; however, the pathophysiological meaning of this phenomenon remains unclear. This study was conducted to identify the temperature gradient between the jugular vein and pulmonary artery in comatose patients after cardiopulmonary resuscitation.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The temperatures of the jugular vein and pulmonary artery were measured in 19 patients at 6 and 24 hours after cardiopulmonary resuscitation. Jugular venous blood saturation (SjO2; %) was also measured concomitantly. The patients were divided into 2 groups: high SjO2 (SjO2 > 75%: H-group; n = 10) and normal SjO2 (SjO2 < or = 75%: N-group; n = 9). The temperature gradient was calculated by subtracting the temperature of the pulmonary artery from that of the jugular vein (jugular - pulmonary = dT degrees C). Statistical significance was defined as p < 0.05.

RESULTS

dT was significantly lower in the H-group than in the N-group at 6 hours (0.120 +/- 0.011: mean +/- SD vs. 0.389 +/- 0.036: p = 0.0012) and 24 hours (0.090 +/- 0.005 vs. 0.256 +/- 0.030: p = 0.0136) after cardiopulmonary resuscitation.

CONCLUSION

The temperature gradient between the jugular vein and pulmonary artery was significantly lower in patients with high SjO2 after cardiopulmonary resuscitation. This temperature gradient may be reflected in brain oxygen metabolism.

[Controlled mild-to-moderate hypothermia in the intensive care unit]

Controlled hypothermia is used as a therapeutic intervention to provide neuroprotection and (more recently) cardioprotection. The growing insight into the underlying pathophysiology of apoptosis and destructive processes at the cellular level, and the mechanisms underlying the protective effects of hypothermia, have led to improved application and to a widening of the range of potential indications. In many centres hypothermia has now become part of the standard therapy for post-anoxic coma in certain patients, but for other indications its use still remains controversial. The negative findings of some studies may be partly explained by inadequate protocols for the application of hypothermia and insufficient attention to the prevention of potential side effects. This review deals with some of the concepts underlying hypothermia-associated neuroprotection and cardioprotection, and discusses some potential clinical indications as well as reasons why some clinical trials may have produced conflicting results. Practical aspects such as methods to induce hypothermia, as well as the side effects of cooling are also discussed.

Resuscitative mild hypothermia as a protective tool in brain damage: is there evidence?

Resuscitative mild hypothermia is and will increasingly be used in the emergency department as protection for the brain after an ischaemic insult. The clinical application of resuscitative mild hypothermia and its limitations will be summarized in this paper. The evidence for each application and its underlying mechanism will also be reviewed.

Application of therapeutic hypothermia in the ICU: opportunities and pitfalls of a promising treatment modality. Part 1: Indications and evidence

OBJECTIVE

Hypothermia has been used for medicinal purposes since ancient times. This paper reviews the current potential clinical applications for mild hypothermia (32-35 degrees C).

DESIGN AND SETTING

Induced hypothermia is used mostly to prevent or attenuate neurological injury, and has been used to provide neuroprotection in traumatic brain injury, cardiopulmonary resuscitation, stroke, and various other disorders. The evidence for each of these applications is discussed, and the mechanisms underlying potential neuroprotective effects are reviewed. Some of this evidence comes from animal models, and a brief overview of these models and their limitations is included in this review.

RESULTS

The duration of cooling and speed of re-warming appear to be key factors in determining whether hypothermia will be effective in preventing or mitigating neurological injury. Some other potential usages of hypothermia, such as its use in the peri-operative setting and its application to mitigate cardiac injury following ischemia and reperfusion, are also discussed.

CONCLUSIONS

Although induced hypothermia appears to be a highly promising treatment, it should be emphasized that it is associated with a number of potentially serious side effects, which may negate some or all of its potential benefits. Prevention and/or early treatment of these complications are the key to successful use of hypothermia in clinical practice. These side effects, as well as various physiological changes induced by cooling, are discussed in a separate review.

Brain temperature and cerebral blood flow imaging in patients with severe subarachnoid hemorrhage: report of two cases

BACKGROUND

Temperature reversal, which is defined as observation of higher brain temperature than systemic temperature followed by lower brain temperature than systemic temperature, implies a poor prognosis in patients with severe subarachnoid hemorrhage (SAH). Serial regional cerebral blood flow (CBF) imaging using single-photon emission tomography (SPECT) was performed in 2 patients with severe SAH who showed temperature reversal.

CASE DESCRIPTION

54-year-old woman and a 55-year-old man with severe SAH underwent ventricular drainage using a catheter that allowed monitoring of the brain temperature. SPECT imaging in these two patients showed that CBF was preserved before the occurrence of the temperature reversal and was exhausted afterwards. These patients died within 2 to 3 days.

CONCLUSIONS

Temperature reversal may indicate the exact time when absence of brain perfusion occurs, causing irreversible brain damage.

Brain and systemic temperature in patients with severe subarachnoid hemorrhage

BACKGROUND

The significance of brain temperature (BT) in patients with severe brain damage remains unclear. This study investigated the relationships between BT, systemic temperature (ST), and clinical outcome in patients with severe subarachnoid hemorrhage.

METHODS

Thirty-one comatose patients with severe subarachnoid hemorrhage underwent ventricular drainage immediately after admission. The ventricular catheter also allowed monitoring of BT. ST was continuously measured using a bladder catheter with thermistor probe.

RESULTS

BT at the start of the monitoring was lower than ST in four patients, and all died of brain swelling. BT was higher than ST at first but later fell below ST ("temperature reversal") in 12 patients, who all died of acute brain swelling. BT was higher than ST throughout the monitoring in 15 patients. Five of these patients died of causes other than brain swelling such as rerupture of the cerebral aneurysm, multiple organ failure, or respiratory failure. The other 10 patients survived with various degrees of disability.

CONCLUSIONS

Observation of BT and ST can predict the outcome of severe subarachnoid hemorrhage.

Induced hypothermia in critical care medicine: a review

BACKGROUND

Clinical trials of induced hypothermia have suggested that this treatment may be beneficial in selected patients with neurologic injury.

OBJECTIVES

To review the topic of induced hypothermia as a treatment of patients with neurologic and other disorders.

DESIGN

Review article.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MAIN RESULTS

Improved outcome was demonstrated in two prospective, randomized, controlled trials in which induced hypothermia (33 degrees C for 12-24 hrs) was used in patients with anoxic brain injury following resuscitation from prehospital cardiac arrest. In addition, prospective, randomized, controlled trials have been conducted in patients with severe head injury, with variable results. There also have been preliminary clinical studies of induced hypothermia in patients with severe stroke, newborn hypoxic-ischemic encephalopathy, neurologic infection, and hepatic encephalopathy, with promising results. Finally, animal models have suggested that hypothermia that is induced rapidly following traumatic cardiac arrest provides significant neurologic protection and improved survival.

CONCLUSIONS

Induced hypothermia has a role in selected patients in the intensive care unit. Critical care physicians should be familiar with the physiologic effects, current indications, techniques, and complications of induced hyperthermia.

Disassociation between intracranial and systemic temperatures as an early sign of brain death

Intracranial temperature and its normal variation, as well as its response to various pathologic conditions, has become a critical component of monitoring in neurosurgical intensive care. In a prospective clinical study of 54 neurosurgical patients, intracranial pressure, cerebral perfusion pressure, and intraventricular and systemic temperatures were monitored in a neurosurgical intensive care unit. All of our patients' intraventricular temperatures were initially higher than their systemic temperatures. In 11 patients, the intraventricular temperature became lower than the systemic temperature, in a median time of 4.43 hours (range, 4.21-5.18 hours), prior to any changes in intracranial and cerebral perfusion pressures. Reversal of the disassociation between intraventricular and systemic temperatures may be an early marker of patients with a poor prognosis.

Safety and efficacy of a novel intravascular cooling device to control body temperature in neurologic intensive care patients: a prospective pilot study

OBJECTIVE

To determine the safety and efficacy of a novel intravascular cooling device (Cool Line catheter with Cool Gard system) to control body temperature (temperature goal <37 degrees C) in neurologic intensive care patients.

DESIGN

A prospective, uncontrolled pilot study in 51 consecutive neurologic intensive care patients.

SETTING

A neurologic intensive care unit at a tertiary care university hospital.

PARTICIPANTS

Patients were 51 neurologic intensive care patients with an intracranial disease requiring a central venous catheter due to the primary (intracranial) disease. We excluded patients under the age of 19 yrs and those with active cardiac arrhythmia, full sepsis syndrome, bleeding diathesis and infection, or bleeding at the site of the intended catheter insertion. Male to female ratio was 31:20, and the median age was 55 yrs (range, 24-85 yrs). Forty-four of 51 patients (86.3%) had an initial Glasgow Coma Scale score of 3, three patients had a Glasgow Coma Scale score of 9, one patient presented with an initial Glasgow Coma Scale score of 11, two patients had an initial Glasgow Coma Scale score of 13, and one patient had an initial Glasgow Coma Scale score of 15. The mean initial tissue injury severity score was 45.1 and the median initial tissue injury severity score 45.0 (range, 19-70).

INTERVENTIONS

Patients were enrolled prospectively in a consecutive way. Within 12 hrs after admission, the intravascular cooling device (Cool Line catheter) was placed, the temperature probe was located within the bladder (by Foley catheter), and the Cool Gard cooling device was initiated. This Cool Gard system circulates temperature-controlled sterile saline through two small balloons mounted on the distal end of the Cool Line catheter. The patient's blood is gently cooled as it is passed over the balloons. The Cool Gard system has been set with a target temperature of 36.5 degrees C. The primary purpose and end point of this study was to evaluate the cooling capacity of this intravascular cooling device. Efficacy is expressed by the calculation formula of fever burden, which is defined as the fever time product ( degrees C hours) under the fever curve.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

The cooling device was in operation for a mean of 152.4 hrs. The ease of insertion was judged as easy in 42 of 51 patients; in a single patient, the catheter was malpositioned within the jugular vein, requiring early removal. The rate of infectious and noninfectious complications (nosocomial pneumonia, bacteremia, catheter-related ventriculitis, pulmonary embolism, etc.) was comparable to the rate usually observed in our neurologic intensive care patients with such severe intracranial diseases. The total fever burden within the entire study period of (on average) 152.4 hrs was 4.0 degrees C hrs/patient, being equivalent to 0.6 degrees C hrs/patient and day. Thirty of 51 patients showed an elevation of the body temperature (>37.9 degrees C) within 24 hrs after termination of the cooling study. One awake patient (subarachnoid hemorrhage, Glasgow Coma Scale score 15) experienced mild to moderate shivering throughout the entire period of 7 days. The mortality rate was 23.5%.

CONCLUSION

This novel intravascular cooling device (Cool Line catheter and Cool Gard cooling device) was highly efficacious in prophylactically controlling the body temperature of neurologic intensive care patients with very severe intracranial disease (median Glasgow Coma Scale score, 3-15). Morbidity and mortality rates were consistent with the ranges reported in the literature for such neurologic intensive patients.

The importance of brain temperature in patients after severe head injury: relationship to intracranial pressure, cerebral perfusion pressure, cerebral blood flow, and outcome

Brain temperature was continuously measured in 58 patients after severe head injury and compared to rectal temperature, intracranial pressure, cerebral blood flow, and outcome after 3 months. The temperature difference between brain and rectal temperature was also calculated. Mild hypothermia (34-36 degrees C) was also used to treat uncontrollable intracranial pressure (ICP) above 20 mm Hg when other methods failed. Brain and rectal temperature were strongly correlated (r = 0.866; p < 0.001). Four groups were identified. The mean brain temperature ranged from 36.9 +/- 0.4 degrees C in the normothermic group to 38.2 +/- 0.5 degrees C in the hyperthermic group, 35.3 +/- 0.5 degrees C in the mild therapeutic hypothermia group, and 34.3 +/- 1.5 degrees C in the hypothermia group without active cooling. The mean DeltaT(br-rect) was positive for patients with a T(br) above 36.0 degrees C (0.0 +/- 0.5 degrees C) and negative for patients during mild therapeutic hypothermia (-0.2 +/- 0.6 degrees C) and also in those with a brain temperature below 36 degrees C without active cooling (0.8 +/- -1.4 degrees C) - the spontaneous hypothermic group. The cerebral perfusion pressure (CPP) was increased significantly by active cooling compared to the normothermic and hyperthermic groups. The mean cerebral blood flow (CBF) in patients with a brain temperature between 36.0 degrees C and 37.5 degrees C was 37.8 +/- 14.0 mL/100 g/min. The lowest CBF was measured in patients with a brain temperature <36.0 degrees C and a negative brain-rectal temperature difference (17.1 +/- 14.0 mL/100 g/min). A positive trend for improved outcome was seen in patients with mild hypothermia. Simultaneous monitoring of brain and rectal temperature provides important diagnostic and prognostic information to guide the treatment of patients after severe head injury (SHI) and the wide differentials that can develop between the brain and core temperature, especially during rapid cooling, strongly supports the use of brain temperature measurement if therapeutic hypothermia is considered for head injury care.

Theoretical simulation of temperature distribution in the brain during mild hypothermia treatment for brain injury

Mild or moderate hypothermia (>30 degrees C) has been proposed for clinical use as a therapeutic option for achieving protection from cerebral ischaemia in brain injury patients. In this research, a theoretical model was developed to examine the brain temperature gradients during selective cooling of the brain surface after head injury. The head was modelled as a hemisphere consisting of several layers, representing the scalp, skull and brain tissue, respectively. The dimensions, physical properties and physiological characteristics for each layer, as well as the arterial blood temperature, were used as the input to the Pennes bioheat transfer equation to simulate the steady-state temperature distribution within the brain. Depending on the head surface temperature, a temperature gradient of up to 13 degrees C exists in the brain tissue. The results have shown that the volumetric-averaged brain tissue temperature Tbt,avg for adults and infants can be 1.7 and 4.3 degrees C, respectively, lower than the temperature of the arterial blood supplied to the brain tissue. The location where the probe should be placed to measure Tbt,avg was also determined by the simulation. The calculation suggests that the temperature sensor should be placed 7.5mm and 5.9 mm beneath the brain tissue surface for adults and infants, respectively, to monitor Tbt,avg continuously.

Monitoring neurologic patients in intensive care

The brain is sensitive to changes in substrate delivery. In neurologically critically ill patients (e.g., those with head injury, subarachnoid hemorrhage, or stroke), interruption of this supply causes ischemic brain damage and thus impairs the outcome. To prevent, detect, and treat these ischemic events as soon as possible, the cerebral blood flow is continuously monitored, its coupling or not with the consumption of oxygen and so forth, and the detected derangements of normal physiology. Intracranial pressure and cerebral perfusion pressure are two parameters that often reflect ischemic events, and thus it is mandatory to continuously measure them. To better assess cerebral hemodynamics, jugular bulb oxymetry and brain pressure tissue oxygen monitoring are two neuromonitoring techniques that allow for a better understanding of the balance between oxygen supply and consumption, and therefore are useful in directing therapy. Transcranial Doppler ultrasonography is a noninvasive technique with the same purpose but with less clinical relevance. The new neuromonitoring technique, microdialysis, is useful for understanding the mechanisms involved in brain ischemia. However, it is clear that the physician who interprets the measurements given by devices and the clinical data (e.g., temperature, glycemia) is still the cornerstone in the management of neurologically critically ill patients.

Cerebrovenous blood temperature-influence of cerebral perfusion pressure changes and hyperventilation: evaluation in a porcine study and in man

The objective of the first part of this study was to use an animal model to investigate the relationship between temperature in the cerebrovenous compartment and cerebral perfusion pressure. In the second part of the study, the objective was to examine the influence of hyperventilation and hypothermia on jugular bulb temperature and body temperature in patients undergoing elective neurosurgery. Intracranial pressure was increased artificially by inflating an infratentorial supracerebellar placed balloon catheter in nine pigs under general anesthesia. Temperature was monitored by thermocouples inserted in the sagittal sinus, white matter of the left lobe and abdominal aorta during the ensuing decrease in cerebral profusion pressure (CPP). Cerebrovenous blood temperature (jugular bulb) and body temperature (urinary bladder) were simultaneously monitored in 24 patients undergoing craniotomy. Moderate hyperventilation was performed in all patients. Cerebrovenous blood and core body temperature were recorded and differences between these two temperatures calculated at the beginning and the end of hyperventilation. At the beginning of the intracranial pressure (ICP), increase mean temperatures of cerebrovenous blood and cerebral tissue (left lobe) were lower than core body temperature. During CPP reduction the difference between core body temperature and cerebrovenous blood temperature increased significantly from 0.86+/-0.44 degrees C prior to ICP rise to 1.19+/-0.58 degrees C at maximum ICP. Before hyperventilation, cerebrovenous blood temperature was higher in 19 patients (+/- difference: 0.34 degrees C +/- 0.27) and equal or lower in five patients (difference: -0.08 degrees C +/- 0.11), than core body temperature. At the end of hyperventilation, the difference between cerebrovenous blood temperature and core body temperature increased (+0.42 degrees C +/- 0.24) in those 19 patients who had started with a higher cerebrovenous blood temperature and decreased (-0.10 degrees C +/- 0. 18) in the other five patients. Both studies demonstrated that the temperature of cerebrovenous blood is influenced by maneuvers which are supposed to decrease cerebral blood flow.

Brain temperature exceeds systemic temperature in head-injured patients

OBJECTIVE

To identify the temperature differences in readings taken from the brain, jugular bulb, and core body in head-injured patients.

DESIGN

Prospective, observational study.

SETTING

Neurosurgical intensive care unit of a university-affiliated county hospital.

PATIENTS

Thirty patients with severe head injuries had measurements of brain and core body temperatures. Fourteen patients also had measurements of jugular venous blood at the level of the jugular bulb.

INTERVENTIONS

None.

MEASUREMENTS AND MAIN RESULTS

Brain temperature was increased an average of 2.0 degrees F (1.1 degrees C) over the core body temperature. In individual patients, the average brain temperature increase over the core body temperature ranged from -0.5 degrees to 3.8 degrees F (-0.30 degrees to 2.1 degrees C). Jugular vein and core body temperatures were similar. The difference in the brain and body temperatures increased when cerebral perfusion pressure decreased to between 20 and 50 mm Hg. The difference in the brain and body temperatures decreased in those patients treated with barbiturate coma.

CONCLUSIONS

Direct measurement of temperature in head-injured patients is a safe procedure. Temperatures in the brain are typically increased over the core body temperature and the jugular bulb temperatures. Jugular vein temperature measurement is not a good measurement of brain temperature since it reflects body, not brain temperature. These findings support the potential importance of monitoring brain temperature and the importance of controlling fever in severely head-injured patients since brain temperature may be higher than expected.

Combating hyperthermia in acute stroke: a significant clinical concern

BACKGROUND

Moderate elevations of brain temperature, when present during or after ischemia or trauma, may markedly worsen the resulting injury. We review these provocative findings, which form the rationale for our recommendation that physicians treating acute cerebral ischemia or traumatic brain injury diligently monitor their patients for incipient fever and take prompt measures to maintain core-body temperature at normothermic levels.

SUMMARY OF REVIEW

In standardized models of transient forebrain ischemia, intraischemic brain temperature elevations to 39 degrees C enhance and accelerate severe neuropathological alterations in vulnerable brain regions and induce damage to structures not ordinarily affected. Conversely, the blunting of even mild spontaneous postischemic hyperthermia confers neuroprotection. Mild hyperthermia is also deleterious in focal ischemia, particularly in reversible vascular occlusion. The action of otherwise neuroprotective drugs in ischemia may be nullified by mild hyperthermia. Even when delayed by 24 hours after an acute insult, moderate hyperthermia can still worsen the pathological and neurobehavioral outcome. Hyperthermia acts through several mechanisms to worsen cerebral ischemia. These include (1) enhanced release of neurotransmitters; (2) exaggerated oxygen radical production; (3) more extensive blood-brain barrier breakdown; (4) increased numbers of potentially damaging ischemic depolarizations in the focal ischemic penumbra; (5) impaired recovery of energy metabolism and enhanced inhibition of protein kinases; and (6) worsening of cytoskeletal proteolysis. Recent studies demonstrate the feasibility of direct brain temperature monitoring in patients with traumatic and ischemic injury. Moderate to severe brain temperature elevations, exceeding core-body temperature, may occur in the injured brain. Cerebral hyperthermia also occurs during rewarming after hypothermic cardiopulmonary bypass procedures. Several studies have now shown that elevated temperature is associated with poor outcome in patients with acute stroke. Finally, recent clinical trials in severe closed head injury have shown a beneficial effect of moderate therapeutic hypothermia.

CONCLUSIONS

The acutely ischemic or traumatized brain is inordinately susceptible to the damaging influence of even modest brain temperature elevations. While controlled clinical investigations will be required to establish the therapeutic efficacy and safety of frank hypothermia in patients with acute stroke, the available evidence is sufficiently compelling to justify the recommendation, at this time, that fever be combatted assiduously in acute stroke and trauma patients, even if "minor" in degree and even when delayed in onset. We suggest that body temperature be maintained in a safe normothermic range (eg, 36.7 degrees C to 37.0 degrees C [98.0 degrees F to 98.6 degrees F]) for at least the first several days after acute stroke or head injury.