The intraorbital arrangement of the anterior and posterior ethmoidal foramina

A Systematic and Critical Review on the Anatomy of the Ethmoidal Foramina

PURPOSE

The osteologic anatomy of the orbit is still a field of intense research, particularly as far as vascular channels are concerned. Among them, ethmoidal foraminas (EFs) are certainly those that have more clinical importance and indeed have been deeply investigated. Unfortunately, the vast production of articles, far from clarifying their anatomy, generated a certain degree of confusion.

METHODS

A search on Pubmed and Scopus databases updated up to December 31, 2023, has been carried out with the keyword "ethmoidal foramen" yielding a list of 357 items. With a careful screening process, 31 articles were enlisted to be included in the present review.

RESULTS

A critical review process confirmed that many results published over the years appear inconsistent, particularly as far as EFs topography is concerned. The possible reasons for this lack of consistency can be traced back to inter-ethnical differences, uncertainty on the anterior bony landmarks employed in the investigations, and lack of a general consensus over EFs classification. A novel approach, based on the normalization of the distance of the anterior landmarks relative to the length of the orbit (relative depth index), should overcome some of the major problems encountered so far.

CONCLUSIONS

Novel and clear guidelines to classify EFs and to locate them on the medial wall are required. Determining the relative depth index of EFs may be an interesting approach to solve the matter. Other methods can be also devised. However, direct measurements from bony landmarks, without any further analysis seem inadequate and possibly misleading.

Position of the anterior ethmoidal foramen and trauma to the cranial base during transconjunctival medial orbital decompression: a systematic literature review

PURPOSE

To review the literature on the location of the anterior ethmoidal foramen (AEF) and trauma during transconjunctival medial wall decompression.

METHODS

A comprehensive literature search was conducted using the PubMed, Embase, and Scopus databases, combining the terms "olfactory fossa" and "fovea ethmoidalis" with "trauma," "cerebrospinal fluid leak," "pneumocephalus," "orbital decompression," and "anterior ethmoidal artery" (AEA). All cases of cranial base trauma during medial orbital decompression and the anatomical studies on the location of the AEF and the course of the AEA were reviewed.

RESULTS

Ninety-four articles were identified, of which 37 were related to the AEF, 41 reported the course of the AEA, and 16 to reported cases of cranial base trauma. Out of these cases, 10 were related to transconjunctival medial orbital decompression, affecting 11 patients. Most AEFs are situated at the frontoethmoidal suture, but up to 38.15% of AEFs are located above the suture on the frontal bone. Most AEFs are adjacent to the roof of the ethmoidal sinus. The distance of the AEF to the cranial base increases in the presence of supraorbital ethmoidal cells (SOEC).

CONCLUSIONS

The position of the AEF is variable and should not be considered a safe landmark for all patients.

Endoscopic Study of Ethmoidal Canals in Cadavers, Including a Histological Analysis of Their Contents

Introduction The advent of the endoscope has enabled the use of the endonasal approach for a variety of diseases. Studying the ethmoidal canals is important for surgeries of the paranasal sinuses and the anterior base of the skull. Objective To investigate the ethmoidal canals and evaluate their structure, the presence of vessels and nerves, their location, and to perform an anatomopathological study of their contents. Methods We evaluated 20 cadavers (20 left and 20 right nasal cavities) through endoscopic dissection of the anterior base of the skull and exposure of the medial periorbita and dura mater; then, the ethmoidal canals were located and measured in relation to the anterior wall of the sphenoid sinus and between the ethmoidal canals, followed by removal of their content for histological analysis. Results Vessels were present in 75% of the left anterior ethmoidal canals, 70% of the left posterior ethmoidal canals, 75% of the left middle ethmoidal canals, 85% of the right anterior ethmoid canals, and 64.5% of the right posterior ethmoid canals; 50% of the right middle ethmoidal canals contained one vessel. Conclusion The ethmoidal canal does not necessarily contain an ethmoidal artery. Studies with a larger sample should be performed to quantify the correct proportion of arteries and ethmoidal canals.

Spontaneous Subperiosteal Orbital Hematoma Associated With Cocaine-Induced Midline Destructive Lesion

The authors present a case of a non-traumatic, spontaneous subperiosteal orbital hematoma in a woman with a history of chronic pansinusitis and absence of midline nasal cavity structures due to chronic inhalational cocaine use. The patient underwent left orbitotomy and drainage of the lesion, showing mostly blood with a small amount of purulence that grew methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus when cultured. The patient received 4 weeks of intravenous antibiotics in addition to functional endoscopic sinus surgery. At 1 month after surgery, her vision had returned to baseline, and proptosis was resolved. Fewer than 20 cases of subperiosteal orbital hematomas associated with chronic sinusitis have been reported. To the authors' knowledge, this is the first reported case of a subperiosteal orbital hematoma associated with cocaine-induced midline destructive lesions. Patient consent to obtain photographs was obtained and archived. All collection and evaluation of patient health information were compliant with the Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act, and this report adheres to the Declaration of Helsinki.

A cadaveric study investigating the anatomy of the medial orbital wall

The purpose of this study is to investigate the applicability of the current surgical guideline, known as ‘24-12-6’ surgical guideline, in the Hispanic and European populations. This guideline is used during numerous orbital surgeries and states that the distance between the anterior lacrimal crest (ALC) to the anterior ethmoidal foramen (AEF) (24 mm), the AEF to the posterior ethmoidal foramen (PEF) (12 mm), and the PEF to the optic canal (OC) (6 mm) follows a Rule of Halves. Previous studies suggest this surgical guideline is not applicable for all ethnicities; however, to our knowledge, no data has been published regarding the accuracy of this guideline pertaining to the Hispanic population. An experimental study was performed on 79 orbits (52 cadavers) donated to the Human Anatomy Program at UT Health San Antonio. The ALC, AEF, posterior ethmoidal foramen, and OC were identified; the orbit was enucleated and all remaining soft tissue removed. The distance between each landmark was recorded using a digital caliper. For all cadavers studied, the distances between the ALC, AEF, posterior ethmoidal foramen, and OC were 24.76 mm, 13.89 mm, and 7.61 mm, respectively. Thus, the ‘24-12-6’ surgical guideline was not applicable to the sample studied. Based on ethnicity data, these relationships were also not true for the European or the Hispanic populations. Therefore, significant anatomical variations exist in the current surgical guideline. Clinicians may need to adjust their methodology during surgical procedures in order to optimize patient care.

An Applied Anatomical Study of the Ethmoidal Arteries: Computed Tomographic and Direct Measurements in Human Cadavers

Computed tomography (CT) images have been used in very few studies on distances to the ethmoidal arteries in the orbit. Most other studies have included direct measurements on cadavers and frequently quote the 24-12-6 mm rule to describe distances from the anterior lacrimal crest to the anterior and posterior ethmoidal foramina (AEF and PEF), optic canal (OC), respectively. However, the large interindividual variation of distances renders absolute values less applicable in a clinical setting. Preoperative measurements on CT images may provide more precise distances than absolute rules and thus lead to safer orbital surgery. The authors hypothesize that the distances to the ethmoidal arteries and the length of the medial wall are positively correlated and that measurements of the distances from the posterior lacrimal crest (PLC) on CT images are feasible with a low intra- and interobserver variability.Fifty intact orbits from 25 Caucasian cadavers were exenterated and examined. In additional, high-resolution CT scans of 48 orbits from 24 other Caucasian nonexenterated cadavers were examined. Distances were measured from 4 different anterior landmarks to the AEF and PEF and the OC.Distances from the most anterior landmarks to the arteries were positively correlated with the length of the medial wall. Measurements of the distances from the PLC to the ethmoidal arteries on CT images were feasible with a low intra- and interobserver variability. In conclusion, iatrogenic damage to the ethmoidal arteries in the orbit may be best avoided by using CT measurements in presurgical planning.

[Variability and age-related features of the anatomy of the midline structures of the anterior skull base]

The article presents the literature data on the structural variability and age-related features of the midline anatomical structures of the anterior skull base (frontal sinus, ethmoid bone, anterior parasellar region, and medial orbital wall). This is the area of surgical interests of neurosurgeons and rhinosurgeons. The study objective is to analyze the literature data on the individual variability and age-related anatomy of these structures. The work is illustrated with original images from the authors' personal archive. The individual anatomical features of eloquent structures in the surgical area (structures within the surgical corridor, key anatomical landmarks, optic tract, internal carotid and ethmoidal arteries, etc.) should be considered in planning surgery in patients of all age groups because they can limit the view and the amount of safe manipulations or increase the risk of complications. The presented data may be useful for neurosurgeons and otolaryngologists whose surgical interests are focused on the midline structures of the anterior skull base.

The revised anatomy of the canals connecting the orbit with the cranial cavity

Orbits are connected with the middle cranial fossa via the optic canal, the superior orbital fissure, the M-type orbitomeningeal foramen, the metoptic canal, an accessory anterior opening of the foramen rotundum, and Warwick's canal. They are also in communication with the anterior cranial fossa via the ethmoidal canals and the A-type orbitomeningeal foramen. The anatomy of these conduits has been recently enriched with several details that are summarized and reviewed in this article.

Ptosis and vertical diplopia after ligation of ethmoidal arteries

The treatment of epistaxis is well codified, ligation of the ethmoidal arteries being the last resort. We report the case of a 25-year-old pregnant patient, who has had a ligation of the anterior and posterior ethmoidal arteries after a persistent epistaxis. Postoperatively, she presented a complete ptosis and an impaired eye elevation without any visual acuity disorders, evoking a lesion of the upper branch of the common oculomotor nerve (third cranial nerve). The patient totally recovered after 3 months. Anatomical study shows that the upper branch of the third cranial nerve is lying very close to the optic nerve and cannot be affected by surgery without any associated damage of the optic nerve. Thus, a vascular etiology seems to be the best explanation of the complication experienced by our patient. Ligation of the posterior ethmoidal artery should be done with caution.

Predictability of Optic Foramen Location From a Ray Through the Ethmoidal Foramina

PURPOSE

To determine how accurately a ray through the anterior and posterior ethmoidal foramina predicts the location of the optic foramen.

METHODS

Dried, well-preserved, complete human skulls without bony defects belonging to the Hamann-Todd osteological collection of the Cleveland Museum of Natural History were examined. Photography was performed and a ray was drawn on orbit photographs extending through the center of the anterior and posterior ethmoidal foramina toward the optic canal. The location of the ray at the anterior aspect of the optic canal was recorded.

RESULTS

Sixty-six total orbits were examined from 36 skulls with 6 skulls with only unilateral data. Thirty-eight orbits were of African descent and 28 were of European descent with an average age 45.25 years (range = 19-89 years). The anterior-posterior ethmoidal foramen ray extended superior (12/66), through (53/66), and inferior (1/66) to the optic canal. Of those rays passing through the optic canal, 32/53 (60%) passed through the upper one-third, 19/53 (36%) passed through the middle one-third, and 2/53 (4%) passed through the lower one-third of the optic canal.

CONCLUSIONS

The anterior-posterior ethmoidal foramen ray highly predicts the superior aspect of the optic canal. This information can guide medial orbital wall surgery.

Positional Relationship of Ethmoidal Foramens With Reference to the Nasion and Its Significance in Orbital Surgery

PURPOSE

The aim of the study was to elucidate the positional relationship of the ethmoidal foramens (EFs) with reference to the nasion to facilitate prediction of the exact location of EFs, the optic canal (OC), and the frontoethmoidal suture (FS), and thereby avoid complications during complex surgery involving the medial wall of the orbit.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred two intact orbits of 57 embalmed cadavers were dissected in this observational anatomic study. Nasion' (N') was defined as the intersection point of the medial orbit margin with the horizontal line through the nasion, and this was used as a reference point. N'-OC was defined as the straight line joining N' and OC. The locations of the anterior ethmoidal foramen (AEF), posterior ethmoidal foramen (PEF), and OC were determined with reference to N'. The vertical distances from N'-OC to EFs and to FS were also determined.

RESULTS

The N'-AEF, AEF-PEF, and PEF-OC distances were 18.4, 15.3, and 8.3 mm, respectively. Vertically, AEF and PEF were situated at 0.2 mm below and 0.4 mm above N'-OC, respectively. At the same reference points, N'-OC was situated at 0.4 and 0.6 mm above FS, respectively.

CONCLUSIONS

N', AEF, PEF, and OC were considered to be situated on the same straight line, and N'-OC could be regarded as coinciding with FS. This means that N' is an easily identifiable and reliable landmark for identifying EFs, OC, and FS. Our navigational parameters with reference to N' will help surgeons to enhance the safety of orbital surgery.

Medial orbital wall landmarks in three different North American populations

PURPOSE

We sought to measure the medial orbital wall foramina distances in two previously unstudied populations, to describe a new bony medial wall feature, and to validate the accuracy of a new coordinate measurement device within the orbit.

METHODS

Dried, well-preserved, complete human skulls without orbital defects were studied. Age, gender, birthplace, ethnicity, and laterality of the orbit were recorded for each skull. Supranumerary ethmoidal foramina were recorded, and the fronto-ethmoidal groove depth was measured. The distances between the anterior lacrimal crest (ALC) - anterior ethmoidal foramen (AEF), AEF - posterior ethmoidal foramen (PEF), and PEF - optic canal (OC) were measured first by surgical ruler and wire and then by the Microscribe coordinate measurement device.

RESULTS

One hundred and forty-six orbits were studied. Fifty-seven orbits were of European or Caucasian descent, 68 orbits of African American descent, 2 orbits of West African descent, 11 orbits of Eskimo descent, and 8 orbits of unknown origin. No significant differences existed between the manual and Microscribe measurements for the ALC-AEF, AEF-PEF, and PEF-OF distances (p < 0.0001). A significant frontoethmoidal groove was observed in 27/146 (19%) orbits, in 6/57 (11%) Caucasian orbits, in 17/70 (24%) African American orbits, and in 4/11 (36%) Eskimo orbits. Supranumerary ethmoidal foramina were found in 50/146 orbits (34.2%) and in 17/27 (63%) orbits with a significant frontoethmoidal grooves.

CONCLUSIONS

No significant differences in medial wall foramina distances exist between African American and Caucasian orbits; however, a frontoethmoidal groove occurs more commonly in African American orbits. This groove often occurs in the presence of supernumerary ethmoidal foramina. The Microscribe coordinate measurement system represents a valid tool to measure distances within the orbit.

Three-dimensional evaluation of the danger zone of ethmoidal foramens on the frontoethmoidal suture line on the medial orbital wall

INTRODUCTION

It is clear that the importance of the ethmoidal foramen (EF) is based on its vascular contents. The frontoethmoidal suture (FS) line is recommended as more reliable navigational landmark for identifying the EF.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

The vertical orientation between the EF and the FS line was studied in 188 orbits using a computer software program.

RESULTS

146 anterior EFs (77.7 %) and 42 anterior EFs (22.3 %) were situated in the FS line as intrasutural and extrasutural, respectively. 146 posterior EFs (77.25 %) and 8 posterior EFs (4.25 %) were presented as intrasutural and extrasutural, respectively. Although accessory EFs were detected in 25.5 % specimen exhibited an extrasutural location. Majority of the EFs (1-4 EFs) were situated on the FS line. The mean distances from the FS and the anterior EF, the posterior EF and the accessory EF were measured as 2.1 ± 0.5, 2.0 ± 1.5 and 2.3 ± 1.2 mm, respectively. The range of the distances from the FS to the anterior EF, posterior EF and accessory EF were -1.2 to 3.32 , -1.02 to 5.76 and -1.1 to 3.65 mm, respectively.

CONCLUSION

The ranges of EF changed within 1-6 mm. As the FS is not a single point, it is more suitable to make the incision 7 mm above the suture line. The data from this study to help the orbital surgeons explain and avoid unexpected hemorrhage during the orbital procedures such as posttraumatic orbital reconstruction, orbital tumor resections, anterior skull base reconstruction, and orbital decompression surgery.

Morphometric study of the medial orbital wall emphasizing the ethmoidal foramina

PURPOSE

Ethmoidal foramina on the medial orbital wall show a higher incidence of variation. Surgeons performing endonasal, anterior cranial fossa and medial orbital wall surgeries must be aware of these variations as they are a source of hemorrhage and also serve as landmark in proximity to the orbital apex.

AIM

The present study aims to describe the morphometric distances of various ethmoidal foramina between anterior lacrimal crest to optic canal in south Indian dry human skulls.

MATERIALS AND METHOD

The study was done on 44 adult dry human skulls. The occurrence of Ethmoidal foramina was noted by direct inspection. The distance of Ethmoidal foramina from anterior lacrimal crest to optic canal was measured with the help of ruler, probe and magnifying glass.

RESULTS

The Posterior ethmoidal foramina were found in all 44 skulls bilaterally. Middle ethmoidal foramen was present in 12 and 13 skulls on right and left, respectively. Anterior ethmoidal foramen was found in 38 and 37 skulls on right and left, respectively. The distance between anterior lacrimal crest (ALC) and posterior lacrimal crest (PLC) was in the range of 3-8 mm and that of ALC to anterior ethmoidal foramen was in the range of 24-30 mm. The range of distance between anterior ethmoidal foramen to posterior ethmoidal foramen was 9-17 mm and that between posterior ethmoidal foramen to optic canal was 5-13 mm.

CONCLUSION

These observations would help to predict the anatomical variations in the position of ethmoidal foramina with respect to anterior and posterior lacrimal crest and ensure the safe and precise performance of medial orbital wall surgeries to avoid injuries to the important neurovascular bundles passing through various foramina and fissures.

Extracranial ligation of ethmoidal arteries before resection of giant olfactory groove or planum sphenoidale meningiomas: 3 illustrative cases with a review of the literature on surgical techniques

Object

There are several surgical techniques for reducing blood loss—open surgical and endoscopic—prior to resection of giant anterior skull base meningiomas, especially when preoperative embolization is risky or not technically feasible. The authors present examples of an institutional experience using surgical ligation of the anterior and posterior ethmoidal arteries producing persistent tumor blush in partially embolized tumors.

Methods

The authors identified 12 patients who underwent extracranial surgical ligation of ethmoidal arteries through either a transcaruncular or a Lynch approach. Of these, 3 patients had giant olfactory groove or planum sphenoidale meningiomas. After approval from the institution privacy officer, the authors studied the medical records and imaging data of these 3 patients, with special attention to surgical technique and outcome. The variations of ethmoidal artery foramina pertaining to this surgical approach were studied using preserved human skulls from the Hamann-Todd Osteological Collection at the Museum of Natural History, Cleveland, Ohio.

Results

The extracranial ligation was performed successfully for control of the ethmoidal arteries prior to resection of hypervascular giant anterior skull base meningiomas. The surgical anatomy and landmarks for ethmoidal arteries were reviewed in anthropology specimens and available literature with reference to described surgical techniques.

Conclusions

Extracranial surgical ligation of anterior, and often posterior, ethmoidal arteries prior to resection of large olfactory groove or planum sphenoidale meningiomas provides a safe and feasible option for control of these vessels prior to either open or endoscopic resection of nonembolized or partially embolized tumors.

The anatomic landmarks of ethmoidal arteries for the surgical approaches

Knowledge of variations in the possible patterns of origins, courses, and distributions of the ethmoidal arteries are necessary for the diagnosis and important for the treatment of orbital disorders. Ethmoidal arteries are damaged in endonasal surgical interventions and in operations performed on the inner wall of the orbita.A description of the anatomic landmarks of the ethmoidal arteries and ethmoidal canals is presented, based on data from microdissection in 19 adult cadavers studied after injection of red-dyed latex into the arterial bed. In all subjects, each of ethmoidal arteries originated from ophthalmic artery. The anterior ethmoidal artery was observed in all specimens except for one case. The diameter of the artery thicker than the posterior ethmoidal artery was 0.92 +/- 0.2 mm on the right and 0.88 +/- 0.15 mm on the left. The branching of the anterior ethmoidal artery from the ophthalmic artery was determined in four different types. The diameter of the posterior ethmoidal artery was measured as 0.66 +/- 0.21 mm on the right and 0.63 +/- 0.19 mm on the left. The anterior ethmoidal canal was located between the second and third lamella in 29 of 38 cases. The mean distance between the limen nasi and anterior ethmoidal canal was 48.1 +/- 3.2 mm.The article confirms the well-known variability of the ethmoidal arteries and their topographic relation to the ethmoidal canals. Advances in surgical techniques, instrumentation, and regional arterial anatomy have resulted in functional operations of endoscopic sinus and orbital surgery with fewer complications.

Evaluation of the anterior and posterior ethmoidal canal by computed tomography

AIM

To examine the anatomy, length and angulation of the anterior and posterior ethmoidal canals (AECs and PECs) using computed tomography (CT), and to determine the anatomical landmarks in which the canals are expected to be seen in transverse and coronal planes.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

CT images of 150 patients were analysed. One, 2, and 3 mm thick sections were obtained separately in axial and coronal images. The frequency of visualization of the AECs and PECs, and if present, a third canal, was noted. The course and the angulation of the AEC and the PEC in transverse and coronal planes were recorded. On axial sections the distance between the AEC and PEC and the previously defined landmarks were measured. On coronal images, the distances were calculated from the thickness of the cross-section and the number of sections between the various structures.

RESULTS

The AEC was identified as a separate canal in 84% of patients, and was embedded in the ethmoid roof in 16%. The PEC was seen as a separate canal in 8% and was present in the ethmoid roof in 92%. On the 1 mm thick coronal and transverse sections, a third canal was identified at the junction of the middle and posterior third of the AEC-PEC distance in both of the images. The average lengths of these canals were 4-12 mm (mean 8.2 mm) for the AEC, and 2-13 mm (mean 7.6 mm) for the PEC.

CONCLUSIONS

To avoid the complications that can develop during endoscopic sinus surgery; the course, length and the angulations of the anterior and posterior ethmoidal arteries and their canals can be identified by CT in standard positions if a sufficiently thin section thickness is used. The present study has shown the exact CT localization of the AECs and PECS, which are frequently overlooked when evaluating para-nasal sinuses.

Anatomy of the orbital apex and cavernous sinus on high-resolution magnetic resonance images

Diseases of the orbital apex and cavernous sinus usually present with involvement of multiple cranial nerves, corresponding to the complex anatomy of the region. In nontraumatic disorders, magnetic resonance imaging is the diagnostic modality of choice. However, its capabilities can be fully used only with thorough knowledge of the complicated topographic relationships in this region. This article describes the imaging anatomy of the cranio-orbital junction and adjacent subarachnoid spaces. High-resolution magnetic resonance images of normal subjects are presented, and the results are compared with findings reported in the literature. The following anatomic structures can be visualized on high-resolution magnetic resonance images: extraocular muscles and corresponding connective tissue, major orbital and cerebral arteries, ophthalmic veins, cavernous sinus, and all sensory and motor cranial nerves of the eye along their intraorbital and intracranial course.

High-resolution MR imaging anatomy of the orbit. Correlation with comparative cryosectional anatomy

High resolution MR imaging of the orbit enables visualization of anatomic details in the orbit, including important blood vessels, muscles, nerves and connective tissue structures. The best resolution of anatomic details currently is obtained by using surface coils and T1-weighted spin echo sequences. Some examples of clinical applications demonstrate that a detailed knowledge of orbital imaging anatomy is a prerequisite for successful interpretation of clinical MR images. Additionally, this noninvasive diagnostic technique may be used for anatomical in vivo studies.