Comparative study of three immunoassays for detection of immunoglobulin M antibodies against Toxoplasma gondii

False-positive results in immunoglobulin M (IgM) toxoplasma antibody tests and importance of confirmatory testing: the Platelia Toxo IgM test

Although tests for detection of immunoglobulin M (IgM) toxoplasma antibodies have been reported to have a high degree of accuracy, it is well recognized by investigators in the United States and Europe that false-positive results may occur with many of these tests, at times to an alarming degree. Unfortunately, this information is not well documented in the literature. Studies on various toxoplasma IgM test kits are frequently flawed. The investigators often use reference tests which have not previously been carefully evaluated as well as sera that were not appropriate to answer the question of how often false-positive results might occur. We recently had the unique opportunity to evaluate the accuracy of the Platelia Toxo IgM test in 575 serum samples obtained during an outbreak of toxoplasmosis which occurred in 1995 in the Capital Regional District of British Columbia, Canada. When compared with results obtained in a reference IgM enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA), the Platelia Toxo IgM test had a sensitivity of 99.4%, specificity of 49.2%, positive predictive value of 51.9%, negative predictive value of 99.3%, and an overall agreement of 67.0%. In an attempt to resolve discrepancies between these two tests, a serological profile (Sabin-Feldman dye test, IgA and IgE antibody tests, differential agglutination [AC/HS] test, and IgG avidity method) was performed. Of 153 serum samples that were positive in the Platelia Toxo IgM test and negative in the IgM ELISA, 71 (46.4%) were negative in the Sabin-Feldman dye test. Of the serum samples that were positive in the dye test, 77 (93.9%) had a serological profile most compatible with an infection acquired in the distant past. These results reveal high numbers of false-positive results in the Platelia Toxo IgM test and highlight the importance of appropriate evaluation of commercial tests that are currently being marked. Our results also emphasize the importance of confirmatory testing to determine whether the results of an IgM antibody test reflect the likelihood of a recently acquired infection.

Performance characteristics of a commercial antibody-capture enzyme immunoassay for detection of Toxoplasma-specific IgM antibodies

Antibody-capture enzyme immunoassay (EIA) for the detection of Toxoplasma-specific IgM has been shown to provide significantly higher specificity than the indirect IgM EIA. A new commercially available antibody-capture EIA (PLATELIA Toxo IgM EIA) converted 99 out of 100 false-positive Toxo-plasma IgM determinations to true negative. Experiments using Toxoplasma IgM calibrators demonstrated the antibody-capture EIA is approximately eightfold more sensitive than a new automated microparticle EIA for Toxoplasma IgM antibodies (IMX Toxo IgM EIA), and approximately equal in sensitivity to the indirect immunofluorescence assay. Precision studies of the antibody capture EIA using low, medium, and high calibrators gave coefficients of variation ranging from 3.0%-4.5% for within-run and 5.2%-11.4% for run-to-run variation experiments. Interference from high levels of bilirubin, albumin, hemoglobin, and lipid was not detected. Sera from patients with inflammatory or infectious disorders were tested for interference in the antibody-capture EIA. False-positive Toxoplasma IgM results were not observed, but low-level negative interference was detectable when patient sera was mixed with Toxoplasma-positive sera. Preparations of purified human IgM also produced negative interference in the antibody-capture EIA for Toxoplasma IgM.

Indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for immunoglobulin G and four immunoassays for immunoglobulin M to Toxoplasma gondii in a series of heart transplant recipients

Toxoplasma gondii infections in heart transplant recipients were monitored by indirect enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay for immunoglobulin G (ELISA-IgG), indirect ELISA-IgM in serum IgM fractions, antibody capture ELISA-IgM, IgM-immunosorbent agglutination assay (ISAGA), and IgM immunoblotting. Basic immunosuppression consisted of cyclosporine and low-dose steroids. Before transplantation, 26 of 43 recipients showed serological evidence of infection. In serum samples from 15 (35%) recipients, specific antibodies were not detected. Approximately 50% of the heart donors, were toxoplasma seropositive. Eight of the fifteen seronegative recipients received hearts from toxoplasma-seropositive donors. In four of the eight recipients, seroconversion could be demonstrated with all tests used. In three of these four patients, clinical disease developed. One patient with strong serological evidence of toxoplasmosis died, but toxoplasma parasites and antigens were not detected at autopsy. In two patients, toxoplasma cysts were found in cardiac biopsies. Seroconversion was not prevented by the use of spiramycin prophylaxis in two recipients. Reactivations of latent infections or reinfections were detected by indirect ELISA in six (23%) seropositive recipients, but symptoms and signs of active T. gondii infection were not seen. Seroconversion and reactivation of infection were readily found by a combined use of indirect ELISA-IgG and ELISA-IgM and antibody capture ELISA-IgM. Discrepancies in results could be examined by immunoblotting. IgM-ISAGA retained stable positive values longer than IgM-ELISAs did. Cyclosporine treatment did not hamper detection of seroconversion but could cause antibody levels to remain relatively low in primary infections. Seronegative recipients should receive antitoxoplasma treatment on seroconversion.