Relationship of electroconvulsive therapy to course in affective illness: a collaborative study

Long-term follow-up after successful electroconvulsive therapy for depression: a 4- to 8-year naturalistic follow-up study

OBJECTIVES

A long-term follow-up of depressed patients responsive to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) with intensive pre-ECT pharmacotherapy treatment failure who also participated in a 6-month trial directly post-ECT in which imipramine was compared with placebo for relapse prevention.

METHODS

A total of 26 patients responsive to ECT who participated in the 6-month continuation trial were invited 4 to 8 years later to assess their follow-up status. The groups with and without relapse within 6 months were compared with regard to recurrence of depression up to 8 years later. Recurrence was defined as a new episode of depression that needed antidepressant medication and/or readmission in hospital and/or a new ECT course.

RESULTS

At the time of follow-up (mean duration, 6.8 years), the recurrence rate of depression for the total sample was 42.3%. There was no significant difference in the recurrence rates and number of recurrences between the nonrelapse and relapse groups. The small study population limits generalization of the results; the design of the study is naturalistic and retrospective.

CONCLUSION

In our small sample of depressed patients with pharmacotherapy treatment failure, recurrence is not influenced by relapse after terminating ECT. Continuation of medication started immediately after ECT seems to be an important factor in preventing recurrence.

Does type of first contact in depressive and bipolar disorders predict subsequent hospitalisation and risk of suicide?

BACKGROUND

Only a few studies have investigated how the type of first contact is associated with the risk of subsequent hospitalisation and the risk of committing suicide for patients with depressive or bipolar disorders.

METHOD

All outpatients (patients in psychiatric ambulatories and community psychiatry centres) and in-patients (patients admitted during daytime or overnight to a psychiatric hospital) with a diagnosis of depressive or bipolar disorder at first contact ever in a period from 1995 to 1999 in Denmark were identified from the Danish Psychiatric Central Research Register (DPCRR). The risk of subsequent hospitalisation and the risk of suicide were compared according to type of first contact.

RESULTS

The risk of subsequent hospitalisation was significantly increased for patients who were admitted to inpatient facilities during first contact compared to patients with outpatient treatment as their first contact. Patients with depressive disorder who were admitted also had increased risk of committing suicide eventually.

LIMITATIONS

The diagnoses are clinician based.

CONCLUSIONS

Patients referred to inpatient treatment have a poorer long-term prognosis than patients treated as outpatients.

Coadministration of melatonin and fluoxetine does not improve the 3-month outcome following ECT

At least 50% of patients with manic depressive disorder (MDD) treated successfully with electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) will experience a relapse within the first year of follow-up. Sleep disturbances are very common in MDD and may constitute forerunners of relapse. In this study we tested the hypothesis that melatonin, a sleep-promoting hormone, would decrease the 3-month relapse rate after successful ECT. We included in the study patients with MDD successfully treated with ECT (post-ECT Hamilton Rating Scale for Depression [HRSD] < or = 10). Patients were blindly randomized to two groups, one receiving fluoxetine + placebo and one receiving fluoxetine + melatonin. Assessments (HRSD, Brief Psychiatric Rating Scale, Global Assessment of Function Scale, Global Depression Scale, Pittsburgh Sleep Quality Index, Mini-Mental State Exam, and pill count) were performed for 12 weeks after ECT. Ten of the 35 patients (28.5%) relapsed during the follow-up period. Relapse rates were similar in both groups of patients. Sleep reports were not improved by melatonin. Patients who achieved a higher functional state post-ECT relapsed less often. We conclude that the addition of melatonin to on-going fluoxetine treatment did not have a beneficial effect either on the 3-month outcome post-ECT or on the sleep reports of these patients.

No evident neuronal damage after electroconvulsive therapy

Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is regarded as one of the most effective treatments for major depressive disorder but has also been associated with cognitive deficits possibly reflecting brain damage. The aim of this study was therefore to evaluate whether ECT induces cerebral damage as reflected by different biochemical measures. The concentrations in the cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) of three established markers of neuronal/glial degeneration, tau protein (tau), neurofilament (NFL) and S-100 beta protein, were determined in nine patients who fulfilled DSM-IV criteria for major depression. CSF samples were collected before and after a course of six ECT sessions. The CSF/serum (S) albumin ratio reflecting potential blood-brain barrier (BBB) dysfunction was also determined at these time points. The treatment was clinically successful with a significant decline of depressive symptoms in all patients as assessed by the Montgomery-Asberg Rating Scale for Depression. Several patients had signs of BBB dysfunction and/or neuronal damage before the start of treatment. Levels of CSF-tau, CSF-NFL and CSF-S-100 beta levels were not significantly changed by ECT. Also the CSF/S albumin ratio was found to be unchanged after the course of ECT. In conclusion, no biochemical evidence of neuronal/glial damage or BBB dysfunction could be demonstrated following a therapeutic course of ECT.

Relapse of depression after ECT: a review

Relapse of severe depression after successful treatment with electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) continues to be a major problem. We review the literature on relapse after ECT and factors that predict relapse. Early studies showed that the relapse rate was approximately 50% without follow-up treatment and that the majority of these relapses occurred in the first 6 months. More recent studies have found even higher rates in delusional depression and possibly in "double depression." Studies of biological markers as predictors of relapse were examined. Six of nine studies of the dexamethasone suppression test and one study of cortisol hypersecretion show that post-ECT nonsuppressors are at higher risk; although insensitive for diagnostic purposes, this test may be useful, when persistently abnormal, as a predictor of relapse. Studies of the thyrotropin-releasing hormone stimulation test and shortened rapid eye movement sleep latency are inconclusive. Medication resistance pre-ECT has been shown to predict relapse in two studies and highlights the need for more aggressive and effective treatment in this group. Further research into the prediction and prevention of depressive relapse after ECT is needed, and the field anxiously awaits current trials comparing ECT with combination lithium and nortriptyline.

Sleep-onset rapid eye movement after electroconvulsive therapy is more frequent in patients who respond less well to electroconvulsive therapy

The response to electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) was monitored with sleep polysomnography studies (SPS) performed pre- and post-ECT, in 25 patients with major depressive disorder (MDD). Patients included in this study met research diagnostic criteria for MDD and had been free of psychotropic medication for at least 10 days before SPS were performed. We compared ECT responders and nonresponders on SPS, demographic, and clinical parameters. Many SPS parameters, regardless of the clinical response, changed significantly with ECT. The presence of delusions was significantly associated with SOREM post-ECT. The presence of sleep-onset REM periods post-ECT was associated with poor response to ECT. SPS performed during a course of ECT may help identify patients at risk of responding less well to this modality of treatment.

Relapse and recurrence following a course of ECT: reasons for concern and strategies for further investigation

Patients treated with electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) have a more severe illness. This severity is evidenced in the clinical profile of the illness, in the course of the illness, in the resistance to pharmacotherapy, and in the high relapse and recurrence rates after the course of ECT. In this article the authors explore some of the issues, particularly those of biological correlates of severe mood disorders and the continuation of treatment after ECT, which may be factors in this increased severity. The authors propose avenues for the investigation and treatment of severe mood disorders treated with ECT.

Shortened REM latency PostECT is associated with rapid recurrence of depressive symptomatology

Electroconvulsive therapy (ECT) is highly effective in the treatment of major depressive disorder (MDD). The 1-year relapse rates are reported to be high and in the 30%-60% range, however. To test whether polysomnography (PS) can identify patients with a propensity for relapse we studied 20 patients, responders to a course of ECT, with PS studies. All patients met baseline diagnostic criteria for MDD, were treated with ECT following standardized protocols, had PS studies performed after the course of ECT in a medication-free state, received maintenance antidepressants postECT, and were followed periodically with phone interviews. The recurrence of depressive symptoms was determined at 3 months and 6 months after discharge. Fifty-five percent of the patients were symptomatic when evaluated 6 months after the ECT. Sleep Onset rapid eye movement (REM) periods were identified in 55% of the patients. As a group, patients who had experienced a recurrence of depressive symptoms by 6 months after discharge, had significantly shorter REM latencies after the course of ECT. A shorter REM latency after ECT identified patients who at six months demonstrated significant depressive symptomatology. Shortened REM latency after ECT in patients with MDD appears to be a correlate of vulnerability for relapse.

Sleep Electroencephalographic Studies After ECT: Age and Clinical Response

Forty-one patients with major depressive disorder were treated with electroconvulsive therapy (ECT). Sleep polysomnography studies (SPSs) were performed after the course of ECT. The hypotheses tested were that age is a significant factor in post-ECT SPS results and that some SPS parameters are correlates of outcome of ECT. An interaction between age and response to ECT could not be identified; however, older patients demon strated significantly disrupted sleep post-ECT. Response to ECT was associated with lower REM activity and lower REM density. Sleep-onset REM periods post-ECT were observed in almost 50% of the patients regardless of age. The SPS monitoring of recovery after a course of ECT may identify sleep correlates of response to ECT and variables associated with poorer longitudinal outcome.