Esophageal balloon dilatation: a follow-up study in 74 patients

Prospective randomized comparison of polyvinyl bougies and through-the-scope balloons for dilation of peptic strictures of the esophagus

We prospectively compared the efficacy of polyvinyl bougies (Savary type) passed over a guide wire and through-the-scope balloons for the dilation of peptic esophageal strictures in a randomized study. Thirty-four patients, 17 in each treatment arm, were studied. At entry, dysphagia was assessed according to a six-point scale (0, unable to swallow; 5, normal). The end-point for dilation was to size 45F or 15 mm. Discomfort during the procedure was graded on a four-point scale (0, no discomfort; 1, mild; 2, moderate; 3, severe discomfort). Follow-up visits were at 1 week, 1 month, 3 months, and every 3 months thereafter for 2 years. At the 1-week visit, the size of esophageal lumen was measured by 8-, 10-, and 12-mm pills. Both devices effectively relieved dysphagia. By life-table analysis, stricture recurrence during the first year of follow-up was similar in both groups, but during the second year, the risk of recurrence was significantly lower in patients whose strictures were dilated with balloons. Other advantages of balloons included the need for fewer treatment sessions to achieve the defined end-diameter for dilation (1.1 + 0.1 versus 1.7 + 0.2, p < .05), and less procedural discomfort (p < .05). The differences in luminal size after dilation, measured by the barium pill test, were not significant. Ability to pass the 12-mm pill and absence of dysphagia were correlated. Our results indicate that both devices are effective in relieving dysphagia, but balloons may have a long-term advantage.

Balloon dilatation of the pharynx

Balloon dilatation has become a widely accepted technique in the management of oesophageal and other gastrointestinal strictures. The use of this procedure in the pharynx has rarely been reported. We have performed 55 balloon dilatations on 13 patients with pharyngeal strictures. In three patients all symptoms were permanently abolished after one dilatation. Seven patients were successfully managed with repeated, regular dilatations. Two patients had a good initial response but this was not maintained and one patient had no relief of symptoms. Balloon dilatation is minimally invasive, less traumatic than rigid pharyngoscopy with dilatation, and well tolerated. It may be frequently repeated, and has successfully relieved dysphagia caused by benign and malignant strictures of the pharynx, including instances where previous rigid bouginage had failed.

The radiological management of gastrointestinal strictures and other obstructive lesions

Balloon dilation of gastrointestinal strictures using a radiologic, endoscopic or combined approach is a safe, effective means of managing an ever-increasing variety of stricturing processes. At present the ability to dilate strictures in the gastrointestinal tract is limited mainly by access. Balloon dilation is now well established in the management of oesophageal and anastomotic lesions. The place of balloon dilation in the management of Crohn's disease and in the management of malignant disease requires further evaluation.