[Torticollis spasmodicus, blepharospasm and hemifacial spasm. Subjective evaluation of therapy by patients]

Treatment satisfaction with botulinum toxin: a comparison between blepharospasm and cervical dystonia

BACKGROUND

Differential effects of botulinum toxin (BoNT) treatment in cervical dystonia (CD) and blepharospasm (BSP) treatment satisfaction and emotional responses to a life with a disabling condition were investigated. Special interest was drawn to the course within a BoNT treatment cycle and the effects of subjective well-being vs perceived intensity of motor symptoms and quality of life.

METHODS

A questionnaire was distributed among 372 CD patients and 125 BSP patients, recruited from 13 BoNT centers throughout Germany. Items were related to dystonic symptoms, BoNT treatment responses and treatment satisfaction, quality of life, working situation, and emotional reactions to a life with dystonia.

RESULTS

CD patients and BSP patients were widely satisfied with BoNT treatment, but treatment satisfaction worsened significantly within the treatment cycle. Especially CD patients reported that both the dystonic symptoms and the effects of BoNT treatment were influenced by emotional factors. Despite good overall treatment effects, patients from both groups perceived marked persistence of motor symptoms, restrictions of everyday life functions, and reduced quality of life. Functional amelioration of motor symptoms and emotional well-being were only moderately correlated. About 22% of patients from both groups reported mental disorders or emotional disturbances prior to the onset of dystonia.

CONCLUSION

As numerous psychological factors determine perceived outcome, BoNT treatment should be further improved by patient's education strategies enhancing behavioral self-control. From the patient's perspective, individual intervals, which may avoid exacerbation between injection points, should be considered. Moreover, patients at risk, with reduced adherence and poor BoNT outcome, should be identified and addressed within psychoeducation.

[Botulinum toxin therapy for spasmodic torticollis: medical and non-medical adjunct treatment]

BACKGROUND

Spasmodic torticollis patients were investigated with respect to the number of adjunct treatments used before and after the introduction of botulinum toxin therapy (Btx). The study was designed in a similar way to an earlier investigation by Birner et al. (Nervenarzt 70:903-908, 1999).

MATERIAL AND METHODS

A total of 247 patients with idiopathic spasmodic torticollis were assessed at three time points for the diagnosis: before 1988 (n = 63), between 1989 and 1998 (n = 107) and after 1999 (n = 77).

RESULTS

Independent of the year of diagnosis patients underwent a mean of 14.3 different treatments. In addition to Btx most of the patients were subjected to massage, physiotherapy, medication and a large number of non-medical treatments including praying. No associations to clinical or personal variables were found. Those patients with emotional disorders prior to onset of dystonia displayed a higher rate of medical and non-medical treatments in addition to Btx.

CONCLUSIONS

The results confirmed those found by Birner et al.. In order to enhance compliance patients should undergo psychoeducation with respect to illness behaviour and specific history taking with respect to emotional disorders prior to dystonia.

Utilization and perceived effectiveness of complementary and alternative medicine in patients with dystonia

The use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) is increasing worldwide, especially by patients with chronic diseases. To date, no data are available about utilization and perceived effectiveness of CAM in patients with dystonia. A questionnaire survey on utilization and costs of CAM was completed by 180 members of the German Dystonia Society, a patient advocate group. In total, 131 dystonia patients (73%) were current or former users of CAM, 55 patients used CAM in addition to botulinum toxin A injections, and 86 patients had experience with three or more CAM methods. The options used most widely were acupuncture (56%), relaxation techniques (44%), homeopathy (27%), and massages (26%). Among users of specific CAM methods, breathing therapy, Feldenkrais, massages, and relaxation techniques were perceived as most effective. On average, patients spent 1,513 Euro on CAM without reimbursement. There was no correlation between costs and perceived effectiveness of different methods. In line with other studies on chronically ill patients, our results show that dystonia patients frequently utilize CAM methods, often in addition to conventional treatment. There is a growing need to evaluate scientifically the effect of CAM methods on symptom severity and quality of life in dystonia, to prevent utilization of costly and ineffective CAM treatments.