Characteristics of persistent urinary incontinence after successful fistula closure in Ethiopian women

A systematic review and meta-analysis of urinary incontinence following successful obstetric fistula repair: findings from five countries in sub-Saharan Africa

BACKGROUND

Obstetric vesico-vaginal fistula is a known complication that can occur following damage to the bladder wall during prolonged obstructed labor and operative delivery. Urinary incontinence following the repair of obstetric fistula remains a significant health problem and can greatly damage a women's ability to function confidently. There are approximately two million women suffering from urinary incontinence following obstetric fistula repair, most of whom are primarily in Africa.

OBJECTIVE

We aimed to systematically review and conduct meta-analysis on the magnitude of urinary incontinence among women following successful obstetric fistula repair in sub-Saharan African countries.

METHODS

We thoroughly searched online database including Medline, Scopus, Science Direct, Excerpta Medica Database, African Journals Online and Google Scholar for eligible articles from their inception to November 10, 2024. This systematic review followed the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-analysis (PRISMA) 2020 checklist. To generate pooled prevalence of urinary incontinence, we used random-effects model. The presence of publication bias was determined using a funnel plot and Egger's regression test.

RESULTS

Out of 1044 articles found following our initial search and after titles and abstracts review, we considered 277 full text articles for inclusion. Lastly, a total of 12 articles from five sub-Saharan African countries comprising 6,104 participants met the inclusion criteria for quantitative meta-analysis. The pooled prevalence of urinary incontinence following obstetric fistula repair was 16.32% (95%CI: 11.80, 20.84; I2 = 96.5%, P < 0.001).

CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS

Overall, our findings show post-fistula repair incontinence remains an important clinical problem. Therefore, we believe that policy planners and researchers of sub-Saharan African nations may use the findings of the current study for evidence based care planning and patient counseling strategy.

REGISTRATION

Registered in PROSPERO under protocol number CRD42023416541.

FIGO good practice recommendations to standardize the assessment of outcomes following vesicovaginal fistula surgery

Obstetric fistula is a debilitating childbirth injury causing immense suffering for women and girls with the condition. The majority of fistulas can be successfully treated with a surgical repair, performed by a competent surgeon who has undergone specialist training and who works with a holistic fistula care team. As well as surgical repair, a critical component of fistula treatment is meticulous postoperative assessment to accurately determine surgical outcomes so that further treatment and support can be provided as required, and the risk substantially reduced of any patient being discharged with associated ongoing problems, such as urinary retention or residual/ongoing incontinence. Based on the opinions of experts in the field, these good practice recommendations provide a practical and standardized protocol for the correct assessment of surgical outcomes following vesicovaginal fistula surgery and appropriate subsequent management.

Early bladder dysfunction after vesicovaginal fistula repair: A prospective comparative analysis of transvaginal, open, and laparoscopic abdominal approaches

INTRODUCTION

We aim to compare the clinical and urodynamic profile of lower urinary tract symptoms (LUTS) in patients undergoing laparoscopic, open transabdominal, and laparoscopic transabdominal vesicovaginal fistulae (VVF) repair at 3 months of repair, that is, in early postoperative period.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Fifty-one consecutive patients with endoscopically confirmed VVF were enrolled in our study over 2 years. Malignant fistulae, radiation-induced, and complex fistulae were excluded after cross-sectional imaging. All patients underwent a postoperative assessment for the success of the repair. Then at 3 months, they completed the American Urological Association Symptom Score questionnaire and underwent a dual channel pressure-flow urodynamic study. The results of transvaginal, laparoscopic, and open transabdominal repairs were compared.

RESULTS

All patients belonged to the Indian Caucasian race. The mean age was 35.43 ± 6.63 years. Thirty-two patients had supratrigonal and 19 had trigonal fistulae. Laparoscopic transabdominal repair was done in 15 patients, open transabdominal repair in 22 patients, and transvaginal repair in 14 patients. Forty-six patients reported some LUTS at a median follow-up of 5.83 ± 2.37 months postoperatively. Only 18 (35.2%) of these patients had moderate to severe symptoms The postoperative bladder dysfunction rates in open transabdominal, transvaginal and laparoscopic transabdominal groups were 36.4%, 28.6%, and 20%, respectively. Twenty-seven patients (52.9%) had some urodynamic abnormality, that is, small capacity (5), high voiding pressures (14), genuine stress incontinence (3), and poor compliance (3). Bladder capacity was a significant predictor of bladder dysfunction in our patients.

CONCLUSIONS

In our study, all three surgical approaches were associated with bladder dysfunction, however, it was the least in the laparoscopic transabdominal approach. Postoperative bladder capacity is a significant predictor of bladder dysfunction.

Urinary incontinence following successful closure of obstetric vesicovaginal fistula repair in Southern Ethiopia

BACKGROUND

Urinary incontinence (UI) after successful closure of obstetric vesicovaginal fistula (VVF) repair is a widely recognized public health problem. However, there is insufficient research evaluating the factors associated with UI after successful obstetric VVF repair in Ethiopia.

OBJECTIVES

The main aim of this study was to assess the magnitude and associated factors of UI following the successful closure of obstetric VVF repair at the Yirgalem Hamlin Fistula Center in the Sidama region of southern Ethiopia.

METHODS

A retrospective cross-sectional analytical study was performed on patients who underwent obstetric VVF repair at the Yirgalem Hamlin Fistula Center between 2016 and 2020. The data were collected from September to October 2021. EPI Data Version 3.1 and SPSS Version 25.0 were used for data entry and analysis. A multivariable binary logistic regression model was used for all variables significant in the bivariate binary logistic analysis to determine the association between the independent variables and outcome variables. The data are presented in tables and figures. Variables with a p-value < 0.05 were considered to be statistically associated with the study outcome.

RESULTS

In total, 499 study subjects were included. The magnitude of UI after successful closure of obstetric VVF repair was 23.25%. A Goh type 4 fistula (AOR = 4.289; 95% CI 1.431, 12.852), a fistula size > 3 cm (AOR = 8.855; 95% CI 4.786, 16.382), a partially damaged urethra (AOR = 2.810; 95% CI 1.441, 5.479), and a completely destroyed urethra (AOR = 5.829; 95% CI 2.094, 16.228) were found to be significantly associated factors with the outcome variable.

CONCLUSIONS

Nearly one in four patients who had successful closure of obstetric VVF repair at the Yirgalem Hamlin fistula center had UI, which is above the WHO recommendations. The presence of a Goh type 4 fistula, large fistula size, and damaged urethral status significantly affect the presence of UI. Therefore, interventions are necessary to prevent and manage UI among patients who underwent obstetric VVF repair and had a closed fistula.

Identifying opportunities for prevention of adverse outcomes following female genital fistula repair: protocol for a mixed-methods study in Uganda

BACKGROUND

Female genital fistula is a traumatic debilitating injury, frequently caused by prolonged obstructed labor, affecting between 500,000-2 million women in lower-resource settings. Vesicovaginal fistula causes urinary incontinence, and other morbidity may occur during fistula development. Women with fistula are stigmatized, limit social and economic engagement, and experience psychiatric morbidity. Improved surgical access has reduced fistula consequences yet post-repair risks impacting quality of life and well-being include fistula repair breakdown or recurrence and ongoing or changing urine leakage or incontinence. Limited evidence on risk factors contributing to adverse outcomes hinders interventions to mitigate adverse events. This study aims to quantify these adverse risks and inform clinical and counseling interventions to optimize women's health and quality of life following fistula repair through: identifying predictors and characteristics of post-repair fistula breakdown and recurrence (Objective 1) and post-repair incontinence (Objective 2), and to identify feasible and acceptable intervention strategies (Objective 3).

METHODS

This mixed-methods study incorporates a prospective cohort of women with successful vesicovaginal fistula repair at approximately 12 fistula repair centers in Uganda (Objectives 1-2) followed by qualitative inquiry among key stakeholders (Objective 3). Cohort participants will have a baseline visit at the time of surgery followed by data collection at 2 weeks, 6 weeks, 3 months and quarterly thereafter for 3 years. Primary predictors to be evaluated include patient-related factors, fistula-related factors, fistula repair-related factors, and post-repair behaviors and exposures, collected via structured questionnaire at all data collection points. Clinical exams will be conducted at baseline, 2 weeks post-surgery, and for outcome confirmation at symptom development. Primary outcomes are fistula repair breakdown or fistula recurrence and post-repair incontinence. In-depth interviews will be conducted with cohort participants (n ~ 40) and other key stakeholders (~ 40 including family, peers, community members and clinical/social service providers) to inform feasibility and acceptability of recommendations.

DISCUSSION

Participant recruitment is underway. This study is expected to identify key predictors that can directly improve fistula repair and post-repair programs and women's outcomes, optimizing health and quality of life. Furthermore, our study will create a comprehensive longitudinal dataset capable of supporting broad inquiry into post-fistula repair health. Trial Registration ClinicalTrials.gov Identifier: NCT05437939.

Factors associated with reintegration trajectory following female genital fistula surgery in Uganda

BACKGROUND

A female genital fistula, primarily caused by prolonged obstructed labor or after cesarean delivery in resource-limited countries, affects 500,000 to 2,000,000 women worldwide. Fistula is preventable with timely access to high-quality obstetrical care. Access to surgical repair of a female genital fistula has greatly increased over time. However, research surrounding postrepair reintegration, the process of returning to an individual's normal life, remains limited, and further efforts are needed to understand the factors shaping women's ability to rebuild their relationships and lives following repair.

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to characterize the 12-month reintegration trajectory after female genital fistula repair by participant sociodemographic and clinical characteristics.

STUDY DESIGN

This study analyzed quantitative survey and medical record data of women (N=60) participating in a longitudinal cohort study assessing recovery after genital fistula repair in Uganda, with baseline and 4 quarterly follow-up assessments in 12 months. The primary outcome of reintegration was assessed using a 19-item postfistula repair reintegration instrument (range, 0-100) where a higher score represents better reintegration. Predictors of interest included parity and living children, quality of life, depressive symptoms at baseline, self-esteem, stigma, trauma, physical symptoms, and social support. We described participant baseline characteristics using means and proportions and estimated a series of mixed-effects linear regression models, including interactions of characteristics with time to understand how these characteristics influence reintegration trajectory in the 12 months after repair.

RESULTS

The participants' physical and psychosocial morbidities at baseline were high; more than 80% of participants reported fistula-related physical symptoms, 82% of participants described their general health as poor, and measures of self-esteem, overall social support, and overall quality of life were low. The mean reintegration score at baseline was 33 (standard deviation, 20), which increased to 78 (standard deviation, 19) at 12 months after fistula repair. The participant sociodemographic characteristics statistically associated with reintegration included any living children (β, 1.08; 95% confidence interval, -0.08 to 2.23). Moreover, psychosocial factors significantly affected reintegration with steeper trajectories for women with depressive symptoms (β, 0.89; 95% confidence interval, 0.02-1.75) or women experiencing internalized stigma (β, 0.05; 95% confidence interval, -0.00 to 0.11) and less steep for those with higher self-esteem (β, -0.11; 95% confidence interval, -0.24 to 0.01), overall social support (β, -0.06; 95% confidence interval, -0.12 to -0.01), and partner support (β, -0.21; 95% confidence interval, -0.35 to -0.07).

CONCLUSION

Understanding the prominent factors associated with differences in reintegration trajectories across the year after genital fistula surgery has the potential to inform interventions that mitigate challenges and improve women's postrepair recovery experiences.

The Siege of Ayder Hospital: A Cri de Coeur From Tigray, Ethiopia

The use of rape, starvation, and the destruction of healthcare infrastructure by the Ethiopian government violates the laws of war and the Geneva Conventions.

In November 2020, the federal government of Ethiopia invaded its northern region of Tigray, in collusion with the Government of Eritrea and ethnic Amhara militias. The invading forces pillaged the schools, destroyed the transportation infrastructure, burned crops and killed livestock, and looted the health care system. Thousands of civilians were killed, often in extrajudicial executions. Thousands of Tigrayan women were raped. Tens of thousands of Tigrayans fled to Sudan as refugees. Hundreds of thousands face famine and millions more have been internally displaced. The region is under a total communications blackout. The banking system has collapsed. The federal government has harassed external aid workers and imposed a de facto blockade on all medicines and famine relief. A man-made humanitarian catastrophe unlike any in recent memory is unfolding. The world medical community must speak up. The madness must stop.

Characterizing persistent urinary incontinence after successful fistula closure: the Uganda experience

BACKGROUND

Obstetric fistula is a devastating childbirth injury. Despite successful closure of the fistula, 16% to 55% of women suffer from persistent urinary incontinence after surgery.

OBJECTIVE

This study assessed the type and severity of persistent incontinence after successful fistula closure and its impact on the quality of life of Ugandan women post-fistula treatment.

STUDY DESIGN

This cross-sectional study enrolled women with a history of obstetric fistula repair who continued to have persistent urinary incontinence (cases, N=36) and women without incontinence (controls, N=52) after successful fistula closure. Data were collected in central and eastern Uganda between 2017 and 2019. All the participants completed a semistructured questionnaire. Cases underwent a clinical evaluation and a 2-hour pad test and completed a series of incontinence questionnaires, including two novel tools designed to assess the severity of incontinence in low-literacy populations.

RESULTS

Cases were more likely to have acquired a fistula during their first delivery (63% vs 37%, P=.02), were younger when they developed a fistula (20.3±5.8 vs 24.8±7.5 years old, P=.003), and were more likely to have had >2 fistula surgeries (67% vs 2%, P≤.001). Cases reported a much higher rate of planned home birth for their index pregnancy compared to controls (44% vs 11%), though only 14% of cases and 12% of controls actually delivered at home. Cases reported higher rates of pain with intercourse (36% vs 18%, P=.05), but recent sexual activity status (intercourse within the previous six months) was not significantly different between the groups (47% vs 62%, P=.18). Among cases, 67% reported stress incontinence, 47% reported urgency incontinence, and 47% reported mixed incontinence. The cough stress test was successfully done with 92% of the cases, and of these, almost all (97%) had a positive cough stress test. More than half (53%) rated their incontinence as "very severe," which was consistent with objective findings. The 24-hour voiding diary indicated both high urinary frequency (average 14) and very frequent leakage episodes (average 20). Two-hour pad-tests indicated that 86% of cases had >4 g change in pad weight within 2 hours. Women with more severe incontinence reported a more negative impact on their quality of life. The mean score of the International Consultation on Incontinence Questionnaire-Quality of Life was 62.77±12.76 (range, 28-76, median=67), with a higher score indicating a greater impact on the quality of life. There was also a high mental health burden, with both cases and controls reporting high rates of suicidal ideation at any point since developing fistula (36% vs 31%, P=.67).

CONCLUSION

Women with obstetric fistulas continue to suffer from severe persistent urinary incontinence even after successful fistula closure. Both stress and urgency incontinence are highly prevalent in this population. Worsening severity of incontinence is associated with a greater negative impact on the quality of life.

Contemporary Issues in Obstetric Fistula

We discuss a variety of contemporary issues relating to obstetric fistula. These include definitions of these injuries, the etiologic mechanisms by which fistulas occur, the role of specialist fistula centers in diagnosis and management, the classification of fistulas, and the assessment of surgical outcomes. We also review the growing need for complex reconstructive surgical procedures, follow-up challenges, and the transition to a fistula-free world in which other pathologies (such as pelvic organ prolapse) will be of increasing importance. Finally, we discuss the need to develop responsive systems of maternal health care that treat women with competence, compassion, respect, and fairness.

Provider Perspectives on Persistent Urinary Incontinence Following Obstetric Fistula Repair in Ethiopia

Each year an estimated 50,000 to 100,000 women worldwide are affected by obstetric fistula. This devastating but preventable maternal morbidity leaves women incontinent, stigmatized, isolated, and often with a still birth. While fistula rates in Ethiopia have declined in recent years, estimates range from 7 to 40 percent of women suffer from persistent urinary incontinence after successful closure of their fistula. Few studies have focused on the unique experiences and challenges that providers face treating fistula patients, particularly those who experience persistent urinary incontinence. The goal of this research is to characterize the fistula provider's accounts of how to manage, support, and understand their patient's experience. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with a purposive sample of fistula care providers in Mekelle and Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. The main themes that emerged were a perceived exacerbated impact on quality of life for women with persistent urinary incontinence; a “double hit” of isolation from both their community and from other recovered fistula patients; how the church both influences how patients internalize their injury and provides them with hope and support; and the need for comprehensive and compassionate fistula care. Understanding how providers perceive and relate to their patients provides valuable insight to the unique challenges of treating this population and may better inform treatment programmes to address the gap between patient needs and current fistula care models.