Describing transition metal homogeneous catalysis using the random phase approximation

Frozen-Core Analytical Gradients within the Adiabatic Connection Random-Phase Approximation from an Extended Lagrangian

The implementation of the frozen-core option in combination with the analytic gradient of the random-phase approximation (RPA) is reported based on a density functional theory reference determinant using resolution-of-the-identity techniques and an extended Lagrangian. The frozen-core option reduces the dimensionality of the matrices required for the RPA analytic gradient, thereby yielding a reduction in computational cost. A frozen core also reduces the size of the numerical frequency grid required for accurate treatment of the correlation contributions using Curtis-Clenshaw quadratures, leading to an additional speedup. Optimized geometries for closed-shell, main-group, and transition metal compounds, as well as open-shell transition metal complexes, show that the frozen-core method on average elongates bonds by at most a few picometers and changes bond angles by a few degrees. Vibrational frequencies and dipole moments also show modest shifts from the all-electron results, reinforcing the broad usefulness of the frozen-core method. Timings for linear alkanes, a novel extended metal atom chain and a palladacyclic complex show a speedup of 35-55% using a reduced grid size and the frozen-core option. Overall, our results demonstrate the utility of combining the frozen-core option with RPA to obtain accurate molecular properties, thereby further extending the range of application of the RPA method.

Efficient Implementation of the Random Phase Approximation with Domain-Based Local Pair Natural Orbitals

We present an efficient implementation of the direct random phase approximation (RPA) for molecular systems within the domain-based local pair natural orbital (DLPNO) framework. With recommended loose, normal, and tight parameter settings, DLPNO-RPA achieves approximately 99.7-99.95% accuracy in the total correlation energy compared to a canonical implementation, enabling highly accurate reaction energies and potential energy surfaces to be computed while substantially reducing computational costs. As an application, we demonstrate the capability of DLPNO-RPA to efficiently calculate basis set-converged binding energies for a set of large molecules, with results showing excellent agreement with high-level reference data from both coupled cluster and diffusion Monte Carlo. This development paves the way for the routine use of RPA-based methods in molecular quantum chemistry.

Symmetry Breaking in a Triferrous Extended Metal Atom Chain

Semilocal and random phase approximation (RPA) density functional theory (DFT) and complete active space (CASSCF + NEVPT2) methodologies were applied to investigate a new class of extended metal atom chain (EMAC) complexes. A novel triferrous complex has been synthesized recently that does not utilize the usual 2,2'-dipyridylamine (dpa) ligand framework, which essentially always results in a tetragonal coordination environment and general formula M3(dpa)4X2, where X is an anion. Instead, the triferrous complex utilizes a dianionic, 2,6-bis(trimethylsilylamido)pyridine ligand (L2-) resulting in the formation of trigonal complexes with general formula Fe3L3. To better understand the electronic structure of this complex, calculations were utilized to explore the experimentally isolated Fe3L3, and a smaller theoretical complex, in order to compare and contrast with the traditional dpa-based EMACs. Due to the absence of anionic, axial ligands, the sigma nonbonding orbitals formed from the metal d orbitals are lower in energy than in the dpa complexes, and compete with the pi bonding orbitals for occupation in the Fe3L3 complex. While the idealized geometry of these complexes is D3h, a helical distortion of the ligands and subsequent electronic symmetry breaking due to Jahn-Teller distortions are predicted utilizing both semilocal and RPA DFT methods, ending in a C2 structure that closely matches the reported crystal structure. Predicted Mössbauer isomer shifts and ultraviolet/visible (UV/vis) spectra also agree with the experimental data available in the literature. Magnetic coupling constants also indicate ferromagnetic coupling between nearest neighbor irons. Two-dimensional (2D) potential energy surfaces were calculated for a range of fixed Fe-Fe bond lengths, revealing a flat potential energy surface over a wide range of Fe-Fe bond lengths and verifying the ability of RPA to act as a higher-level check on semilocal DFT results. In order to verify the predicted high-spin ground state, CASSCF + NEVPT2 was applied to selected molecular configurations and confirmed the predictions made by DFT. These calculations shed light on the physical ground state electron configuration of Fe3L3 and correlate this electronic configuration with the available experimental data.

Chelate Complexes of 3d Transition Metal Ions─A Challenge for Electronic-Structure Methods?

Different electronic-structure methods were assessed for their ability to predict two important properties of the industrially relevant chelating agent nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA): its selectivity with respect to six different first-row transition metal ions and the spin-state energetics of its complex with Fe(III). The investigated methods encompassed density functional theory (DFT), the random phase approximation (RPA), coupled cluster (CC) theory, and the auxiliary-field quantum Monte Carlo (AFQMC) method, as well as the complete active space self-consistent field (CASSCF) method and the respective on-top methods: second-order N-electron valence state perturbation theory (NEVPT2) and multiconfiguration pair-density functional theory (MC-PDFT). Different strategies for selecting active spaces were explored, and the density matrix renormalization group (DMRG) approach was used to solve the largest active spaces. Despite somewhat ambiguous multi-reference diagnostics, most methods gave relatively good agreement with experimental data for the chemical reactions connected to the selectivity, which only involved transition-metal complexes in their high-spin state. CC methods yielded the highest accuracy followed by range-separated DFT and AFQMC. We discussed in detail that even higher accuracies can be obtained with NEVPT2, under the prerequisite that consistent active spaces along the entire chemical reaction can be selected, which was not the case for reactions involving Fe(III). A bigger challenge for electronic-structure methods was the prediction of the spin-state energetics, which additionally involved lower spin states that exhibited larger multi-reference diagnostics. Conceptually different, typically accurate methods ranging from CC theory via DMRG-NEVPT2 in combination with large active spaces to AFQMC agreed well that the high-spin state is energetically significantly favored over the other spin states. This was in contrast to most DFT functionals and RPA which yielded a smaller stabilization and some common DFT functionals and MC-PDFT even predicting the low-spin state to be energetically most favorable.

Hybrid RPA:DFT Approach for Adsorption on Transition Metal Surfaces: Methane and Ethane on Platinum (111)

The hybrid QM:QM approach is extended to adsorption on transition metal surfaces. The random phase approximation (RPA) as the high-level method is applied to cluster models and, using the subtractive scheme, embedded in periodic models which are treated with density functional theory (DFT) that is the low-level method. The PBE functional, both without dispersion and augmented with the many-body dispersion (MBD), is employed. Adsorption of methane and ethane on the Pt(111) surface is studied. For methane in a 2 × 2 surface cell, the hybrid RPA:PBE and RPA:PBE+MBD results, -14.3 and -16.0 kJ mol-1, respectively, are in close agreement with the periodic RPA value of -13.8 kJ mol-1 at significantly reduced computational cost (factor of ∼50). For methane and ethane, the RPA:PBE results (-14.3 and -17.8 kJ mol-1, respectively) indicate underbinding relative to energies derived from experimental desorption barriers for relevant loadings (-15.6 ± 1.6 and -27.2 ± 2.9 kJ mol-1, respectively), whereas the hybrid RPA:PBE+MBD results (-16.0 and -24.9 kJ mol-1, respectively) agree with the experiment well within experimental uncertainty limits (deviation of -0.4 ± 1.5 and +2.3 ± 2.9 kJ mol-1, respectively). Finding a cluster that adequately and robustly represents the adsorbate at the bulk surface is important for the success of the RPA-based QM:QM scheme for metals.

Toward Pair Atomic Density Fitting for Correlation Energies with Benchmark Accuracy

Pair atomic density fitting (PADF) has been identified as a promising strategy to reduce the scaling with system size of quantum chemical methods for the calculation of the correlation energy like the direct random-phase approximation (RPA) or second-order Møller-Plesset perturbation theory (MP2). PADF can however introduce large errors in correlation energies as the two-electron interaction energy is not guaranteed to be bounded from below. This issue can be partially alleviated by using very large fit sets, but this comes at the price of reduced efficiency and having to deal with near-linear dependencies in the fit set. One posibility is to use global density fitting (DF), but in this work, we introduce an alternative methodology to overcome this problem that preserves the intrinsically favorable scaling of PADF. We first regularize the Fock matrix by projecting out parts of the basis set which gives rise to orbital products that are hard to describe by PADF. After having thus obtained a reliable self-consistent field solution, we then also apply this projector to the orbital coefficient matrix to improve the precision of PADF-MP2 and PADF-RPA. We systematically assess the accuracy of this new approach in a numerical atomic orbital framework using Slater type orbitals (STO) and correlation consistent Gaussian type basis sets up to quintuple-ζ quality for systems with more than 200 atoms. For the small and medium systems in the S66 database we show the maximum deviation of PADF-MP2 and PADF-RPA relative correlation energies to DF-MP2 and DF-RPA reference results to be 0.07 and 0.14 kcal/mol, respectively. When the new projector method is used, the errors only slightly increase for large molecules and also when moderately sized fit sets are used the resulting errors are well under control. Finally, we demonstrate the computational efficiency of our algorithm by calculating the interaction energies of large, non-covalently bound complexes with more than 1000 atoms and 20000 atomic orbitals at the RPA@PBE/CC-pVTZ level of theory.

PtOx Cly (OH)z (H2 O)n Complexes under Oxidative and Reductive Conditions: Impact of the Level of Theory on Thermodynamic Stabilities

Platinum-based catalysts with Cl^- , OH^- , O^2- and H₂ O ligands, are involved in many industrial processes. Their final chemical properties are impacted by calcination and reduction applied during the preparation and activation steps. We investigate their stability under these reactive conditions with density functional theory (DFT). We benchmark various functionals (PBE-dDsC, optPBE, B3LYP, HSE06, PBE0, TPSS, RTPSS and SCAN) against ACFDT-RPA. PBE-dDsC is well adapted, although hybrid functionals are more accurate for redox reactions. Thermodynamic phase diagrams are determined by computing the chemical potential of the species as a function of temperature and partial pressures of H₂ O, HCl, O₂ and H₂ . The stability and nature of the Pt species are highly sensitive to the activation conditions. Under O₂ , high temperatures favour PtO₂ while under H₂ , platinum is easily reduced to Pt(0). Chlorine modifies the coordination sphere of platinum during calcination by stabilizing PtCl₄ and shifts the reduction of platinum to higher temperatures under H₂ .

Assessment of the Second-Order Statically Screened Exchange Correction to the Random Phase Approximation for Correlation Energies

With increasing interelectronic distance, the screening of the electron–electron interaction by the presence of other electrons becomes the dominant source of electron correlation. This effect is described by the random phase approximation (RPA) which is therefore a promising method for the calculation of weak interactions. The success of the RPA relies on the cancellation of errors, which can be traced back to the violation of the crossing symmetry of the 4-point vertex, leading to strongly overestimated total correlation energies. By the addition of second-order screened exchange (SOSEX) to the correlation energy, this issue is substantially reduced. In the adiabatic connection (AC) SOSEX formalism, one of the two electron–electron interaction lines in the second-order exchange term is dynamically screened (SOSEX(W, v_c)). A related SOSEX expression in which both electron–electron interaction lines are statically screened (SOSEX(W(0), W(0))) is obtained from the G3W2 contribution to the electronic self-energy. In contrast to SOSEX(W, v_c), the evaluation of this correlation energy expression does not require an expensive numerical frequency integration and is therefore advantageous from a computational perspective. We compare the accuracy of the statically screened variant to RPA and RPA+SOSEX(W, v_c) for a wide range of chemical reactions. While both methods fail for barrier heights, SOSEX(W(0), W(0)) agrees very well with SOSEX(W, v_c) for charged excitations and noncovalent interactions where they lead to major improvements over RPA.

Energies, structures, and harmonic frequencies of small water clusters from the direct random phase approximation

The binding energies, structures, and vibrational frequencies of water clusters up to 20 molecules are computed at the direct random phase approximation (RPA) level of theory and compared to theoretical benchmarks. Binding energies of the WATER27 set, which includes neutral and positively and negatively charged clusters, are predicted to be too low in the complete basis set limit by an average of 7 kcal/mol (9%) and are worse than the results from the best density functional theory methods or from the Møller-Plesset theory. The RPA shows significant basis set size dependence for binding energies. The order of the relative energies of the water hexamer and dodecamer isomers is predicted correctly by the RPA. The mean absolute deviation for angles and distances for neutral clusters up to the water hexamer are 0.2° and 0.6 pm, respectively, using quintuple-ζ basis sets. The relative energetic order of the hexamer isomers is preserved upon optimization. Vibrational frequencies for these systems are underestimated by several tens of wavenumbers for large basis sets, and deviations increase with the basis set size. Overall, the direct RPA method yields accurate structural parameters but systematically underestimates binding energies and shows strong basis set size dependence.

Selfconsistent random phase approximation methods

This Perspective reviews recent efforts toward selfconsistent calculations of ground-state energies within the random phase approximation (RPA) in the (generalized) Kohn-Sham (KS) density functional theory context. Since the RPA correlation energy explicitly depends on the non-interacting KS potential, an additional condition to determine the energy as a functional of the density is necessary. This observation leads to the concept of functional selfconsistency (FSC), which requires that the KS density equals the interacting density defined as the functional derivative of the ground-state energy with respect to the external potential. While all existing selfconsistent RPA schemes violate FSC, the recent generalized KS semicanonical projected RPA (GKS-spRPA) method takes a step toward satisfying it. This leads to systematic improvements in densities, binding energy curves, reference state stability, and molecular properties compared to non-selfconsistent RPA as well as optimized effective potential RPA. GKS-spRPA orbital energies accurately approximate valence and core ionization potentials, and even electron affinities of non-valence bound anions. The computational cost and performance of GKS-spRPA are compared to those of related selfconsistent schemes, including GW and orbital optimization methods, and limitations are discussed. Large differences between KS and interacting densities observed in the absence of FSC and the well-rounded performance of GKS-spRPA suggest that the KS potential as a density functional should be defined via the FSC condition for explicitly potential-dependent density functionals.

Investigation of the rhodium-catalyzed hydroboration of NHC-boranes: the role of alkene coordination and the origin of enantioselectivity

The mechanism of the intramolecular enantioselective rhodium(i)-catalyzed hydroboration of NHC-boranes is investigated by experiments and calculations, using Density Functional Theory and Random Phase Approximation methods.