Zoledronic Acid in a Mouse Model of Human Fibrous Dysplasia: Ineffectiveness on Tissue Pathology, Formation of "Giant Osteoclasts" and Pathogenetic Implications

Patient-Derived Organoids Recapitulate Pathological Intrinsic and Phenotypic Features of Fibrous Dysplasia

Fibrous dysplasia (FD) is a rare bone disorder characterized by the replacement of normal bone with benign fibro-osseous tissue. Developments in our understanding of the pathophysiology and treatment options are impeded by the lack of suitable research models. In this study, we developed an in vitro organotypic model capable of recapitulating key intrinsic and phenotypic properties of FD. Initially, transcriptomic profiling of individual cells isolated from patient lesional tissues unveiled intralesional molecular and cellular heterogeneity. Leveraging these insights, we established patient-derived organoids (PDOs) using primary cells obtained from patient FD lesions. Evaluation of PDOs demonstrated preservation of fibrosis-associated constituent cell types and transcriptional signatures observed in FD lesions. Additionally, PDOs retained distinct constellations of genomic and metabolic alterations characteristic of FD. Histological evaluation further corroborated the fidelity of PDOs in recapitulating important phenotypic features of FD that underscore their pathophysiological relevance. Our findings represent meaningful progress in the field, as they open up the possibility for in vitro modeling of rare bone lesions in a three-dimensional context and may signify the first step towards creating a personalized platform for research and therapeutic studies.

A pathogenic role for brain-derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) in fibrous dysplasia of bone

Brain derived neurotrophic factor (BDNF) is a neurotrophin, expressed in the central nervous system and in peripheral tissues, that is regulated by the Gsα/cAMP pathway. In bone, it regulates osteogenesis and stimulates RANKL secretion and osteoclast formation in osteolytic tumors such as Multiple Myeloma. Fibrous dysplasia (FD) of bone is a rare genetic disease of the skeleton caused by gain-of-function mutations of the Gsα gene in which RANKL-dependent enhanced bone resorption is a major cause of bone fragility and clinical morbidity. We observed that BDNF transcripts are expressed in human FD lesions. Specifically, immunolocalization studies performed on biopsies obtained from FD patients revealed the expression of BDNF in osteoblasts and, to a lower extent, in the spindle-shaped cells within the fibrous tissue. Therefore, we hypothesized that BDNF can play a role in the pathogenesis of FD by stimulating RANKL secretion and bone resorption. To test this hypothesis, we used the EF1α-GsαR201C mouse model of the human disease (FD mice). Western blot analysis revealed a higher expression of BDNF in bone segments of FD mice compared to WT mice and the immunolabeling pattern within mouse FD lesions was similar to that observed in human FD. Treatment of FD mice with a monoclonal antibody against BDNF reduced the fibrous tissue along with the number of osteoclasts and osteoblasts within femoral lesions. These results reveal BDNF as a new player in the pathogenesis of FD and a potential molecular mechanism by which osteoclastogenesis may be nourished within FD bone lesions. They also suggest that BDNF inhibition may be a new approach to reduce abnormal bone remodeling in FD.

Denosumab use in bone fibrous dysplasia refractory to bisphosphonate: A retrospective multicentric study

INTRODUCTION

Increased RANKL expression is observed in the bone tissue of fibrous dysplasia of bone/McCune-Albright syndrome (FD/MAS). In one animal model of FD/MAS, the inhibition of RANKL reduced tumor volume. A beneficial effect of denosumab on pain in patients refractory to bisphosphonates has been reported, but without systematic quantification of pain improvement. This work describes the clinical experience of our group on the efficacy on pain of denosumab treatment, along with safety, in FD/MAS patients refractory to bisphosphonates.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

We have conducted a retrospective multicenter study in 6 academic rheumatology centers in France. We have collected patients and FD/MAS characteristics, duration of prior exposure to bisphosphonates, denosumab treatment modalities (dosage - administration regimen - number of courses); evolution of pain evaluated by Visual Analogic Scale (VAS).

RESULTS

13 patients were included (10 women and 3 men) 45 years on average, 5 MAS, 4 monostotic and 4 polyostotic forms. The average duration post-diagnosis of FD/MAS was 25 years and the mean duration of prior exposure to bisphosphonates was 4.7 years. Pain could be analyzed in 7 patients, showing a significant improvement from a mean VAS of 7.8 to 2.9 (-4.9 points, p = 0.003). In one patient with fronto-orbital FD/MAS, a 30 % decrease in lesional volume, assessed by MRI, was observed within 6 months of treatment, that was sustained over the following 12 months. Treatment regimens were heterogeneous. No hypercalcemia was observed after treatment cessation and the clinical tolerance was good.

DISCUSSION

This study suggests that denosumab reduces pain in patients with DF/MAS refractory to bisphosphonates, and quantifies this improvement for the first time in a multicenter study. In our cohort, no patients who discontinued denosumab developed hypercalcemia and clinical tolerance was overall good. This study also provides encouraging data regarding lesion volume control. Further controlled studies are required to determine the place and modalities of the denosumab treatment of FD/MAS.

CONCLUSION

Denosumab significantly decreased pain in FD/MAS refractory to bisphosphonate. This study paves the way for a randomized clinical trial to validate and standardize the prescription of denosumab in FD/MAS.

GsαR201C and estrogen reveal different subsets of bone marrow adiponectin expressing osteogenic cells

The Gsα/cAMP signaling pathway mediates the effect of a variety of hormones and factors that regulate the homeostasis of the post-natal skeleton. Hence, the dysregulated activity of Gsα due to gain-of-function mutations (R201C/R201H) results in severe architectural and functional derangements of the entire bone/bone marrow organ. While the consequences of gain-of-function mutations of Gsα have been extensively investigated in osteoblasts and in bone marrow osteoprogenitor cells at various differentiation stages, their effect in adipogenically-committed bone marrow stromal cells has remained unaddressed. We generated a mouse model with expression of GsαR201C driven by the Adiponectin (Adq) promoter. Adq-GsαR201C mice developed a complex combination of metaphyseal, diaphyseal and cortical bone changes. In the metaphysis, GsαR201C caused an early phase of bone resorption followed by bone deposition. Metaphyseal bone formation was sustained by cells that were traced by Adq-Cre and eventually resulted in a high trabecular bone mass phenotype. In the diaphysis, GsαR201C, in combination with estrogen, triggered the osteogenic activity of Adq-Cre-targeted perivascular bone marrow stromal cells leading to intramedullary bone formation. Finally, consistent with the previously unnoticed presence of Adq-Cre-marked pericytes in intraosseous blood vessels, GsαR201C caused the development of a lytic phenotype that affected both cortical (increased porosity) and trabecular (tunneling resorption) bone. These results provide the first evidence that the Adq-cell network in the skeleton not only regulates bone resorption but also contributes to bone formation, and that the Gsα/cAMP pathway is a major modulator of both functions.

RANKL inhibition halts lesion progression and promotes bone remineralization in mice with fibrous dysplasia

Fibrous dysplasia (FD) is a rare bone disease caused by GNAS mutation in skeletal stem cells, typically originating from and worsening in childhood. Till now, no cure for FD exists despite the well-recognized etiology. Studies have demonstrated that osteoclastogenesis hyperactivity is caused by elevated RANKL expression, making RANKL inhibition a potential therapy. Although a human monoclonal anti-RANKL antibody, denosumab, has been used in FD patients, the effects and mechanisms of RANKL inhibition for FD treatment require assessment. Denosumab is expensive and can only be injected. Therefore, formulating an oral-administered, cost-effective medicine is encouraged. In the current study, we evaluated the effects of a small-molecule RANKL inhibitor, AS2676293, on a transgenic FD mouse model. AS2676293 effectively suppressed osteoclastogenesis and halted FD progression. The pre-existing bone defects were primarily replaced by newly formed mineralized bone after two weeks of AS2676293 administration. The potent RANKL inhibitory effect and easier route of delivery make AS2676293 a promising target therapy of FD. Results from our study suggested that RANKL inhibition is effective in halting FD progression and promoting bone remineralization, which could benefit the patients with early onset of FD.

Fibrous dysplasia animal models: A systematic review

BACKGROUND

Fibrous dysplasia (FD) is a rare genetic bone disorder resulting in an overproduction of cAMP leading to a structurally unsound tissue, caused by a genetic mutation in the guanine nucleotide-binding protein gene (GNAS). In order to better understand this disease, several animal models have been developed with different strategies and features.

OBJECTIVE

Conduct a systematic review to analyze and compare animal models with the causative mutation and features of FD.

METHODS

A PRISMA search was conducted in Scopus, PubMed, and Web of Science. Studies reporting an in vivo model of FD that expressed the causative mutation were included for analysis. Models without the causative mutation, but developed an FD phenotype and models of FD cell implantation were included for subanalysis.

RESULTS

Seven unique models were identified. The models were assessed and compared for their face validity, construct validity, mosaicism, and induction methods. This was based on the features of clinical FD that were reported within the categories of: macroscopic features, imaging, histology and histomorphometry, histochemical and cellular markers, and blood/urine markers.

LIMITATIONS

None of the models reported all features of FD and some features were only reported in one model. This made comparing models a challenge, but indicates areas where further research is necessary.

CONCLUSION

The benefits and disadvantages of every model were assessed from a practical and scientific standpoint. While all published reports lacked complete data, the models have nonetheless informed our understanding of FD and provided meaningful information to guide researchers in bench and clinical research.

Nanostring technology on Fibrous Dysplasia bone biopsies. A pilot study suggesting different histology-related molecular profiles

Identifying the molecular networks that underlie Fibrous Dysplasia (FD) is key to understand the pathogenesis of the disease, to refine current diagnostic approaches and to develop efficacious therapies. In this study, we used the NanoString nCounter Analysis System to investigate the gene signature of a series of nine Formalin Fixed Decalcified and Paraffin-Embedded (FFDPE) bone biopsies from seven FD patients.

We analyzed the expression level of 770 genes. Unsupervised clustering analysis demonstrated partitioning into two clusters with distinct patterns of gene expression. Differentially expressed genes included growth factors, components of the Wnt signaling system, interleukins and some of their cognate receptors, ephrin ligands, matrix metalloproteinases, neurotrophins and genes encoding components of the cAMP-dependent protein kinase. Interestingly, two tissue samples obtained from the same skeletal site of one patient one year apart failed to segregate in the same cluster. Retrospective histological review of the samples revealed different microscopic aspects in the two groups.

The results of our pilot study suggest that the genetic signature of FD is heterogeneous and varies according to the histology and, likely, to the age of the lesion. In addition, they show that the Nanostring technology is a valuable tool for molecular translational studies on archival FFDPE material in FD and other rare bone diseases.

•

We used the NanoString technology to analyze Formalin Fixed Decalcified Paraffin Embedded (FFDPE) Fibrous Dysplasia samples.

•

We show that Fibrous Dysplasia lesions may have different molecular profiles consistent with its histological heterogeneity.

•

NanoString technology is a valuable tool for molecular studies on rare bone diseases by using FFDPE archival material.

From Stem Cells to Bone-Forming Cells

Bone formation starts near the end of the embryonic stage of development and continues throughout life during bone modeling and growth, remodeling, and when needed, regeneration. Bone-forming cells, traditionally termed osteoblasts, produce, assemble, and control the mineralization of the type I collagen-enriched bone matrix while participating in the regulation of other cell processes, such as osteoclastogenesis, and metabolic activities, such as phosphate homeostasis. Osteoblasts are generated by different cohorts of skeletal stem cells that arise from different embryonic specifications, which operate in the pre-natal and/or adult skeleton under the control of multiple regulators. In this review, we briefly define the cellular identity and function of osteoblasts and discuss the main populations of osteoprogenitor cells identified to date. We also provide examples of long-known and recently recognized regulatory pathways and mechanisms involved in the specification of the osteogenic lineage, as assessed by studies on mice models and human genetic skeletal diseases.