Accessory anterolateral talar facet associated with tarsal coalition: prevalence and cross-sectional characterization

How accurate is MRI for diagnosing tarsal coalitions? A retrospective diagnostic accuracy study

OBJECTIVES

This study aimed to evaluate the diagnostic accuracy, inter-reader agreement, and associated pathologies on MR images of patients with confirmed TC.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

In this retrospective study, 168 ankle MRI exams were included, consisting of 56 patients with clinically or surgically confirmed TC and 112 controls without TC, matched for age and sex. Images were analyzed independently by three radiologists blinded to clinical information. The evaluation criteria included the presence, type, and location of TC, as well as associated pathologies. After calculating diagnostic accuracy and the odds ratio of demographic data and anatomic coalition type for associated pathologies, inter-reader agreement was assessed using kappa statistics.

RESULTS

The majority of TCs were non-osseous (91.1%) and located at the calcaneonavicular (33.9%) or talocalcaneal joint (66.1%). Associated pathologies included adjacent and distant bone marrow edema (57.1% and 25.0%), osteochondral defect of the talar dome (OCD, 19.6%), and joint effusion (10.7%) and accessory anterolateral talar facet (17.9%). Talar OCD was associated with increased patient age (p = 0.03). MRI exhibited a cumulative sensitivity and specificity of 95.8% and 94.3% with almost perfect inter-reader agreement (κ = 0.895).

CONCLUSION

MRI is a reliable method for detecting tarsal coalition and identifying commonly associated pathologies. Therefore, we recommend the routine use of MRI in the diagnostic workup of patients with foot pain and suspected tarsal coalition.

CLINICAL RELEVANCE STATEMENT

MRI is an accurate and reliable modality for diagnosing tarsal coalitions and detecting associated pathologies, while improving patient safety compared to computed tomography by avoiding radiation exposure.

KEY POINTS

• Despite the technological progress in magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), computed tomography (CT) is still regarded as the gold standard for diagnosing tarsal coalition (TC). • MRI had a cumulative sensitivity of 95.8% and specificity of 94.3% for detecting tarsal coalition with an almost perfect inter-reader agreement. • MRI demonstrates high accuracy and reliability in diagnosing tarsal coalitions and is useful for identifying associated pathologies, while also improving patient safety by avoiding radiation exposure.

Are enlarged peroneal tubercle and accessory anterolateral talar facet associated with calcaneal spur?

BACKGROUND

As the anatomical variations of the foot, enlarged peroneal tubercle (EPT) and accessory anterolateral talar facet (AALTF) have attracted the attention of foot surgeons in recent years. However, EPT and AALTF have not been examined for a relationship with calcaneus spur (CS) as a common osteophyte.

METHODS

The subjects were 369 individuals who died in northeastern Thailand and were preserved as skeletal specimens. The authors examined for the presence of left and right EPT, AALTF, and calcaneus spur (CS). We divided the EPT (+) group with EPT and the EPT (-) group without it and also divided the AALTF (+) group with AALTF and the AALTF (-) group without it. The age at death and the presence of CS were compared statistically between the EPT (+) and EPT (-) groups and between the AATLF (+) and AALTF (-) groups.

RESULTS

Out of the total 369 cases, EPT was found in 117 cases (31.7%), AALTF was positive in 91 cases (24.7%), and CS was found in 194 cases (52.3%). In comparison between EPT (+) and EPT (-) groups, CS was significantly higher (p < 0.0001) in the EPT (+) group, but there was no significant difference in age at death. In comparison between AALTF (+) and AALTF (-) groups, there was no significant difference in age at death or CS.

CONCLUSION

This study showed a strong relationship between EPT and CS, and the prevalence of EPT and AALTF by age in Thailand was first reported. We believe it helps to know the pathogenesis and biomechanism of EPT and AALTF.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

Not applicable.

Accessory Talar Facet Impingement and Sinus Tarsi Pain Associated With Accessory Anterolateral Talar Facet

BACKGROUND

Sinus tarsi pain caused by accessory talar facet impingement (ATFI) owing to accessory anterolateral talar facet (AALTF) is not well documented. We evaluated prevalence of AALTF and differences of magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) findings between persons with and without sinus tarsi pain, and investigated the relevant association between MRI findings and sinus tarsi pain in persons with AALTF.

METHODS

We performed a case-control study on 120 ankles with sinus tarsi pain and 120 age- and gender-matched ankles without sinus tarsi pain. As MRI findings, bone marrow edema (BME), sinus tarsi fat obliteration (STFO), calcaneal cyst, talocalcaneal coalition, Gissane angle, talar inferolateral surface (TILS) angle, and calcaneal cortical thickness (CCT) were evaluated. The MRI findings were compared between persons with and without sinus tarsi pain, and between persons with and without AALTF. Among persons with AALTF, MRI findings were compared between those with and without sinus tarsi pain. Relevant association was evaluated between MRI findings and sinus tarsi pain in persons with AALTF.

RESULTS

Presence of AALTF, BME, and STFO were significantly higher in the group with sinus tarsi pain. The Gissane angle was significantly smaller, and the TILS angle and CCT were significantly larger in the group with sinus tarsi pain. The BME (OR 7.571, CI 1.453-39.446) and small Gissane angle (OR 0.891, CI 0.804-0.986) were significantly associated with sinus tarsi pain in persons with the AALTF.

CONCLUSION

The study provides evidence for ATFI related to impingement of an AALTF associated with talocalcaneal BME.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level III, case-control study.