A prospective observational study on the long-term results of 90Yttrium citrate radiosynoviorthesis of synovitis in osteoarthritis of the knee joint

Safety and Efficacy of Radiosynoviorthesis: A Prospective Canadian Multicenter Study

Radiosynoviorthesis is approved in several European countries and the United States to treat refractory synovitis in many inflammatory joint diseases, such as rheumatoid arthritis, spondyloarthropathies, and other arthritic joint diseases. No radiopharmaceuticals for radiosynoviorthesis are currently approved in Canada. The aim of this Health Canada-approved trial was to demonstrate the safety and efficacy of radiosynoviorthesis. Methods: Between July 2012 and November 2017, we conducted a multicenter, prospective, interventional Canadian trial. Patients (n = 360) with synovitis refractory to standard treatments after failing 2 intraarticular glucocorticoid injections were included. They were followed up at 3, 6, and 12 mo. Outcome measures included adverse events (AEs) and clinical signs of synovitis (pain, swelling, and joint effusion) measured with the Health Assessment Questionnaire Disability Index, the Disease Activity Score, and the Visual Analog Scale. Results: In total, 392 joints were treated, including those reinjected after 6 mo (n = 34). Of these, 83.4% (327/392) were injected with [90Y]Y-citrate for the knees and 9.9% (39/392) with [186Re]Re-sulfide for medium-sized joints. Of the joints treated, 82.7% (324/392) were knees. Fifty-five AEs, most of them of mild grade, occurred and resolved without sequelae and were not life-threatening. The incidence of radiosynoviorthesis-related AEs was 9.4% (34/360). The proportion of patients showing an improvement in synovitis symptoms after radiosynoviorthesis was significant at 3 mo and was maintained up to 12 mo (P < 0.001). Conclusion: This study confirmed the safety of radiosynoviorthesis in the treatment of patients with synovitis refractory to standard treatments. There is evidence of sustained clinical efficacy at 12 mo, suggesting that radiosynoviorthesis is an effective treatment for improving synovitis symptoms.

Recurrence-Free Survival after Synovectomy and Subsequent Radiosynoviorthesis in Patients with Synovitis of the Knee-A Retrospective Data Analysis

BACKGROUND

Persistent knee synovitis leads to joint discomfort, incapacitating inflammation, and functional limitations. The conventional approach has involved surgical procedures to eliminate the actively inflamed synovial membrane. This study aims to investigate the recurrence-free survival and functional outcome after synovectomy and subsequent radiosynoviorthesis (RSO) in patients with knee synovitis.

METHODS

Thirty-seven knees diagnosed with pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS), rheumatoid arthritis (RA), and peripheral spondyloarthritis underwent synovectomy and subsequent RSO between May 2005 and October 2016. The mean age was 34.9 ± 15.1 years, and the mean follow-up period was 84 ± 36.4 months. Clinical outcomes were assessed using the Oxford Knee Score and the presence of swelling and pain at the last follow-up. Recurrence-free survival denotes the duration from synovectomy to surgical re-synovectomy.

RESULTS

In general, twelve knees underwent re-synovectomy after a mean follow-up of 34.8 ± 24.9 months. The recurrence-free survival was 83.8% at two years, 71.3% at five years, and 61.7% at ten years. The subgroup analysis revealed recurrence-free survival at two years in 63.6% of patients with PVNS, 86.7% of those with RA, and 100% of individuals with peripheral spondyloarthritis.

CONCLUSIONS

This study demonstrates that combined therapy for synovitis is an effective approach, significantly improving clinical outcomes.

Radiosynoviorthesis: almost seventy years of experience but still somewhat fameless

Radiosynoviorthesis (RSO) or radiation synovectomy has been practiced for more than half a century, but in many parts of the world, it is still relatively unknown and not used to its full potential in the standard care for chronic, persistent or recurrent synovitis. The working mechanism of RSO is simple yet elegant. Radiopharmaceutical particles are, after injection in the affected synovial joint, gobbled up by phagocytizing subsynovial inflammatory cells. As a consequence, the synovium will be irradiated locally resulting in synovial cell necrosis and inhibition of cell proliferation, which eventually leads to a decrease in the inflammatory response in the joint cavity. In this review RSO is once again brought to the attention and common indications for RSO are discussed. Also, appropriate activities of the administrated radiopharmaceuticals and coadministrated glucocorticoids are provided. Furthermore, a detailed database-assisted chronological overview of published literature of RSO in inflammatory and non-inflammatory diseases, like rheumatoid arthritis, psoriatic arthritis, osteoarthritis and osteochrondomatosis, hemophilic hemarthrosis and pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS) is provided. Based upon the published literature an indication of level of evidence of RSO is discussed. There is evidence that RSO is effective in persistent synovitis in patients with a variety of causes for synovitis, although the effectiveness seems to decrease over time. In these patients, RSO may not be used to its full potential in many parts of the world. Results in of RSO in hemophilia patients with hemarthrosis are favourable, however the evidence for the effectiveness of RSO in these patients is less firm and mainly based on case series. The evidence for the efficacy of RSO as adjuvant therapy in PVNS is, at best, of very low quality.

Long-term clinical results from 10 years follow-up after radiosynoviorthesis: a prospective observational study

BACKGROUND

The aim of this study was to assess the long-term anti-inflammatory effect and safety of 90-Yttrium and 166-Holmium radiosynoviorthesis (RSO) for treating chronic knee synovitis of various origins.

METHODS

A total of 820 patients were included in this study and were followed up to 10 years after the procedure for objective and subjective changes in signs and symptoms of inflammation.

RESULTS

Five years after RSO, excellent and good results were seen in 71% (95% CI 67-74%) of patients. Six, seven, eight and nine years following RSO, efficacy did not decrease significantly. Ten years after RSO, the effectiveness of the therapy fell to 65% (95% CI 59-71%). Overall, 64% of patients did not need another joint puncture ten years after RSO. We achieved excellent to good results at 5 years in 79% of patients with rheumatoid arthritis, 59% with ankylosing spondylitis, and 62% with osteoarthritis. Efficacy was mainly affected by the local X-ray stage of the knee joint. A significant association was also found between the diagnosis of the underlying disease and the success of radiosynoviorthesis. Efficacy, however, was not substantially affected by any of the following factors: the duration of synovitis, the number of punctures before radiosynoviorthesis, the number of intraarticular steroid injections before the procedure, or the number of interventions before radiosynoviorthesis (radiotherapy, surgery).

CONCLUSIONS

Radiosynoviorthesis is an effective long-term method of treating chronic synovitis. The treatment showed the most favorable effects in patients with rheumatoid arthritis and those with mild to moderate degenerative osseous changes.

The future of radiosynoviorthesis: bright or bleak?

Radiosynoviorthesis (RSO) is a decades known, effective intra-articular nuclear medicine local therapy, with few rare side-effects, in which inflamed synovial membrane is treated by means of colloidal beta-emitters. There are major variations worldwide in terms of acceptance, frequency of use and approved indications for this procedure. Thus, reliable figures that reflect reality are only available for a few countries. A Europe-wide survey revealed that RSO is carried out most frequently in Germany, where RSO is the most common nuclear medicine therapy with about 70,000 joints treated per year. The main indications include synovitis due to rheumatoid arthritis, hemophilia and pigmented villonodular synovitis (PVNS), and depending on national approvals, osteoarthritis. Despite the many indications, there are very few published scientific studies and therefore, RSO evidence is lacking. Reliable data on the clinical usage of RSO and demographics of RSO specialists are only available in Germany, thus we discuss the future challenges of RSO mainly from a German perspective. In the German healthcare system, RSO is performed primarily on an outpatient basis and plays only a minor role in the university setting. The necessary expertise for RSO is therefore lacking, for the most part, at university training centers. Currently, nearly more than three quarters of the German RSO experts are over fifty years old, illustrating a shortage of young talent. In the future, RSO providers from the non-university or private sector will have to cooperate with universities through networks and will have to intensify their cooperation with referring physicians, such as rheumatologist and orthopedic surgeons, and patients in order to maintain a timely and beneficial exchange of information. In networks of RSO experts, the participants must jointly develop and establish training concepts and facilities for future talents, elaborate on guidelines, if clinically useful expand the range of indications, initiate studies to generate further evidence and finally make the procedure more public. In addition, it is worthwhile to apply this process beyond human medicine to other fields, such as medical physics and veterinary medicine. If these points are implemented, the future of RSO will be bright, if it fails, it looks bleak.

Intra-articular Treatment of Digital Osteoarthritis by Radiosynoviorthesis-Clinical Outcome in Long-term Follow-up

PURPOSE

This retrospective study analyzed the long-term effects of radiosynoviorthesis (RSO) with special emphasis to local joint pain in patients from 4 different RSO centers in Germany and Austria.

METHODS

A total of 168 finger joints in 147 patients with digital joint OA were investigated. The indication for RSO was based on both clinical complaints and a proven synovitis, despite anti-inflammatory pharmacotherapy and previous intra-articular corticosteroid injections. Radiosynoviorthesis was performed according to international guidelines. A numeric visual analog scale (VAS) before and after treatment was used to measure the outcome. Follow-up was done for at least 2 years after treatment, in some patients even over 10 years.

RESULTS

Radiosynoviorthesis resulted in a significant reduction of VAS values in most of the patients, lasting for the whole period of follow-up. Two-thirds of the treated joints showed clinically relevant improvement, if a reduction of 30% in VAS values was defined as a reasonable cutoff. The best results were achieved in thumb base joints.

CONCLUSIONS

This article confirms that RSO is a suitable treatment option for digital joint OA with a proven synovitis. The analgesic effect is long-lasting and comparable to the success of RSO in patients with rheumatoid arthritis.

The EANM guideline for radiosynoviorthesis

PURPOSE

Radiosynoviorthesis (RSO) using the intraarticular application of beta-particle emitting radiocolloids has for decades been used for the local treatment of inflammatory joint diseases. The injected radiopharmaceuticals are phagocytized by the superficial macrophages of the synovial membrane, resulting in sclerosis and fibrosis of the formerly inflamed tissue, finally leading to reduced joint effusion and alleviation of joint pain.

METHODS

The European Association of Nuclear Medicine (EANM) has written and approved these guidelines in tight collaboration with an international team of clinical experts, including rheumatologists. Besides clinical and procedural aspects, different national legislative issues, dosimetric considerations, possible complications, and side effects are addressed.

CONCLUSION

These guidelines will assist nuclear medicine physicians in performing radiosynoviorthesis. Since there are differences regarding the radiopharmaceuticals approved for RSO and the official indications between several European countries, this guideline can only give a framework that must be adopted individually.

Prospective Clinical Evaluation of Intra-Articular Injection of Tin-117m (117mSn) Radiosynoviorthesis Agent for Management of Naturally Occurring Elbow Osteoarthritis in Dogs: A Pilot Study

Purpose

To evaluate the clinical effects of an intra-articular injection of ^117mSn-colloid for management of canine grade 1 or 2 elbow osteoarthritis (OA).

Patients and Methods

This was a prospective study in 23 dogs with grade 1 or 2 elbow OA. An orthopedic examination and elbow radiographs were performed to confirm the presence of OA. Dogs were randomly assigned to receive unilateral intra-articular (IA) injection of low-dose (LD: 1.0mCi, n =8), medium-dose (MD: 1.75mCi, n =6), or high-dose (HD: 2.5mCi, n =9) of ^117mSn-colloid. The primary outcome measure was peak vertical force (PVF) from force-plate gait analysis and secondary outcome measures included the Canine Brief Pain Inventory score (CBPI) and elbow goniometry. The CBPI was evaluated at pretreatment and then monthly post treatment for 1 year, and goniometry and PVF were evaluated at pretreatment, and at 1, 3, 6, 9 and 12 months post treatment.

Results

PVF improved at 3, and 9 months compared to pretreatment values in the HD group. CBPI scores improved at most of the time points in all dose groups. There was no significant difference in elbow goniometry between treated and untreated elbows. There were no self-reports of any adverse effects of the injection by the owners and none were noted by the examining veterinarian at the time of regularly scheduled re-evaluations.

Conclusion

^117mSn IA injection was free of any obvious adverse effects, improved CBPI scores, and increased weight bearing in limbs with elbow OA providing preliminary evidence that ^117mSn may be beneficial in the management of elbow OA in dogs. Although ^17mSn appeared to be effective for management of elbow OA in these dogs, this pilot study has inherent limitations; therefore, future studies with larger numbers and with placebo group are needed.

[RSO in clinical practice: Status in Germany 2020]

BACKGROUND

 Radiosynoviorthesis (RSO) is a local radionuclide therapy of inflammatory joint diseases, successfully performed since several decades mainly as an outpatient-protocol in ambulatory health care centers or nuclear medicine practices. Despite of long-term experience in some centers, only very few valuable or comparable data about the procedure itself and/or the clinical results of this treatment are available.

OBJECTIVES

 The aim of this online survey is to assess reliable data of the current status in Germany.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

 A web-based questionnaire was designed to evaluate the status of RSO in Germany including demographic data, training, pretherapeutic diagnostics, clinical procedures, and follow-up. The survey was distributed via the supplier of RSO-nuclides, national nuclear medicine societies, and personal networks. It was available for 28 days and closed on November 30, 2020.

RESULTS

 A total of 78 specialists in nuclear medicine answered the questionnaire, which corresponds to a response rate of 23 %. Several differences and concordances in pre-therapeutic diagnostics, in the procedure of RSO itself, and follow-up were documented in this survey for the first time. Most important, less than 70 nuclear medicine specialists in Germany perform more than 75 % of all RSO-procedures and most of them are older than 50 years of age. This implies the urgent need of a dedicated advancement of young academics in nuclear medicine and a professional advanced training in RSO to offer this beneficial treatment to future patients.

CONCLUSIONS

 To achieve these goals, an association of RSO experts would be useful, through which, among other things, an RSO training curriculum is developed and theoretical and practical trainings are organized. Moreover, possible cooperation agreements between ambulant and inpatient institutions would foster the education of young nuclear medicine specialists interested in RSO.

90Y Radiosynovectomy in Persistent Synovitis Caused by Knee Replacement: Long-Term Outcome

INTRODUCTION

After knee replacement, therapy resistant, persistent synovitis is a common issue, which causes effusion and pain, and leads to loosing. It has been hypothesized that radiosynovectomy (RSO) is useful in these patients.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A cohort of 55 patients with 57 knee replacements and persistent synovitis underwent RSO using 4.9 ± 0.24 mCi (182 ± 9 MBq) of Y-citrate. The number of RSOs ranged from 1 to 4. Bone scans before and 3 months after every RSO were performed. Long-term follow-up ranged from 0.8 to 7.6 years with a mean of 23.2 months. For qualitative analysis, an established 4 steps scoring was used. For quantification, the uptake was determined within the Tc-MDP scintigraphy blood pool phase before and after therapy.

RESULTS

Long-term response was in 27% with excellent, 24% good, 30% weak, and 20% no response. The duration of response was 12.0 ± 12.0 months (maximum, 54 months). In patients with repeated treatment, the effect after the first therapy was lesser than in patients who received a single treatment in total. However, 3 months after the last RSO, patients with repeated treatment showed a similar effectiveness than single treated patients. At the end of long-term follow-up, patients with repeated RSOs had a higher effectiveness at similar duration response. In bone scan, 65% of patients showed a reduction of uptake. When comparing subjective and objective response, 78% of patients showed a concordance in both symptoms and scintigraphy. Pilot histological analysis revealed that the synovitis is triggered by small plastic particles.

CONCLUSIONS

We concluded that RSO is an effective therapy in patients with knee replacement and persistent synovitis with high long-term response. Repeated treatment leads to a stronger long-time response.