Evaluation of class II cystic renal masses proposed in Bosniak classification version 2019: a systematic review of supporting evidence

Applicability of Bosniak 2019 for renal mass classification on portal venous phase at the era of spectral CT imaging using rapid kV-switching dual-energy CT

OBJECTIVES

To evaluate the applicability of Bosniak 2019 criteria on a monophasic portal venous phase using rapid kilovoltage-switching DECT (rsDECT).

MATERIALS AND METHODS

One hundred twenty-seven renal masses assessed on rsDECT were included, classified according to Bosniak 2019 classification using MRI as the reference standard. Using the portal venous phase, virtual monochromatic images at 40, 50, and 77 keV; virtual unenhanced (VUE) images; and iodine map images were reconstructed. Changes in attenuation values between VUE and 40 keV, 50 keV, and 77 keV measurements were computed and respectively defined as ∆HU40keV, ∆HU50keV, and ∆HU77keV. The values of ∆HU40keV, ∆HU50keV, and ∆HU77keV thresholds providing the optimal diagnostic performance for the detection of internal enhancement were determined using Youden index.

RESULTS

Population study included 25 solid renal masses (25/127, 20%) and 102 cystic renal masses (102/127, 80%). To differentiate solid to cystic masses, the specificity of the predefined 20 HU threshold reached 88% (95%CI: 82, 93) using ∆HU77keV and 21% (95%CI: 15, 28) using ∆HU40keV. The estimated optimal threshold of attenuation change was 19 HU on ∆HU77keV, 69 HU on ∆HU50eV, and 111 HU on ∆HU40eV. The rsDECT classification was highly similar to that of MRI for solid renal masses (23/25, 92%) and for Bosniak 1 masses (62/66, 94%). However, 2 hyperattenuating Bosniak 2 renal masses (2/26, 8%) were classified as solid renal masses on rsDECT.

CONCLUSION

DECT is a promising tool for Bosniak classification particularly to differentiate solid from Bosniak I-II cyst. However, known enhancement thresholds must be adapted especially to the energy level of virtual monochromatic reconstructions.

CLINICAL STATEMENT

DECT is a promising tool for Bosniak classification; however, known enhancement thresholds must be adapted according to the types of reconstructions used and especially to the energy level of virtual monochromatic reconstructions.

KEY POINTS

• To differentiate solid to cystic renal masses, predefined 20 HU threshold had a poor specificity using 40 keV virtual monochromatic images. • Most of Bosniak 1 masses according to MRI were also classified as Bosniak 1 on rapid kV-switching dual-energy CT (rsDECT). • Bosniak 2 hyperattenuating renal cysts mimicked solid lesion on rsDECT.

Scientific Status Quo of Small Renal Lesions: Diagnostic Assessment and Radiomics

Background: Small renal masses (SRMs) are defined as contrast-enhanced renal lesions less than or equal to 4 cm in maximal diameter, which can be compatible with stage T1a renal cell carcinomas (RCCs). Currently, 50-61% of all renal tumors are found incidentally. Methods: The characteristics of the lesion influence the choice of the type of management, which include several methods SRM of management, including nephrectomy, partial nephrectomy, ablation, observation, and also stereotactic body radiotherapy. Typical imaging methods available for differentiating benign from malignant renal lesions include ultrasound (US), contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS), computed tomography (CT), and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Results: Although ultrasound is the first imaging technique used to detect small renal lesions, it has several limitations. CT is the main and most widely used imaging technique for SRM characterization. The main advantages of MRI compared to CT are the better contrast resolution and tissue characterization, the use of functional imaging sequences, the possibility of performing the examination in patients allergic to iodine-containing contrast medium, and the absence of exposure to ionizing radiation. For a correct evaluation during imaging follow-up, it is necessary to use a reliable method for the assessment of renal lesions, represented by the Bosniak classification system. This classification was initially developed based on contrast-enhanced CT imaging findings, and the 2019 revision proposed the inclusion of MRI features; however, the latest classification has not yet received widespread validation. Conclusions: The use of radiomics in the evaluation of renal masses is an emerging and increasingly central field with several applications such as characterizing renal masses, distinguishing RCC subtypes, monitoring response to targeted therapeutic agents, and prognosis in a metastatic context.

Clinical Evaluation of Cystic Renal Masses With Bosniak Classification by Contrast-Enhanced Ultrasound and Contrast-Enhanced Computer Tomography

OBJECTIVES

The study aims to compare retrospectively three clinically applied methods for the diagnostic performance of cystic renal masses (CRMs) by contrast-enhanced ultrasound (CEUS) and contrast-enhanced computer tomography (CECT) with Bosniak classification system.

METHODS

A total of 52 cases of Bosniak II-IV CRMs in 49 consecutive patients were diagnosed from January 2013 to July 2022 and their data were analyzed. All patients had been subjected to CEUS and CECT simultaneously. Pathological diagnoses and masses stability were used as standard references to determine whether lesions were malignant or benign. Then 49 CRMs only with pathologic results were classified into group 1 and 2.

RESULTS

A total of 52 CRMs in 49 enrolled patients were classified into 8 category II, 16 category IIF, 15 category III, and 13 category IV by CEUS (EFSUMB 2020), 10 category II, 13 category IIF, 16 category III, and 13 category IV by CEUS (V2019), while 15 category II, 9 category IIF, 13 category III, and 15 category IV by CECT (V2019). Pathological results and masses stability longer than 5 years follow-up performed substantially for CEUS (EFSUMB 2020), CEUS (V2019), and CECT (V2019) (kappa values were 0.696, 0.735, and 0.696, respectively). Among 49 pathologic approving CRMs, wall/septation thickness ≥4 mm, wall/septation thickness, presence of enhancing nodule and the diameter were found to be statistically significant for malignancy. Twenty-two malignant masses were correctly diagnosed by CEUS (V2019), while 21 malignant masses were both correctly diagnosed by CEUS (EFSUMB 2020) and CECT (V2019), and 1 mass was misdiagnosed.

CONCLUSIONS

Bosniak classification of EFSUMB 2020 version might be as accurate as version 2019 CEUS and version 2019 CECT in diagnosing CRMs, and CEUS is found to have an excellent safety profile in dealing with clinical works.

Prevalence of malignant or possibly malignant renal masses among homogeneous low-attenuation masses that are too small to characterize at computed tomography

BACKGROUND

Homogeneous low-attenuation renal masses that are too small to characterize (tstc) are considered clinically insignificant; however, based primarily on expert opinion.

OBJECTIVE

To determine the prevalence of malignant or possibly malignant masses among homogeneous low-attenuation renal masses that are tstc.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

This retrospective cross-sectional study evaluated 75 patients with 104 tstc who underwent renal CT and MRI between Jan 2016 and Jul 2022. Low-attenuation renal masses measuring < 1 cm in size were identified and, independently evaluated by two blinded radiologists measuring attenuation (Hounsfield Units, HU) at non-contrast enhanced CT (NECT) and nephrographic phase contrast-enhanced (CE)-CT when possible. Reference standard for benign cyst was MRI and for other renal masses was pathology or MRI showing enhancement.

RESULTS

Average tstc size was 6 ± 2 (range 2-10) mm. Considering only incidental tstc (CT performed for another reason), 100% (98/98, 95%CI 96-100%) tstc were benign. Overall, considering both incidental and tstc referred for further characterization, there were 94% (98/104; 95% Confidence Intervals [CIs] 88-98%) benign cysts and 6% (6/104; 95%CI 2-12%) other masses (1 Bosniak 2F cystic mass, 2 probable renal cell carcinoma (RCC), three metastases). Pseudoenhancement, attenuation change > 10 HU or > 20 HU, was present in 29% (15/59) and 12% (7/59) benign cysts. All six other masses enhanced by > 20 HU. CECT threshold of ≤ 30 HU correctly classified 62% of benign cysts (61/98). All six other masses measured > 30 HU at CECT.

CONCLUSION

The prevalence of malignant or possibly malignant renal masses among homogeneous low-attenuation too small to characterize masses among incidental tstc masses is near zero. Attenuation measurements misclassify a substantial proportion of these cysts, likely due to their small size.

Proportion of malignancy in Bosniak classification of cystic renal masses version 2019 (v2019) classes: systematic review and meta-analysis

OBJECTIVES

Determine the proportion of malignancy within Bosniak v2019 classes.

METHODS

MEDLINE and EMBASE were searched. Eligible studies contained patients with cystic renal masses undergoing CT or MRI renal protocol examinations with pathology confirmation, applying Bosniak v2019. Proportion of malignancy was estimated within Bosniak v2019 class. Risk of bias was assessed using QUADAS-2.

RESULTS

We included 471 patients with 480 cystic renal masses. No class I malignant masses were observed. Pooled proportion of malignancy were class II, 12% (6/51, 95% CI 5-24%); class IIF, 46% (37/85, 95% CI 28-66%); class III, 79% (138/173, 95% CI 68-88%); and class IV, 84% (114/135, 95% CI 77-90%). Proportion of malignancy differed between Bosniak v2019 II-IV classes (p = 0.004). Four studies reported the proportion of malignancy by wall/septa feature. The pooled proportion of malignancy with 95% CI were class III thick smooth wall/septa, 77% (41/56, 95% CI 53-91%); class III obtuse protrusion ≤ 3 mm (irregularity), 83% (97/117, 95% CI 75-89%); and class IV nodule with acute angulation, 86% (50/58, 95% CI 75-93%) or obtuse angulation ≥ 4 mm, 83%, (64/77, 95% CI 73-90%). Subgroup analysis by wall/septa feature was limited by sample size; however, no differences were found comparing class III masses with irregularity to class IV masses (p = 0.74) or between class IV masses by acute versus obtuse angles (p = 0.62).

CONCLUSION

Preliminary data suggest Bosniak v2019 class IIF masses have higher proportion of malignancy compared to the original classification, controlling for pathologic reference standard. There are no differences in proportion of malignancy comparing class III masses with irregularities to class IV masses with acute or obtuse nodules.

KEY POINTS

• The proportion of malignancy in Bosniak v2019 class IIF cystic masses is 46% (37 malignant/85 total IIF masses, 95% confidence intervals (CI) 28-66%). • The proportion of malignancy in Bosniak v2019 class III cystic masses is 79% (138/173, 95% CI 68-88%) and in Bosniak v2019 class IV cystic masses is 84% (114/135, 95% CI 77-90%). • Class III cystic masses with irregularities had similar proportion of malignancy (83%, 97/117, 95% CI 75-89%) compared to Bosniak class IV masses (84%, 114/135, 95% CI 77-90%) overall (p = 0.74) with no difference within class IV masses by acute versus obtuse angulation (p = 0.62).

The safety and efficacy of laparoscopic microwave ablation-assisted partial nephrectomy: a new avenue for the treatment of cystic renal tumors

PURPOSE

Clinically, the management of cystic renal masses is tricky. The study aims to evaluate the safety and efficacy of laparoscopic microwave ablation-assisted partial nephrectomy (LMAPN) for cystic renal tumors.

METHODS AND MATERIALS

Between November 2017 and January 2022, LMAPN was performed on 43 patients (29 men and 14 women; age range: 22-80 years; median age 54 years) with Bosniak category III (n = 15) or IV (n = 28) cystic renal tumors (size range: 1.2-5.0 cm; mean size 2.8 cm). The median follow-up period was 26 months (range: 7-56 months). Baseline and perioperative data, pathological features, renal function, postoperative complications and oncologic outcomes were collected and evaluated.

RESULTS

Forty-three cystic renal tumors were successfully managed by LMAPN. The mean operating time was 79 min (range: 40-130 min). The mean time of renal pedicle clamping was 19 min (range: 12-25 min). Mean intraoperative blood loss was 28.4 mL (range: 10-80 mL). The mean postoperative hospitalization duration was 4 days (range: 2-6 days). Negative surgical margins were diagnosed in all cases. During the follow-up, no patient appeared with distant metastasis, wound or peritoneal cavity implantation. No major but minor complications of Clavien-Dindo grade I were encountered after the operation. The 1-, 3- and 4-year overall survival rate was 100%, 96.6% and 88.5%, respectively.

CONCLUSION

This is the first study focusing on LMAPN for cystic renal tumors, demonstrating its favorable feasibility, safety and disease control. Long-term follow-up is necessary to draw conclusions on the preference and advantages of the new therapeutic approach.