Results from a pooled analysis of two European, randomized, placebo-controlled, phase 3 studies of ATX-101 for the pharmacologic reduction of excess submental fat

Degradation Therapy with Collagenase and Deoxycholate

Deoxycholate (deoxycholic acid) and collagenase are naturally occurring substances whose ability to degrade adipose tissue and collagen respectively has given rise to a variety of therapeutic applications. This article will discuss the indications for the use of deoxycholic acid, primarily its well-established role in the non-surgical reduction of submental fat, with a focus on patient assessment, procedural technique, risks, pitfalls, and key clinical tips. It will also review the indications for collagenase as a degradation therapy, its mechanism of action, and benefits in the management of wound healing, scarring, and adipose tissue modification.

Efficacy, safety, and potential industry bias in using deoxycholic acid for submental fat reduction ‒ A systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials

Lipolytic substance injections to reduce localized fat have been extensively used because it is a low-invasive method. This review aimed to evaluate the efficacy and safety of deoxycholic acid in submental fat reduction compared to a placebo and investigate the potential industry sponsorship bias in the results of randomized clinical trials on this topic. Ten electronic databases were extensively searched for randomized clinical trials without restriction on language and year of publication. Two reviewers extracted the data and assessed the individual risk of bias in the studies with the RoB 2.0 tool. The industry sponsorship bias was evaluated according to citations in the articles regarding industry funding/sponsorship throughout the texts. Fixed and random effects meta-analyses were performed, and the results were reported in Risk Ratio (RR) at a 95% Confidence Interval (95% CI). The initial search provided 5756 results, of which only five were included. Only two studies had a low risk of bias. All studies showed a potential industry bias. The meta-analysis showed that patients treated with deoxycholic acid had significant positive results for all efficacy outcomes and a higher risk of fibrosis, pain, erythema, numbness, swelling, edema, pruritus, nodules, headache, and paresthesia. The low to moderate certainty of evidence found allows concluding that deoxycholic acid is effective in submental fat reduction, causing well-tolerated adverse effects. However, all eligible studies showed a potential industry bias.

Successful treatment of submental fat using a non-focused pulsed ultrasound

BACKGROUND

The prevalence of non-invasive aesthetic treatments is increasing, with patients demanding easier, safer, and more effective non-invasive cosmetic procedures. Submental fat is usually addressed using liposuction, which is associated with significant adverse events and a long recovery. Although newer, non-invasive submental fat treatments are gaining popularity, they are often complex, require frequent injections, or have adverse side effects.

AIMS

Assess the safety and efficacy of vacuum-assisted acoustic wave technology for treating submental.

PATIENTS/METHODS

Fourteen female patients underwent a total of three weekly 15-min treatments using ultrasound with a 40 mm bell-shaped sonotrode. Improvement in submental fat was assessed 3 months after the final treatment using questionnaires for the patients and physicians. Two blinded dermatologists rated each patient using the Clinician-Reported Submental Fat Rating Scale (CR-SMFRS) 5-point scale.

RESULTS

Both physicians rated a significant improvement in all 14 patients. Furthermore, self-evaluation of the 14 patients on a 1 to 5 satisfaction scale averaged 2.14, indicating that most patients were somewhat satisfied.

CONCLUSION

This study demonstrates that a three-treatment course with an acoustic wave ultrasound applicator with 1-week intervals leads to a significant reduction in submental fat and can be used as a novel, efficient treatment paradigm.

CONTOUR Australia: Condition of Submental Fullness and Treatment Outcomes with Belkyra Registry

Submental fat (SMF) contributes to an aged or overweight appearance that may negatively impact an individual's psychological well-being. Deoxycholic acid (ATX-101) is an injectable formulation of deoxycholic acid approved to treat SMF. The Condition of Submental Fullness and Treatment Outcomes Registry (CONTOUR) Australia study was designed to understand treatment patterns and outcomes with ATX-101 in Australia.

Methods

CONTOUR Australia was a phase 4, prospective, observational, multicenter registry that enrolled adults considering treatment for SMF reduction.

Results

The registry enrolled 86 patients from six sites. Significant changes from baseline through the end of treatment indicated improvement in mild to moderate fullness associated with SMF on the Clinician-Reported SMF Rating Scale and the Patient-Reported SMF Rating Scale, improvement in SMF-associated psychological impact after treatment on the Patient-Reported SMF Impact Scale, no overall worsening in skin laxity based on Submental Skin Laxity Grade, and increased patient satisfaction with the face/chin on the Subject Self-Rating Scale after receiving treatment. Adverse events were all mild and mostly related to the injection site (ie, bruising and swelling).

Conclusion

CONTOUR Australia observed clinically meaningful and significant outcomes and further supports ATX-101 as a well-tolerated and effective treatment for SMF reduction.

Submental Area Treatment with ATX-101: Relationship of Mechanism of Action, Tissue Response, and Efficacy

ATX-101 is an injectable, synthetically derived formulation of deoxycholic acid used for submental fat reduction.

Methods

A narrative review of references relevant to the mechanism of action of ATX-101 and its relationship to efficacy and inflammatory adverse events was conducted.

Results

When injected into subcutaneous fat, deoxycholic acid physically disrupts adipocyte cell membranes, leading to local adipocytolysis, cell death, and a mild, local inflammatory reaction consisting of macrophage infiltration and fibroblast recruitment. At Day 28 postinjection, inflammation largely resolves, and key histologic features include fibrotic septal thickening, neovascularization, and atrophy of fat lobules. Based on the mechanism of action of ATX-101 and the demonstrated inflammatory response, localized inflammation and swelling are expected following treatment. Indeed, postinjection swelling and other local injection-site events, including pain, erythema, and bruising, are common during and after treatment. Because of inflammatory sequelae following injection, reduction in submental fat is gradual and may require months before the full response is apparent. Patients may also require multiple treatment sessions to achieve their treatment goals. Repeated treatments may result in less pain and swelling over time owing to a combination of factors, including less target tissue allowing for lower doses/injection volumes, persistent numbness, and greater tissue integrity from thickened fibrous septa.

Conclusions

Physicians can manage expectations by counseling patients that, based on the mechanism of action of ATX-101 and data from pivotal clinical trials, ATX-101 treatment results in localized inflammation/swelling and gradual submental fat reduction. Patient education about common local adverse events is critical.

Improvements in Submental Contour up to 3 Years After ATX-101: Efficacy and Safety Follow-Up of the Phase 3 REFINE Trials

BACKGROUND

ATX-101 (deoxycholic acid) significantly reduced submental fat (SMF) severity in two 24-week Phase 3 studies (REFINE-1 and REFINE-2).

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to evaluate the durability of effect and long-term safety of ATX-101.

METHODS

REFINE study patients who maintained ≥1-grade improvement on the Clinician-Reported SMF Rating Scale (CR-1 responders) 12 weeks after their last REFINE treatment were eligible for enrollment in this multicenter, double-blind, nontreatment, long-term, follow-up study (NCT02163902). The primary endpoint was CR-1 response at Years 1, 2, and 3. Patient-reported satisfaction, psychological impact, and adverse events were monitored.

RESULTS

In total, 224 patients (ATX-101, n = 113; placebo, n = 111) were enrolled. Maintenance of CR-1 response was significantly better in the ATX-101 group than in the placebo group at Year 1 (86.4% vs 56.8%; P < 0.001), Year 2 (90.6% vs 73.8%; P = 0.014), and Year 3 (82.4% vs 65.0%; P = 0.03). Most (74%) ATX-101‒treated patients satisfied at 12 weeks remained satisfied at Year 3. Significant reductions from baseline in psychological impact scores were sustained through Year 3 (P < 0.001). No new treatment-related adverse events were reported.

CONCLUSIONS

Improvements in submental contour achieved with ATX-101 are maintained for 3 years in most patients. No new safety signals emerged.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 2

Safety and Efficacy of Deoxycholic Acid Injection for Hypogastric Fat Reduction: A Pilot Study

BACKGROUND

Although deoxycholic acid (DCA) has been proposed for use in other areas, it is used primarily for treating moderate-to-severe fat in the submental area.

OBJECTIVE

To evaluate the safety and efficacy of DCA for fat reduction in the hypogastric region.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A prospective, longitudinal, nonrandomized, open-label, interventional pilot study was performed. Deoxycholic acid was transcutaneously injected in upper right, upper left, lower right, and lower left hypogastric zones. Fat thickness was assessed using calipers, ultrasound, and 3-dimensional scanning. The primary end point safety was evaluated by laboratory tests and the incidence of adverse events.

RESULTS

Fourteen patients (54 treatment sessions) were included. The mean total volume administered was 26.6 mL. The main local adverse events were edema (94.4%), bruising (90.7%), and erythema (79.6%), all being self-limited (the mean duration 9.6, 7, and 2 days, respectively). A DCA dose was significantly associated with erythema duration (p = .0421) but not with edema duration (p = .1611) or bruising incidence (p = .1013). Measurement using calipers, ultrasound, and 3-dimensional scanning revealed significant fat thickness reduction. Patient-reported outcome measure scores revealed a significant improvement in patient satisfaction.

CONCLUSION

Deoxycholic acid may be a safe and effective option for reducing fat thickness in the hypogastric region, although given the cost/benefit ratio probably should be reserved for small deposits.

Randomized, Placebo-Controlled Phase 1/2 Study to Determine the Appropriate ATX-101 Concentration for Reduction of Submental Fat

BACKGROUND

ATX-101 is indicated for submental fat treatment.

OBJECTIVE

Evaluate ATX-101 versus placebo for reducing submental fat.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Adults with unwanted submental fat across 6 global sites were randomized to ATX-101 (0.5%, 1.0%, or 2.0%) or placebo for ≤4 treatments every 28 days. Outcomes included safety (adverse events and pain visual analog scale) throughout the study and efficacy (submental fat rating, patient satisfaction, and submental fat improvements) at Week 16.

RESULTS

Eighty-four of 85 enrolled patients received ≥1 ATX-101 treatment (0.5% [n = 20], 1.0% [n = 20], 2.0% [n = 22] or placebo [n = 22]). Most patients (n = 82) experienced adverse events, which were mostly mild/moderate, seemed to be dose-related, and led to no study discontinuations. The mean pain scores were highest in the ATX-101 1.0% and 2.0% groups. Week-16 change from baseline in the submental fat rating scale was significantly greater for ATX-101 0.5% and 1.0% versus placebo (p ≤ .05). At Week 16, 71%, 74%, 53%, and 40% of patients in the ATX-101 0.5%, 1.0%, 2.0%, and placebo groups, respectively, achieved a ≥1-grade reduction in submental fat from baseline. Satisfaction with appearance and patient-assessed global improvement ratings increased in all ATX-101 treatment groups versus placebo.

CONCLUSION

All ATX-101 concentrations were safe and efficacious for moderate/severe submental fat reduction.

Best Clinical Practices with ATX-101 for Submental Fat Reduction: Patient-related Factors and Physician Considerations

Background:

Submental fat can be reduced with ATX-101 (deoxycholic acid injection), a customizable and minimally invasive alternative to liposuction. In the years since its approval, the treatment patterns of ATX-101 have evolved.

Methods:

A panel of experienced physicians from the United States gathered to generate best practices for the use of ATX-101 in submental contouring.

Results:

The expert panel provided their insights on appropriate patient selection, managing patient expectations of ATX-101 treatment outcomes, and adverse events, and guidance on ATX-101 administration for optimal outcomes are presented here.

Conclusion:

These best clinical practices on the use of ATX-101 for the reduction of submental fat should enable physicians to enhance the patient treatment experience and outcomes.

Evaluating a Topical Adjunctive Post Submental ATX-101 (Deoxycholic Acid) Injections for Improved Recovery: A Single-Center, Double-Blind, Randomized Controlled Pilot Study

Background

Optimizing postprocedural recovery and outcomes for patients is the aim for all physicians. TransFORM Body Treatment with TriHex Technology (TFB) is a topical product that aids in the elimination of fat particles created during procedures and the reduction of associated inflammation, thus speeding up postprocedure recovery time.

Objectives

Evaluation of postprocedural symptoms, signs, and healing following submental deoxycholic acid (DCA) injections in combination with TFB.

Methods

Participants received 2 treatments of submental DCA injections. Posttreatment 1, every participant received TFB to apply twice daily to the submental area. Follow-up visits included weeks 1, 2, and 4. After week 4, participants discontinued TFB for 30 days before the second treatment. At the second treatment visit, participants were randomized to receive either TFB or a bland moisturizer to apply twice daily with the same follow-up visits as posttreatment 1. Induration measurements, submental fullness grading, and standardized photography were captured at every visit. At all follow-up visits and before treatment 2, investigator assessments and participant assessments were completed.

Results

Posttreatment 2, investigator assessments of edema and induration decreased in participants using TFB at weeks 1 and 2 compared with the bland moisturizer. Induration measurements objectively showed a statistically significant reduction at week 2 (posttreatment 2) in participants using TFB compared with the bland moisturizer. Furthermore, participants reported less tenderness and soreness in the TFB group over the bland moisturizer.

Conclusions

Investigator assessments, participant query, and objective induration analyses have demonstrated that the use of TFB post DCA injections may reduce induration, edema, and discomfort associated with this procedure.

Level of Evidence: 2

Development and Validation of the Patient-Reported Submental Fat Rating Scale and the Patient-Reported Submental Fat Impact Scale

BACKGROUND

No validated assessment tools are available to evaluate patient-reported outcomes specifically related to submental fat (SMF).

OBJECTIVE

To develop and validate scales measuring the severity (Patient-Reported SMF Rating Scale [PR-SMFRS]) and psychological impact (Patient-Reported SMF Impact Scale [PR-SMFIS]) of SMF.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

A literature review, content validation interviews (concept elicitation [n = 29] and cognitive debriefing [n = 15]) in adults with SMF, and expert interviews (n = 3) were conducted to develop the PR-SMFRS and PR-SMFIS. Psychometric validity (acceptability, reliability, and validity) for the PR-SMFRS and PR-SMFIS was assessed using data from 1 phase 2 and 5 phase 3 ATX-101 studies in patients with excess SMF.

RESULTS

The PR-SMFRS was constructed as a single-item, 5-point rating of the SMF amount/size. The PR-SMFIS was constructed as a 6-item scale, with an 11-point numeric rating for each item. Both scales demonstrated acceptable psychometric properties (test-retest reliability and internal consistency). The anchor-based minimally important difference analysis suggests a 1-point improvement on the PR-SMFRS (scale of 0‒4) and a 3-point improvement on the PR-SMFIS (scale of 0‒10) represent clinically meaningful change.

CONCLUSION

The PR-SMFRS and PR-SMFIS are reliable, valid instruments for assessing the severity and psychosocial impact, respectively, of SMF and detecting clinically meaningful change with intervention.

Efficacy and safety of injectable deoxycholic acid for submental fat reduction: a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials

Objective: To investigate the efficacy and safety of deoxycholic acid (DOC) for SMF reduction.Methods: We conducted a systematic review and meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. We searched PubMed/MEDLINE, EMBASE, and Cochrane databases until June 2020. Efficacy outcomes: Clinician-Reported Submental Fat Rating Scale; Patient-Reported Submental Fat Rating Scale; Subject Self-Rating Scale; SMF reduction measured using caliper and resonance magnetic imaging; Early therapeutic success. Safety outcomes: Withdrawals due to adverse events (AEs), Rates of AEs, Skin laxity.Results: Five studies were included, comprising 1,838 participants. DOC (1 or 2 mg/cm²) had greater improvement in all efficacy measures compared to placebo. No differences were seen between both doses of DOC. Withdrawals due to AEs were low with 1 and 2 mg/cm² of DOC (6.8% vs. 9.9%, respectively), and there was no difference between the two doses (p = 0.22). AEs were usually associated with the injection site, were predominantly transient, and commonly resolved within the treatment session interval. Injection site pain, hematoma, anesthesia/numbness, erythema, and swelling/edema were the most common AEs. There was no difference in their prevalence between both doses of DOC.Conclusions: DOC is effective and safe for SMF reduction with no differences between doses of 1 and 2 mg/cm².

Development and Validation Clinician and Patient Reported Photonumeric Scales to Assess Buttocks Cellulite Severity

Supplemental Digital Content is Available in the Text.

The Clinician Reported Photonumeric Cellulite Severity Scale (CR-PCSS) and Patient Reported PCSS (PR-PCSS) are newly developed tools for assessing cellulite severity.

Jowl Reduction With Deoxycholic Acid

BACKGROUND

The study proposes a novel protocol for targeting the jowls using deoxycholic acid (DCA) injections, with emphasis on safety and feasibility of the procedure.

METHODS

This prospective study was conducted at a cosmetic practice between June 2016 and May 2017. Twelve consecutive patients seeking reduction/improvement in mild/moderate jowl fat were injected with DCA subcutaneously in a predefined circular area 1.0 cm above the mandibular border. Treatment response was assessed using physician-evaluated Global Aesthetic Improvement Scale (GAIS) and Subject GAIS.

RESULTS

Twelve patients (11 women and 1 man) with mild (n = 8) or moderate (n = 4) jowls were treated. After the first treatment, GAIS responses for 24 jowls showed 5 jowls with vast improvement, 15 with moderate improvement, and 4 with no change. After the second session for 5 jowls in 3 patients, GAIS responses showed vast improvement in 4 jowls and moderate improvement in 1. Adverse events included induration (n = 4), bruising (n = 6), numbness (n = 2), pain (n = 5), redness (n = 3), edema (n = 9), and dysphagia (n = 1).

CONCLUSION

Results of this early experience showed that DCA injections were safe and effective for nonsurgical jowl reduction.

Real-World Experience With 100 Consecutive Patients Undergoing Neck Contouring With ATX-101 (Deoxycholic Acid): An Updated Report With A 2-Year Analysis

Deoxycholic acid (DCA; ATX-101) injection was approved for the treatment of mild-to-moderate convexity associated with submental fat in 2015.

Current Trends in Management of Submental Liposis: A Pooled Analysis and Survey

Importance

Since its approval by the US Food and Drug Administration for treatment of moderate to severe submental liposis in April 2015, deoxycholic acid (Kybella) has received significant media attention as a novel aesthetic treatment. Four phase 3 clinical trials have published data demonstrating the safety and efficacy of the drug compared with placebo; however, no study has juxtaposed the product with submental liposuction.

Objective

To evaluate the efficacy of injectable deoxycholic acid in the treatment of isolated submental liposis.

Evidence Review

A pooled analysis of the data from the 2 European and 2 North American phase 3 clinical trials was performed by grouping the study participants by treatment arm to analyze efficacy, adverse effects, and treatment variables. Members of the American Academy of Facial Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery (AAFPRS) were also surveyed regarding their clinical use of deoxycholic acid, fees, and adverse events.

Findings

The pooled analysis included 1738 unique patients (348 men [20.0%] and 1390 women [80.0%]; mean [SD] age, 47.7 [1.6] years) and revealed that all studies demonstrated efficacy compared with placebo. However, a significant number of patients experienced pain, edema, and numbness after injection. The clinical trial population was injected with a mean (SD) of 186.0 (106.6) mg of drug per patient during the course of treatment. A total of 102 members responded to the survey, representing 4% of AAFPRS membership. Based on the results of the survey, clinicians reported charging a mean (SD) of $691.04 ($168.68) per 20-mg vial of deoxycholic acid, resulting in a cost of $6426.35 per study participant. The survey revealed a mean (SD) total cost to the patient for submental liposuction to be $2976.56 ($1041.62).

Conclusions and Relevance

Although the clinical trials demonstrated functional drug efficacy, the large volume of drug used precluded cost-effectiveness. The survey found clinical practice to differ from the protocols used in the trials. Deoxycholic acid may be only fiscally efficacious for patients with mild to moderate submental liposis who require only 20 to 30 mg of drug per treatment for 3 treatment sessions.

Level of Evidence

1.

Evaluation of Safe and Effectiveness of an Injectable Solution Acid Deoxycholic Based for Reduction of Localized Adiposities

Background:

The use of deoxycholic acid to reduce localized fat deposits is a procedure that has been in use for about 30 years. Its effectiveness as treatment is due to emulsification of phospholipids and therefore, solubilization of the biological membranes with resulting fat necrosis. The purpose of the study was to assess the effectiveness and the safety of an injectable solution containing sodium deoxycholtate 1.25% (DB125), used as intralipotherapy.

Methods:

The effectiveness and safety of DB125 solution have been assessed with a multicentre observational prospective study carried out between February and October 2017. The 221 selected patients presented with various forms and degrees of localized fat in several areas. Intralipotherapy treatments were performed 6 weeks apart and until the clinical result was obtained. Aesthetic outcomes were evaluated by the authors using preoperative and postoperative photographic documentation and by the patients with their level of satisfaction by filling out an anonymous form. Major adverse events were reported by each doctor who performed the treatment.

Results:

Two hundred twenty-one patients treated in 273 cases of different localized fat deposits. One hundred eighty-five patients who could be assessed for final results gave the effectiveness of the treatment an average score of 7.4. The failure percentage of the treatment was 3.8%. The medical evaluation showed treatment success in 93.5% of cases. Adverse events can be divided into 2 groups: minor adverse events, which are very frequent and major ones, which are extremely rare. For both groups, the adverse events can be ascribed to localized problems in the treatment area.

Conclusion:

Studies have shown that the second-generation solution containing sodium deoxycholate 1.25% is effective and safe to treat different localized fat deposits. The high degree of effectiveness shown in the study was not associated with a lesser degree of handling because, at the doses indicated and with the use of intralipotherapy, the occurrence of adverse events was minimal.

Deoxycholate (ATX-101) Mixed with Lidocaine to Minimize Pain/Discomfort in Nonsurgical Treatment of Submental Fullness Appearance

In the present study pain/discomfort reduction in submental fullness treatment with the injections of a DC based drug (ATX-101, Allergan, Dublin, Ireland) premixed with lidocaine 2% on a sample of 12 patients retrospectively evaluated has been performed All patients indicated improvement in skin tightening from the 2nd month postinjection. Three patients had minor ecchymoses at the injection sites, which resolved spontaneously within 10 days posttreatment. One patient experienced dysesthesia of the treated area, which lasted approximately 40 days and resolved spontaneously. No other complications—such as nerve paresis or alopecia—were recorded. No patient required analgesic drugs postinjection.

Noninvasive submental fat reduction using colder cryolipolysis

BACKGROUND

Cryolipolysis has shown to significantly reduce localized subcutaneous fat, including submental fat. Temperatures below -11°C have not been used to treat the submental region.

OBJECTIVE

The purpose of this study was to evaluate safety and efficacy of Cryolipolysis for noninvasive reduction of submental fat using lower temperatures and reduced treatment time.

METHODS

A small volume applicator was used to treat 15 subjects, using a noninvasive tissue cooling device (CoolSculpting System, ZELTIQ Aesthetics, Pleasanton, CA, USA) during 45 and 30 minutes at -12 and -15°C, respectively, to induce reduction of submental fat. Two treatments with an interval of 10 weeks were performed. Adverse events were monitored to assess safety. Treated area was evaluated using digital photography, and caliper measurements prior treatment, 10 weeks after first treatment and 12 weeks after second treatment. All patients were also evaluated before and after 12-week postlast treatment by Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI).

RESULTS

The mean (SD) reduction measured by skin fold caliper was 33% (3.2 mm [1.7 mm]), (95% CI, 0.2297-0.4236; P=.05), and by MRI, mean (SD) reduction was 1.78 mm (1.157 mm). Independent blinded panel was able to correctly identify 60% of before and after photographs; 12 of 15 subjects (80%) were satisfied or very satisfied with the treatment. Side effects were mild and resolved completely within 10 weeks, except for one hyperpigmentation, which resolved spontaneously within 6 months after last treatment.

CONCLUSION

Cryolipolysis with colder temperature and reduced treatment time continues to be effective and is safe for noninvasive reduction of the submental fat.

Early Experience in 100 Consecutive Patients With Injection Adipocytolysis for Neck Contouring With ATX-101 (Deoxycholic Acid)

BACKGROUND

Deoxycholic acid (DCA) is approved for improvement in the appearance of moderate to severe convexity or fullness associated with submental fat.

OBJECTIVE

To assess early treatment experience with DCA injection in a clinical practice setting.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

In this single-center, prospective, single-arm, observational study, 100 consecutive patients seeking to decrease submental fullness received subcutaneous DCA (2 mg/cm) injections in the submental area (maximum of 6 sessions at ≥1 month intervals). Treatment response was assessed 1 and 5 to 7 weeks posttreatment using the clinician-reported submental fat rating scale (CR-SMFRS) and retrospective independent photograph review by 2 physicians.

RESULTS

Overall, 100 patients had 152 treatment sessions (58, 33, 8, and 1 patients had 1, 2, 3, and 4 sessions, respectively). CR-SMFRS score improved by ≥1 point from baseline in 88 (88%) patients; of these, 46, 33, 8, and 1 patients had 1, 2, 3, and 4 sessions, respectively. Local edema, numbness, and tenderness were reported for a mean (SD) of 7.7 (5.3), 28.5 (11.4), and 3.5 (3.5) days, respectively. Two patients experienced marginal mandibular nerve paresis.

CONCLUSION

Deoxycholic acid injection, a minimally invasive procedure for neck contouring, was effective and generally well tolerated in the private practice setting.

Use of a controlled subdermal radio frequency thermistor for treating the aging neck: Consensus recommendations

INTRODUCTION

A new temperature-controlled device has been used as a percutaneous radio frequency probe to treat lax submental and other facial areas. It has significant advantages over other esthetic devices as it provides the dual benefit of fat lipolysis and skin tightening. Our goal here is to present consensus recommendations for treating the aging neck.

METHODS

A panel of 11 expert physicians convened in Dallas, Texas, on October 15, 2016 to arrive at a consensus on the best current practice for submental skin tightening and contour improvement. Prior to the meeting, a comprehensive review of the literature was performed and a survey was sent to esthetic dermatologists and plastic surgeons who were queried about various aspects of neck rejuvenation.

RESULTS

The literature search revealed 10 different technologies for neck rejuvenation evaluated in double-blind (n = 2) and single-blind (n = 1) clinical trials and other clinical evaluations (n = 21). The survey was sent via an email to 1248 individuals and was completed by 92 respondents. Review of the data and discussion by meeting attendees generated eight consensus recommendations.

DISCUSSION

Subdermal monopolar radio frequency represents an effective means for disrupting fat volume and skin tightening of the face, neck, and jawline. For suitable patients, this treatment can be used to achieve significant esthetic improvements.

Overview of ATX-101 (Deoxycholic Acid Injection): A Nonsurgical Approach for Reduction of Submental Fat

In 2015, ATX-101 (deoxycholic acid injection; Kybella in the United States and Belkyra in Canada; Kythera Biopharmaceuticals, Inc., Westlake Village, CA [an affiliate of Allergan plc, Dublin, Ireland]) was approved as a first-in-class injectable drug for improvement in the appearance of moderate to severe convexity or fullness associated with submental fat. ATX-101 has been evaluated in a clinical development program that included 18 Phase 1 to 3 studies supporting the current indication. Since 2007, the toxicity and safety profiles of ATX-101 have been characterized in numerous preclinical studies, its pharmacokinetics, pharmacodynamics, and optimal treatment paradigm have been defined in multiple Phase 1 and 2 studies, and its efficacy and clinical safety have been confirmed in 4 large Phase 3 trials (2 conducted in Europe and 2 in the United States and Canada [REFINE-1 and REFINE-2]). As subcutaneous injection of deoxycholic acid has been shown to cause adipocytolysis, the reduction in submental fat achieved after ATX-101 treatment is expected to be long lasting. This prediction is confirmed by data from long-term follow-up studies of up to 4 years after last treatment with ATX-101, which demonstrate that the treatment response is maintained over time in most subjects. ATX-101 offers a durable, minimally invasive alternative to liposuction and surgery for addressing submental fullness.

Deoxycholic Acid: A Review in Submental Fat Contouring

Deoxycholic acid is a secondary bile acid involved in dietary fat emulsification/solubilization that causes adipocyte lysis when injected into subcutaneous fat tissue. A 10 mg/mL injectable solution of synthetic deoxycholic acid (Kybella™; Belkyra™) is indicated in various countries, including the USA and several within Europe/the EU, to improve the appearance of moderate to severe convexity or fullness associated with submental fat (SMF) in adults, where it is currently the only approved treatment for fat below the chin. In several phase III trials conducted in this setting, injecting deoxycholic acid 2 mg/cm² into the SMF reduced the convexity/fullness of moderate to severe SMF relative to placebo (with a single treatment comprising up to 50 injections, and up to six treatments given at least 1 month apart). These SMF benefits (which were measured subjectively by clinicians and recipients, as well as objectively, 12 weeks after the last treatment session) generally occurred without detriment to skin laxity and were largely maintained over extended follow-up (e.g. 2 years after treatment). Deoxycholic acid injections are generally well tolerated, with adverse events usually involving the treatment area, being mild to moderate in severity and resolving within approximately one treatment interval. However, not all patients with SMF may be suitable for deoxycholic acid therapy, making patient selection key to achieving desired aesthetic outcomes. Thus, deoxycholic acid injections are an effective and generally well tolerated, minimally invasive option for the treatment of moderate to severe SMF in select adults.

ATX-101 (deoxycholic acid injection) for reduction of submental fat

INTRODUCTION

The shape and contour of the chin and neck play an important role in facial esthetics. As such, excess fat within the submental area (double chin) can negatively affect facial esthetics and body image. Common treatments for submental contouring include invasive procedures such as surgical rejuvenation and targeted liposuction. Energy devices (lasers, radiofrequency, and ultrasound) may be used to improve submental skin laxity while cryolipolysis was recently cleared in the United States for use in the submental area. However, ATX-101 (deoxycholic acid injection) is the only injectable drug approved in the United States and Canada for reduction of submental fat.

AREAS COVERED

The efficacy and safety of ATX-101 have been extensively evaluated in a global clinical development program including multiple Phase I/II studies and four large Phase III trials. Available data from ATX-101 trials are reviewed. Expert commentary: Injectables have been well established for facial rejuvenation. Extending injectable treatment into the chin and neck is a major advance for nonsurgical cosmetic correction. Overall, the evidence supports ATX-101 as a safe and effective, minimally invasive treatment alternative for reduction of submental fat that will provide a major tool for the esthetic physician.

Deoxycholic Acid (ATX-101) for Reduction of Submental Fat

Objective: To review trials evaluating purified synthetic deoxycholic acid (DCA; ATX-101) for the reduction of submental fat (SMF). Data Sources: A literature search was conducted using MEDLINE (1946 to week 4 of April 2016) and Evidence Based Medicine Database (1974 to 6 May, 2016). Keywords searched included deoxycholic acid, ATX-101, and submental fat. Study Selection and Data Extraction: All human studies published in English that addressed the effects of DCA for the reduction of SMF were selected for analysis. Data Synthesis: Five phase III, multicenter, randomized, double-blinded clinical trials enrolling more than 1700 patients have demonstrated the efficacy of ATX-101 in the reduction of SMF via a variety of validated scales as well as objective measurements. Purified synthetic DCA 2 mg/cm2 injected monthly for 4 to 6 treatment sessions demonstrated improvement in scales evaluated by both clinicians and patients. Improvement in skin caliper measurements of SMF and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) provide objective evidence of the efficacy of ATX-101. Adverse events (AEs) are very common but are transient and localized to the treatment area. Pain at the injection site is the most common AE, occurring in more than 80% of patients treated. Other common AEs include swelling, bruising, numbness, and induration. Appropriate injection technique is patient specific and requires detailed knowledge of the submental anatomy to minimize AEs. Conclusions: ATX-101 is the first pharmacological intervention approved for the reduction of SMF and offers an alternative to invasive measures to improve the submental profile and positively affect patient self-image.

ATX-101 for reduction of submental fat: A phase III randomized controlled trial

BACKGROUND

ATX-101, an injectable form of deoxycholic acid, causes adipocytolysis when injected subcutaneously into fat.

OBJECTIVE

We sought to evaluate the efficacy and safety of ATX-101.

METHODS

In this phase III trial (REFINE-2), adults dissatisfied with their moderate or severe submental fat (SMF) were randomized to ATX-101 or placebo. Coprimary end points, evaluated at 12 weeks after last treatment, were composite improvements of 1 or more grades and 2 or more grades in SMF observed on both the validated Clinician- and Patient-Reported SMF Rating Scales. Other end points included magnetic resonance imaging-based assessment of submental volume, assessment of psychological impact of SMF, and additional patient-reported outcomes.

RESULTS

Among those treated with ATX-101 or placebo (n = 258/treatment group), 66.5% versus 22.2%, respectively, achieved a composite improvement of 1 or more grades (Mantel-Haenszel risk ratio 2.98; 95% confidence interval 2.31-3.85) and 18.6% versus 3.0% achieved a composite improvement of 2 or more grades in SMF (Mantel-Haenszel risk ratio 6.27; 95% confidence interval 2.91-13.52; P < .001 for both). Those treated with ATX-101 were more likely to achieve submental volume reduction confirmed by magnetic resonance imaging, greater reduction in psychological impact of SMF, and satisfaction with treatment (P < .001 for all). Overall, 85.7% of adverse events in the ATX-101 group and 76.9% in the placebo group were localized to the injection site.

LIMITATIONS

Follow-up was limited to 44 weeks.

CONCLUSION

ATX-101 is an alternative treatment for SMF reduction.

Mesotherapy, Microneedling, and Chemical Peels

Mesotherapy, microneedling, and chemical peels are minimally invasive techniques used to combat facial aging. Chemical peeling is one of the oldest methods of facial rejuvenation. By using different chemicals in various combinations, strengths, and application techniques, plastic surgeons can tailor a patient's treatment for optimal, safe, and consistent results. Mesotherapy and microneedling have emerged in the plastic surgery literature with increasingly complex indications. Both techniques have increased in popularity although research into efficacy and long-term results is lagging. With a thorough understanding of patients and the modalities available, plastic surgeons can use the appropriate minimally invasive technique to provide patients with desired skin changes.

Safety and efficacy of cryolipolysis for non-invasive reduction of submental fat

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Cryolipolysis has previously received FDA clearance for fat reduction in the abdomen, flanks, and thighs. There is also interest in small volume fat reduction for areas such as the chin, knees, and axilla. This article reports the results of a cryolipolysis pivotal IDE study for reduction of submental fullness.

STUDY DESIGN/MATERIAL AND METHODS

A prototype small volume vacuum applicator (CoolMini applicator, CoolSculpting System, ZELTIQ Aesthetics) was used to treat 60 subjects in the submental area. At each treatment visit, a single treatment cycle was delivered at -10°C for 60 minutes, the same temperature and duration used in current commercially-available cryolipolysis vacuum applicators. At the investigator's discretion, an optional second treatment was delivered 6 weeks after the initial treatment. The primary efficacy endpoint was 80% correct identification of baseline photographs by independent physician review. The primary safety endpoint was monitoring incidence of device- and/or procedure-related serious adverse events. Secondary endpoints included assessment of fat layer thickness by ultrasound and subject satisfaction surveys administered 12 weeks after final cryolipolysis treatment.

RESULTS

Independent photo review from 3 blinded physicians found 91% correct identification of baseline clinical photographs. Ultrasound data indicated mean fat layer reduction of 2.0 mm. Patient questionnaires revealed 83% of subjects were satisfied, 80% would recommend submental cryolipolysis to a friend, 77% reported visible fat reduction, 77% felt that their appearance improved following the treatment, and 76% found the procedure to be comfortable. No device- or procedure-related serious adverse events were reported.

CONCLUSION

The results of this clinical evaluation of 60 patients treated in a pivotal IDE study demonstrate that submental fat can be reduced safely and effectively with a small volume cryolipolysis applicator. Patient surveys revealed that submental cryolipolysis was well-tolerated, produced visible improvement in the neck contour, and generated high patient satisfaction. These study results led to FDA clearance of cryolipolysis for submental fat treatment.