Complications of Aesthetic Surgical Tourism Treated in the USA: A Systematic Review

Domestic and International Cosmetic Tourism Complications Presenting to a US Tertiary Hospital

BACKGROUND

Cosmetic surgery tourism has become a significant global industry. Often patients who develop postoperative complications present for care in their US home state.

OBJECTIVES

In this study we evaluated patients who either traveled abroad or to other states within the United States for cosmetic surgeries and later came with complications for treatment at the authors' center. We sought to compare rates of complications between patients who underwent cosmetic surgery internationally and domestically.

METHODS

In this retrospective cross-sectional study we reviewed patients who presented from June 2014 to June 2022 with concerns related to cosmetic surgeries performed in another state or abroad. Binary logistic regressions were performed to assess differences in outcomes between domestic and international cases, including complications, interventions, and admissions.

RESULTS

One-hundred twenty-three patients (97.6% female, mean age 34.0 ± 8.7 years, range 16-62 years) sought 159 emergency department consultations. The most common procedures included abdominoplasty (n = 72) and liposuction (n = 56). Complications included wound dehiscence (n = 39), infection (n = 38), and seroma (n = 34). Over one-half of patients required intervention. Twenty-nine patients (23.6%) required hospital admission. On multivariate regression analyses, incidence of seroma (P = .025) and oral (P = .036) and intravenous antibiotic prescriptions (P = .045) was significantly greater among the international cohort than the domestic, and all other complication variables were nonsignificant. There were no other significant differences in operative interventions or hospital admissions between international and domestic cohorts.

CONCLUSIONS

Compared to domestic tourism cases, international tourism cases were associated with significantly higher rates of seroma formation and antibiotic use. There were no significant differences otherwise in overall complications, including infections, operative interventions, or hospital admissions.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE: 3

Ethics in Global Plastic Surgery Missions

Background

Delivering ethical care in global plastic surgery is challenging due to the unique complexities of resource-limited settings. Additionally, the rise of medical tourism has highlighted the importance of informed consent and awareness of the potential risks that are associated with seeking medical care in foreign countries. This article aims to consider core medical ethics principles and apply them in the context of delivering global plastic surgery.

Methods

This article examines the application of the four core medical ethics principles in a framework set forth by Beauchamp and Childress, namely autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice, in the context of delivering plastic surgery in international settings. A literature review was performed, where all potential global plastic surgery articles were reviewed to better understand the application of the four core medical ethics framework in this context.

Results

Increased communication between visiting surgeons and local healthcare providers; heightened education of surgeons traveling to low-to-middle-income countries regarding local medical practices, resource availability, and cultural norms before providing surgical education; and a greater emphasis on collecting and publishing data analyzing short- and long-term outcomes in low-to-middle-income countries are all likely to improve the success of international medical missions, ensuring that all patients receive medical treatment in a manner that upholds Beauchamp and Childress' four core medical ethics principles.

Conclusion

Providing plastic and reconstructive surgery abroad can be done ethically if the four main principles of medical ethics (respect for autonomy, beneficence, nonmaleficence, and justice) are used.

Unintended Souvenirs: Case Report of a Retained Foreign Body During Cosmetic Surgery Tourism

Medical tourism has grown exponentially, spurred by incentives such as cost reductions, minimal wait times, and the allure of recuperative vacations. However, this trend carries substantial risks, as illustrated by the case of a 52-year-old female patient who underwent an abdominoplasty as part of a medical tourism package in Miami, FL, which resulted in a retained foreign body. The case highlights the broader issues of continuity of care, patient safety, and the legal and ethical ramifications faced by patients opting for medical tourism surgical procedures domestically and abroad. It also emphasizes the need for updated standards from professional societies and international cooperation to safeguard patient well-being in the expanding medical tourism sector. Lastly, it underscores the need for physicians and surgeons who manage these complications at home to recognize that prompt management and intervention are critical to avoid the escalation of complications and the increased risk of morbidity and mortality.

Level of Evidence 5 Therapeutic

Using Microeconomic Spending Traits to Inform Trends in Utilization of Cosmetic Procedures by Race and Ethnicity

Background

Cosmetic plastic surgery in the United States is underutilized by African American and Hispanic populations compared with their White and Asian counterparts. This study evaluated whether microeconomic spending traits as a representation of financial stability can inform trends in cosmetic procedure volumes by racial group.

Methods

Annual volumes for the top five cosmetic surgical and cosmetic minimally invasive procedures by racial/ethnic group from 2012 to 2020 were collected from the American Society of Plastic Surgeons' annual reports. Factor analysis was used to calculate inflexible and flexible consumer spending by racial/ethnic groupings from the US Bureau of Labor Statistics' consumer expenditure data. All four factors were calculated across US Bureau of Labor Statistics-defined racial/ethnic groupings and standardized so they could be interpreted relative to each other.

Results

Compared with the other groupings, the White/Asian/other grouping spent significantly more on average for inflexible consumer spending (P = 0.0097), flexible consumer spending (P < 0.0001), cosmetic surgical procedures (P < 0.0001), and cosmetic minimally invasive procedures (P = 0.0006). In contrast, African American people spent significantly less on average for all four factors (all P < 0.01). For Hispanic people, values were significantly less on average for flexible consumer spending (P = 0.0023), cosmetic surgical procedures (P < 0.0001), and cosmetic minimally invasive procedures (P = 0.0002).

Conclusions

This study demonstrates that inflexible and flexible consumer spending follow trends in utilization of cosmetic surgical and minimally invasive procedures by racial/ethnic groups. These microeconomic spending inequities may help further contextualize the racial/ethnic variation in access to cosmetic surgery.

Challenges with medical tourism

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

With the return of international travels to almost prepandemic levels, the number of patients who travel abroad to seek healthcare services is once again growing rapidly. Nevertheless, the expected benefits of medical tourism may be challenged by serious infectious complications. This review summarizes the evolving published evidence on infectious complications related with medical tourism of the last eighteen months.

RECENT FINDINGS

There has been an increase of reported infectious complications in patients who had received healthcare abroad. Such complications were frequently associated with serious and prolonged morbidity, repeated treatments and hospitalizations, high healthcare costs, and occasionally fatalities. A devastating outbreak of fungal meningitis occurred among US residents who underwent epidural anesthesia for cosmetic surgery in two clinics in Mexico. Overall, as of July 5, 2023 there were 31 cases with severe cerebrovascular complications and eight deaths. Infections caused by nontuberculum mycobacteria and Candida sp have been also reported the last years.

SUMMARY

Considering the expected expansion of medical tourism in the forthcoming years, public health authorities and scientific societies should raise awareness of such infections among physicians and other healthcare professionals and issue recommendations for their management. A system to report complications in patients receiving healthcare abroad is needed.

Silicone Embolism Syndrome Causing Altered Mental Status and Respiratory Failure After an Unlicensed Gluteal Silicone Injection: A Case Report

Introduction

Unlicensed cosmetic procedures, which come at increased risk of infection and potential surgical complications, have introduced new challenges in healthcare. Physicians should be aware of presentations that may arise secondary to these procedures.

Case Report

We describe a case in which a previously healthy, 28-year-old female presented with new-onset seizures and acute respiratory distress syndrome (ARDS) in the setting of a recent cosmetic procedure with silicone injections to the gluteal region. The patient's hospital course was complicated by altered mental status, respiratory failure, rapid hemodynamic compromise, and eventual death.

Conclusion

In rare cases, one possible complication of cosmetic procedures is silicone embolism syndrome, which is characterized by pneumonitis, alveolar hemorrhage, and ARDS. The patient described in this report also experienced neurologic symptoms including seizure and altered mental status. This is a clinical diagnosis that relies upon thorough history-taking and detailed physical exam. Documentation on this phenomenon is limited, and medical management has not yet been standardized for this condition. Morbidity and mortality remain high.

Deaths of U.S. Citizens Undergoing Cosmetic Surgery - Dominican Republic, 2009-2022

Although infections resulting from cosmetic surgery performed outside the United States have been regularly reported, deaths have rarely been identified. During 2009-2022, 93 U.S. citizens died after receiving cosmetic surgery in the Dominican Republic. The number of deaths increased from a mean of 4.1 per year during 2009-2018 to a mean of 13.0 during 2019-2022 with a peak in of 17 in 2020. A subset of post-cosmetic surgery deaths occurring during peak years was investigated, and most deaths were found to be the result of embolic events (fat emboli or venous thromboembolism) for which a high proportion of the patients who died had risk factors, including obesity and having multiple procedures performed during the same operation. These risk factors might have been mitigated or prevented with improved surgical protocols and postoperative medical care, including prophylactic measures against venous thromboembolism. U.S. citizens interested in receiving elective cosmetic surgery outside the United States should consult with their health care professionals regarding their risk for adverse outcomes. Public health authorities can support provider education on the importance of preoperative patient evaluation and the potential danger of performing multiple cosmetic procedures in one operation.

Plastic Surgery Tourism: Complications, Costs, and Unnecessary Spending?

Background

The liability of plastic surgery tourism in patient health and postoperative resource allocation is significant. Procedures completed within the context of medical tourism often lack rigorous quality assurance and provide limited preoperative evaluation or postoperative care. Not only does this jeopardize the patient's well-being, but it also increases the financial burden and redirects invaluable resources domestically through often unnecessary diagnostic tests and hospitalizations.

Objectives

This manuscript will examine the complications and associated costs following plastic surgery tourism and highlight unnecessary expenses for patients with outpatient complications.

Methods

A retrospective review was conducted of all patients 18 years or older who underwent destination surgery and were seen within 1 year postoperatively in consultation with plastic surgery at our health system between January 11, 2015 and January 7, 2022. Patient admissions were reviewed and deemed necessary or unnecessary after review by 2 physicians.

Results

The inclusion criteria were met by 41 patients, of whom hospitalization was deemed necessary in 28 patients vs unnecessary in 13 patients. The most common procedures included abdominoplasty, liposuction, breast augmentation, and "Brazilian butt lift." The most common complications were seroma and infection. Patients deemed to have a necessary admission often required at least 1 operation, were more likely to need intravenous antibiotics, were less likely to have the diagnosis of "pain," necessitated a longer hospitalization, and incurred a higher cost. The total financial burden was $523,272 for all 41 patients.

Conclusions

Plastic surgery tourism poses substantial health risks, the morbidities are expensive, and it strains hospital resources.

Level of Evidence 5