Cost-effectiveness of noninvasive telemedical interventional management in patients with heart failure: health economic analysis of the TIM-HF2 trial

The present and future of cardiological telemonitoring in Europe: a statement from seven European countries

Cardiovascular diseases remain one of the leading causes of death worldwide, placing a significant burden on individuals, families and healthcare systems. Telemedicine, in particular remote monitoring of patients with cardiovascular diseases, reduces this burden as it links the continuous monitoring of the health status with individual education and adaptation of the therapy to the needs of the patients. This improves patient outcomes and facilitates access to specialised healthcare services, independent of time and distance. Furthermore, telemedicine enables improvements in efficiency and promotes patients' self-care. However, the widespread adoption of remote patient monitoring faces several hurdles. A round table of experts from seven European countries (France, Germany, Italy, Poland, Spain, the Netherlands and the United Kingdom) reviewed the current state of telemedicine within the participating countries in order to learn from each other with an impetus for European co-operation. The creation of reliable regulations, overcoming regional differences, the redefinition of roles and processes, the personalisation of healthcare services, the promotion of innovation and research, the use of artificial intelligence and, finally, the efficient management and safeguarding of healthcare data were identified as key levers for further development of telemedicine. This discussion paper emphasises the need for cross-national research activities, involving all stakeholders, such as researchers, industry and patients, to foster the integration of telemedicine in clinical pathways.

Linkage of Clinical Trial Data to Routinely Collected Data Sources: A Scoping Review

Importance

Patients who participate in clinical trials generate valuable routinely collected data (eg, medical records, electronic health records, claims databases, disease registries, or vital statistics) through their routine interactions with the health care system before, during, and after the trial. When this routinely collected data is linked at the participant level, it can supplement active data collection in the trial and provide deeper insights into the benefits, risks, and costs of treatments.

Objective

To review clinical trials linked to routinely collected data in various countries, identifying the use cases and designs of these linkage studies.

Evidence Review

Research articles that reported the linkage of clinical trials to medical records, electronic health records, claims databases, disease registries, or vital statistics in their title or abstract were searched for in PubMed and MEDLINE. The search covered the period from January 1, 2016, through December 30, 2023. Opinion pieces, study protocols, or studies that involved interventions other than medications, dietary supplements, vaccines, devices, procedures, or diagnostics (eg, behavioral interventions) were excluded. Study eligibility and data extraction were performed independently by 2 reviewers to ensure the accuracy of findings.

Findings

Of the 990 abstracts initially screened, a full text review was conducted for 147 articles. In total, 71 studies were included in the results, including 42 medication, vaccine, and dietary supplement trials (59.2%) and 29 device, procedure, or diagnostic trials (40.8%). Of these 71 studies, 24 (32.4%) were conducted in the US. In 32 studies (45.1%), consent for linkage was obtained prospectively as part of the main trial, while 33 studies (46.5%) received a waiver of authorization from the respective ethical review boards. The most frequent use cases of linkage to were posttrial long-term follow-up (22 studies [31.0%]), capturing primary or secondary outcomes of trials (19 studies [26.8%]), validation of routinely collected data outcomes (17 studies [23.9%]), and measuring health care resource utilization and cost in trials (12 studies [16.9%]).

Conclusions and Relevance

This study found that the linkage of patients' clinical trial data to routinely collected data has been implemented in several trials for various use cases and that most studies obtained consent for linkage prospectively as part of the main trial or received a waiver of authorization from ethical review boards. These findings demonstrate the feasibility and provide an overview of the use cases for linking trials to routinely collected data.

Cost-effectiveness of a multidimensional post-discharge disease management program for heart failure patients-economic evaluation along a one-year observation period

OBJECTIVE

This study aimed to assess the cost-effectiveness of the telemedically assisted post-discharge management program (DMP) HerzMobil Tirol (HMT) for heart failure (HF) patients in clinical practice in Austria.

METHODS

We conducted a cost-effectiveness analysis along a retrospective cohort study (2016-2019) of HMT with a propensity score matched cohort of 251 individuals in the HMT and 257 in the usual care (UC) group and a 1-year follow-up. We calculated the effectiveness (hospital-free survival, hospital-free life-years gained, and number of avoided rehospitalizations), costs (HMT, rehospitalizations), and the incremental cost-effectiveness ratio (ICER). We performed a nonparametric sensitivity analysis with bootstrap sampling and sensitivity analyses on costs of HF rehospitalizations and on costs per disease-related diagnosis (DRG) score for rehospitalizations.

RESULTS

Base-case analysis showed that HMT resulted in an average of 42 additional hospital-free days, 40 additional days alive, and 0.12 avoided hospitalizations per patient-year compared with UC during follow-up. The average HMT costs were EUR 1916 per person. Mean rehospitalization costs were EUR 5551 in HMT and EUR 6943 in UC. The ICER of HMT compared to UC was EUR 4773 per life-year gained outside the hospital. In a sensitivity analysis, HMT was cost-saving when "non-HF related costs" related to the DMP were replaced with average costs.

CONCLUSIONS

The economic evaluation along the cohort study showed that the HerzMobil Tirol is very cost-effective compared to UC and cost-saving in a sensitivity analysis correcting for "non-HF related costs." These findings promote a widespread adoption of telemedicine-assisted DMP for HF.

Economic Evaluations of Digital Health Interventions for Patients With Heart Failure: Systematic Review

BACKGROUND

Digital health interventions (DHIs) have shown promising results in enhancing the management of heart failure (HF). Although health care interventions are increasingly being delivered digitally, with growing evidence on the potential cost-effectiveness of adopting them, there has been little effort to collate and synthesize the findings.

OBJECTIVE

This study's objective was to systematically review the economic evaluations that assess the adoption of DHIs in the management and treatment of HF.

METHODS

A systematic review was conducted using 3 electronic databases: PubMed, EBSCOhost, and Scopus. Articles reporting full economic evaluations of DHIs for patients with HF published up to July 2023 were eligible for inclusion. Study characteristics, design (both trial based and model based), input parameters, and main results were extracted from full-text articles. Data synthesis was conducted based on the technologies used for delivering DHIs in the management of patients with HF, and the findings were analyzed narratively. The PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines were followed for this systematic review. The reporting quality of the included studies was evaluated using the CHEERS (Consolidated Health Economic Evaluation Reporting Standards) guidelines.

RESULTS

Overall, 27 economic evaluations were included in the review. The economic evaluations were based on models (13/27, 48%), trials (13/27, 48%), or a combination approach (1/27, 4%). The devices evaluated included noninvasive remote monitoring devices (eg, home telemonitoring using digital tablets or specific medical devices that enable transmission of physiological data), telephone support, mobile apps and wearables, remote monitoring follow-up in patients with implantable medical devices, and videoconferencing systems. Most of the studies (24/27, 89%) used cost-utility analysis. The majority of the studies (25/27, 93%) were conducted in high-income countries, particularly European countries (16/27, 59%) such as the United Kingdom and the Netherlands. Mobile apps and wearables, remote monitoring follow-up in patients with implantable medical devices, and videoconferencing systems yielded cost-effective results or even emerged as dominant strategies. However, conflicting results were observed, particularly in noninvasive remote monitoring devices and telephone support. In 15% (4/27) of the studies, these DHIs were found to be less costly and more effective than the comparators (ie, dominant), while 33% (9/27) reported them to be more costly but more effective with incremental cost-effectiveness ratios below the respective willingness-to-pay thresholds (ie, cost-effective). Furthermore, in 11% (3/27) of the studies, noninvasive remote monitoring devices and telephone support were either above the willingness-to-pay thresholds or more costly than, yet as effective as, the comparators (ie, not cost-effective). In terms of reporting quality, the studies were classified as good (20/27, 74%), moderate (6/27, 22%), or excellent (1/27, 4%).

CONCLUSIONS

Despite the conflicting results, the main findings indicated that, overall, DHIs were more cost-effective than non-DHI alternatives.

TRIAL REGISTRATION

PROSPERO CRD42023388241; https://tinyurl.com/2p9axpmc.

Effectiveness of Telemonitoring in Reducing Hospitalization and Associated Costs for Patients With Heart Failure in Finland: Nonrandomized Pre-Post Telemonitoring Study

BACKGROUND

Many patients with chronic heart failure (HF) experience a reduced health status, leading to readmission after hospitalization despite receiving conventional care. Telemonitoring approaches aim to improve the early detection of HF decompensations and prevent readmissions. However, knowledge about the impact of telemonitoring on preventing readmissions and related costs remains scarce.

OBJECTIVE

This study assessed the effectiveness of adding a telemonitoring solution to the standard of care (SOC) for the prevention of hospitalization and related costs in patients with HF in Finland.

METHODS

We performed a nonrandomized pre-post telemonitoring study to estimate health care costs and resource use during 6 months on SOC followed by 6 months on SOC with a novel telemonitoring solution. The telemonitoring solution consisted of a digital platform for patient-reported symptoms and daily weight and blood pressure measurements, automatically generated alerts triggering phone calls with secondary care nurses, and rapid response to alerts by treating physicians. Telemonitoring solution data were linked to patient register data on primary care, secondary care, and hospitalization. The patient register of the Southern Savonia Social and Health Care Authority (Essote) was used. Eligible patients had at least 1 hospital admission within the last 12 months and self-reported New York Heart Association class II-IV from the central hospital in the Southern Savonia region.

RESULTS

Out of 50 recruited patients with HF, 43 completed the study and were included in the analysis. The hospitalization-related cost decreased (49%; P=.03) from €2189 (95% CI €1384-€2994; a currency exchange rate of EUR €1=US $1.10589 is applicable) during SOC to €1114 (95% CI €425-€1803) during telemonitoring. The number of patients with at least 1 hospitalization due to HF was reduced by 70% (P=.002) from 20 (47%) out of 43patients during SOC to 6 (14%) out of 43 patients in telemonitoring. The estimated mean total health care cost per patient was €3124 (95% CI €2212-€4036) during SOC and €2104 (95% CI €1313-€2895) during telemonitoring, resulting in a 33% reduction (P=.07) in costs with telemonitoring.

CONCLUSIONS

The results suggest that the telemonitoring solution can reduce hospital-related costs for patients with HF with a recent hospital admission.

Digital Transformation in the Diagnostics and Therapy of Cardiovascular Diseases: Comprehensive Literature Review

BACKGROUND

The digital transformation of our health care system has experienced a clear shift in the last few years due to political, medical, and technical innovations and reorganization. In particular, the cardiovascular field has undergone a significant change, with new broad perspectives in terms of optimized treatment strategies for patients nowadays.

OBJECTIVE

After a short historical introduction, this comprehensive literature review aimed to provide a detailed overview of the scientific evidence regarding digitalization in the diagnostics and therapy of cardiovascular diseases (CVDs).

METHODS

We performed an extensive literature search of the PubMed database and included all related articles that were published as of March 2022. Of the 3021 studies identified, 1639 (54.25%) studies were selected for a structured analysis and presentation (original articles: n=1273, 77.67%; reviews or comments: n=366, 22.33%). In addition to studies on CVDs in general, 829 studies could be assigned to a specific CVD with a diagnostic and therapeutic approach. For data presentation, all 829 publications were grouped into 6 categories of CVDs.

RESULTS

Evidence-based innovations in the cardiovascular field cover a wide medical spectrum, starting from the diagnosis of congenital heart diseases or arrhythmias and overoptimized workflows in the emergency care setting of acute myocardial infarction to telemedical care for patients having chronic diseases such as heart failure, coronary artery disease, or hypertension. The use of smartphones and wearables as well as the integration of artificial intelligence provides important tools for location-independent medical care and the prevention of adverse events.

CONCLUSIONS

Digital transformation has opened up multiple new perspectives in the cardiovascular field, with rapidly expanding scientific evidence. Beyond important improvements in terms of patient care, these innovations are also capable of reducing costs for our health care system. In the next few years, digital transformation will continue to revolutionize the field of cardiovascular medicine and broaden our medical and scientific horizons.

Healthcare costs of a telemonitoring programme for heart failure: indirect deterministic data linkage analysis

AIMS

We aim to evaluate the costs associated with healthcare resource consumption for chronic heart failure (HF) management in patients allocated to telemonitoring versus standard of care (SC).

METHODS AND RESULTS

OSICAT-ECO involved 745 patients from the OSICAT trial (NCT02068118) who were successfully linked to the French national healthcare database through an indirect deterministic data linkage approach. OSICAT compared a telemonitoring programme with SC follow-up in adults hospitalized for acute HF ≤ 12 months. Healthcare resource costs included those related to hospital and ambulatory expenditure for HF and were restricted to direct costs determined from the French health data system over 18 months of follow-up. Most of the total costs (69.4%) were due to hospitalization for HF decompensation, followed by ambulatory nursing fees (11.8%). During 18-month follow-up, total costs were 2% lower in the telemonitoring versus the SC group, due primarily to a 21% reduction in nurse fees. Among patients with NYHA class III/IV, a 15% reduction in total costs (€3131 decrease) was observed over 18-month follow-up in the telemonitoring versus the SC group, with the highest difference in hospital expenditure during the first 6 months, followed by a shift in costs from hospital to ambulatory at 12 months.

CONCLUSIONS

HF hospitalization and ambulatory nursing fees represented most of the costs related to HF. No benefit was observed for telemonitoring versus SC with regard to cost reductions over 18 months. Patients with severe HF showed a non-significant 15% reduction in costs, largely related to hospitalization for HF decompensation, nurse fees, and medical transport.

Digital Technologies to Support Better Outcome and Experience of Care in Patients with Heart Failure

PURPOSE OF REVIEW

In this article, we review a range of digital technologies for possible application in heart failure patients, with a focus on lessons learned. We also discuss a future model of heart failure management, as digital technologies continue to become part of standard care.

RECENT FINDINGS

Digital technologies are increasingly used by healthcare professionals and those living with heart failure to support more personalised and timely shared decision-making, earlier identification of problems, and an improved experience of care. The COVID-19 pandemic has accelerated the acceptability and implementation of a range of digital technologies, including remote monitoring and health tracking, mobile health (wearable technology and smartphone-based applications), and the use of machine learning to augment data interpretation and decision-making. Much has been learned over recent decades on the challenges and opportunities of technology development, including how best to evaluate the impact of digital health interventions on health and healthcare, the human factors involved in implementation and how best to integrate dataflows into the clinical pathway. Supporting patients with heart failure as well as healthcare professionals (both with a broad range of health and digital literacy skills) is crucial to success. Access to digital technologies and the internet remains a challenge for some patients. The aim should be to identify the right technology for the right patient at the right time, in a process of co-design and co-implementation with patients.

[Telemedicine in chronic heart failure-From clinical studies to standard care]

Telemedicine has the potential to solve many current and especially future challenges in medical care. Using the example of heart failure (HF), the transition of telemedicine from clinical studies to standard care is presented. In patients with chronic HF, randomized controlled trials have shown that telemedicine-based care leads to a reduction in mortality and cardiovascular morbidity. Based on these data, the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA) decided that for the first time a digital method should be introduced into standard care for high-risk patients with reduced left ventricular ejection fraction. In the future, this group of patients will be entitled to telemedical care using active rhythm devices or noninvasive measuring devices. The indications are assessed by the primary treating physician (PBA), who works together with a telemedicine center (TMZ) managed through cardiology that receives daily telemetric data and notifies the PBA of abnormal findings. Alternatively, a cardiologist PBA with an associated TMZ infrastructure can also provide telemedical care. In the future, advanced technologies such as artificial intelligence or mobile communication standard 5G will help to make telemedicine both widely available and usable for alternative sensor technology.