Lower revascularization rates after high-speed rotational atherectomy compared to modified balloons in calcified coronary lesions: 5-year outcomes of the randomized PREPARE-CALC trial

Orbital atherectomy versus balloon angioplasty before drug-eluting stent implantation in severely calcified lesions eligible for both treatment strategies (ECLIPSE): a multicentre, open-label, randomised trial

BACKGROUND

Coronary artery calcification is common among patients undergoing percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI), and severe coronary artery lesion calcification is associated with increased procedural complexity, stent under-expansion, and high rates of intraprocedural complications and out-of-hospital adverse events. Whether calcium ablation before stent implantation can mitigate these adverse events is not currently established. We aimed to prospectively compare orbital atherectomy with a balloon angioplasty-based strategy before stent implantation for the treatment of severely calcified coronary lesions.

METHODS

In this multicentre, open-label, randomised controlled trial conducted at 104 medical centres in the USA, patients (aged ≥18 years) with severely calcified coronary lesions were randomly assigned (1:1) to orbital atherectomy or balloon angioplasty before PCI with drug-eluting stents using a web-based system (block sizes of four and six) and stratified by intended treatment of single versus multiple lesions and enrolling site. Randomly assigned lesions were deemed by operators to be eligible for both treatment strategies. Operators and patients were not masked to treatment. The two powered coprimary study endpoints were target vessel failure at 1 year (a composite of cardiac death, target vessel myocardial infarction, or ischaemia-driven target vessel revascularisation) and post-procedural minimal stent area at the site of maximal calcification, as assessed by intravascular optical coherence tomography in an imaging patient cohort. Primary analyses were by intention-to-treat. The trial is registered at ClinicalTrials.govNCT03108456, and 2-year follow-up is ongoing.

FINDINGS

From March 27, 2017, to April 13, 2023, 2005 patients with 2492 lesions were randomly assigned to lesion preparation with orbital atherectomy (1008 patients with 1250 lesions) or balloon angioplasty (997 with 1242 lesions) before stent implantation. Median patient age was 70·0 years (IQR 64·0-76·0). 541 (27·0%) of 2005 patients were female and 1464 (73·0%) were male. Angiographically severe calcium was confirmed by the core laboratory in 1088 (97·1%) of 1120 lesions assigned to orbital atherectomy and 1068 (97·0%) of 1101 lesions assigned to balloon angioplasty. PCI was guided by intravascular imaging in 627 (62·2%) of 1008 patients in the orbital atherectomy group and 619 (62·1%) of 997 in the balloon angioplasty group. Target vessel failure events within 1 year occurred in 113 of 1008 patients in the orbital atherectomy group (1-year target vessel failure 11·5% [95% CI 9·7 to 13·7]) and in 97 of 997 patients in the balloon angioplasty group (10·0% [8·3 to 12·1]; absolute difference 1·5% [96% CI -1·4 to 4·4]; hazard ratio 1·16 [96% CI 0·87 to 1·54], p=0·28). Among those in the optical coherence tomography substudy cohort (276 patients with 286 lesions in the orbital atherectomy group and 279 patients with 292 lesions in the balloon angioplasty group), the mean minimal stent area at the site of maximal calcification was 7·67 mm2 (SD 2·27) in the orbital atherectomy group and 7·42 mm2 (2·54) in the balloon angioplasty group (mean difference 0·26 [99% CI -0·31 to 0·82]; p=0·078). Cardiac death events within 1 year occurred in 39 of 1008 patients in the orbital atherectomy group and in 26 of 997 in the balloon angioplasty group.

INTERPRETATION

Routine treatment with orbital atherectomy before drug-eluting stent implantation did not increase minimal stent area or reduce the rate of target vessel failure at 1 year compared with a balloon angioplasty-based approach in severely calcified lesions deemed eligible for both treatment strategies. These data support a balloon-first approach for most calcified coronary artery lesions that can be crossed and dilated before stent implantation, guided by intravascular imaging.

FUNDING

Abbott Vascular (Abbott).

Fracture of Rotational Atherectomy Burr: Pre-Fracture Signs, Mechanisms, and Management Strategies

BACKGROUND

Burr fracture during rotational atherectomy (RA) is a rare but potentially devastating complication. Due to its infrequency, comprehensive data on its incidence, mechanisms, and management are lacking. This study aimed to investigate the incidence, contributing factors, and management strategies for burr fractures during RA procedures.

METHODS

This retrospective analysis included all patients who underwent PCI with RA at a single center between January 2013 and October 2024. Data were collected from a prospective registry.

RESULTS

Among 3738 patients, three cases of burr fracture without entrapment were identified (incidence: 0.08%). Burr fractures occurred at the burr-driveshaft junction (tip fracture) in two cases and at the driveshaft in one case. Pre-fracture warning signs included incoherent burr-advancer knob movement, fluoroscopic translucency, and frequent driveshaft prolapse. Significant proximal tortuosity or enlargement and non-coaxiality between the RA device and the coronary artery were identified as potential contributing factors. In two cases involving tip fractures, simple manual traction removed the fractured burr. In the third case involving driveshaft fracture, coronary rupture necessitated covered stent implantation and urgent surgery.

CONCLUSION

Burr fractures during RA are rare but potentially serious complications. Significant proximal tortuosity or enlargement and non-coaxiality between the RA device and the coronary artery may increase the risk of burr fracture. Recognizing pre-fracture warning signs and understanding the underlying mechanisms are crucial for minimizing complications and optimizing procedural safety.

Calcified coronary lesions: Imaging, prognosis, preparation and treatment state of the art review

Calcific coronary artery stenosis is a complex disease associated with adverse outcomes and suboptimal percutaneous treatment. Calcium plaque modification has emerged as a key strategy to tackle the issues that accompany calcific stenosis - namely reduced device deliverability, unpredictable lesion characteristics, and difficult dilatation. Atherectomy has traditionally been the treatment modality of choice for heavily calcified coronary stenoses. Contemporary technologies have emerged to aid with planning, preparation, and treatment of calcified coronary stenosis in an attempt to improve procedural success and long-term outcomes. In this State Of The Art Review, we synthesize the body of data surrounding the diagnosis, imaging, and treatment of calcific coronary disease, with a focus on i) intravascular imaging, ii) calcific lesion preparation, iii) treatment modalities including atherectomy, and iv) updated treatment algorithms for the management of calcified coronary stenosis.