Biomechanical evaluation of hip joint after Salter innominate osteotomy: a long-term follow-up study

Angulated Salter osteotomy in the treatment of developmental dysplasia of the hip

Salter osteotomy is widely used to improve acetabular coverage in the treatment of developmental dysplasia of the hip. Herein we describe angulated Salter osteotomy (ASO) as the modified Salter osteotomy, which creates a two-point contact between the proximal and distal fragments and better stabilizes the fixation of the fragments. We reported our results of ASO and compared it with that of Salter osteotomy performed previously by us. We retrospectively reviewed 41 unilateral hips that underwent ASO, with no other accompanying procedures, between 2012 and 2018. We investigated the radiographic measurements included the preoperative values of the acetabular index and center-edge angle (CEA), immediate postoperative values of distance d (lateral displacement of the distal fragment), lateral rotation angle (LRA), the ratio of the obturator height (ROH), pelvic height increase percentage (PHIP) and the values of acetabular index and CEA during the last follow-up. Measurements were compared with 20 unilateral hips that underwent Salter osteotomy. The mean age at the time of surgery was 5.4 years, and the mean follow-up duration was 3.3 years. Immediately after surgery, the mean distance d, LRA, ROH and PHIP were 8 mm, 19°, 70 and 1%, respectively. The last follow-up values of acetabular index and CEA significantly improved from the preoperative values by 18° and 21°, respectively. Patients treated with ASO showed significantly larger distance d, more improvement in CEA, and lesser PHIP than those treated with Salter osteotomy. The short-term outcomes of ASO are favorable. ASO was as effective as or better than Salter osteotomy in pulling out and stabilizing the distal fragment anterolaterally. ASO prevents elongation of the ilium, which causes pelvic obliquity.

Impact of triple pelvic osteotomy on contact stress pressure distribution in the hip joint

PURPOSE

We studied changes of contact stress distribution in the hip joint after Tonnis triple pelvic osteotomy applied in the treatment of dysplasia and hip joint incongruence in adolescents.

METHODS

In a group of 75 patients, 54 (72 %) female, who underwent surgery by triple pelvic osteotomy in adolescence for developmental disorder of the hip and avascular necrosis of the femoral head, a three-dimensional hip joint model was used based on the radiography of the pelvis with hips. The following biomechanical parameters were calculated: resultant hip force normalised to body weight (R/Wb), inclination of the resultant hip force (θ-R), the position of the stress pole (θ), peak contact hip stress (Pmax), and peak contact hip stress normalised to body weight (Pmax/Wb). Gait quality was also assessed.

RESULTS

After surgery the Wiberg CE angle was increased by 17.85° (114 %), resultant hip force normalised to body weight (R/Wb) was decreased by 0.107 (3.3 %), the position of the stress pole was shifted medially by 27.59° (63.5 %), and peak contact hip stress normalised to body weight (Pmax/Wb) was decreased by 2249.74 (55.9 %). Waddling gait was reduced from 17 (23.9 %) to four cases (5.6 %). All changes were statistically highly significant (p<0.01).

CONCLUSIONS

The effect of Tonnis triple pelvic osteotomy lies in the improvement of stress distribution across the acetabular cartilage of the hip joint, thus slowing down the degenerative damage of the hip joint.

Radiographic analysis of movements of the acetabulum and the femoral head after Salter innominate osteotomy

BACKGROUND

Salter innominate osteotomy (SIO) is widely used to improve the coverage of the femoral head in dysplastic acetabulum, but the geometric change after osteotomy and its effect on the outcome have not been well elucidated.

METHODS

Pelvic radiographs of the 90 hips in 86 patients who underwent SIO for the treatment of acetabular dysplasia were reviewed and the movement of the distal fragment and the shift of the femoral head after SIO were analyzed. On the basis of the anteroposterior radiographs of the pelvis in a supine position taken at 5 weeks after operation, various parameters including an open-wedged angle at the osteotomy site (lateral rotation angle, LRA), lateral displacement of the distal fragment (distance d), and the ratio of the bilateral obturator foramen heights (the ratio of obturator heights, ROH), were measured. Improvement in the center-edge angle (CEA) and acetabular index (AI) after SIO was correlated with the LRA, distance d, and ROH. Horizontal and vertical distances from the pubic symphysis to the center of the femoral head were also measured from preoperative and postoperative pelvic radiographs and changes in the position of the femoral head were calculated. For the patients who were followed until skeletal maturity, final radiographic results were also assessed according to the Severin classification.

RESULTS

The average improvement of the CEA and AI after SIO was 19.6 and 13.3 degrees, respectively. The average value of the LRA, distance d, and ROH were 30.2 degrees, 4.07 mm, and 73.0%, respectively. The LRA and distance d positively and the ROH negatively correlated with the improvement of the CEA and AI. The center of the femoral head moved an average of 7.06 mm caudally and 3.11 mm medially after SIO. Thirty-six hips (40%) in 36 patients were available for follow-up until skeletal maturity. The radiographic outcome was good (Severin I or II) in 33 hips and poor (Severin III) in 3 hips. Preoperative CEA was relatively smaller in a poor group. Greater improvement of the CEA during postoperative follow-up was observed in a good group.

CONCLUSIONS

Favorable coverage of the femoral head was obtained after SIO by shifting the center of the femoral head caudally and medially as well as rotating the distal fragment anterolaterally. SIO is a very effective procedure in improvement of the dysplastic acetabulum for the hips with round and spherical femoral head.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Therapeutic studies, level III (retrospective study).

Association between Sub-Clinical Acetabular Dysplasia and a Younger Age at Hip Arthroplasty in Idiopathic Osteoarthritis

This retrospective study was designed to investigate whether sub-clinical acetabular dysplasia, defined by a reduced centre-edge angle of Wiberg, was associated with a younger age at hip arthroplasty in patients with idiopathic osteoarthritis (OA). Fifty-four patients with 69 performed arthroplasties and no previous referral for hip dysplasia were selected from a list of consecutive recipients of hip endoprostheses due to idiopathic OA. The centre-edge angle was measured from standard pelvic radiographs taken a mean of 5.1 years prior to the endoprosthesis operation when there were minimal signs of hip OA. The age at which hip arthroplasty was carried out was compared between those patients with low (20° − 35°) and those with high (≥ 35°) centre-edge angles. The mean age at hip arthroplasty was significantly younger in the group with centre-edge angles of 20° − 35° (65.6 years) compared with those with centre-edge angles ≥ 35° (69.2 years). These results suggest that sub-clinical acetabular dysplasia was associated with a younger age at hip arthroplasty in idiopathic OA.

Triple pelvic osteotomy in the treatment of hip dysplasia

INTRODUCTION

Insufficient femoral head coverage is found in a variety of diseases, with acetabular dysplasia as the most frequent disorder and triple pelvic osteotomy as the most recently introduced surgical treatment.

OBJECTIVE

This study analyses pre- and postoperative pathoanatomic characteristics of triple in comparison to Salter and Chiari osteotomies, with a logistic regression analysis of outcome predictor and effect explanator factors in relation to the chosen type of operation.

METHODS

The study involved 136 adolescents treated with Salter and Chiari osteotomies or a triple pelvic osteotomy at the Institute of Orthopaedic Surgery "Banjica" in Belgrade. The patients were between 10-20 years old at the time of operation. We collected and analyzed data from all the patients: illness history, operative parameters, preoperative and postoperative pathoanatomic data. The data was statistically processed using the statistical software SPSS, defining standard descriptive values, and by using the appropriate tests of analytic statistics: t-test for dependent and independent variables, chi2-test, Fisher's exact test, Wilcoxon's test, parameter correlation, one-way ANOVA, multi-factorial ANOVA and logistic regression, according to the type of the analyzed data and the conditions under which the statistical methods were applied.

RESULTS

The average CE angle after triple pelvic osteotomy was 43.5 degrees, more improved than after the Salter osteotomy (33.0 degrees) and Chiari osteotomy (31.4 degrees) (F = 16.822; p < 0.01). Postoperative spherical congruence was also more frequent after the triple osteotomy than after the other two types of operations, and with a high significance. Preoperative painful discomfort was found to be a valid predictor of indications for the triple osteotomy over both Chiari and Salter osteotomies. The valid explanators of effect for the triple osteotomy are: postoperative joint congruence (compared to the Chiari osteotomy) and increase in joint coverage (compared to Salter osteotomy).

CONCLUSION

Triple pelvic osteotomy is the method of choice in the management of acetabular dysplasia and other disturbances of hip joint containment in adolescent age.

The role of obesity, biomechanical constitution of the pelvis and contact joint stress in progression of hip osteoarthritis

OBJECTIVE

The aim of our study was to explore whether earlier hip arthroplasty for idiopathic osteoarthritis (OA) might be explained by enlarged contact stress in the hip joint, and to what amount can that be attributed to obesity and biomechanical constitution of the pelvis.

METHOD

Fifty subjects were selected from a list of consecutive recipients of hip endoprosthesis due to idiopathic OA; standard pelvic radiographs made years prior to surgery were the main selection criteria. For 65 hips resultant hip force and peak contact hip stress normalized to the body weight (R/Wb and p(max)/Wb) were determined from the radiographs with the HIPSTRESS method. Body weight and body mass index (BMI) were obtained with an interview. Regression analysis was used to correlate parameters of obesity (body weight, BMI), biomechanical constitution of the pelvis (R/Wb, p(max)/Wb) and mechanical loading within the hip joint (R, p(max)) with age at hip arthroplasty.

RESULTS

Younger age at hip arthroplasty was associated with higher body weight (P=0.009), higher peak contact hip stress normalized to the body weight - p(max)/Wb (P=0.019), higher resultant hip force -R (P=0.027) and larger peak contact hip stress - p(max) (P<0.001), but not with BMI (P=0.121) or R/Wb (P=0.614).

CONCLUSION

Our results suggest that enlarged contact stress (p(max)) plays an important role in rapid progression of hip OA with both obesity (increased body weight) and unfavorable biomechanical constitution of the pelvis (greater p(max)/Wb) contributing.

Modified pubic osteotomy for medialization of the femoral head in periacetabular osteotomy: a retrospective study of 144 hips

BACKGROUND AND PURPOSE

Medial displacement of the femoral head reduces the force transmitted across the hip joint. Since 2005, we have performed a modified Ganz's osteotomy with curved periacetabular osteotomy (CPO) to obtain medialization of the femoral head. The modification involves cutting of the pubis at 30 degrees to the horizontal line. Here, we examined whether this modified CPO procedure medialized the femoral head more than the conventional CPO procedure.

PATIENTS AND METHODS

69 patients (mean age 37 years, 72 hips) treated with the modified CPO procedure (the M group) were compared with 68 patients (mean age 38 years, 72 hips) previously treated with conventional CPO (the C group). All patients were operated because of dysplastic hips. We used radiographic measurements from anteroposterior radiographs. The magnitude of the resultant hip force normalized with respect to the body weight (R/WB) and hip contact joint stress (Pmax/ WB) was calculated in all cases.

RESULTS

The average lateral center-edge (CE) angle, acetabular roof obliquity (ARO), and acetabulum-head index (AHI) improved in both groups. The CE angle, ARO, and AHI were similar in the 2 groups before and after surgery. Medialization of the femoral head was larger in the M group than in the C group (p < 0.001). The average value of the resultant hip force decreased from 3.2 to 2.9 in the M group and remained unchanged, at 3.1, in the C group. In addition, the average value of the peak contact stress decreased more in the M group (from 9.4 kPa/N to 3.4 kPa/N) than in the C group (from 9.1 kPa/N to 4.3 kPa/N).

INTERPRETATION

In dysplastic hips, the modified CPO reduces the contact hip stress more than the conventional CPO because of better medialization of the femoral head.

Cumulative hip contact stress predicts osteoarthritis in DDH

Hip stresses are generally believed to influence whether a hip develops osteoarthritis (OA); similarly, various osteotomies have been proposed to reduce contact stresses and the risk of OA. We asked whether elevated hip contact stress predicted osteoarthritis in initially asymptomatic human hips. We identified 58 nonoperatively treated nonsubluxated hips with developmental dysplasia (DDH) without symptoms at skeletal maturity; the control group included 48 adult hips without hip disease. The minimum followup was 20 years (mean, 29 years; range, 20-41 years). Peak contact stress was computed with the HIPSTRESS method using anteroposterior pelvic radiographs at skeletal maturity. The cumulative contact stress was determined by multiplying the peak contact stress by age at followup. We compared WOMAC scores and radiographic indices of OA. Dysplastic hips had higher mean peak contact and higher mean cumulative contact stress than normal hips. Mean WOMAC scores and percentage of asymptomatic hips in the study group (mean age 51 years) were similar to those in the control group (mean age 68 years). After adjusting for gender and age, the cumulative contact stress, Wiberg center-edge angle, body mass index, but not the peak contact stress, independently predicted the final WOMAC score in dysplastic hips but not in normal hips. Cumulative contact stress predicted early hip OA better than the Wiberg center-edge angle.

LEVEL OF EVIDENCE

Level II, prognostic study. See the Guidelines for Authors for a complete description of levels of evidence.

Higher peak contact hip stress predetermines the side of hip involved in idiopathic osteoarthritis

BACKGROUND

Biomechanical parameters of the hip have been suggested to have an important influence on the development of osteoarthritis. We aimed to find out whether higher stress is generated in a hip that subsequently results in earlier hip arthroplasty compared to the contralateral hip in the same subject.

METHODS

Standard anterior-posterior pelvic radiographs with no or subtle radiological signs of hip osteoarthritis, of 59 female patients, who underwent hip arthroplasty for primary osteoarthritis years later, were selected from the archives. For each subject peak contact hip stress of the hip with earlier arthroplasty and of the contralateral hip (pair of hips), was calculated from the radiographically obtained geometrical parameters with the HIPSTRESS program, which is based on a three-dimensional biomechanical model of the resultant hip force in the one-legged stance and a three-dimensional mathematical model of the contact hip stress distribution. Differences in peak contact hip stress within pairs of hips were determined for subjects with unilateral (22 pairs of hips) and bilateral disease (37 pairs of hips) by using paired-samples T-test.

FINDINGS

In the population of subjects with unilateral osteoarthritis, average peak contact hip stress was significantly higher (P = 0.007) in hips with arthroplasty (2.44 kPa/N) than in contralateral hips (2.32 kPa/N). In the population of subjects with bilateral osteoarthritis, average peak contact hip stress was significantly higher (P<0.001) in hips with earlier arthroplasty (2.54 kPa/N) than in contralateral hips (2.35 kPa/N).

INTERPRETATION

Results are consistent with the hypothesis that higher peak contact hip stress results in earlier hip arthroplasty due to faster development of idiopathic osteoarthritis.

Association between contact hip stress and RSA-measured wear rates in total hip arthroplasties of 31 patients

BACKGROUND

The main concern in the long run of total hip replacements is aseptic loosening of the prosthesis. Optimization of the biomechanics of the hip joint is necessary for optimization of long-term success. A widely implementable tool to predict biomechanical consequences of preoperatively planned reconstructions still has to be developed. A potentially useful model to this purpose has been developed previously. The aim of this study is to quantify the association between the estimated hip joint contact force by this biomechanical model and RSA-measured wear rates in a clinical setting.

METHODS

Thirty-one patients with a total hip replacement were measured with RSA, the gold standard for clinical wear measurements. The reference examination was done within 1 week of the operation and the follow-up examinations were done at 1, 2 and 5 years. Conventional pelvic X-rays were taken on the same day. The contact stress distribution in the hip joint was determined by the computer program HIPSTRESS. The procedure for the determination of the hip joint contact stress distribution is based on the mathematical model of the resultant hip force in the one-legged stance and the mathematical model of the contact stress distribution. The model for the force requires as input data, several geometrical parameters of the hip and the body weight, while the model for stress requires as input data, the magnitude and direction of the resultant hip force. The stress distribution is presented by the peak stress-the maximal value of stress on the weight-bearing area (p(max)) and also by the peak stress calculated with respect to the body weight (p(max)/W(B)) which gives the effect of hip geometry. Visualization of the relations between predicted values by the model and the wear at different points in the follow-up was done using scatterplots. Correlations were expressed as Pearson r values.

RESULTS

The predicted p(max) and wear were clearly correlated in the first year post-operatively (r = 0.58, p = 0.002), while this correlation is weaker after 2 years (r = 0.19, p = 0.337) and 5 years (r = 0.24, p = 0.235). The wear values at 1, 2 and 5 years post-operatively correlate with each other in the way that is expected considering the wear velocity curve of the whole group. The correlation between the predicted p(max) values of two observers who were blinded for each other's results was very good (r = 0.93, p < 0.001).

CONCLUSION

We conclude that the biomechanical model used in this paper provides a scientific foundation for the development of a new way of constructing preoperative biomechanical plans for total hip replacements.

Slotted acetabular augmentation for the treatment of residual hip dysplasia in adults: early results of 12 patients

INTRODUCTION

Different pelvic osteotomies and various shelf procedures are used for the operative treatment of hip dysplasia. Slotted acetabular augmentation (SAA) is a well-established technique for the treatment of children and adolescents with hip dysplasia. It has not been widely accepted for treating hip dysplasia in adults although good outcomes have been reported with other augmentation techniques in adults.

MATERIALS AND METHODS

Since 1997, SAA has been used for the prevention of hip arthrosis in 14 dysplastic hips in 12 female patients. The median age at operation was 38.5 (17-42) years; the median follow-up period was 4 (1-8) years. The patients were evaluated on the basis of radiographic, biomechanical and clinical data prior to surgery and at follow-up.

RESULTS

The median centre-edge angle of Wiberg increased from 9 degrees (1-26) before the operation to 43 degrees (31-55) at the latest follow-up (P < 0.001). The median peak stress on the weight-bearing area of the hip, calculated mathematically, was reduced from 14.9 (6.3-28-1) MPa prior to the operation to 4.1 (3-6.1) MPa at the latest follow-up (P < 0.001); the median Harris Hip Score increased from 60 (45-98) points preoperatively to 93 (49-100) points at the follow-up (P < 0.001). There was no difference between the preoperative and follow-up hip joint-space width (P = 0.2).

CONCLUSION

There were no postoperative complications. In our series, the procedure has proved reliable and safe. Its advantages include symptomatic pain relief, adequate acetabular roof coverage and reduced peak stress on the weight bearing area of the hip. It can be used to postpone the development of hip arthrosis in adults with acetabular dysplasia.

Contact stress in hips with osteonecrosis of the femoral head

Contact stress distribution in the articular surface of the hip is considered a factor in the development of osteoarthritis, a common complication in hips with aseptic necrosis of the femoral head. We present evidence supporting the hypothesis that osteoarthritis in hips with aseptic necrosis of the femoral head can be caused by elevated contact stress related to the reduced load-bearing ability of the necrotic bone. By using a previously validated mathematical model, we observed that hip contact stress may increase considerably if the load-bearing capacity of the necrotic lesion is decreased, if the size of the necrotic segment is increased, and if the necrotic segment is located more laterally. These effects are affected by the intrinsic shape of the hip. As the estimated values of stress in hips with osteonecrosis are in the range obtained by the same method in dysplastic hips, osteoarthritis in hips with osteonecrosis can be caused by elevated contact stress.

High contact hip stress is related to the development of hip pathology with increasing age

BACKGROUND

High contact hip stress is believed to be one of the key biomechanical factors involved in the hip cartilage degeneration and osteoarthritis. Accordingly, with increasing age high contact hip stress is expected to cause elimination of subjects from the population of healthy hips, but its predictive value has not been evaluated so far. The objective of the paper is to investigate whether the exposure of healthy hips to estimated high contact hip stress is related to the development of hip pathology with increasing age.

METHODS

A cross-sectional age- and gender-matched analysis of the peak contact hip stress calculated from pelvic geometry was made in 103 adult subjects with healthy hips. The peak contact hip stress was calculated from anterior-posterior pelvic radiographs of healthy hips by using a mathematical model of the human hip in the static one-legged stance.

FINDINGS

In both female and male population, the average values of the peak contact hip stress normalized to the body weight are significantly higher and the values are also more dispersed in younger subjects when compared to older subjects.

INTERPRETATION

The hip joints which remain healthy in the old age have lower average estimated peak contact hip stress. These results are consistent with the explanation that subjects with high estimated peak contact hip stress are more likely to develop hip disease in the course of life.

Intertrochanteric osteotomy in young adults for sequelae of Legg-Calvé-Perthes' disease--a long term follow-up

Between 1974 and 1999 we performed 15 intertrochanteric osteotomies in 14 patients with a painful hip secondary to Legg-Calvé-Perthes' disease. In seven patients, the osteotomy was combined with advancement of the greater trochanter, acetabular roof plasty, or both. One patient died 5 years after the osteotomy and one patient was lost to follow-up. One patient had a revision osteotomy 21 years after the initial osteotomy, and five patients had a prosthetic replacement 8-25 years after the osteotomy. The average follow-up of the remaining osteotomies was 11.3 years. An intertrochanteric osteotomy can decrease pain and improve clinical function medium and long term without radiological progression of joint degeneration.

Gradient of contact stress in normal and dysplastic human hips

The stress gradient index (G(p)) is introduced for the assessment of dysplasia in human hip joint. The absolute value of G(p) is equal to the magnitude of the gradient of the contact stress at the lateral acetabular rim. The parameter G(p) normalized with respect to the body weight (W(B)) is determined from the standard anteroposterior radiographs of adult human hips and pelvises using the mathematical model. The average value of G(p)/W(B) was determined for the group of dysplastic hips and for the group of normal hips. In the group of normal hips the average value of G(p)/W(B) is smaller (-0.445x10(5) m(-3)) than in the group of dysplastic hips (+1.481x10(5) m(-3)). The difference is statistically significant P<0.001. The average value of G(p)/W(B) changes its sign at the value of the centre-edge angle theta(CE) approximately 20( composite function ) which is usually considered as the boundary value of theta(CE) (lower limit) for the normal hips. Accordingly we suggest a new definition for the hip dysplasia with respect to the size and sign of the normalized stress gradient index G(p)/W(B). The hips with positive G(p)/W(B) are considered to be dysplastic while the hips with negative G(p)/W(B) are considered to be normal. The statistically significant correlation between the value of the Harris hip score, used in the clinical assessment of the hip dysplasia, and the normalized stress gradient index was found.

Mathematical estimation of stress distribution in normal and dysplastic human hips

By using a mathematical model of the adult human hip in the static one-legged stance position of the body, the forces acting on the hip, peak stress in the hip joint and other relevant radiographic and biomechanical parameters were assessed. The aims were to examine if the peak stress in dysplastic hips is higher than in normal hips and to find out which biomechanical parameters contribute significantly to higher peak stress. The average normalized peak stress in dysplastic hips (7.1 kPa/N) was markedly higher (to approximately 100%) than the average normalized peak stress in normal hips (3.5 kPa/N). The characteristic parameters that contributed to higher peak stress in dysplastic hips included the smaller lateral coverage of the femoral head, the larger interhip distance, the wider pelvis, and the medial position of the greater trochanter. These results are consistent with the hypothesis that stress distribution over weight-bearing surface of the hip joint is the relevant parameter for assessment of the risk for developing coxarthrosis.

Hip stress reduction after Chiari osteotomy

A mathematical model was developed to study the effect of the Chiari osteotomy on the distribution of contact hip stress over the weight-bearing area. It was shown that Chiari osteotomy can increase the weight-bearing area directly (on the lateral side), owing to the additional area formed by the ala ossis ilii segment, and indirectly (on the medial side), owing to the shift of the stress pole in the medial direction. As a consequence, the contact hip stress is reduced after Chiari osteotomy. The indirect effect is important and often larger than the direct one. Using the proposed mathematical model and standard anteroposterior roentgenographs from archives, the average peak stress on the weight-bearing area, normalised with respect to the body weight (pmax/ W(B)), was determined before and after Chiari osteotomy (8,310m(-2) and 4,480 m(-2), respectively) on a population of 29 dysplastic hips. The difference was statistically significant (p < 0.005). Based on the results presented, it can be concluded that the hip joint contact stress in dysplastic hips considerably decreases after Chiari osteotomy, indicating a favourable biomechanical effect of this operation.

Contact Stresses in the Human Hip: Implications for Disease and Treatment

Contact stresses in the hip articular surfaces relate in some way to normal maintenance as well as destruction of joints. In vivo determinations of cartilage-on-cartilage contact pressure histories have never been reported, and current technology does not allow such measurements without the potential for artifact: all experimental methods require introducing some material between the surfaces, and all numerical methods have yet to be fully validated. Nonetheless, a variety of distinct experimental and numerical approaches lead to estimates of contact stresses and surprisingly, despite the choice of technique, values for peak contact stresses lie within a range of one order of magnitude (i.e. 0.5–5.0 MPa) and usually closer. Pathological conditions increase this to the range of over 5.0 MPa, while surgical procedures designed to reduce peak pressures theoretically can achieve reductions. Two critical unresolved issues are 1.) What aspect of the contact stress history (e.g. contact stress gradients over time) in fact cause the biological responses? 2.) What level of contact stress history is tolerated by the cartilage? Future research will need to address these critical issues.