Identifying the barriers to universal cervical length screening for preterm birth prevention at a tertiary hospital in Thailand (patient's perspectives): implementation research

Cervical elastography: finding a novel predictor for improving the prediction of preterm birth in uncomplicated twin pregnancies

OBJECTIVE

This study set out to investigate a novel ultrasound parameter using cervical elastosonography for improving the prediction of spontaneous preterm birth (sPTB) in twin pregnancies.

STUDY DESIGN

The study was comprised of 106 twin pregnancies from October 2020 to January 2022 in Beijing Obstetrics and Gynecology Hospital. They were divided into two groups according to gestational age (GA) at delivery (delivery < 35 weeks and delivery ≥ 35 weeks). There were five elastographic parameters: Elasticity Contrast Index (ECI), Cervical Hardness Ratio (CHR), Closed Internal cervical ostium Strain rate (CIS); External cervical ostium strain rate (ES), CIS/ES ratio and Cervical Length (CL). All of the clinical and ultrasonic indicators with P < 0.1 were considered candidate indicators via univariate logistic regression. Based on the extracted unified combination of clinical indicators, the combinations of permutation with the candidate ultrasound indicators were performed step by step in multivariable logistic regression. The best ultrasound indicator with the lowest Akaike Information Criterion (AIC) and the highest Areas Under the receiver operating characteristic Curve (AUC) was chosen for establishing the prediction score.

RESULTS

Over 30% (36/106) of those who delivered before 35 weeks gestation. There were distinct differences in the clinical characteristics and cervical elastography parameters between the two groups. Seven major clinical variables were identified as a unified clinical indicator. CISmin as the best ultrasound elastography predictor indicated the lowest AIC and the highest AUC and outperformed alternative indicators significantly in the prediction of delivery before 35 weeks of gestation. Unfortunately, CLmin which was commonly used in clinical practice ranked far from all of the cervical elastography parameters and presented the highest AIC and the lowest AUC. A preliminary scoring rule was established and the ability to predict the risk of sPTB in twin pregnancies was improved (Accuracy: 0.896 vs 0.877; AIC: 81.494 vs 91.698; AUC: 0.923 vs 0.906).

CONCLUSIONS

The cervical elastosonography predictor such as CISmin might be a more useful indicator applied for enhancing the ability in predicting twin pregnancies preterm birth than CL. Furthermore, there would be more benefits for advancing clinical decision-making in actual clinical practice by using cervical elastosonography in the near future.

A pragmatic evaluation of the implementation and acceptance of a universal second trimester cervical length screening program in an un-selected population

PURPOSE

To evaluate patients' acceptance of a universal transvaginal ultrasound cervical length (CL) screening program and the feasibility of initiating treatment with progesterone in a clinical setting in women found to have a short cervix.

METHODS

An observational, pragmatic cohort study was conducted at one tertiary care facility from 2012-2015, involving eligible women with singleton pregnancies who accepted and underwent second-trimester CL screening. The primary outcomes were the percentage of women who were eligible and accepting of screening, compliance with progesterone treatment, and the screening value of TVCL in predicting SPTB. Secondary outcomes were the number of women who received progesterone treatment and the rates of SPTB.

RESULTS

Overall cervical length screening acceptance rate was found to be 82.5%. Of the 797 women that underwent screening, 21 women (2.6%) had a TVCL < 25 mm, of whom nine had a TVCL < 20.0 mm. Nineteen of the 21 women with a TVCL < 25 mm were treated with progesterone, with a 94.7% compliance rate. Delivery outcomes were obtained for 767 women. Of those with a TVCL < 25 mm, there was a 35% rate of SPTB as opposed to a 6.3% SPTB rate in those with TVCL > 25 mm. The negative predictive value for SPTB with a TVCL 25 mm or greater was 94.0%.

CONCLUSION

Universal cervical length screening was successfully implemented in 82.5% of the patient population with a high compliance rate with progesterone treatment. Furthermore, there was a higher rate of SPTB in those with a shorter cervix. Based on our outcomes obtained in an observational and pragmatic manner, we showed that incorporating second trimester transvaginal cervical length screening into routine clinical practice is readily accepted and, with the addition of vaginal progesterone treatment, may reduce the rate of prematurity.

Implementing a Universal Cervical Length Screening Program in a Large Hospital System, it Takes Some Time to Achieve Consistent Results

OBJECTIVE

To describe changes in the acceptance of transvaginal (TV) cervical length (CL) measurements, and in the variance of CL measurements among operators, after implementation of universal TV-CL measurements at 18+0-23+6 weeks/days of gestation.

STUDY DESIGN

Retrospective cohort study Participants/Materials, Setting, Methods This study was performed after universal TV-CL screening was implemented at the University of Texas Health Science Center in Houston, Texas, for all women undergoing an anatomy ultrasound (US) between 18 0/6 and 23 6/7 weeks of gestation. Pregnant women carrying singletons without prior history of preterm delivery who underwent anatomy ultrasound evaluation between September 2017 and March 2020 (30 months) were included. The complete study period was divided in five epochs of six months each. Changes in patient's acceptance for the TV scan, in CL distribution, in the prevalence of short cervix defined as ≤15, ≤20, or ≤25 mm, and in the performance of ultrasound operators across the five epochs were evaluated. For this analysis, success rate was defined as the percentage of TV-CL measurements obtained in relation to the number of second trimester anatomy scans.

RESULTS

A total of 22,207 low risk pregnant women evaluated by 36 trained sonographers were analyzed. Overall, the acceptance for TV-CL measurement was 82.3% (18,289/22,207), increasing from 76.7% in the first epoch to 82.8% (p<0.0001) in the last epoch. The mean CL did not significantly change from 38.6 mm in the first epoch to 38.5 mm in the last epoch (p=0.7); however, the standard deviation decreased from 7.9 mm in the first epoch to 7.04 mm in the last epoch (p=<0.01). The prevalence of a short cervix ≤25 mm was 2.2% (n=399/18,289), ≤20 mm was 1.2% (224/18,289), and ≤15 mm was 0.9% (162/18,289). This prevalence varied only for CL ≤25 mm from 3.02% (88/2,907) in the first epoch to 1.77% (64/3,615) in the last epoch (p=0.0009). There was a variation in CL measurements among operators (mean 3.3 mm). Sonographers with less than one year of experience had a lower success rate for completing TV-CL examinations than more experienced sonographers (80.8% vs. 85.8%; p <0.03). In general 77% (27/35) of operators had a success rate ≥80% for completing TV-SL scans.

LIMITATIONS

Characteristics of individuals who accepted versus those who declined TV-CL were not compared; CL values were not correlated with clinical outcomes.

CONCLUSIONS

During the first six months after implementation of a universal cervical length screening program, there was greater variation in CL measurements, lower acceptance for a TV ultrasound, and a higher number of women diagnosed with a CL ≤25 mm, as compared to subsequent epochs. After the first six months, these metrics improved and remained stable. Most operators improved their performance over time; however, there were a few with a low success rate for TV-CL, and others who systematically over or under estimate CL measurements.