Investigation on the correlation between energy deposition and clustered DNA damage induced by low-energy electrons

Position in proton Bragg curve influences DNA damage complexity and survival in head and neck cancer cells

Background and purpose

Understanding the cellular and molecular effect of proton radiation, particularly the increased DNA damage complexity at the distal end of the Bragg curve, is current topic of investigation. This work aims to study in vitro clonogenic survival and DNA damage foci kinetics of a head and neck squamous cell carcinoma cell line at various positions along a double passively scattered Bragg curve. Complementary in silico studies are conducted to gain insights into the link between cell survival variations, experimentally yielded foci and the number and complexity of double strand breaks (DSBs).

Materials and methods

Proton irradiations are performed at the HollandPTC R&D proton beamline, using a double passively scattered setup. A custom water phantom setup is employed to accurately position the samples within the Bragg curve. FaDu cells are irradiated at the proximal 36 % point of the Bragg peak, (P36), proximal 80 % point of the Bragg peak (P80) and distal 20 % point of the Bragg peak (D20), with dose-averaged mean lineal energies (y D ¯ ) of 1.10 keV/μm, 1.80 keV/μm and 7.25 keV/μm, respectively.

Results

Clonogenic survival correlates strongly withy D ¯ , showing similar survival for P36 (D37%=3.0 Gy) and P80 (D37%=2.9 Gy), but decreased survival for D20 (D37% = 1.6 Gy). D20 irradiated samples exhibit increased 53BP1 foci shortly after irradiation, slower resolution of the foci, and larger residual 53BP1 foci after 24 h, indicating unrepaired complex breaks. These experimental observations are supported by the in silico study which demonstrates that irradiation at D20 leads to a 1.7-fold increase in complex DSBs with respect to the total number of strand breaks compared to P36 and P80.

Conclusions

This combined approach provides valuable insights into the cellular and molecular effect of proton radiation, emphasizing the increased DNA damage complexity at the distal end of the Bragg curve, and has the potential to enhance the efficacy of proton therapy.

IDDRRA: A novel platform, based on Geant4-DNA to quantify DNA damage by ionizing radiation

PURPOSE

This study proposes a novel computational platform that we refer to as IDDRRA (DNA Damage Response to Ionizing RAdiation), which uses Monte Carlo (MC) simulations to score radiation induced DNA damage. MC simulations provide results of high accuracy on the interaction of radiation with matter while scoring the energy deposition based on state-of-the-art physics and chemistry models and probabilistic methods.

METHODS

The IDDRRA software is based on the Geant4-DNA toolkit together with new tools that were developed for the purpose of this study, including a new algorithm that was developed in Python for the design of the DNA molecules. New classes were developed in C++ to integrate the GUI and produce the simulation's output in text format. An algorithm was also developed to analyze the simulation's output in terms of energy deposition, Single Strand Breaks (SSB), Double Strand Breaks (DSB) and Cluster Damage Sites (CDS). Finally, a new tool was developed to implement probabilistic SSB and DSB repair models using MC techniques.

RESULTS

This article provides the first benchmarks that the user of the IDDRRA tool can use to validate the functionality of the software as well as to provide a starting point to produce different types of DNA simulations. These benchmarks incorporate different kind of particles (e-, e+, protons, electron spectrum) and DNA molecules.

CONCLUSION

We have developed the IDDRRA tool and demonstrated its use to study various aspects of the modeling and simulation of a DNA irradiation experiment. The tool is expandable and can be expanded by other users with new benchmarks and applications based on the user's needs and experience. New functionality will be added over time, including the quantification of the indirect damage.

Ionizing Radiation and Complex DNA Damage: Quantifying the Radiobiological Damage Using Monte Carlo Simulations

Ionizing radiation is a common tool in medical procedures. Monte Carlo (MC) techniques are widely used when dosimetry is the matter of investigation. The scientific community has invested, over the last 20 years, a lot of effort into improving the knowledge of radiation biology. The present article aims to summarize the understanding of the field of DNA damage response (DDR) to ionizing radiation by providing an overview on MC simulation studies that try to explain several aspects of radiation biology. The need for accurate techniques for the quantification of DNA damage is crucial, as it becomes a clinical need to evaluate the outcome of various applications including both low- and high-energy radiation medical procedures. Understanding DNA repair processes would improve radiation therapy procedures. Monte Carlo simulations are a promising tool in radiobiology studies, as there are clear prospects for more advanced tools that could be used in multidisciplinary studies, in the fields of physics, medicine, biology and chemistry. Still, lot of effort is needed to evolve MC simulation tools and apply them in multiscale studies starting from small DNA segments and reaching a population of cells.

A Simplified Cluster Analysis of Electron Track Structure for Estimating Complex DNA Damage Yields

Complex DNA damage, defined as at least two vicinal lesions within 10-20 base pairs (bp), induced after exposure to ionizing radiation, is recognized as fatal damage to human tissue. Due to the difficulty of directly measuring the aggregation of DNA damage at the nano-meter scale, many cluster analyses of inelastic interactions based on Monte Carlo simulation for radiation track structure in liquid water have been conducted to evaluate DNA damage. Meanwhile, the experimental technique to detect complex DNA damage has evolved in recent decades, so both approaches with simulation and experiment get used for investigating complex DNA damage. During this study, we propose a simplified cluster analysis of ionization and electronic excitation events within 10 bp based on track structure for estimating complex DNA damage yields for electron and X-ray irradiations. We then compare the computational results with the experimental complex DNA damage coupled with base damage (BD) measured by enzymatic cleavage and atomic force microscopy (AFM). The computational results agree well with experimental fractions of complex damage yields, i.e., single and double strand breaks (SSBs, DSBs) and complex BD, when the yield ratio of BD/SSB is assumed to be 1.3. Considering the comparison of complex DSB yields, i.e., DSB + BD and DSB + 2BD, between simulation and experimental data, we find that the aggregation degree of the events along electron tracks reflects the complexity of induced DNA damage, showing 43.5% of DSB induced after 70 kVp X-ray irradiation can be classified as a complex form coupled with BD. The present simulation enables us to quantify the type of complex damage which cannot be measured through in vitro experiments and helps us to interpret the experimental detection efficiency for complex BD measured by AFM. This simple model for estimating complex DNA damage yields contributes to the precise understanding of the DNA damage complexity induced after X-ray and electron irradiations.

Microdosimetric calculations of the direct DNA damage induced by low energy electrons using the Geant4-DNA Monte Carlo code

To calculate the yield of direct DNA damage induced by low energy electrons using Monte Carlo generated microdosimetric spectra at the nanometer scale and examine the influence of various simulation inputs. The potential of classical microdosimetry to offer a viable and simpler alternative to more elaborate mechanistic approaches for practical applications is discussed. Track-structure simulations with the Geant4-DNA low-energy extension of the Geant4 Monte Carlo toolkit were used for calculating lineal energy spectra in spherical volumes with dimensions relevant to double-strand-break (DSB) induction. The microdosimetric spectra were then used to calculate the yield of simple and clustered DSB based on literature values of the threshold energy of DNA damage. The influence of the different implementations of the dielectric function of liquid water available in Geant4-DNA (Option 2 and Option 4 constructors), as well as the effect of particle tracking cutoff energy and target size are examined. Frequency- and dose-mean lineal energies in liquid-water spheres of 2, 2.3, 2.6, and 3.4 nm diameter, as well as, number of simple and clustered DSB/Gy/cell are presented for electrons over the 100 eV to 100 keV energy range. Results are presented for both the 'default' (Option 2) and 'Ioannina' (Option 4) physics models of Geant4-DNA applying several commonly used tracking cutoff energies (10, 20, 50, 100 eV). Overall, the choice of the physics model and target diameter has a moderate effect (up to ~10%-30%) on the DSB yield whereas the effect of the tracking cutoff energy may be significant (>100%). Importantly, the yield of both simple and clustered DSB was found to vary significantly (by a factor of 2 or more) with electron energy over the examined range. The yields of electron-induced simple and clustered DSB exhibit a strong energy dependence over the 100 eV-100 keV range with implications to radiation quality issues. It is shown that a classical microdosimetry approach for the calculation of DNA damage based on lineal energy spectra in nanometer-size targets predicts comparable results to computationally intensive mechanistic approaches which use detailed atomistic DNA geometries, thus, offering a relatively simple and robust alternative for some practical applications.

Clustered DNA Damages induced by 0.5 to 30 eV Electrons

Low-energy electrons (LEEs) of energies ≤30 eV are generated in large quantities by ionizing radiation. These electrons can damage DNA; particularly, they can induce the more detrimental clustered lesions in cells. This type of lesions, which are responsible for a large portion of the genotoxic stress generated by ionizing radiation, is described in the Introduction. The reactions initiated by the collisions of 0.5-30 eV electrons with oligonucleotides, duplex DNA, and DNA bound to chemotherapeutic platinum drugs are explained and reviewed in the subsequent sections. The experimental methods of LEE irradiation and DNA damage analysis are described with an emphasis on the detection of cluster lesions, which are considerably enhanced in DNA-Pt-drug complexes. Based on the energy dependence of damage yields and cross-sections, a mechanism responsible for the clustered lesions can be attributed to the capture of a single electron by the electron affinity of an excited state of a base, leading to the formation of transient anions at 6 and 10 eV. The initial capture is followed by electronic excitation of the base and dissociative attachment-at other DNA sites-of the electron reemitted from the temporary base anion. The mechanism is expected to be universal in the cellular environment and plays an important role in the formation of clustered lesions.

Clustered DNA Damage Induced by 2-20 eV Electrons and Transient Anions: General Mechanism and Correlation to Cell Death

The mechanisms of action of low-energy electrons (LEEs) generated in large quantities by ionizing radiation constitute an essential element of our understanding of early events in radiolysis and radiobiology. We present the 2-20 eV electron energy dependence of the yields of base damage (BD), BD-related cross-links (CLs), and non-double-strand break (NDSB) clustered damage induced in DNA. These new yield functions are generated by the impact of LEEs on plasmid DNA films. The damage is analyzed by gel electrophoresis with and without enzyme treatment. Maxima at 5 and 10 eV in BDs and BD-related CLs yield functions, and two others, at 6 and 10 eV, in those of NDSB clustered damage are ascribed to core-excited transient anions that decay into bond-breaking channels. The mechanism causing all types of DNA damages can be attributed to the capture of a single electron by a base followed by multiple different electron transfer pathways.