Disjunctive saccadesduring smooth pursuit eye movements in ocular myasthenia gravis

Oculomotor fatigability with decrements of saccade and smooth pursuit for diagnosis of myasthenia gravis

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

As the efficacy of current diagnostic methods for myasthenia gravis (MG) remains suboptimal, there is ongoing interest in developing more effective diagnostic models. As oculomotor fatigability is one of the most common and diagnostic symptoms in MG, we aimed to investigate whether quantitative saccadic and smooth-pursuit fatigability analyses with video-oculography (VOG) are useful for diagnosis of MG.

METHODS

A convenience cohort of 46 MG patients was recruited prospectively, including 35 with ocular and 11 with generalized MG (mean age, 50.9 ± 14.5 years; 17 females); 24 healthy controls (HCs) (mean age, 50.6 ± 16.3 years; 13 females) also were enrolled. Seventy-five repetitive saccades and smooth pursuits were recorded in ranges of 20° (horizontal plane) and 15° (vertical plane) using a three-dimensional VOG system. Based on the oculomotor range of the second saccade and smooth pursuit and the mean ranges of the last five of each, the estimated decrements (%) reflecting oculomotor fatigability were calculated.

RESULTS

The baseline oculomotor ranges did not show significant difference between the MG and HCs groups. However, following repetitive saccades and pursuits, the oculomotor ranges were decreased substantially during the last five cycles compared to baseline in the MG group. No such decrements were observed in the HC group (p < 0.01, Mann-Whitney U test). Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) analysis revealed that repetitive vertical saccades yielded the best differentiation between the MG and HC groups, with a sensitivity of 78.3% and specificity of 95.8% when using a decrement with an amplitude of 6.4% as the cutoff.

CONCLUSION

This study presents an objective and reproducible method for measuring decrements of oculomotor ranges after repetitive saccadic and pursuit movements. Quantification of oculomotor fatigability using VOG could be a sensitive and specific diagnostic tool for MG and allows easy, cost-effective, accurate, and non-invasive measurements.

CLASSIFICATION OF EVIDENCE

This study provides class III evidence that VOG-based quantification of saccadic and pursuit fatigability accurately identifies patients with MG.

Tracking Eye Movements for Diagnosis in Myasthenia Gravis: A Comprehensive Review

BACKGROUND

Around 60%--75% of myasthenia gravis (MG) patients initially present with nonspecific ocular symptoms. Failed recognition of these symptoms may delay the diagnosis of MG up to 5 years or more, leading to a reduced likelihood of remission and increased morbidity. Current diagnostic tests are either poorly sensitive for patients presenting with ocular symptoms alone or are time consuming, invasive, require a high level of technical expertise, and generally are universally difficult to obtain. This review will explore quantitative eye and pupil tracking as a potential noninvasive, time-effective, and less technically demanding alternative to current diagnostic tests of MG.

EVIDENCE ACQUISITION

Comprehensive literature review.

RESULTS

Thirty-two publications using oculography for the diagnosis of MG and 6 studies using pupillometry were evaluated. In MG patients, extra ocular muscle fatigue was evident in reports of intersaccadic, intrasaccadic and postsaccadic abnormalities, changes in optokinetic nystagmus, slow eye movements, disconjugate saccades, and pupillary constrictor muscle weakness.

CONCLUSIONS

Our review identified several potentially useful variables that derive from oculography and pupillometry studies that could assist with a timely diagnosis of MG. Limitations of this review include heterogeneity in design, sample size, and quality of the studies evaluated. There is a need for larger, well-designed studies evaluating eye-tracking measures in the diagnosis of MG, especially for patients presenting with purely ocular symptoms.

The Use of the Saccadometer to Identify Saccadic Characteristics in Myasthenia Gravis: A Pilot Study

BACKGROUND

Myasthenia gravis (MG) often presents with ocular signs that mimic other forms of ocular defects, such as isolated cranial nerve palsy. Normal velocity or even hyperfast saccadic eye movements in the presence of deficits of smooth pursuit have been well described in the literature in myasthenic patients. The reason for these paradoxical clinical findings has been reported to be due to increased postsynaptic folding of the fast-twitch fibers responsible for the execution of a saccade which is absent in those fibers responsible for slower, smooth eye movement. Saccadic characteristics therefore offer a point of differential diagnosis between patients suspected of having ocular motility deficits as a result of MG and those caused by other neuropathies. The advent of portable quantitative saccadic assessment means that previously laboratory-based assessments that require specialist equipment and training may now be undertaken clinically, providing a noninvasive test that can aid the differential diagnosis of the condition. The aim of this pilot study was to investigate the feasibility of the saccadometer (Ober Consulting, Poznan, Poland) in detecting the saccadic characteristics associated with myasthenia, specifically normal peak velocity (PV) in a group of patients confirmed with myasthenia.

METHODS

A group of 5 patients with a confirmed diagnosis of MG were recruited from a single site into the study along with 5 age-matched healthy volunteers. All myasthenic patients had ocular signs such as underaction or limitations of motility confirmed through ocular clinical examination. Healthy volunteers were screened for any underlying ocular motility or neurological defects before inclusion within the study. All participants undertook 100 trials of both 10 and 20° amplitude saccades, and mean PV, amplitude, and latency were recorded using the saccadometer for each individual. Overall, mean PV, amplitude, and latency were collated for both myasthenic and healthy control groups for each saccade size and compared.

RESULTS

The mean PV was significantly greater (481 ± 103.5 deg/seconds) for myasthenic patients compared with healthy controls (384 ± 42.8 deg/seconds) (P < 0.05) in 10° saccades. PV was also greater in myasthenics for 20° saccades; however, this difference did not reach statistical significance for patients with MG (547 ± 89.8 deg/seconds vs 477 ± 104.5 deg/seconds) (P = 0.14). The latency of participants with MG was not significantly different from those of age-matched healthy participants in 10° saccades but was significantly different for 20° saccades. There was no difference in amplitude measured between the groups.

CONCLUSIONS

PV for both 10 and 20° saccades was greater in myasthenic patients compared with healthy controls. All myasthenic patients produced normal velocity saccades in the presence of deficits of smooth ocular motility. The results from this small pilot study demonstrate the potential use of the saccadometer in a clinical setting to provide a noninvasive aid in the diagnosis of patients suspected with myasthenia.