A follow-up study on occupational exposure to inhaled anaesthetics in Eastern European surgeons and circulating nurses

Occupational Exposure to Halogenated Anaesthetic Gases in Hospitals: A Systematic Review of Methods and Techniques to Assess Air Concentration Levels

Objective During the induction of gaseous anaesthesia, waste anaesthetic gases (WAGs) can be released into workplace air. Occupational exposure to high levels of halogenated WAGs may lead to adverse health effects; hence, it is important to measure WAGs concentration levels to perform risk assessment and for health protection purposes. Methods A systematic review of the scientific literature was conducted on two different scientific databases (Scopus and PubMed). A total of 101 studies, focused on sevoflurane, desflurane and isoflurane exposures in hospitals, were included in this review. Key information was extracted to provide (1) a description of the study designs (e.g., monitoring methods, investigated occupational settings, anaesthetic gases in use); (2) an evaluation of time trends in the measured concentrations of considered WAGs; (3) a critical evaluation of the sampling strategies, monitoring methods and instruments used. Results Environmental monitoring was prevalent (68%) and mainly used for occupational exposure assessment during adult anaesthesia (84% of cases). Real-time techniques such as photoacoustic spectroscopy and infrared spectrophotometry were used in 58% of the studies, while off-line approaches such as active or passive sampling followed by GC-MS analysis were used less frequently (39%). Conclusions The combination of different instrumental techniques allowing the collection of data with different time resolutions was quite scarce (3%) despite the fact that this would give the opportunity to obtain reliable data for testing the compliance with 8 h occupational exposure limit values and at the same time to evaluate short-term exposures.

Detrimental effects detected in exfoliated buccal cells from anesthesiology medical residents occupationally exposed to inhalation anesthetics: An observational study

Operating room professionals are scarcely aware of their individual occupational exposure to waste anesthetic gases (WAGs). Medical residents spend several hours per day in operating rooms and consequently experience occupational exposure to WAGs. Considering that no studies have yet evaluated the potential toxicity in medical residents exposed to WAGs using the buccal micronucleus cytome (BMCyt) assay, this pioneering study aimed to compare the BMCyt assay markers, including DNA damage, cell proliferation, and cell death in the exfoliated buccal cells of surgery and anesthesiology residents occupationally exposed to WAGs. The study enrolled a total of 60 physicians, including internal medicine residents (unexposed group), and residents from surgery and anesthesiology programs who were occupationally exposed to sevoflurane, isoflurane and nitrous oxide. WAGs were measured, and the mean values were higher than the international recommendation. The anesthesiology residents (high exposure) showed statistically significant lower frequencies of basal cells, and statistically significant higher frequencies of micronuclei, karyorrhexis, pyknosis, and differentiated cells than did the unexposed group; karyolysis frequencies were significantly higher in anesthesiology residents than were those in the unexposed group or in surgical residents (low exposure). The findings suggest a genetic risk for young professionals exposed to WAGs at the beginning of their careers. Thus, exposure to high WAGs concentrations leads to impairment of the buccal cell proliferative potential, genomic instability and cell death, especially in anesthesiology residents, demonstrating an early impact on their health.

Suitability of the Limit Dose in Evaluating Reproductive Toxicity of Substances and Preparations

An oral dose of 1000 mg/kg body weight/day is mentioned in Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) and European Union (EU) guidelines as a default maximum dose in limit tests for studies on reproductive toxicity. This paper investigated whether upper range human exposure data from the workplace are supportive of this limit dose as an upper limit of possible human exposure. To this end, published exposure data as well as data from the database MEGA of the German “Berufsgenossenschaften” were evaluated. These data indicate that exposure concentrations in the range of 500 to 2000 mg/m3 (time-weighted averages) can be considered high human exposures to volatile compounds. Inhalation exposure to aerosols and dermal exposure result in lower dose levels. By applying suitable extrapolation factors, it was concluded that occupational exposures up to 325 mg/m3 can reliably be assessed with limit tests using a dose level of 1000 mg/kg/day. The limit dose has been proposed for use in the EU as a starting point to derive specific concentration limits for hazard classification of preparations containing reproductive toxicants, with the objective to consider the potency of the substances. This analysis shows that for some groups of chemicals, instead of the limit dose, the putative maximum levels of human exposure should be taken into account when deriving concentration limits for the classification of preparations. Furthermore, possible deviations from a linear correlation between concentration in the preparation and exposure should be considered.

[Comparison of waste anesthetic gases in operating rooms with or without an scavenging system in a Brazilian University Hospital]

BACKGROUND AND OBJECTIVES

Occupational exposure to waste anesthetic gases in operating room (OR) without active scavenging system has been associated with adverse health effects. Thus, this study aimed to compare the trace concentrations of the inhaled anesthetics isoflurane and sevoflurane in OR with and without central scavenging system.

METHOD

Waste concentrations of isoflurane and sevoflurane were measured by infrared analyzer at different locations (near the respiratory area of the assistant nurse and anesthesiologist and near the anesthesia station) and at two times (30 and 120minutes after the start of surgery) in both OR types.

RESULTS

All isoflurane and sevoflurane concentrations in unscavenged OR were higher than the US recommended limit (2 parts per million), regardless of the location and time evaluated. In scavenged OR, the average concentrations of isoflurane were within the limit of exposure, except for the measurements near the anesthesia station, regardless of the measurement times. For sevoflurane, concentrations exceeded the limit value at all measurement locations and at both times.

CONCLUSIONS

The exposure to both anesthetics exceeded the international limit in unscavenged OR. In scavenged OR, the concentrations of sevoflurane, and to a lesser extent those of isoflurane, exceeded the recommended limit value. Thus, the OR scavenging system analyzed in the present study decreased the anesthetic concentrations, although not to the internationally recommended values.

Application of predictive models for estimation of health care workers exposure to sevoflurane

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to assess the potential use of predictive models to estimate professional exposure to chemicals in the workplace, such as the operating room, by simultaneous determination of the levels of exposure using a model and measurements.

METHODS

Measurements included determinations of sevoflurane (SEV) in the workplace air of 117 operating rooms of 31 hospitals in one Polish region. Measurements were carried out at the time of various surgical procedures during administration of anaesthetics by endotracheal intubation. The measurement results were compared with the values estimated using two models: ECETOC TRA and Stoffenmanager.

RESULTS

In one case the ECETOC TRA estimated the exposure concentration almost equal to the measured concentration but, because of the need to maintain a margin of safety in case of modelling, it can be concluded that the model underestimated the concentration. The Stoffenmanager model provided accurate exposure estimates in the examined case, and it can be used as a screening tool for the assessment of occupational inhalation exposure of medical personnel to anaesthetics.

CONCLUSIONS

The results are of particular importance to the circumstances in Eastern Europe, where the levels of anaesthetics often exceed the relevant occupational exposure limits.

Effects of isoflurane inhalation on the male reproductive system in rats

The 15-day intact adult male assay was used to evaluate effects of isoflurane on the testes and sexual hormones. Forty adult male Sprague-Dawley rats were divided into five groups exposed to air containing 0, 50, 300, 1800 or 10,800 ppm isoflurane. After the treatments, serum was collected for the hormones assay. The right testis was to be used for daily sperm production. The left testis was processed for histopathology and electron microscopy observation. Daily sperm productions were significantly decreased at doses of 300, 1800 and 10,800 ppm. Impaired seminiferous tubules were noted at doses of 300, 1800 and 10,800 ppm. Ultrastructural changes included nucleus agglutination of spermatocytes, big lipid drops and autophagosome in cytoplasm. The serum follicle-stimulating hormone and testosterone concentrations reduced significantly at doses of 1800 and 10,800 ppm. Isoflurane induced impairments of seminiferous tubules and spermatogenesis. The testicular damages caused by isoflurane can be related to the imbalances in the sexual hormones.

Occupational exposure to sevoflurane during cardiopulmonary bypass

Volatile anaesthetic agents are widely used for maintenance of anaesthesia in all kinds of surgical procedures. Despite the implementation of measures such as adequate ventilation of the operating room and the use of efficient scavenging systems, concern remains about the risks for occupational exposure, especially in situations associated with an increased risk of anaesthetic gas waste, such as with the use of volatile anaesthetic agents on cardiopulmonary bypass. The present contribution reports the results of a preliminary safety assessment involving measurements of sevoflurane concentrations in the ambient air of a cardiac surgery operating room.

In 22 cardiac surgical procedures with cardiopulmonary bypass (11 with open and 11 with closed venous reservoir), measurements of trace concentrations were obtained every 10 min at the following sites: at the outlet of the oxygenator, at the outlet of the cardiotomy reservoir, in the breathing zone of the perfusionist and above the surgical field. The concentrations were measured on-line using a photoacoustic infrared spectrometer.

Mean sevoflurane waste concentrations remained consistently below the recommended target value of 4.68 ppm throughout the observation period at the different measurement sites.

These results indicate that, with the use of sevoflurane on cardiopulmonary bypass, the recommended levels for occupational exposure are not exceeded, provided adequate operation room ventilation and waste gas scavenging is performed.

Impaired vitamin B12 metabolic status in healthcare workers occupationally exposed to nitrous oxide

BACKGROUND

Previous studies demonstrated inactivation of vitamin B12 by nitrous oxide (N(2)O). The intraoperative exposure to N(2)O was shown to induce megaloblastic anaemia and myelopathy in subjects with subclinical vitamin B12 deficiency. In contrast, no data concerning the influence of occupational exposure to N(2)O on vitamin B12 metabolic status are available to date. In the present study, the vitamin B12 status in operating theatre personnel was assessed in relation to the extent of exposure.

METHODS

Ninety-five operating theatre nurses with the history of exposure to N(2)O and 90 unexposed counterparts were examined. Vitamin B12 and folic acid were measured by immunoassay. Total homocysteine (tHcy), an indicator of impaired vitamin B12 metabolism, was determined by high performance liquid chromatography. N(2)O concentration was monitored by adsorption gas chromatography and mass spectrometry.

RESULTS

No significant differences were found between both groups with respect to haematological parameters and folic acid. However, subjects exposed to N(2)O presented with lower vitamin B12 [372.8 (12.1) vs 436.8 (13.2) pmol litre(-1), P<0.001] and higher tHcy [11.2 (0.5) vs 8.9 (0.5) micromol litre(-1), P=0.006]. The changes in vitamin B12 status were aggravated in subjects exposed to N(2)O in concentrations substantially exceeding occupational exposure limit (180 mg m(-3)) [vitamin B12: 341.9 (17.7) vs 436.8 (13.2) pmol litre(-1), P=0.006; tHcy: 12.9 (0.7) vs 8.9 (0.5) micromol litre(-1), P=0.047].

CONCLUSIONS

Exposure to N(2)O in healthcare workers is associated with alterations of vitamin B12 metabolic status, the extent of which depends on the level of exposure.

Occupational exposure to nitrous oxide – The role of scavenging and ventilation systems in reducing the exposure level in operating rooms

OBJECTIVES

The aim of this study was to assess the level of occupational exposure to nitrous oxide (N(2)O) in operating rooms (ORs), as related to different ventilation and scavenging systems used to remove waste anaesthetic gases from the work environment.

METHODS

The monitoring of N(2)O in the air covered 35 ORs in 10 hospitals equipped with different systems for ventilation and anaesthetic scavenging. The examined systems included: natural ventilation with supplementary fresh air provided by a pressure ventilation system (up to 6 air changes/h); pressure and exhaust ventilation systems equipped with ventilation units supplying fresh air to and discharging contaminated air outside the working area (more than 10 air changes/h); complete air-conditioning system with laminar air flow (more than 15 air changes/h). The measurements were carried out during surgical procedures (general anaesthesia induced intravenously and maintained with inhaled N(2)O and sevofluran delivered through cuffed endotracheal tubes) with connected or disconnected air scavenging. Air was collected from the breathing zone of operating personnel continuously through the whole time of anaesthesia to Tedlar((R)) bags, and N(2)O concentrations in air samples were analyzed by adsorption gas chromatography/mass spectrometry.

RESULTS

N(2)O levels in excess of the occupational exposure limit (OEL) value of 180mg/m(3) were registered in all ORs equipped with ventilation systems alone. The OEL value was exceeded several times in rooms with natural ventilation plus supplementary pressure ventilations and twice or less in those with pressure/exhaust ventilation systems or air conditioning. N(2)O levels below or within the OEL value were observed in rooms where the system of air conditioning or pressure/exhaust ventilation was combined with scavenging systems. Systems combining natural/pressure ventilation with scavenging were inadequate to maintain N(2)O concentration below the OEL value.

CONCLUSION

Air conditioning and an efficient pressure/exhaust ventilation (above 12 air exchanges/h) together with efficient active scavenging systems are sufficient to sustain N(2)O exposure in ORs at levels below or within the OEL value of 180mg/m(3).

A comparison of sister chromatid exchanges in lymphocytes of anesthesiologists to nonanesthesiologists in the same hospital

An increased incidence of sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) in peripheral lymphocytes of operating room personnel exposed to waste anesthetic gases has been reported. We investigated whether the increase of SCEs in anesthesiologists was reversible. Twenty-five anesthesiologists exposed to waste anesthetic gases such as sevoflurane and nitrous oxide were compared with nonexposed internists working in the same hospital. The concentrations of sevoflurane and nitrous oxide in the operating rooms were measured. The incidence of SCE was measured in lymphocytes cultures of anesthesiologists before and after a 2-mo leave from the operating room. These values of SCE were compared with those of nonexposed physicians. Occupational exposure to sevoflurane and nitrous oxide in the operating rooms were above the threshold values. There was a significant difference in SCE values of the anesthesiologists compared with the nonexposed physicians (11.9 +/- 4.4 versus 4.2 +/- 1.1, P < 0.001). After a 2-mo leave from the operating room, the SCE values of the anesthesiologists were significantly lower compared with those taken before the leave (4.8 +/- 1.8 and 11.9 +/- 4.4, respectively, P < 0.001). We conclude that the increase of SCE in anesthesiologists exposed to increased environmental concentrations of waste anesthetics gases, such as sevoflurane and nitrous oxide, are reversible if they work free from exposure for 2 mo.

Exposition des Personals gegenüber Sevofluran

BACKGROUND

Occupational exposure to volatile anaesthetics cannot be completely avoided even in modern operating theatres. In 1997, the staff exposure during balanced anaesthesia in our hospital was low (sevoflurane 0.49 ppm; N(2)O 11.5 ppm). In 1999, N(2)O was completely omitted at our hospital, therefore, exposure to volatile anaesthetics, namely sevoflurane, might have increased.

METHODS

Environmental exposure was measured by photoacoustic infrared spectrometry. To determine the personal exposure and to compare it with environmental exposure, 14 anaesthetists wore diffusion samplers near their breathing zones for 1 week.

RESULTS

The median environmental concentration of sevoflurane was between 0.09 and 0.21 ppm in central operating theatres and between 0 and 24.8 ppm in intervention rooms. The median personal concentration was 0.19 ppm.

CONCLUSION

The occupational exposure to volatile anaesthetics is not higher using sevoflurane alone compared to the combination of sevoflurane and N(2)O. In addition, the data acquired from environmental and personal measurements showed similar results.