Hyperbaric oxygen pretreatment reduces the incidence of decompression sickness in rats

Pre-dive Whole-Body Vibration Better Reduces Decompression-Induced Vascular Gas Emboli than Oxygenation or a Combination of Both

Purpose: Since non-provocative dive profiles are no guarantor of protection against decompression sickness, novel means including pre-dive "preconditioning" interventions, are proposed for its prevention. This study investigated and compared the effect of pre-dive oxygenation, pre-dive whole body vibration or a combination of both on post-dive bubble formation. Methods: Six healthy volunteers performed 6 no-decompression dives each, to a depth of 33 mfw for 20 min (3 control dives without preconditioning and 1 of each preconditioning protocol) with a minimum interval of 1 week between each dive. Post-dive bubbles were counted in the precordium by two-dimensional echocardiography, 30 and 90 min after the dive, with and without knee flexing. Each diver served as his own control. Results: Vascular gas emboli (VGE) were systematically observed before and after knee flexing at each post-dive measurement. Compared to the control dives, we observed a decrease in VGE count of 23.8 ± 7.4% after oxygen breathing (p < 0.05), 84.1 ± 5.6% after vibration (p < 0.001), and 55.1 ± 9.6% after vibration combined with oxygen (p < 0.001). The difference between all preconditioning methods was statistically significant. Conclusions: The precise mechanism that induces the decrease in post-dive VGE and thus makes the diver more resistant to decompression stress is still not known. However, it seems that a pre-dive mechanical reduction of existing gas nuclei might best explain the beneficial effects of this strategy. The apparent non-synergic effect of oxygen and vibration has probably to be understood because of different mechanisms involved.

Effect of oxygen-breathing during a decompression-stop on bubble-induced platelet activation after an open-sea air dive: oxygen-stop decompression

PURPOSE

We highlighted a relationship between decompression-induced bubble formation and platelet micro-particle (PMP) release after a scuba air-dive. It is known that decompression protocol using oxygen-stop accelerates the washout of nitrogen loaded in tissues. The aim was to study the effect of oxygen deco-stop on bubble formation and cell-derived MP release.

METHODS

Healthy experienced divers performed two scuba-air dives to 30 msw for 30 min, one with an air deco-stop and a second with 100% oxygen deco-stop at 3 msw for 9 min. Bubble grades were monitored with ultrasound and converted to the Kisman integrated severity score (KISS). Blood samples for cell-derived micro-particle analysis (AnnexinV for PMP and CD31 for endothelial MP) were taken 1 h before and after each dive.

RESULTS

Mean KISS bubble score was significantly lower after the dive with oxygen-decompression stop, compared to the dive with air-decompression stop (4.3 ± 7.3 vs. 32.7 ± 19.9, p < 0.001). After the dive with an air-breathing decompression stop, we observed an increase of the post-dive mean values of PMP (753 ± 245 vs. 381 ± 191 ng/μl, p = 0.003) but no significant change in the oxygen-stop decompression dive (329 ± 215 vs. 381 +/191 ng/μl, p = 0.2). For the post-dive mean values of endothelial MP, there was no significant difference between both the dives.

CONCLUSIONS

The Oxygen breathing during decompression has a beneficial effect on bubble formation accelerating the washout of nitrogen loaded in tissues. Secondary oxygen-decompression stop could reduce bubble-induced platelet activation and the pro-coagulant activity of PMP release preventing the thrombotic event in the pathogenesis of decompression sickness.

Endurance exercise immediately before sea diving reduces bubble formation in scuba divers

Previous studies have observed that a single bout of exercise can reduce the formation of circulating bubbles on decompression but, according to different authors, several hours delay were considered necessary between the end of exercise and the beginning of the dive. The objective of this study was to evaluate the effect of a single bout of exercise taken immediately before a dive on bubble formation. 24 trained divers performed open-sea dives to 30 msw depth for 30 min followed by a 3 min stop at 3 msw, under two conditions: (1) a control dive without exercise before (No-Ex), (2) an experimental condition in which subjects performed an exercise before diving (Ex). In the Ex condition, divers began running on a treadmill for 45 min at a speed corresponding to their own ventilatory threshold 1 h before immersion. Body weight, total body fluid volume, core temperature, and volume of consumed water were measured. Circulating bubbles were graded according to the Spencer scale using a precordial Doppler every 30 min for 90 min after surfacing. A single sub-maximal exercise performed immediately before immersion significantly reduces bubble grades (p < 0.001). This reduction was correlated not only to sweat dehydration, but also to the volume of water drunk at the end of the exercise. Moderate dehydration seems to be beneficial at the start of the dive whereas restoring the hydration balance should be given priority during decompression. This suggests a biphasic effect of the hydration status on bubble formation.

Oxygen pretreatment as protection against decompression sickness in rats: pressure and time necessary for hypothesized denucleation and renucleation

Pretreatment with HBO at 300-500 kPa for 20 min reduced the incidence of decompression sickness (DCS) in a rat model. We investigated whether this procedure would be effective with lower oxygen pressures and shorter exposure, and tried to determine how long the pretreatment would remain effective. Rats were pretreated with oxygen at 101 or 203 kPa for 20 min and 304 kPa for 5 or 10 min. After pretreatment, the animals were exposed to air at 1,013 kPa for 33 min followed by fast decompression. Pretreatment at 101 or 203 kPa for 20 min and 304 kPa for 10 min significantly reduced the number of rats with DCS to 45%, compared with 65% in the control group. However, after pretreatment at 304 kPa for 5 min, 65% of rats suffered DCS. When pretreatment at 304 kPa for 20 min was followed by 2 h in normobaric air before compression and decompression, the outcome was worse, with 70-90% of the animals suffering DCS. This is probably due to the activation of "dormant" micronuclei. The risk of DCS remained lower (43%) when pretreatment with 100% O(2) at normobaric pressure for 20 min was followed by a 2 h interval in normobaric air (but not 6 or 24 h) before the hyperbaric exposure. The loss of effectiveness after a 6 or 24 h interval in normobaric air is related to micronuclei rejuvenation. Although pretreatment with hyperbaric O(2) may have an advantage over normobaric hyperoxia, decompression should not intervene between pretreatment and the dive.

Preconditioning methods and mechanisms for preventing the risk of decompression sickness in scuba divers: a review

Scuba divers are at risk of decompression sickness due to the excessive formation of gas bubbles in blood and tissues following ascent, with potentially subsequent neurological injuries. Since nonprovocative dive profiles are no guarantor of protection against this disease, novel means are required for its prevention including predive procedures that could induce more resistance to decompression stress. In this article, we review the recent studies describing the promising preconditioning methods that might operate on the attenuation of bubble formation believed to reduce the occurrence of decompression sickness. The main practical applications are simple and feasible predive measures such as endurance exercise in a warm environment, oral hydration, and normobaric oxygen breathing. Rheological changes affecting tissue perfusion, endothelial adaptation with nitric oxide pathway, up-regulation of cytoprotective proteins, and reduction of preexisting gas nuclei from which bubbles grow could be involved in this protective effect.

Effect of in-water oxygen prebreathing at different depths on decompression-induced bubble formation and platelet activation

Effect of in-water oxygen prebreathing at different depths on decompression-induced bubble formation and platelet activation in scuba divers was evaluated. Six volunteers participated in four diving protocols, with 2 wk of recovery between dives. On dive 1, before diving, all divers breathed normally for 20 min at the surface of the sea (Air). On dive 2, before diving, all divers breathed 100% oxygen for 20 min at the surface of the sea [normobaric oxygenation (NBO)]. On dive 3, before diving, all divers breathed 100% O2 for 20 min at 6 m of seawater [msw; hyperbaric oxygenation (HBO) 1.6 atmospheres absolute (ATA)]. On dive 4, before diving, all divers breathed 100% O2 for 20 min at 12 msw (HBO 2.2 ATA). Then they dove to 30 msw (4 ATA) for 20 min breathing air from scuba. After each dive, blood samples were collected as soon as the divers surfaced. Bubbles were measured at 20 and 50 min after decompression and converted to bubble count estimate (BCE) and numeric bubble grade (NBG). BCE and NBG were significantly lower in NBO than in Air [0.142+/-0.034 vs. 0.191+/-0.066 (P<0.05) and 1.61+/-0.25 vs. 1.89+/-0.31 (P<0.05), respectively] at 20 min, but not at 50 min. HBO at 1.6 ATA and 2.2 ATA has a similar significant effect of reducing BCE and NBG. BCE was 0.067+/-0.026 and 0.040+/-0.018 at 20 min and 0.030+/-0.022 and 0.020+/-0.020 at 50 min. NBG was 1.11+/-0.17 and 0.92+/-0.16 at 20 min and 0.83+/-0.18 and 0.75+/-0.16 at 50 min. Prebreathing NBO and HBO significantly alleviated decompression-induced platelet activation. Activation of CD62p was 3.0+/-0.4, 13.5+/-1.3, 10.7+/-0.9, 4.5+/-0.7, and 7.6+/-0.8% for baseline, Air, NBO, HBO at 1.6 ATA, and HBO at 2.2 ATA, respectively. The data show that prebreathing oxygen, more effective with HBO than NBO, decreases air bubbles and platelet activation and, therefore, may be beneficial in reducing the development of decompression sickness.

Hyperbaric oxygen pretreatment according to the gas micronuclei denucleation hypothesis reduces neurologic deficit in decompression sickness in rats

During sudden or too rapid decompression, gas is released within supersaturated tissues in the form of bubbles, the cause of decompression sickness. It is widely accepted that these bubbles originate in the tissue from preexisting gas micronuclei. Pretreatment with hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) has been hypothesized to shrink the gas micronuclei, thus reducing the number of emerging bubbles. The effectiveness of a new HBO pretreatment protocol on neurologic outcome was studied in rats. This protocol was found to carry the least danger of oxygen toxicity. Somatosensory evoked potentials (SSEPs) were chosen to serve as a measure of neurologic damage. SSEPs in rats given HBO pretreatment before a dive were compared with SSEPs from rats not given HBO pretreatment and SSEPs from non-dived rats. The incidence of abnormal SSEPs in the animals subjected to decompression without pretreatment (1,013 kPa for 32 min followed by decompression) was 78%. In the pretreatment group (HBO at 304 kPa for 20 min followed by exposure to 1,013 kPa for 33 min and decompression) this was significantly reduced to 44%. These results call for further study of the pretreatment protocol in higher animals.

Combined effect of denucleation and denitrogenation on the risk of decompression sickness in rats

We previously hypothesized that the number of bubbles emerging on decompression from a dive, and the resultant risk of decompression sickness (DCS), may be reduced by a process whereby effective gas micronuclei that might otherwise have formed bubbles on decompression are shrunk and eliminated. In a procedure defined by us as denucleation, exposure to hyperbaric oxygen (HBO) would result in oxygen replacing the resident gas in the micronuclei, to be subsequently consumed by the mitochondria when the oxygen pressure is reduced. Support for the validity of our hypothesis may be found in our previous studies on the transparent prawn and the reduction of DCS in the rat. In all of these studies, HBO pretreatment was given before supersaturation with inert gas at high pressure. The purpose of the present study was to compare DCS outcome in rats that underwent nitrogen washout (denitrogenation) alone (9 min O2 at 507 kPa) after exposure to air at high pressure (33 min at 1,266 kPa), and rats treated by both procedures (denitrogenation + denucleation; 8 min of O2 breathing followed by 5 min air breathing, both at 507 kPa) after high-pressure air exposure. This was done with the same nitrogen load in both groups before the final decompression (a nitrogen pressure of 467 kPa in fatty and 488 kPa in aqueous tissue). Six of 20 rats in the denitrogenation + denucleation group died, compared with 13 in the denitrogenation group ( P < 0.03). Three rats in the denitrogenation + denucleation group suffered mild DCS, recovering completely within 2 h of decompression. The present study indicates an advantage in considering both denitrogenation and denucleation before decompression. This may have practical application before escape from a disabled submarine, when aborting a technical dive, or in the preparation of aviators for high altitude.