Reliability of H-reflex in vastus lateralis and vastus medialis muscles during passive and active isometric conditions

Relating cortical morphology, corticospinal excitability, corticomotor representation, and quadriceps strength after anterior cruciate ligament injury

The current study investigated the relationship between sensorimotor cortical thickness, corticospinal excitability, corticomotor topography, and quadriceps strength after ACL reconstruction (ACLR). Ten women with a history of unilateral ACLR and 10 controls (CON) received single-pulse transcranial magnetic stimulation during unilateral, submaximal isometric knee extensions. Pulses were delivered to each vastus medialis oblique (VMO) hotspot with concurrent biceps femoris (BF) monitoring. Corticospinal excitability was assessed by delivering 40 pulses at various intensities to each hotspot. Motor-evoked potentials (MEPs) were averaged at each intensity and fitted to a Boltzmann sigmoidal curve using nonlinear regression to derive v50, slope, and MEPMAX. A motor mapping procedure included 120 pulses delivered in a 6 × 6 cm grid placed around each hotspot. Ultrasonography was used to measure VMO muscle thickness. Structural MRIs were acquired to derive paracentral lobule (PCL) cortical thickness. ACLR group's previously injured leg was weaker than the healthy leg, with no between-leg differences in CON. Regardless of group, v50 was asymmetrical between legs. Slope, MEPMAX, VMO map measures, and VMO thickness were similar between legs and groups. ACLR tended to have asymmetrical PCL thickness with BF map measures larger in the hemisphere of the previously injured leg than healthy leg, whereas CON had symmetrical PCL thickness and BF map measures. Results indicate that even years after ACLR corticomotor structure plasticity is homotopic with persistent asymmetrical knee extension strength but no differences in corticospinal excitability. Overall, the hemispheric asymmetry in leg-specific brain structure may contribute to the knee extensor strength deficits common after ACLR.

Single-session measures of quadriceps neuromuscular function are reliable in healthy females and unaffected by age

PURPOSE

This study aimed to determine the inter-session reliability of quadriceps neuromuscular function measurements in healthy young and older females.

METHODS

Twenty-six females aged 19-74 years completed two identical experimental sessions on different days. Quadriceps neuromuscular function measurements included isometric maximal voluntary force, high- and low-frequency twitch force, voluntary and evoked (H-reflex, M-wave) electromyography (EMG), and estimated maximal torque, velocity and power derived from torque-velocity relationships. Intra-class correlation coefficients (ICCs), coefficients of variation (CoV) and Bland-Altman plots assessed inter-session reliability. The effect of age on reliability was assessed by linear regression.

RESULTS

Excellent reliability (ICC > 0.8) was shown for all voluntary and evoked mechanical outcomes. Vastus lateralis EMG outcomes showed excellent reliability (ICC > 0.8) with CoVs < 12%, which were better than those of vastus medialis and rectus femoris. Age was not associated with reliability for 27/28 outcomes (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSION

Excellent reliability of voluntary and evoked force and vastus lateralis EMG outcomes measured in healthy females can be attained in one experimental session, irrespective of age. Female neuromuscular function can be accurately assessed across the lifespan with minimal inconvenience, increasing feasibility for future research. The random error should however be considered when quantifying age-related differences in neuromuscular function.

Do soleus responses to transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation show similar changes to H-reflex in response to Achilles tendon vibration?

INTRODUCTION/PURPOSE

Recently, the use of transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation (TSCS) has been proposed as a viable alternative to the H-reflex. The aim of the current study was to investigate to what extent the two modes of spinal cord excitability investigation would be similarly sensitive to the well-known vibration-induced depression.

METHODS

Fourteen healthy participants (8 men and 6 women; age: 26.7 ± 4.8 years) were engaged in the study. The right soleus H-reflex and TSCS responses were recorded at baseline (PRE), during right Achilles tendon vibration (VIB) and following 20 min of vibration exposure (POST-VIB). Care was taken to match H-reflex and TSCS responses amplitude at PRE and to maintain effective stimulus intensities constant throughout time points.

RESULTS

The statistical analysis showed a significant effect of time for the H-reflex, with VIB (13 ± 5% of maximal M-wave (Mmax) and POST-VIB (36 ± 4% of Mmax) values being lower than PRE-values (48 ± 6% of Mmax). Similarly, TSCS responses changed over time, VIB (9 ± 5% of Mmax) and POST-VIB (27 ± 5% of Mmax) values being lower than PRE-values (46 ± 6% of Mmax). Pearson correlation analyses revealed positive correlation between H-reflex and TSCS responses PRE-to-VIB changes, but not for PRE- to POST-VIB changes.

CONCLUSION

While the sensitivity of TSCS seems to be similar to the gold standard H-reflex to highlight the vibratory paradox, both responses showed different sensitivity to the effects of prolonged vibration, suggesting slightly different pathways may actually contribute to evoked responses of both stimulation modalities.

Relationship between vastus medialis Hoffmann reflex excitability and knee extension biomechanics during different tasks in women with patellofemoral pain

BACKGROUND

Impaired knee extension biomechanics and spinal excitability have been reported in women with patellofemoral pain, but their relationship has not been explored. A significant relationship between them could indicate the need for investigating the potential benefits of disinhibitory interventions for women with patellofemoral pain. Thus, this study aimed to investigate the relationship between vastus medialis Hoffmann reflex and (1) maximal isometric, concentric and eccentric knee extensor strength and rate of torque development; (2) knee extensor torque steadiness; and (3) knee extensor moment during functional tasks; in women with patellofemoral pain.

METHODS

Spinal excitability of twenty-four participants was assessed by the amplitude of maximal vastus medialis Hoffmann reflex. Knee extensor strength, rate of torque development and torque steadiness were assessed using an isokinetic dynamometer. Knee extensor moment during step-down and stair descent tasks were obtained using a three-dimensional motion analysis system.

FINDINGS

A moderate negative relationship was found between vastus medialis Hoffmann reflex and knee extensor torque steadiness (r = -0.35; p = 0.05); whereas a moderate positive relationship was found with maximal isometric knee extensor strength (r = 0.37; p = 0.044). No significant relationships were found between vastus medialis Hoffmann reflex and the other variables.

INTERPRETATION

Our findings provide insight on the relationship between spinal excitability and neuromuscular control of maximal and submaximal isometric torque production in women with patellofemoral pain. Conversely, spinal excitability does not seem to be related with dynamic torques and moments of the knee extensors in women with patellofemoral pain.

Optimal stimulation site of the femoral nerve to record F waves from the vastus lateralis muscle

INTRODUCTION/AIMS

The conventional recording of F waves from the vastus lateralis muscle (VL) may not accurately measure the F-wave amplitude, as the F-wave latency is short and overlaps with the M wave. However, the optimal stimulation site of the femoral nerve for recording M and F waves separately from the VL remains unclear. In this study we aimed to determine the optimal stimulation site of the femoral nerve to record M and F waves separately from the VL.

METHODS

Stimulating electrodes were placed medial and lateral to the VL (50%, 60%, 70%, and 80% of the distance along a line extending from the proximal to the distal thigh). Each site of the distal thigh was electrically stimulated at random and F waves were recorded from the VL. Each stimulation site was considered to be success if there was no severe pain or discomfort during electrical stimulation of the femoral nerve and no overlap between the recorded M and F waves; otherwise, it was determined as a failure.

RESULTS

Thirteen healthy men participated in the study. F waves were successfully recorded in five participants at the 50% sites, eight participants at the 60% site, and 12 participants at the 70% and 80% sites. In cases of failed F-wave measurement, the participants experienced severe pain or discomfort due to electrical stimulation.

DISCUSSION

M and F waves could be recorded separately from the VL when the relevant branch of the femoral nerve was stimulated in the distal thigh.

Individual differences in the neural strategies to control the lateral and medial head of the quadriceps during a mechanically constrained task

We observed that the distribution of the strength of neural drive between the vastus lateralis and vastus medialis during a single-joint isometric task varied across participants. Also, we observed that the proportion of neural drive that was shared within and between these muscles also varied across participants. These results provide evidence that the neural strategies to control the vastus lateralis and vastus medialis muscles widely vary across individuals, even during a mechanically constrained task.

Inter-muscle differences in modulation of motor evoked potentials and posterior root-muscle reflexes evoked from lower-limb muscles during agonist and antagonist muscle contractions

Voluntary contraction facilitates corticospinal and spinal reflex circuit excitabilities of the contracted muscle and inhibits spinal reflex circuit excitability of the antagonist. It has been suggested that modulation of spinal reflex circuit excitability in agonist and antagonist muscles during voluntary contraction differs among lower-limb muscles. However, whether the effects of voluntary contraction on the excitabilities of corticospinal and spinal reflex circuits depend on the tested muscles remains unknown. The purpose of this study was to examine inter-muscle differences in modulation of the corticospinal and spinal reflex circuit excitabilities of multiple lower-limb muscles during voluntary contraction. Eleven young males performed isometric plantar-flexion, dorsi-flexion, knee extension, and flexion at low torque levels. Motor evoked potentials (MEPs) and posterior root-muscle reflexes from seven lower-leg and thigh muscles were evoked by transcranial magnetic stimulation and transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation, respectively, at rest and during weak voluntary contractions. MEP and posterior root-muscle reflex amplitudes of agonists were significantly increased as agonist torque level increased, except for the reflex of the tibialis anterior. MEP amplitudes of antagonists were significantly increased in relation to the agonist torque level, but those of the rectus femoris were slightly depressed during knee flexion. Regarding the posterior root-muscle reflex of the antagonists, the amplitudes of triceps surae and the hamstrings were significantly decreased, but those of the quadriceps femoris were significantly increased as the agonist torque level increased. These results demonstrate that modulation of corticospinal and spinal reflex circuit excitabilities during agonist and antagonist muscle contractions differed among lower-limb muscles.

Changes in the quadriceps spinal reflex pathway after repeated sprint cycling are not influenced by ischemic preconditioning

PURPOSE

We examined the effect of ischemic preconditioning (IPC) on changes in muscle force, activation, and the spinal reflex pathway during and after repeated sprint cycling.

METHODS

Eight recreationally active men (high-intensity cardiorespiratory training > 3 times per week, > 6 months) completed two exercise sessions (5 sets of 5 cycling sprints, 150% max W), preceded by either IPC (3 × 5 min leg occlusions at 220 mmHg) or SHAM (3 × 5 min at 20 mmHg). Knee extensor maximal force and rate of force were measured before (PRE), immediately post (POST), 1H, and 24H after cycling. Twitch interpolation and resting potentiated twitches were applied to estimate voluntary activation and muscle contractility, respectively. Quadriceps H-reflex recruitment curves were collected at all time-points using 10 Hz doublet stimulation to allow estimation of H-reflex post-activation depression. Surface electromyograms and tissue oxygenation (via near-infrared spectroscopy) were continuously recorded during cycling.

RESULTS

IPC did not affect any measure of neuromuscular function or performance during cycling. Maximal force and muscle contractility were significantly lower at POST and 1H compared to PRE and 24H by up to 50% (p < 0.01). Maximal force was lower than PRE at 24H by 8.7% (p = 0.028). Voluntary activation and rate of force were unchanged. A rightwards shift was observed for the H-reflex recruitment curve POST, and post-activation depression was higher than all other time-points at 24H (p < 0.05). Muscle activation and oxygenation decreased during cycling.

CONCLUSIONS

IPC has a nominal effect on mechanisms associated with neuromuscular function during and after exercise in healthy populations.

Repeatability of spinal reflexes of lower limb muscles evoked by transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation

Transcutaneous electrical stimulation is a relatively new technique to evoke spinal reflexes in lower limb muscles. The advantage of this technique is that the spinal reflex responses can be obtained from multiple lower limb muscles simultaneously. However, repeatability of spinal reflexes evoked by transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation between days has not been evaluated. We aimed to examine repeatability of recruitment properties of the spinal reflexes evoked by transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation. Recruitment curves of the spinal reflexes evoked by transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation of 8 lower limb muscles (i.e., foot, lower leg, and thigh muscles) of 20 males were measured on two consecutive days. To confirm that responses were caused by activation of the sensory fiber, a double-pulse stimulation with 50 ms inter-pulse interval was delivered. Peak-to-peak amplitude of the first response was calculated for each muscle when no response was observed in the second response owing to post-activation depression. For comparison with the spinal reflexes evoked by transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation, the recruitment curves of the H-reflex amplitude of the soleus of 9 males were measured. Threshold intensity and maximal slope of the recruitment curves were calculated, and inter-day repeatability of the properties was quantified using intraclass correlation coefficients. For the spinal reflexes evoked by transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation, the intraclass correlation coefficient values of threshold intensity and maximal slope for each muscle ranged from 0.487 to 0.874 and from 0.471 to 0.964, respectively. Regarding the soleus H-reflex, the intraclass correlation coefficients of threshold intensity and maximal slope were 0.936 and 0.751, respectively. The present data showed that repeatability of the recruitment properties of the spinal reflexes evoked by transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation in the lower limb was moderate to high. Measurement of the spinal reflexes evoked by transcutaneous spinal cord stimulation would be useful for longitudinal neurophysiological studies.

The Reliability of Neurological Measurement in the Vastus Medialis: Implications for Research and Practice

The integrity of the corticomotor pathway is paramount in the optimal functioning of skeletal muscle. However, variability of neurophysiological assessment via peripheral nerve and transcranial magnetic stimulation can render interpretation difficult. Seldom evidence exists regarding the reliability of such measurements in the leg extensors, which have important locomotive and functional roles. This study aimed to assess the test-retest reliability of peripheral, corticospinal and intracortical responses in the vastus medialis. Transcranial magnetic and direct current electrical nerve stimulation were delivered to sixteen healthy young adults (8M and 8F) on two separate occasions. The Hoffmann reflex, maximal compound wave, motor evoked potential, corticospinal silent period, intracortical facilitation, and short-interval intracortical inhibition were recorded from the vastus medialis at rest, and during controlled submaximal voluntary contraction. Relative reliability was quantified using intra-class correlation coefficient (ICC2,1). Absolute reliability was quantified using standard error of measurement (SEm) and minimal detectable change (MDC). Corticospinal silent period, corticospinal silent period/motor evoked potential ratio, active motor evoked potential, maximal Hoffman reflex, and passive short-interval intracortical inhibition demonstrated “good to excellent” relative reliability (ICC ≥ 0.643). Intracortical facilitation demonstrated the lowest relative reliability (ICC = 0.420–0.908). Corticospinal silent period displayed the lowest absolute reliability (SEm ≤ 18.68%). Good reliability of the maximal compound wave, Hoffman reflex, motor evoked potential, and corticospinal silent period allow for reliable neurological evaluation of peripheral and corticospinal pathways in the vastus medialis. Future research should investigate reliability of the intracortical (short-interval intracortical inhibition and intracortical facilitation) measures by using different paired-pulse stimulus parameters. These findings hold important implications for neurophysiological assessment conducted in the leg extensor group.

Patellar Tendon Reflex and Vastus Medialis Hoffmann Reflex Are Down Regulated and Correlated in Women With Patellofemoral Pain

OBJECTIVES

The aims of this study were threefold: (1) to compare the amplitude of patellar tendon reflex (T-reflex) between women with patellofemoral pain (PFP) and pain-free controls; (2) to compare the amplitude of vastus medialis Hoffmann reflex (VM H-reflex) between women with PFP and pain-free controls; (3) to investigate the association between the amplitude of patellar T-reflex and VM H-reflex in women with PFP and pain-free controls.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional observational study.

SETTING

Laboratory of biomechanics and motor control.

PARTICIPANTS

Thirty women with PFP and 30 pain-free women aged 18 to 35 years (N=60).

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Peak-to-peak amplitudes of maximal VM H-reflex (elicited via electrical stimulation on the femoral nerve) and patellar T-reflex (elicited via mechanical percussion on the patellar tendon) were estimated.

RESULTS

Women with PFP had significant lower amplitude of patellar T-reflex (mean difference=0.086; 95% confidence interval=0.020 to 0.151; P=.010; moderate effect) and VM H-reflex (mean difference=0.150; 95% confidence interval =0.073 to 0.227; P<.001; large effect) compared to pain-free controls. The VM H-reflex was strongly correlated with patellar T-reflex in both PFP group (r=0.66; P<.001) and control group (r=0.72; P<.001).

CONCLUSIONS

As the T-reflex is easier to perform than H-reflex assessments in a clinical setting, it represents a feasible option to assess the impaired excitability of the stretch reflex pathway associated with PFP.

Neuromuscular Changes and Damage after Isoload versus Isokinetic Eccentric Exercise

PURPOSE

This study compared the effects of isoload (IL) and isokinetic (IK) knee extensor eccentric exercises on changes in muscle damage and neuromuscular parameters to test the hypothesis that the changes would be different after IL and IK exercises.

METHODS

Twenty-two young men were paired based on their strength and placed in the IL (N = 11) or the IK (N = 11) group. The IL group performed 15 sets of 10 eccentric contractions with a 150% of predetermined one-repetition maximum load. The IK group performed 15 sets of several maximal eccentric contractions matched set by set for the total amount of work and mean angular velocity with the IL group. Muscle damage markers (voluntary isometric peak torque, muscle soreness, and creatine kinase activity) and neuromuscular variables (e.g., voluntary activation, H-reflex, M-wave, and evoked torque) were measured before, immediately after, and 24, 48, 72, and 96 h postexercise.

RESULTS

Voluntary isometric peak torque decreased to the same extent (P = 0.94) in both groups immediately after (IL = -40.6% ± 13.8% vs IK = -42.4% ± 10.2%) to 96 h after the exercise (IL = -21.8% ± 28.5% vs IK = -26.7% ± 23.5%). Neither peak muscle soreness (IL = 48.1 ± 28.2 mm vs IK = 54.7 ± 28.9 mm, P = 0.57) nor creatine kinase activity (IL = 12,811 ± 22,654 U·L vs IK = 15,304 ± 24,739 U·L, P = 0.59) significantly differed between groups. H-reflex (IL = -23% vs IK = -35%) and M-wave (IL = -10% vs IK = -17%) significantly decreased immediately postexercise similarly between groups.

CONCLUSION

The changes in muscle damage and neuromuscular function after the exercise are similar between IL and IK, suggesting that resistance modality has little effects on acute muscle responses.

The fatigue of a full body resistance exercise session in trained men

OBJECTIVES

We examined the fatigue and recovery for 48h following a full-body resistance exercise session in trained men.

DESIGN

Experimental cross-sectional study.

METHODS

Eight resistance trained men volunteered to participate (mean±SD; age 27.0±6.0 years, height 1.79±0.05m, weight 81.8±6.8kg, training experience 7.8±5.0 years). Fatigue and pain was measured before, after, 1h post, 24h and 48h post the full-body resistance exercise session, which was based on in-season models used in contact team sports (e.g. AFL, NRL). Other measures included maximal torque and rate of torque development, central motor output (quadriceps muscle activation, voluntary activation, H-reflexes), and muscle contractility (evoked twitch responses). Linear mixed-model ANOVA procedures were used for data analysis.

RESULTS

Fatigue, soreness, and muscle pain did not return to pre-exercise levels until after 48h rest. Quadriceps maximal torque and muscle contractility were reduced from pre-exercise (p<0.01), and did not return to pre-exercise levels until 24h. Early rates of torque development and muscle activation were unchanged. The amplitude and slope of the normalized quadriceps H-reflex was higher immediately after exercise (p<0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

Full-body resistance exercise including multiple lower limb movements immediately reduced maximal torque, muscle contractility, and increased pain. While recovery of voluntary and evoked torque was complete within a day, 48h rest was required for fatigue and pain to return to baseline. Maximal voluntary effort may be compromised for lower-limb training (i.e. sprinting, jumping) prescribed in the 48h after the session.

Effects of Kinesio taping in patients with quadriceps inhibition: A randomized, single-blinded study

OBJECTIVE

To determine effects of Kinesio taping (KT) on quadriceps activation and maximal voluntary isometric contraction (MVIC) in patients with quadriceps inhibition.

DESIGN

Randomized, single-blinded.

SETTING

Laboratory.

PATIENTS

Sixteen participants (9 males, 7 females) with quadriceps inhibition, as determined by 90% or lower in central activation ratio (CAR), participated.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Hoffmann reflex (H-reflex) of the vastus medialis and quadriceps CAR and MVIC were measured before taping, and participants were randomly allocated to either KT (KT application with tension) or sham (non-elastic tape application without tension) group. H-reflexes were assessed immediately and 20 min after tape was applied over the rectus femoris. All outcomes were measured again after tape was removed when participants returned the laboratory 24-48 h after taping.

RESULTS

Two-way repeated ANOVA found no group-by-time interaction for: H-reflex (F_3,42 = 1.94, P = 0.14), CAR (F_1,14 = 0.03, P = 0.86), or MVIC (F_1,14 = 0.007, P = 0.93). None of the outcome measures differed between groups or over time (P > 0.05).

CONCLUSIONS

KT applied to the rectus femoris did not change H-reflex of the vastus medialis and quadriceps CAR and MVIC in patients with quadriceps inhibition.

Lower Amplitude of the Hoffmann Reflex in Women With Patellofemoral Pain: Thinking Beyond Proximal, Local, and Distal Factors

OBJECTIVES

To investigate whether vastus medialis (VM) Hoffmann reflexes (H-reflexes) differ on the basis of the presence or absence of patellofemoral pain (PFP) and to assess the capability of VM H-reflex measurements in accurately discriminating between women with and without PFP.

DESIGN

Cross-sectional study.

SETTING

Laboratory of biomechanics and motor control.

PARTICIPANTS

Women (N=30) aged 18 to 35 years were recruited, consisting of 2 groups: women with PFP (n=15) and asymptomatic controls (n=15).

INTERVENTIONS

Not applicable.

MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES

Maximum evoked responses were obtained by electrical stimulation applied to the femoral nerve, and peak-to-peak amplitudes of maximal Hoffmann reflex (Hmax) and maximal motor wave (Mmax) ratios were calculated. Independent samples t tests were performed to identify differences between groups, and a receiver operating characteristic curve was constructed to assess the discriminatory capability of VM H-reflex measurements.

RESULTS

VM Hmax/Mmax ratios were significantly lower in participants with PFP than in pain-free participants (P=.007). In addition, the VM Hmax/Mmax ratios presented large and balanced discriminatory capability values (sensitivity, 73%; specificity, 67%).

CONCLUSIONS

This study is the first to show that VM H-reflexes are lower in women with PFP than in asymptomatic controls. Therefore, increasing the excitation of the spinal cord in PFP participants may be essential to maintaining the gains acquired during the rehabilitation programs.

Between-day reliability of the trapezius muscle H-reflex and M-wave

INTRODUCTION

The aim of this study was to investigate the between-day reliability of the trapezius muscle H-reflex and M-wave.

METHODS

Sixteen healthy subjects were studied on 2 consecutive days. Trapezius muscle H-reflexes were evoked by electrical stimulation of the C3/4 cervical nerves; M-waves were evoked by electrical stimulation of the accessory nerve. Relative reliability was estimated by intraclass correlation coefficients (ICC2,1 ). Absolute reliability was estimated by computing the standard error of measurement (SEM) and the smallest real difference (SRD). Bland-Altman plots were constructed to detect any systematic bias.

RESULTS

Variables showed substantial to excellent relative reliability (ICC = 0.70-0.99). The relative SEM ranged from 1.4% to 34.8%; relative SRD ranged from 3.8% to 96.5%. No systematic bias was present in the data.

CONCLUSIONS

The amplitude and latency of the trapezius muscle H-reflex and M-wave in healthy young subjects can be measured reliably across days.